Absent Priest, Valid Mass?

  • Thread starter Thread starter youkokun
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sbyvl said:
That’s why I am able to cite 2,000 years of Catholic doctrine. Riiiight. I actually have a blog, if you need to verify that I’m not a Proddie heretic. sbyvl.wordpress.com
Click to expand...
You asked how you were disrespecting other Christians, and you use the term “proddie” again?
Unbelievable.
 
Sbyvl, You should know that I used to be a member of SD, until I realized their errors.

You are only continuing to show us how rejecting the Magisterium leads one to self-deception.
 
Sbyvl said:
Very well, then. From Pope Pius X’s Catechism of the Catholic Church:

3 Q. Who is a true Christian?
A. A true Christian is he who is baptised, who believes and professes the Christian Doctrine, and obeys the lawful pastors of the Church.
Click to expand...
I have just gone through the Catechism no such question or answer was there.
 
Emile_McKenzie said:
Sbyvl, You should know that I used to be a member of SD, until I realized their errors.

You are only continuing to show us how rejecting the Magisterium leads one to self-deception.
Click to expand...
Once again, show me what article of the INFALLIBLE Magisterium I have contradicted. Show me that Vatican II did not deviate from the Catholic faith. I’m listening.
 
floresco said:
He is a sedevacantist Catholic. They do not accept that the pope is the pope and they reject Vatican II.

It is an extreme form of traditionalist Catholicism.
Click to expand...
I know that’s it’s classified as extremist Catholicism, but its exactly like Protestantism in that it is a position grounded in the authority of individuals to reject Catholic teaching based on their private opinions and disagreements over the implementation of procedure.

Thanks for the heads up though.
 
Sbyvl said:
Silly Modernist. Protestants aren’t Christians.
Click to expand...
More Christian than you.

“How quick can I get banned?” is a game played by children, for children.

Your form of “Catholicism” looks a lot like Protestantism, BTW.
Enjoy your self-appointed authority over the church.
 
1newcatholic said:
More Christian than you.

“How quick can I get banned?” is a game played by children, for children.

Your form of “Catholicism” looks a lot like Protestantism, BTW.
Enjoy your self-appointed authority over the church.
Click to expand...
Look on the previous page. Show me where I have rejected the Magisterium in any form, and I will recant. Show me that Vatican II didn’t deviate from de fide. I’m all ears.
 
Sbyvl said:
If there is no TLM near you, then you don’t have to go to Mass. Just as a Lutheran service does not fulfill your Sunday obligation, neither does the Novus Ordo.
Click to expand...
Reported…there is only so much I can take!
 
1newcatholic said:
More Christian than you.

“How quick can I get banned?” is a game played by children, for children.

Your form of “Catholicism” looks a lot like Protestantism, BTW.
Enjoy your self-appointed authority over the church.
Click to expand...
You don’t read much, do you?
 
1newcatholic said:
I know that’s it’s classified as extremist Catholicism, but its exactly like Protestantism in that it is a position grounded in the authority of individuals to reject Catholic teaching based on their private opinions and disagreements over the implementation of procedure.
Click to expand...
That is true of the positions of both the far left and far right of people calling themselves Catholic.
 
Sbyvl said:
Silly Modernist. Protestants aren’t Christians.
Click to expand...
you are more Protestant than Catholic with your attitudes and posts, because you reject the Catholic church and are part of a cult that think it knows it all. You have more in common with fundamentalists than the Catholics on this web site. I am not sure why you are on. All your posts are angry and contentious. Who do you think you are trying to influence. No one and calling Protestants non-Christians Really? Are you really promoting anything but your deep anger and misinformation. I pity you.
 
Sbyvl said:
Silly Modernist. Protestants aren’t Christians.
Click to expand...
All the Baptized are Christians - no, I am too loose with that - all the Baptized are Catholic, though they protest all they want. You, also, are Catholic with Francis as your Pope, just as Paul VI was your Pope, though you protest all you want. There is only one Church, no matter how many may protest saying they are their own “church” or “affiliation”.

Give up the anger and resentment and replace them with patience.

John Martin
 
robwar said:
you are more Protestant than Catholic with your attitudes and posts, because you reject the Catholic church and are part of a cult that think it knows it all. You have more in common with fundamentalists than the Catholics on this web site. I am not sure why you are on. All your posts are angry and contentious. Who do you think you are trying to influence.** No one and calling Protestants non-Christians** Really? Are you really promoting anything but your deep anger and misinformation. I pity you.
Click to expand...
So you admit that you are against Pope Blessed Pius IX, then?

The substance of my statements are not Protestant, whereas, your heresies are. I’m not a Modernist, you are.
 
John_Martin said:
All the Baptized are Christians - no, I am too loose with that - all the Baptized are Catholic, though they protest all they want. You, also, are Catholic with Francis as your Pope, just as Paul VI was your Pope, though you protest all you want. There is only one Church, no matter how many may protest saying they are their own “church” or “affiliation”.

Give up the anger and resentment and replace them with patience.

John Martin
Click to expand...
Paul VI and Francis are not Catholic. I covered that already. Proddies are not Christians, nor are they Catholic. To believe they are is a heresy condemned by Pius IX.
 
Sbyvl said:
Silly Modernist. Protestants aren’t Christians.
Click to expand...
Ad hominem

You do realize that you are in the same boat as the Old Catholics, Lutherans, Baptist, who also decided what was the true Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top