About Mariology: denouncing false beliefs

  • Thread starter Thread starter philipmarie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

philipmarie

Guest
By the pure and Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary,

I am writing this thread to show the true way of thinking of the Church in regards to the ever Blessed Virgin Mary. I am not fallible but, if my opinions do tend to contradict Church teaching, please tell me although I will make and state many objections and answer them.

That loathesome heretic Ronald Conte is nothing but a proud, arrogant, poor excuse of a theologian. He denies that the Blessed Virgin is the Mediatrix of all graces. He is a modernist and one knows how a modernist acts…

"It is owing to their pride that they seek to be the reformers of others while they forget to reform themselves,-His Holiness, Pope Saint Pius X, Pascendi Dominici Gregis, September 8, 1907.

I was a bit angry to see so many people trying to change Marian devotio according to their own caprices. I am not speaking of Protestants, who almost do not honour the ever Blessed Virgin(and if the do honour Her, the praise that they give her has nothing to do with what She truly deserves), nor other religions. I am spekaing of Catholics and modern, Novus Ordo Catholics. I am speaking also of traditionalist Catholics who show so much ignorance and pride when trying to reform others!

*But what is the remedy that is wanted? What is the remedy indicated by God Himself? If we may rely on the disclosure of the saints, it is an immense increase of devotion to the Blessed Lady; but, remember, nothing short of an immense one. Here in England, Mary is not half enough preached. Devotion to her is low and thin and poor. It is frightened out of its wits by the sneers of heresy. It is always invoking human respect and carnal prudence, wishing to make Mary so little of a Mary that Protestants may feel at ease about her.

Its ignorance of theology makes it unsubstantial and unworthy. It is not the prominent characteristic of our religion which it ought to be. It has no faith in itself. Hence it is that Jesus is not loved, that heretics are not converted, that the Church is not exalted; that souls which might be saints wither and dwindle; that the Sacraments are not rightly frequented, or souls enthusiastically evangelized.

Jesus is obscured because Mary is kept in the background. Thousands of souls perish because Mary is withheld from them. It is the miserable, unworthy shadow which we call our devotion to the Blessed Virgin that is the cause of all these wants and blights, these evils and omissions and declines. Yet, if we are to believe the revelations of the saints, God is pressing for a greater, a wider, a stronger, quite another devotion to His Blessed Mother.*
 
This is from the preface of Father Faber to True Devotion to Mary(TAN books. They have the greatest and best translation of the masterpiece). This is what false Catholics do, belittling the Blessed Virgin, even trying to dispense with Her for the Protestants.

I was a bit severe; forgive me, but I will not retract what I have said because I have done and said nothing wrong and nothing contrary to what Christ and the Church teach.

I love the Blessed Virgin so mcuh, so much do I love Her, so attached towards Her have I become that it is easier to seperate fire from the sun, the soul from the body tthan to seperate me from the Lady I love the most. I am not worthy to be a child of the Blessed Virgin Mary, yet that won’t stop me. I suffer great interior trials, the devils make me sad and depressed yet, despite all that, I am still protected by the Blessed Virgin and I did NOT fall.

Mary, Mary, my sweetest and most amiable Love, for you may I suffer, for you may I die: grant that I may be everything yours and nothing in mine. The devils are trying to convince me that God is displeased with my devotion towards thee. They pretend that I am excessively devoted towards thee.

The devil tries to alienate a soul devoted to the Blessed Virgin even under the guise of devotion towards Jesus Christ. He knows that when a soul strays from Her, he will not recieve so much grace. My father too noticed that post conciliar priests do not consider the Blessed Virgin very much. No wonder, the Blessed Virgin is withheld from them!

I do not mean in the least to be severe or to condemn Vatican II(!), but I had to give way to some zeal and holy anger. Yes, there is such a thing as holy anger!

Please do not post on this thread until I say so, please. I will not make it boring as I will insert a picture now and then. I need a few posts to write what I want to say, else, it will become very muddled and I can’t write a whole thread in one day. I would recieve pins and needles on my legs! So please do not post.

O Mary, concieved without sin, pray for us, who have recourse to thee. To thee is this thread dedicated, thou who arth the most loveable and amiable creature that has ever existed. THOU, who arth the beloved, the sweetheart of God. Thou, who the most high embracest and kisses the most(see the Canticle of Canticles).

My beloved Lady to me and I to Her. She who feeds among the lilies, Her children. Amen.
 
Philip, just wondering if maybe this is posted to the wrong sub-forum? If you PM a moderator they can move the thread for you.
 
…That loathesome heretic Ronald Conte is nothing but a proud, arrogant, poor excuse of a theologian. He denies that the Blessed Virgin is the Mediatrix of all graces. He is a modernist and one knows how a modernist acts….
philipmarie,

While I sympathise with your frustration over certain other participants of the forums, it’s a violation of the rules to talk about other members. If it’s too late to edit that out, it would be good to report yourself to the mods for the violation; afterward you can restart the thread with the offending material removed.

