Accepted as family

  • Thread starter Thread starter BlueEyedLady
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BlueEyedLady

Guest
This question stems from an interesting conversation that I was having with a few friends last night over dinner since we are all preparing to head home and see our families for the holidays with our significant others. When is a person considered a full-fledged member of your family?

In my family it happens pretty quick. Once you’re brought to dinner and you’re presented as a serious partner that’s it, you’re in. Its always been that way in my family. If you’re loved by one of us you are completely included by everyone else. We give you presents on your birthday and Christmas, you are welcome at any dinner or function, you are even welcome to stay with one of us if you are in town for the weekend and need a couch to crash on. Maybe it’s because I have a very small family. But no matter the reason, I love that it works this way. (Heck, the guy I was engaged to several years ago turned out to be gay, but we remained best friends and he is still welcome at every function, and my nieces still call him ‘uncle’. Even my current fiance loves him like a brother.)

How does it work in your family? Does religion play in to it? How soon would you feel comfortable considering your adult child’s SO family? What about your adult sibling’s SO? Did it take years after you were married to really feel included in your spouse’s family?
 
Well, in our family, my cousins boyfriend of nearly 4 years has been accepted in our family since they started dating. She brought him to dinner once, and ever since he’s been accepted at all family do’s and has become part of the family. Would feel strange to think of the family without including him. Him and my cousin come as a pair now.

It doesn’t really matter about religion to be honest. I am Catholic, she and her side of the family are baptist, my mother and father are atheist, and my grandparents are protestant. Doesn’t matter really.
 
In my family it is when Children or marriage is involved. I have a cousin who brings a different girl to each holiday. It is kind of a joke. I am bad with names and don’t even bother until I see her twice in a row…🤷
 
This question stems from an interesting conversation that I was having with a few friends last night over dinner since we are all preparing to head home and see our families for the holidays with our significant others. When is a person considered a full-fledged member of your family?

In my family it happens pretty quick. Once you’re brought to dinner and you’re presented as a serious partner that’s it, you’re in. Its always been that way in my family. If you’re loved by one of us you are completely included by everyone else. We give you presents on your birthday and Christmas, you are welcome at any dinner or function, you are even welcome to stay with one of us if you are in town for the weekend and need a couch to crash on. Maybe it’s because I have a very small family. But no matter the reason, I love that it works this way. (Heck, the guy I was engaged to several years ago turned out to be gay, but we remained best friends and he is still welcome at every function, and my nieces still call him ‘uncle’. Even my current fiance loves him like a brother.)

How does it work in your family? Does religion play in to it? How soon would you feel comfortable considering your adult child’s SO family? What about your adult sibling’s SO? Did it take years after you were married to really feel included in your spouse’s family?
It’s really cool that you have such a close family, alot of people are not that lucky.
I’ve only had one girlfriend, my current one, I hope to marry her. She lives down the street and our mothers were close growing up. My sister who is one year old than me has always been one of her best friends. Before we were together she was always around for Christmas, Easter, etc. and often came to mass with us. It hasn’t been different now that we’re together, just that we spend more time together. If she weren’t Catholic I don’t think she would be as much part of the family and I don’t think I would want to be with her in the first place… Actually, I don’t really know… We’re both devout Catholics so it’s irrelevant.
God bless you. 🙂
 
This question stems from an interesting conversation that I was having with a few friends last night over dinner since we are all preparing to head home and see our families for the holidays with our significant others. When is a person considered a full-fledged member of your family?

In my family it happens pretty quick. Once you’re brought to dinner and you’re presented as a serious partner that’s it, you’re in. Its always been that way in my family. If you’re loved by one of us you are completely included by everyone else. We give you presents on your birthday and Christmas, you are welcome at any dinner or function, you are even welcome to stay with one of us if you are in town for the weekend and need a couch to crash on. Maybe it’s because I have a very small family. But no matter the reason, I love that it works this way. (Heck, the guy I was engaged to several years ago turned out to be gay, but we remained best friends and he is still welcome at every function, and my nieces still call him ‘uncle’. Even my current fiance loves him like a brother.)

