M
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
T
ThomasMT
Guest
They should have presented a purely audio blog.
G
gracepoole
Guest
For anyone who is fresh to these folks, it might be worth their time to read Benedict Carter’s Twitter feed. An account is not required to read his tweets.
https://twitter.com/BenedictCarter6
His views are…extreme.
https://twitter.com/BenedictCarter6
His views are…extreme.
F
Funvod
Guest
People still argue for colonialism?
M
Maximian
Guest
Can you be specific?
And regardless of his views on other subjects, of which Im unaware, how does that invalidate the discussion on the liturgy.
For example, I have extreme views about the use of plastic in architecture. This doesn’t invalidate my views on the need for social welfare.
And regardless of his views on other subjects, of which Im unaware, how does that invalidate the discussion on the liturgy.
For example, I have extreme views about the use of plastic in architecture. This doesn’t invalidate my views on the need for social welfare.
G
gracepoole
Guest
You mean more specific than his claim in the video that the “Novus Ordo Mass” is not Catholic? That seems extreme to me. But if one needs more, he claims to know about a secret Catholic cabal he calls “Trad, Inc.,” which is comprised of popular traditional Catholics (like Taylor Marshall) and which controls the narrative of criticisms re: the Church. That doesn’t just sound extreme to me — it sounds baffling.
F
Feanor2
Guest
I believe that some views are so out there that they call other ideas a person may have into question.You mean more specific than his claim in the video that the “Novus Ordo Mass” is not Catholic? That seems extreme to me. But if one needs more, he claims to know about a secret Catholic cabal he calls “Trad, Inc.,” which is comprised of popular traditional Catholics (like Taylor Marshall) and which controls the narrative of criticisms re: the Church. That doesn’t just sound extreme to me — it sounds baffling.
More extreme notions demonstrate that someone may have distorted ideas about everything they think.
Here are 2 examples of ideas that would just make me not listen to anything someone says.
White supremacy
Denial of the holocaust
P
puer.dei
Guest
Ugh. My brain needs a shower.For anyone who is fresh to these folks, it might be worth their time to read Benedict Carter’s Twitter feed. An account is not required to read his tweets.
https://twitter.com/BenedictCarter6
S
sallybutler
Guest
Since Taylor Marshall thinks that Latin is a holy language that Satan is afraid of, I have decided to un-subscribe from his youTube channel. If that is what the trads thinks, well, I don’t even know what to say
S
stpurl
Guest
I haven’t heard the actual words on this particular you tube, but Sally, all religions have ‘sacred languages’.
The more sacred something is, the more the devil fears it.
No matter what today’s thoroughly modern millie(nnial) or buxom boomer, gen A to Zer might think, the Church actually does teach that Latin when used as part of the rites (such as exorcism) is more powerful than the vernacular.
Not ‘better’ as in, “My mea culpa makes me better than you saying sorry”, but with regard to a liturgy, a more unified and powerful statement.
There is no single vernacular language in the Roman Rite that is ‘preeminent’ the way Latin is. We have English, the Romance languages, even Aramaic (and that in the Eastern Catholic is also a sacred language used for worship), but as far as Roman Latin goes, there is a reason we are ROMAN Catholics of the LATIN rite.
The more sacred something is, the more the devil fears it.
No matter what today’s thoroughly modern millie(nnial) or buxom boomer, gen A to Zer might think, the Church actually does teach that Latin when used as part of the rites (such as exorcism) is more powerful than the vernacular.
Not ‘better’ as in, “My mea culpa makes me better than you saying sorry”, but with regard to a liturgy, a more unified and powerful statement.
There is no single vernacular language in the Roman Rite that is ‘preeminent’ the way Latin is. We have English, the Romance languages, even Aramaic (and that in the Eastern Catholic is also a sacred language used for worship), but as far as Roman Latin goes, there is a reason we are ROMAN Catholics of the LATIN rite.
S
sallybutler
Guest
And here I thought it was because we were united with Rome, not because we used to use Latin during Mass
- Status
- Not open for further replies.