Abuse of the annulment process

  • Thread starter Thread starter EvelynEVF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EvelynEVF

Guest
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.

Everyone I’ve ever discussed this with can see how ridiculous it is, how the process is being abused in order to perpetuate control, but all we can do is look at each other and acknowledge that, because there is nothing anybody can actually do about it. I doubt the people who set up the process long ago ever even imagined it could be misused like this. I would like very much to hear from someone who has been through this and come out the other side.

Thanks.
 
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.

Everyone I’ve ever discussed this with can see how ridiculous it is, how the process is being abused in order to perpetuate control, but all we can do is look at each other and acknowledge that, because there is nothing anybody can actually do about it. I doubt the people who set up the process long ago ever even imagined it could be misused like this. I would like very much to hear from someone who has been through this and come out the other side.

Thanks.
I’m so sorry that is happening to you. Prayers!
 
Fortunately, I have not experienced this myself but I feel very sorry t hear anout your experience. I will pray for you to conti ue to persevere.
 
I am very sorry to read this.

Yes, sadly, this does happen.

I assure you of my prayers.
 
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.

Everyone I’ve ever discussed this with can see how ridiculous it is, how the process is being abused in order to perpetuate control, but all we can do is look at each other and acknowledge that, because there is nothing anybody can actually do about it. I doubt the people who set up the process long ago ever even imagined it could be misused like this. I would like very much to hear from someone who has been through this and come out the other side.

Thanks.
My (admittedly somewhat limited) understanding is that although he has the RIGHT to appeal to the Roman Rota, he’s not guaranteed that they will AGREE to even look at the case. dans0622 (Dan) is a canon lawyer and he might be able to address specific concerns that you have. I’ll pray for you.
 
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.

Everyone I’ve ever discussed this with can see how ridiculous it is, how the process is being abused in order to perpetuate control, but all we can do is look at each other and acknowledge that, because there is nothing anybody can actually do about it. I doubt the people who set up the process long ago ever even imagined it could be misused like this. I would like very much to hear from someone who has been through this and come out the other side.

Thanks.
If you received a judgement of nullity, it matters not what the ex does or says. Ignore these threats. Nothing will change just because he is upset about it.👍
 
Unfortunately, my understanding is that an appeal to the Roman Rota will add around a decade to the process.
 
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.

Everyone I’ve ever discussed this with can see how ridiculous it is, how the process is being abused in order to perpetuate control, but all we can do is look at each other and acknowledge that, because there is nothing anybody can actually do about it. I doubt the people who set up the process long ago ever even imagined it could be misused like this. I would like very much to hear from someone who has been through this and come out the other side.

Thanks.
In case a bright side to this depressing situation is helpful, I just wanted to say that normally takes quite a bit of time to get over an abusive marriage. Perhaps God knows that you need this time? I say this from experience because I was in an abusive marraige - verbal and emotional. I lived the marriage trying to please him, and obey “as unto the Lord”, which is the Protestant counsel I always got, and I wanted to live as I understood was God’s way at the time. However, it became evident that my cooperating with his kind of headship was only making him a worse person…

After divorce I did not date because I was the mom of a young son who had one parent starting a new family and it seemed better to me to be all about my son than distracted about something for me in these formative years. I intended to wait till my son was married or had begun a career before I considered marriage, and meanwhile learn to be content single - because I really needed to know if God even wanted me to marry. How do you know God’s will for that? So I did what I could do - I worked on accepting that His will might be to *not *marry. However I did fall in love unexpectedly as my son finished high school, and over time it became very clear to me that this was in fact God’s will. We pursued annulments which took 18 months, and then we married.

When I met and fell in love with my now husband, I had just received a healing of the heart from Jesus at a ministry in my now-husband’s state that God, through circumstances and miraculous encouragement, led me to. Even with the years of graces as a Catholic after my divorce, and the many ways God helped me, I still needed wholeness. Living in an abusive marriage for a long time causes PTSD, and I have become convinced that only Jesus can heal that. Psychology offers helps, but Jesus offers complete healing.