How does it work in your family? Does religion play in to it? How soon would you feel comfortable considering your adult child’s SO family? What about your adult sibling’s SO? Did it take years after you were married to really feel included in your spouse’s family?
My family is the same as yours. His family…“not so much”. Not in any sense of the word.
 
So funny you mention it, because I remember my wife (at the time, fiancee) once got into an “argument” about this.

It turns out, we interpreted the word “family” differently… and that’s all there was to it.

At the time, she said that I was her “family” and I said she wasn’t my “family.” I told her that making her a member of family, starting a new family together… that was one of the main reasons I wanted to marry her. I was looking at it in a more official way, I.E., once we are married, then we were family.

She was upset because she interpreted it differently. To her, when I said that marriage will “make us” a family, she interpreted my words to mean, “When we marry, my feelings for you will suddenly change overnight.”

But that wasn’t what I was saying. So I had to clarify that I just meant “officially,” but in my heart, yes, we were already family.

To address your question more directly, my fiancee was “accepted” as “family” after about two years of dating, a couple years before we got engaged.
 
I’m not really sure. My sisters and I never invited men to family events like Christmas day before being engaged. Certainly our family met men we were dating, especially if we dated seriously. However, I would not have expected a man I was just dating to be considered family.

My husband and I both felt welcomed by family once we ourselves were dating seriously and planning marriage.
 
Wow, I have never invited any of the people I previously dated to meet my parents. I never liked nor understood how I could introduce someone to my family (who mean to world to mean) because I simply do not want anyone getting attached if it is not going to work out–pride too I guess. I would feel like a fool to have wasted time and effort into a relationship that didn’t last and ontop of that, waste my family’s time (A little extreme in thinking, I am aware).
My close friends would joke that the first man I brought home to meet my parents was the one I was going to marry…:o
 
For me it has to do with marriage. My brother has a relationship that is probably going somewhere but I don’t consider his gf to be a part of family yet.

My husband’s parents are very different, something like the OPs. When we started dating he immediately introduced me and I was then invited to all family gatherings. I was in. But that made me feel extremely uncomfortable because I wasn’t used to that kind of approach. Also, I wondered how genuine they were because they didn’t even know me as a person. For example, whenever my BIL brings home a new girl she is treated the same way, ie. like family. I feel like that doesn’t really mean much.
 
I tried to bring a guy home for Christmas one year because we were serious, and my mother was aghast that I would bring a “stranger” into the house for Christmas. When he and I got engaged 3 months later, she was aghast that I would get engaged to somebody they’d never met. I was finally allowed to bring him home, and mom had THREE framed photos of my college boyfriend on display in the house, including one on the fridge. They were clearly not happy at our wedding and didn’t treat my husband like part of the family for a long time. Mom came around after 12 years; it took Dad 14 years and a cancer diagnosis.

Meanwhile, they accepted my sister’s husband (who grew up down the street) as soon as they had their first date, and my younger sister’s female partner on the first visit (wanting to be politically correct, of course). They never liked my brother’s first wife (married right out of high school, divorced in less than 2 years, no kids), but they warmed up to his second wife after a year or two.

They didn’t like my husband because (1) he is a devoted Christian, (2) he was in a rock band, (3) he’s younger than I am, and (4) he’s from Nebraska, which in their minds must mean that he’s a white supremacist (I don’t get it, either). So religion is part of it - my parents rejecting my husband’s religion.

My husband’s family welcomed me right away, gave me presents my first Christmas with them (the same one that my mom refused to let me bring my guy home), etc., but I’m not 100% part of the family. For example, in family photos of 4 generations, it’s my mil’s parents, mil and fil and her siblings and their spouses, my husband and his siblings & cousins but NO spouses, and the great-grandkids. The third-generation spouses all stand around feeling awkward. I mean, I’ve been in the family for more than 17 years and I still don’t count for stuff like that? I’m good enough to wash the dishes and clean up after a family party, but not to be in the photo. Kind of weird. We’re all Christians, so that doesn’t explain it.
 