I’d also like to point out that the Church has not yet defined a doctrine declaring Mary as Mediatrix, therefore by definition one cannot be a heretic for denying it.
 
Philip, just wondering if maybe this is posted to the wrong sub-forum? If you PM a moderator they can move the thread for you.
Why should this post be moved to another sub-forum? It should be deleted, period. It is against forum rules to call people such unsavory names as “vile heretic”, "arrogant"etc. Why poison any other forum with this slander?
 
This thread certainly has no place in this forum. Whether it should be moved or deleted entirely is up to the moderator.
 
the True Devotion to Mary by St Louis de Montfort is one of the greatest books I’ve ever read 🙂
 
Perhaps Phillip you could explain why you posted this on the Eastern forum. It simply does not address anything about the East.:confused:

I might add that the East is very, very Marian. I can’t say that I have been to a regular Sunday liturgy that did not sing at least one hymn to Mary.
 
Conte (notwithstanding his lamentable support of Garabandal and Merdjugorje) is right on the money, especially on fraudulent Marian apparitions which underpin the entire Mediatrix movement. Conte takes a traditional Catholic approach to things and offers strong arguments against this.

catholicplanet.com/CMA/

The only vaguely Eastern thing, and something which I think might have some resonance to folk in this forum, is Conte’s belief that May’s death - or dormition - before her assumption - both meets his litmus test of an infallible non-binding teaching (in the Roman Catholic tradition) AND is of GREATER theological import than the spurious movement which the original poster defends.
Now certainly the Dormition is a teaching of at least the Ordinary Magisterium, for the teaching that Mary died and rose from the dead prior to her Assumption is found in the Apostolic Constitution of Pope Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus, which also defines Mary’s Assumption infallibly. In that Constitution, the Pope refers to the death of the Virgin Mary at least seven times, and to her resurrection at least twice. Also, the Dormition has been celebrated in the Catholic Church, particularly in the East, for many centuries, though it is less well-known in the West.
The death and resurrection of the Virgin Mary prior to her Assumption is a fundamental teaching. It relates to sin, which brought death into the world, and also to her perfect imitation of Christ, who died though he was sinless. Was Mary exempt from death because she was sinless, or was she subject to death because God willed her to imitate Christ fully? This question and its answer is fundamental to our understanding of sin, death, discipleship, and Mary.
 
Some more Conte observations.

catholicplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?t=1719
TS 11g: Dormition and Assumption
At the end of the Virgin Mary’s life on earth, she was living at Ephesus. By Divine Providence and grace, 10 of the 11 remaining Apostles (including Matthias who replaced Judas, but not including James the greater, who had been martyred) gathered at Ephesus. There was a holy Mass led by Saint Peter, in which the Virgin Mary received holy Communion and last rites.
Then, soon after receiving her Son in the Sacrament, Mary’s soul left her body by Divine intervention, and so she died. Her soul went to Heaven. Her body remained on earth to be venerated by the Apostles and other holy persons (a kind of wake lasting about 12 days) in a tomb, much like the tomb of our Lord. Then the tomb was sealed, beginning on Friday. On the third day, early on Sunday, Jesus broughy Mary’s soul back from Heaven and raised her from the dead, and she was immediately assumed, with body and soul united, into Heaven.
The Assumption is an infallible dogma. The Dormition (death) and Resurrection of Mary is at least a teaching under the Ordinary Magisterium. The same Apostolic Constitution which infallibly proclaims the Assumption, teaches non-infallibly the death and Resurrection of Mary:
[quoted from my book, Important Dates…]
At the end of her life on earth, the Blessed Virgin Mary died, was resurrected from the dead, and was assumed into Heaven. Some Catholics doubt that the Virgin Mary died and was resurrected before being assumed into Heaven. But the Apostolic Constitution of Pope Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus, (also titled, “Defining the Dogma of the Assumption”), clearly and repeatedly refers to the death of the Virgin Mary. In
no less than seven separate paragraphs this Apostolic Constitution refers, in one way or another, to the death of the Virgin Mary:
  1. “In the same way, it was not difficult for them to admit that the great Mother of God, like her only begotten Son, had actually passed from this life.” (paragraph 14)
  2. “ ‘Venerable to us, O Lord, is the festivity of this day on which the holy Mother of God suffered temporal death….’ ” (paragraph 17)
  3. “ ‘As he kept you a virgin in childbirth, thus he has kept your body incorrupt in the tomb and has glorified it by his divine act of transferring it from the tomb.’ ” (paragraph 1
  4. “…this feast shows, not only that the dead body of the Blessed Virgin Mary remained incorrupt, but that she gained a triumph out of death….” (paragraph 20)
  5. “ ‘It was fitting that she, who had kept her virginity intact in childbirth, should keep her own body free from all corruption even after death.’ ” (paragraph 21)
  6. “ ‘…she has received an eternal incorruptibility of the body together with him who has raised her up from the tomb and has taken her up to himself in a way known only to him.’ ” (paragraph 22)
  7. “Hence the revered Mother of God…finally obtained, as the supreme culmination of her privileges, that she should be preserved free from the corruption of the tomb and that, like her own Son, having overcome death, she might be taken up body and soul to the glory of heaven….” (paragraph 40)
This Apostolic Constitution also clearly refers to the Resurrection of the Virgin Mary, not only by saying she was raised up from the tomb (e.g. #6 above), but also by stating that her soul was reunited with her body:
“…the Virgin Mary’s flesh had remained incorrupt—for it is wrong to believe that her body has seen corruption—because it was really united again to her soul and, together with it, crowned with great glory in the heavenly courts.” (paragraph 28 ). Death is the separation of the soul from the body. Resurrection is the reuniting of the soul with the body. Here is a clear reference to the Resurrection of the Virgin Mary.
Furthermore, nowhere within this Apostolic Constitution does Pope Pius XII in anyway suggest even the possibility that the Virgin Mary may not have died at the end of her life on earth. Therefore, it is the teaching of the Catholic Church that the Virgin Mary died, was resurrected from the dead, and was thereafter assumed into Heaven. This teaching is well understood among the Eastern Churches, where many Christians observe the 14-day Fast of the Dormition prior to their celebration of the Virgin Mary’s Assumption into Heaven. The Dormition of the Virgin Mary is her “falling asleep” in Christ (cf. Jn 11:11-14), in other words, her death.
  1. Mary died so that she could continue to fulfill her perfect imitation of Christ
  1. perhaps her body was left for so many days to be venerated as proof that she did die. The proof that Christ was dead was that He died in full view of many persons on the Cross, and that His side was pierced with a lance. The proof that Mary died was that many persons came to the open tomb to venerate her body, for so many days.
  1. her death, Resurrection, and Assumption is the ordinary path that all the faithful who are saved take: we each die, we each will be raised at the general Resurrection, and we each will then be assumed into the new Heaven.
The traditional view in the East is that she died; it was not a death due to old age or disease or injury or violence. She died because it was God’s will that she follow Christ, even by dying and rising. The term sleep is used to refer to the death of any of the faithful because death is only temporary; we will all be raised at the general Resurrection.
… She was assumed, body and soul, into heaven, not merely bodily.
 