So my thought is, as painful as it is much of the time to be alone, particularly following the worse-aloneness of being in a marraige that is *not *a marraige, the lonely-aloneness seems to be a thing you have to get through before you are able to find God’s peace in the aloneness - to be alone yet abide in the peace that passes all understanding. And its a very good thing to know - its a pearl of great price! Worth every penny of the price you are paying now.

"The end of a thing is better than the beginning thereof". How many times I comforted myself with that phrase. I can tell you now from experience that its true. It will get better when you get through this, and meanwhile you can have the peace that passes all understanding. Seek it, and God will grant it.

I think I would have had “peace in aloneness” much sooner if I had accepted the situation I was in. My not-accepting was a deterrent to my goal of peace. It took a lot of grace to not dwell on the unfairnesses and injustices of my situation. But that’s what you need - grace - because your own effort tends to not get you too far in these big things.

Even now, when so much in my life is good, I can still go back and dwell on the injustices, the loss of my loved home, the financial difficulties and lack of financial stability that i had worked so diligently for - I suffered because of the situation and my ex who made it worse. Just recently some new information came to me that made me struggle again, and again I was very tempted to really dwell on unfairness. But I know what to do now, from experience. I ask Jesus to take away this bitterness and to make me forget the thoughts I am dwelling on. I feel the bitterness, and I offer up the pain of the bitterness while asking God to take it away and replace it with the way He’d rather me be. And He does! I am nearly over the recent incident. Like 95%. I will ask help for the last 5%. Such incidents rarely come up now because God has brought me far. But in the beginning it was constant need for help and grace, and God granted it.

I hope the annulment does not take ten years now. That is bad news to hear, and if there is any way you can hurry the process, you must do what you can possibly do, and actively trust God for the rest. One of the greatest things I learned in my long ordeal was to trust in Jesus. The Divine Mercy devotion had all new meaning. Praying the D.M.Chaplet is easy, and an easy prayer when you are stressed is a very good thing. But the Divine Mercy image means so much to me now because I truly had to learn to trust in Jesus. If it were not for the difficulty I would not know like I know now that I truly can trust Him! It makes me grateful for the bad marriage and the bad divorce, too! I sort of tell myself I must have been too thick-headed to learn this wonderful thing, so I had to go through a great difficulty in order to learn about trusting God. I am glad for it.

Praying for you now for the graces you need.
 
I left an abusive marriage. Because my ex husband (non Catholic) fought the process, it took six years and four months for a local decree. He has now announced his intention to appeal to Rome.
Is his motivation to “fight” the process simply a desire to hurt you, or does he genuinely dispute facts, express some genuine desire to remain married, reconcile, etc.?

It is surely poor form on the part of the church’s bureaucracy if it’s processes are such that a multi-year delay in decision is produced, regardless of whether the appellant is vindictive or genuine.
 
Fortunately the Rota is down to just a couple of years now, because of some procedural changes. They have several options: hear the case because they believe the appeal has merit, hear the case because they don’t believe it has merit but it is something new and interesting so they could use their decision as a legal precedent, refuse to hear it outright because it is only dilatory, or hand it to the archdiocese to hear.

Eliza10, I’m sure you have the best of intentions, but I feel like I just told you my father died and you told me that you know just how it feels because you had to put your cat down last week. I am well aware that it takes time to heal from an abusive relationship. I am through the lonely-aloneness, and God has redeemed these years and allowed me to be a part of some amazing things that I wouldn’t have done had I not been alone. All that is great, but the bottom line is that the will of a sinful man has thwarted the Church process in a very big way, and nobody can do a darn thing about it.

