About canon law and communion

  • Thread starter Thread starter luisvera
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

luisvera

Guest
I have a question, it’s something that confuses me

You see, i’ve come across this passage in Canon Law a few times, that seemingly allows non catholics (Orthodox or other churches that retain a valid eucharist, also those who don’t but those have stricter regulations) to recieve communion, penance and the anointing of the sick from a catholic priest WITHOUT THE NEED OF THEM CONVERTING and provided they “ask so of their own” and “if they cannot approach a minister of their own community”

What? This confuses how may a non catholic who willingly remain outside the Church be “properly disposed”? also, the whole if they don’t have a minister of their own sounds like legitimizing their “ecclesiastical communities”

What do you think? What do we make of this?
 
If I’m dying and there is only an Orthodox priest around, I hope his Church has as much charity as ours does in permitting him to give me the sacraments.

And vice versa for an Orthodox who needs these and only a Catholic priest is available.
 
I have a question, it’s something that confuses me

You see, i’ve come across this passage in Canon Law a few times, that seemingly allows non catholics (Orthodox or other churches that retain a valid eucharist, also those who don’t but those have stricter regulations) to recieve communion, penance and the anointing of the sick from a catholic priest WITHOUT THE NEED OF THEM CONVERTING and provided they “ask so of their own” and “if they cannot approach a minister of their own community”

What? This confuses how may a non catholic who willingly remain outside the Church be “properly disposed”? also, the whole if they don’t have a minister of their own sounds like legitimizing their “ecclesiastical communities”

What do you think? What do we make of this?
What you say is not correct. First there has to be danger of death. Second they have to “demonstrate the Catholic faith” and are also “properly disposed.”

Can 844 §4 If there is a danger of death or if, in the judgement of the diocesan Bishop or of the Episcopal Conference, there is some other grave and pressing need, Catholic ministers may lawfully administer these same sacraments to other christians not in full communion with the Catholic Church, who cannot approach a minister of their own community and who spontaneously ask for them, provided that they demonstrate the Catholic faith in respect of these sacraments and are properly disposed.
 
I’m talking about Eastern Orthodox (as in, Russian Orthodox, Greek Orthodox etc) not Eastern rite catholics such as the Ukranian Greek Catholic Church
 
Me too. They are Catholic. They are not of the Roman Rite.
 
Thanks, seriously thanks, but i have a question again doesnt the “Who cannot approach a minister of their own cmmunity” legitimize them?As in “If you’re an Russian Orthodox dying but you have a Russian Orthodox priest, go to him, if not, you could come here under A B and C, but the ideal is you go to a R. Orthodox”
 
No they’re not catholic who are not roman rite, Eastern Catholics are catholics who are not roman rite, Eastern Orthodox reject the authority of the Pope and thus are not catholic, fun fact: There are Roman Rite Orthodox not in communion with Rome but in communion with the Eastern Orthodox
 
They are catholic (small c), not Catholic (capital C). What this means is that they don’t get lumped into the same category as ecclesial communities (Protestants) because they have maintained valid apostolic succession and sacraments, they just lack a perfect union with the Church, but they are still viewed as proper Churches catholic.
 
Last edited:
You are confusing the issue of union with Rome with the is due of Catholicity. I invite you to explain why canon law would invite supposed “non-Catholics” to communion if what I have said is untrue.
 
Well that is true, but proper churches that broke with THE Church, that’s why Pope Emerits Benedict XVI says they are “defective”
 
I find the post unintelligible. It says “Blockquote.”
 
Last edited:
Being in a state of schism does not deprive one of Catholicity. The Orthodox Churches in question here are true Churches, not ecclesial communities, with all the means of salvation of a true Church. Indeed, their sacraments are equally valid to those celebrated in the Roman Rite because they are, indeed, Catholic. I hope that clarifies the issue.

Also, consider this…

“Because of the close communion between the Catholic Church and
the Eastern Orthodox Churches, it is permissible for a just cause for an
Eastern faithful to act as godparent; together with a Catholic godparent,
at the baptism of a Catholic infant or adult, so long as there is provision
for the Catholic education of the person being baptized, and it is clear
that the godparent is a suitable one.”

_On March 25th, 1993, His Holiness Pope John Paul II approved this Directory, confirmed it by his authority and _
_ordered that it be published. Anything to the contrary notwithstanding. _
_Vatican City _
March 25th, 1993
 
Last edited:
His description does not deprive them of Catholicity. It is a description of the state of schism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top