Abortion and Nuremberg

  • Thread starter Thread starter devoutchristian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Fair enough, but I feel that if it was illegal for the Nazis to commit atrocities against people in foreign countries, it’s not too much of a stretch for the allies to say that it is also a crime to do those same evil things to your own people. You’re only extending who is being protected, not the nature of the crime.
The same is true with regard to abortion, the class of protected persons is being extended.
 
“Crimes against humanity” was a new charge at Nuremberg, with no basis in prior international law.
OK, but its claim to being “international” was at least due to cooperation between the United States, Great Britain, France, and the Soviet Union.

Today, it would probably take the participation of even more nations, for it to be considered an application of “international law” – including the support of the United Nations.

Plus, unlike with Germany, you would have to prosecute individuals not just in one nation, but in virtually all the nations of the world. That would be one heck of a trial, though.

I suppose it would be logical to start not with the United States, but with China 🤷 (“In addition to virtually universal access to contraception, abortion is a way for China to contain its population in accordance with its one-child policy.”–wikipedia).
 
I agree that women who have abortions when legal should be granted immunity. I say “immunity” since there is a principle in international law that some crimes are so horrendous that they may be prosecuted even if they are legal at the time commited.
Ah okay. Is one woman having an abortion really a crime evil enough to try her, in an international court, even though it was legal when she had it done? Well it’s certainly not even close to the same level of what Goring did.
 
The same is true with regard to abortion, the class of protected persons is being extended.
Hmm… I see that now.

Well, if Obama were to one day decide that disabled people were a waste of resources and then started literally ripping the disabled into pieces and throwing their remains into trash cans, the international community would have something to say about it. So why is it okay to do so to the unborn? Governments around the world would have to come to the conclusion that abortion is just as wrong as gassing Jews and all the other crimes committed by the Nazis in WW2, otherwise no one would ever consider trying Obama and his minions on an international level.

I stand with my original response. The leaders should be sent to prison for a set time and then barred from political careers and other jobs of high influence. The women should be immune. Everyone gets therapy.
 
I stand with my original response. The leaders should be sent to prison for a set time and then barred from political careers and other jobs of high influence. The women should be immune. Everyone gets therapy.
I agree, except that I would imprison the leaders for life.
 
How can you give someone immunity if they didn’t commit a crime? They should definitely be sent to prison if they have an abortion when doing so is illegal. They should not be sent to prison for doing something they had every legal right to do.
Then again, who cares if you have a legal right to do something?

At the risk of extending this argument beyond the obvious:

If murder (in the conventional sense) were “legalized” tomorrow, should we not prosecute people who kill other people if that same act were re-illegalized a few years or decades later? Of course we should.
 
Hmm… I see that now.

Well, if Obama were to one day decide that disabled people were a waste of resources and then started literally ripping the disabled into pieces and throwing their remains into trash cans, the international community would have something to say about it. So why is it okay to do so to the unborn? Governments around the world would have to come to the conclusion that abortion is just as wrong as gassing Jews and all the other crimes committed by the Nazis in WW2, otherwise no one would ever consider trying Obama and his minions on an international level.

I stand with my original response. The leaders should be sent to prison for a set time and then barred from political careers and other jobs of high influence. The women should be immune. Everyone gets therapy.
I agree with what you are saying. Abortion is morality and is against natural law but people just don’t seem to understand. And what annoys me the most is some states and countries allow abortion up to 9 months (Canada for example has restriction on its abortion law)

Government should stop promoting these kinds of things.
 
Canada for example has restriction on its abortion law.
Canada’s abortion laws are a joke. Yes, late term abortions are illegal here. But any woman can get an abortion for any reason if she isn’t so far along, no questions asked. Which means certain minority communities who hold the belief that female children are not worth life can simply have abortion after abortion until they conceive a male. And people are aware of this, there was a movement (and even a bill put forward I believe) to have this gender selection thing criminalized, but no. The government wouldn’t talk about it. Abortion is untouchable here. The current prime minister has been in office for years and he runs a pretty tight ship. He has control of the country and he swiftly and easily defeats all opponents. This guy is a conservative and is pro-life, but even he won’t talk about talking about it. It’s ridiculous.
 