That’s nice.

It is an 18th century composition by a Latin Catholic priest in northwest Europe.
I’m not sure what you are trying to say…

that’s true, it was written by a Catholic priest in Europe in the 18th century… (who happens to be one of the greatest Saints of the Church)

it has also changed many people’s lives, brought them closer to God and Mary, and the devotion it describes is a teaching from Heaven and is a great way to holiness.
 
I’m not sure what you are trying to say…

that’s true, it was written by a Catholic priest in Europe in the 18th century… (who happens to be one of the greatest Saints of the Church)

it has also changed many people’s lives, brought them closer to God and Mary, and the devotion it describes is a teaching from Heaven and is a great way to holiness.
It’s one of the most sound, wonderful books I’ve ever read too. :o
 
Hi Philipmarie,

The quote above shows you are not being partial to traditionalists but a strong promoter of Mary. Good for you! Ture Devotion to Mary by St Louis de Monfort is one of the best books on Mary I have ever read! He balances devotion to Mary with sound theology and he did so, in part, to answer the Jansenists. It got me saying the Rosary. You write more like a Traditional Catholic and I love it because naturally I’m that way too. I go to the Latin Mass, use the Douay-Rheims Bible, read almost all traditional spiritual works such as Aquinas, St Teresa of Avila, St John of the Cross, St Francis de Sales, Thomas a Kempis, Tauler, Arintero, Garrigou LaGrange, etc.

I don’t know about the man you quote about the Doctrine of Mediatrix so I can’t comment on it.*
 
I’m not sure what you are trying to say…

that’s true, it was written by a Catholic priest in Europe in the 18th century… (who happens to be one of the greatest Saints of the Church)

it has also changed many people’s lives, brought them closer to God and Mary, and the devotion it describes is a teaching from Heaven and is a great way to holiness.
I hope that Hesychios does not mind me stepping in and responding. :o

You have to put the comment into context:

A. The thread was posted in the Eastern Catholic Forum, but is made no reference to Eastern Catholic teaching/expression of Marian doctrine or devotions, nor did it ask about them.

B. If you read down the comments immediately following, people are asking about why the thread was posted in that forum.

C. de Monfort’s spirituality is distinctively not-Eastern. While I am a lover of the diversity in the Church, I think the point was that “yeah, de Monfort is all fine and dandy, but why is this thread here in the first place.”

Now the thread has been moved to a more appropriate fora, so the issue that was at hand has been resolved.

Nothing says that one cannot created a thread on De Monfort and something relating to Eastern Catholic Spirituality in the Eastern Catholic forum. 🙂 However, this is not what was done.

To be honest, the point of the thread was not entirely clear to begin with.🤷

God Bless,
Rosemary
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top