Abortion: When is the person created?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Decado
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How can a person be Christian and in anyway support abortion at any time or place?

This includes politicians that say they are Christian and vote for laws promoting or sustaining the rights of Pro-Choice laws.
The problem here, particularly for policy makers, is that a person might be personally and spiritually opposed to abortion but not feel that they have the right to enforce their views opon another. This is where the Pro-Choice people have the edge, as seen in the last election.

The Pro-Choice advocates have framed the issue in terms that are very “American”. They are saying that, “We don’t say you have to have an abortion, we’re saying that if you want/need one it should be your choice”. This has the effect of placing the Pro-Life people on the defensive because we are seen as removing “Choice”. - (How Unamerican)

I see this as the primary reason why so many Catholics did not vote Pro-Life in the last election. They are personally opposed to abortion and would never have one, but aren’t sure that they have the right to tell others what to do/believe.

The main task of the Pro-Life movement now has to be one of education. The general public must be made aware that the Science of when life begins is at variance with the Politics of when Life begins. The Science is clear that a human exists at conception. The Law “recognizes” it at birth. Until the general public can see and understand that the Science is correct and the Law is wrong, we can expect little change in the debate.

Abortion has to be seen as murder. To do this People have to see the embryo/fetus as a human.

It’s an uphill Battle folks, but guess who’s side God is on.

Peace
James
 
When the sperm hits the egg? Is this when the soul enters the embryo?

Decado
Fertilization, by definition, is when two gametes of the same species come together to form a new organism of the same species.

For humans this is called “human fertilization” or “conception.”

The actual process takes 12-24 hours (so I’m told).

Before conception there is a sperm and an oocyte, neither of which is fully alive according to biological criteria (growth, metabolism, reaction to stimuli, and reproduction).

After conception is complete, you have a new organism that does meet the criteria for life.

So, scientifically, biologically (human embryology) speaking life begins at conception.

We do not know when a soul enters. That’s not a topic of science, and is not observable. Some argue it never happens, and there is no such thing as a soul.

The abortion debate, which is related to your question, is about personhood, not about when we begin our existence as organisms. (Unless you define personhood as such.)

My (secular) definition of a person is: any unique individual human organism.
So I’m pro-life starting at conception.
 
The legal definition in most 50 states is at conception.

The murder case involving Petersen even in California resulted in the conviction of a double murder. The second was the baby in the womb.

Manslaughter convictions in all 50 states when drunk drivers cause the death of a baby in the Womb during crashes.

Felony convictions on Mothers who take drugs during their pregnancy causing harm to their baby in the womb.

Murder convictions of women trying to self induce abortion or having anyone other than an approved abortionist complete an abortion.

Legally the baby in the womb is a person, science states the baby in the womb is a person, and common sense lets you know the baby in the womb is a person.

The Supreme Court when a legal abortion is done states it is the right of the mother to committ murdrer. they never said the baby in the womb was not a person
What I’m struggling to understand through the logic of the Supreme Court and the concept of rights is if it is indeed a fact that it is the women’s “right to choose” which indeed it is ( we all have free will and a natural right to choose whatever we want whether that is good or evil, God created us with that. )

But at the same time accept the fact ( it never denied it ) that the baby in the womb is indeed a person entitled to rights too. Then by that same logic or principal a women has a right to murder her child without legal consequence? Where as using that same logic we all should have the right to murder each other without legal consequence since we " have the right to choose". If the baby in the womb is a person like you and I, shouldn’t the same laws of murder that apply to server and protect us and punish us if we murder other’s also apply to the baby in the womb?

Or does it only apply when the baby is out of the womb? But if it only applies to the baby out of the womb, then the baby in the womb is not indeed defined as a person by the Supreme Court since it is contradictory.

That is just a lot of the poor logic that I see in allowing abortion and the fallacy and flawed thinking about " rights to choose" . Since that can be applied to anything since we all do have a right to choose to do good or evil things but if we face consequences by murdering our children then shouldn’t women and people who abort babies?

Basically to summarize, to allow abortion under the premise that it is " the women’s right to choose" is the same thing as saying that it is our right to murder our children and we shouldn’t go to jail or face consequences.
Are you sorta following me? It’s either they don’t see the baby as a person entitled to rights until after it is born and is only considered “property” of the women ( which makes no sense since it is a separate biological entity called a human from conception )

Or they see the baby as a person but admit the fact that the women has every right to murder him/her without consequence which totally contradicts our legal system if that is the case.

Anyone agree?

If I’m missing something let me know.
 
Mostly incorrect:

As Catholics: The reason we are against birth control is because we believe that we exist on a spiritual level before the act of intercourse even takes place. It has nothing to do with the sperm hitting the egg or becoming attached or whatever else is going around on this thread. Our definition of “conceive” is the moment God put us in His mind. Not the moment our mothers become pregnant.

God says that he knew us before we were conceived in the womb. We are a unique spiritual being before our parents even have intercourse, before the sperm or the egg have anything to do with it. God creates our soul when we are in essense “a glimmer in our daddy’s eye”.
Interesting way of thinking about it!
 