“Crimes against humanity” was a new charge at Nuremberg, with no basis in prior international law.
actually, it did, the sources were many. but we’ll adopt Nuremberg as our precedent anyway. we’re making this stuff up as we go along anyway.
 
I agree, except that I would imprison the leaders for life.
we must imprison everyone who has ever aborted or had a hand in the abortion or failed to stop an abortion or didn’t do enough to stop abortion laws, for life. that’s the penalty for murder (since we’re devout christians, we can’t execute anyone).

abortion is murder, right?

you vill haff your papers ready.
 
I thought the Nuremberg precedent was to exonerate those who really were “just follovink ordas” while punishing those who issued the orders or who went above-and-beyond obedience to them in terms of cruelty?

In that sense we could exonerate the harried triage doctor in the ER who performs one abortion that is in his judgment “medically necessary”, but convict and punish, say, a Kermit Gosnell.
 
I thought the Nuremberg precedent was to exonerate those who really were “just follovink ordas” while punishing those who issued the orders or who went above-and-beyond obedience to them in terms of cruelty?

In that sense we could exonerate the harried triage doctor in the ER who performs one abortion that is in his judgment “medically necessary”, but convict and punish, say, a Kermit Gosnell.
just the opposite. the post-war trials used the concept of command responsibility (also, the yamashita doctrine) to reach guilty leaders up and down the chain of command who ordered or allowed war crimes actually carried out by their subordinates.

in the OP’s context, Nuremberg means to impose law and punishment ex post facto by the new government which takes over the USA, which is why we’re so gung ho on life sentences for everyone who’s ever been involved, in any way, with abortion.
 
Nothing justifies killing the innocent. That is not what I said.

The example about spanking was about a better way to apply the law. It doesn’t matter that they are completely different crimes of completely different severity. You can’t make something illegal and then go and imprison everyone who did it when it was legal.
Then were the Nuremberg trials illegal? All of those people who were executed at Nuremberg never did anything that was illegal at the time that they did it.

Indeed, most of them were doing what was required by the laws that were in place at the time.

The whole point of the Nuremberg trials was that the legality of an action does not determine its rightness, and that people need to do what is right; and if the wrong thing happens to be legal, or even required, it is still not right.

Its other point was that, if we do evil things that are legal, we cannot assume that we are protected from the just consequences of our actions, merely because those actions happen to be legal at the time that we are doing them.
 
Exactly. If a document can’t even be clear about at least coming remotely close to obeying the natural law, then it’s no good.
Your responses incline me to question your motives, are they to put an end to an unjust law, or do you only desire to pass judgment on others?
 
I thought the Nuremberg precedent was to exonerate those who really were “just follovink ordas” while punishing those who issued the orders or who went above-and-beyond obedience to them in terms of cruelty?
No - the “I was just following orders” defense was actually the fast-track to the gallows, at Nuremberg. They were convicting and giving the death penalty to everyone who was involved; not just the higher-ups.

I think even as late as the early 1980s, they were still tracking down, convicting, and giving the death penalty to old men who had been guards at the prison camps. I vaguely remember a case where they were asking for leniency for this old man who had been recognized by one of the prisoners as the guard who had led her little sister into the gas chamber, and they were saying, don’t give him the death penalty, since he has been an upright and honest citizen for 40 years, and never got into any trouble - but in the end I think he died by firing squad.
 
It won’t allow me to vote, but if I could vote, I would vote for set imprisonment
 
I also voted for set prison terms, and I would say, everyone who cooperated knowingly in the death of the child.
I disagree. That would include the mothers, and it would simply be impractical to imprison all of them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top