I’m happy for your prayers, but I’m not looking for advice (I have a canon lawyer for that, and after six and a half years, you can bet I know all about it) or speculation. I would just really like to meet someone who actually knows what I’m going through. Thanks 🙂
 
…It is surely poor form on the part of the church’s bureaucracy if it’s processes are such that a multi-year delay in decision is produced, regardless of whether the appellant is vindictive or genuine.
I do have some sympathy for tribunal personnel and how a “difficult” Party can cause delays and problems of many sorts. Nevertheless, you are correct. Indeed, according to both the spirit and letter of procedural law, such delays should not be allowed to happen.

Dan
 
Fortunately the Rota is down to just a couple of years now, because of some procedural changes. They have several options: hear the case because they believe the appeal has merit, hear the case because they don’t believe it has merit but it is something new and interesting so they could use their decision as a legal precedent, refuse to hear it outright because it is only dilatory, or hand it to the archdiocese to hear.

**Eliza10, I’m sure you have the best of intentions, but I feel like I just told you my father died and you told me that you know just how it feels because you had to put your cat down last week. ** I am well aware that it takes time to heal from an abusive relationship. I am through the lonely-aloneness, and God has redeemed these years and allowed me to be a part of some amazing things that I wouldn’t have done had I not been alone. All that is great, but the bottom line is that the will of a sinful man has thwarted the Church process in a very big way, and nobody can do a darn thing about it.

I’m happy for your prayers, but I’m not looking for advice (I have a canon lawyer for that, and after six and a half years, you can bet I know all about it) or speculation. ** I would just really like to meet someone who actually knows what I’m going through. ** Thanks 🙂
I was just looking up how many cases the Roman Rota decides in a year, and it’s something like 400–twice as many as previously.

catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=20376

Given that there are a billion Catholics around the globe and 24,000 annulment cases a year in the US, it’s not very likely that there are a lot of people in exactly your situation, even among people applying for annulments.
 
Fortunately the Rota is down to just a couple of years now, because of some procedural changes. They have several options: hear the case because they believe the appeal has merit, hear the case because they don’t believe it has merit but it is something new and interesting so they could use their decision as a legal precedent, refuse to hear it outright because it is only dilatory, or hand it to the archdiocese to hear.

Eliza10, I’m sure you have the best of intentions, but I feel like I just told you my father died and you told me that you know just how it feels because you had to put your cat down last week. I am well aware that it takes time to heal from an abusive relationship. I am through the lonely-aloneness, and God has redeemed these years and allowed me to be a part of some amazing things that I wouldn’t have done had I not been alone. All that is great, but the bottom line is that the will of a sinful man has thwarted the Church process in a very big way, and nobody can do a darn thing about it.

I’m happy for your prayers, but I’m not looking for advice (I have a canon lawyer for that, and after six and a half years, you can bet I know all about it) or speculation. I would just really like to meet someone who actually knows what I’m going through. Thanks 🙂
Well, I know exactly what it is for the will of a sinful man to thwart my life. I thought I made that plain. Maybe not? I can tell you that it was the sinful will of a man that put me through a horrible divorce and custody battle. It was terrifying to face losing my son because of lies I had to find evidence to refute. It was financially devastating because of the lawyer fees that costs me thousands upon thousands wiping out years of hard work and thrift and careful savings and which caused the loss of my home - right when suddenly facing life as a single mom.

I don’t know, maybe you are just looking for someone who understands your *exact *kind of pain (annulment prolongation) that you have experienced? Because you will not have any problem finding people who have experienced unfair pain caused by a sinful man (or woman).

I am glad you are healed and redeemed. God is good.
 
Yes, I am specifically talking about the annulment situation. Not to minimize an abusive marriage at all because it devastating, and a lot of people are still willfully blind to domestic abuse, but there are lots of us out here supporting each other. The specific trauma of having a rapist/abuser insist that we are one flesh, bound by God until death, and the fact that he can use MY Church process to tie me to him with no canonical consequence to himself, while attending Mass when I do and even being up in front as a cantor? That’s something that it’s really hard to find someone who can identify with. It makes me alternately want to bathe in Clorox and bludgeon him. He couldn’t stop me from leaving him or from divorcing him (though he made that hard, too), but he can very effectively keep me from moving on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top