If one does not know definitively when a “human” is formed, the only moral choice is to go to the beginning. Otherwise, a human may be denied its most basic right, the right to life, based on an entirely arbitrary definition.
We have a winner!

Here’s a short story:

One time this man was offered a job. All he had to was wait for a large crate to be brought into the room and placed on a big X. Then, he pushed a button, causing a huge weight to drop, utterly destroying the crate. For each crate he destroyed, he got paid a generous sum of money.

What’s the catch?

Simple: Each time a crate is brought in, there was chance that it would have a person inside. There was no way the man could know which crates contained people and which ones didn’t. Destroying the crate would kill any person inside it.

Thus, could the man be morally justified to ever destroy even one crate?

– Mark L. Chance.
 
Yes, the particular soul is created and infused by God at the moment of conception.

A soul cannot split in half because a soul does not have material properties which can split or be measured as, for example, two halves of a whole.

It is understood that in the case of monozygotic twins, when a zygote is destined to split into two embryos, there were originally two souls imbued at the moment of conception–one for each of the twins that would result.
But if this is true, then a huge number of souls must go to “waste”, because the zygote needs to implant in the uterus in order to develop further, and there’s no guarantee that this will happen. Surely this must cause a loss of human lives which dwarfs anything human intervention causes?

Is there an objective reason to think that this view of the soul is the correct one?
 
But if this is true, then a huge number of souls must go to “waste”, because the zygote needs to implant in the uterus in order to develop further, and there’s no guarantee that this will happen. Surely this must cause a loss of human lives which dwarfs anything human intervention causes?

Is there an objective reason to think that this view of the soul is the correct one?
I do not know what your point is here? There are many miscarriages also.

Is there a lead up to what answer you are trying to receive.

Catholic doctrine along with the scientific community agree human life begins at conception. period
 
I think it is important to keep in mind the reasons for procreation. Procreation is meant for and is a blessing for a man and a woman who have been united through the marital bonds of the Sacrament of Matrimony. With that being said, we are told to be fruitful and multiply. It is truly then, at the moment of conception, that the two become one. Sex is not meant for anybody other than a man and a woman who are married together. I know this concept isn’t popular today or followed per se, but the Church holds this belief, thus participating or committing an abortion is cutting the life of God from our relationship and the woman’s body. Not to mention it is taking the life of a helpless human being in its earliest stage of life. The same can be said for contraception, though that is for another thread.
 
We have a winner!

Here’s a short story:

One time this man was offered a job. All he had to was wait for a large crate to be brought into the room and placed on a big X. Then, he pushed a button, causing a huge weight to drop, utterly destroying the crate. For each crate he destroyed, he got paid a generous sum of money.

What’s the catch?

Simple: Each time a crate is brought in, there was chance that it would have a person inside. There was no way the man could know which crates contained people and which ones didn’t. Destroying the crate would kill any person inside it.

Thus, could the man be morally justified to ever destroy even one crate?

– Mark L. Chance.
The problem with that analogy (and argument you quoted) is that pro-choice people ARE sure (from their perspective) that it’s not a person.
I think this type of analogy is more effective on undecided people.
The one I’ve heard is different. If you are hunting an animal, and you see a rustle in the bush, you don’t shoot at the bush and check later to see what you shot. You have to verify your target first.
Again, people are pro-choice will not be persuaded in the least by this argument.
 
The problem with that analogy (and argument you quoted) is that pro-choice people ARE sure (from their perspective) that it’s not a person.
Actually, I’ve seen pro-abortion arguments that admit that a fetus IS a person, but that killing him/her is justifiable regardless.
 
DustinM;4727544:
The problem with that analogy (and argument you quoted) is that pro-choice people ARE sure (from their perspective) that it’s not a person.
Actually, I’ve seen pro-abortion arguments that admit that a fetus IS a person, but that killing him/her is justifiable regardless.
Pro-choice people are positive THE BABY is a person. As a matter of fact they know the baby is human.

doctors and nurses who perform an abortion do understand science

The process of embryonic stem cell development is a continuous process, with no obvious point at which the fetus magically becomes a “person.” In fact, the development process continues well after birth, including many characteristics that determine our personality or personhood. What are the stages in human embryonic development? Science tells us that the heart of the human fetus begins to form 18 days after conception.1 There is a measurable heart beat 21-24 days after conception.2 This is only 7-10 days after a women would expect to begin her menses. Since most women have cycles that can vary by this amount, they do not discover they are pregnant until after this point. Therefore, all abortions stop a beating heart, even “early” abortions. However, most abortions do not occur until 4-6 weeks after the fetus begins to form. The human brain is formed enough to produce brain waves by 6 weeks, which means that most abortions destroy a functioning human brain.

What is the difference between a 3 day old baby outside the womb and a 3 month old in the womb?

Many abortions occurr when the baby is viable through medical science outside the womb.

The same people understand embryotic Stem cells is science pushing along the process of development of a human Being outside the womb and harvesting that human being (killing) for pure profit.

So the medical community is saying it is not a human because?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top