I think my husband was accepted as family after I had been dating him for a year or two. If there are family pictures or anything of that nature he is included in them. If he tries to hop out of family pictures he’s pulled right back in.

His family is the opposite. It has been made clear time and time again that I am not family. My children are family, but I am not. Pretty much anyone my brother and sister in law are dating become family instantly, but that isn’t extended to me. The bottom line is they don’t like me and refuse to treat me as family. Nothing I have tried to do over the years has made a difference. My mother-in-law and my husband’s brother and sister are the least accepting. My father-in-law is the only one to remotely treat me as a member of the family. My husband’s extended family (aunts, uncles, cousins) are the ones who see me as family on his side.

My mother-in-law was notorious for asking me to step out of pictures when they were taking family pictures. I’ve been asked to get out of pictures with my husband and his siblings, and even pictures with my children and other family members. It’s a hurtful and mean thing to do to someone who is actually part of the family whether or not you like them.

My husband had a falling out with his family earlier this year so now we’re all “out” of the family on his side. Funny thing is being black listed isn’t much different from when he and the kids were “in” the family given how infrequently they had anything to do with us prior to that.
 
When *ARE *you family? When born into, legally adopted into, or married into a family.

When are you treated *LIKE *family? Varies from family to family and situation to situation based on culture, custom, and other factors.
 
When *ARE *you family? When born into, legally adopted into, or married into a family.

When are you treated *LIKE *family? Varies from family to family and situation to situation based on culture, custom, and other factors.
We can get technical and argue semantics and philosophy, or you can answer what was supposed to be an interesting but lighthearted question about families since its the holidays and everyone’s seeing them. I vote for the latter.😃
 
I’ve been waiting 40 years so I’ll let you know if I ever join the in crowd.
In my family, immediately.

In my spouses family, never. What a culture shock. On her death bed my mother-in-law apologized to me saying we were of different culture. Ironic because our back grounds were the same. Something she would never acknowledge.

Daughter in law is the same way cannot accept us as family.

What is hard to remember is that my son’s girlfriend is not family, yet.
 
I’ve been waiting 40 years so I’ll let you know if I ever join the in crowd.
Oh geez! :eek: Sounds like quite a tale… my extended family can be quite cliquish at times, but I believe it has to do with how many of us there are.

My in-laws have been quite accepting and welcoming of me, but they are extremely dysfunctional, so we keep a healthy distance at all costs. They act as if we are stuck up sometimes, as in ‘geez, why won’t you come sleep in our smoke-laden, pet-hair covered home? your wife’s asthma can’t be THAT bad. Guess you guys are too good for that’, but we brush it off. 🤷

My family accepted him while we were dating because he stuck around for so long. We got pregnant 😊 before being engaged or married, but they didn’t have any hard feelings against him for it. If anything they were more angry/disappointed with me. I think my grandmothers breathed a giant sigh of relief when we got married a few years ago, and have been more receptive since!

Religion doesn’t really play much into acceptance, although I think my Grandmother joins me in prayer for his possible conversion one day ;). My mother in law is Southern Baptist and has very strong opinions about ‘other’ religions, but she knows better than to get into it with me.
 
In my family generally they are excepted as family once they start coming to family gatherings and such. The fam gets them presents and everything. My hubbies family, not so much. Most of them accepted me as family once we got married, but some still haven’t, like his Mom, but she is mad because I “took her baby away”.lol. It does suck though. She is mean to me even though she thinks I am “good people” and she liked me up until we got married.
 
You’re family the day you get married. You’re not family before though adults are always welcome to bring SO to family events. Well I should correct that. When I was a teenager, my cousins and I occassionally brought our high school sweethearts along. Occassionally we were allowed to bring friends as well. However its always understood that they’re the guest of a family member, not an actual family member.

In regards to gift giving, the family is large so you just can’t reasonably give everyone a birthday gift. Usually Godparents and parents and grandparents are expected to give Birthday and Christmas presents to a particular member. Other than that occassionally we play Secret Santa at Christmas that way everyone gets a gift without going broke. And usually the spending limit is low so that there isn’t a huge gap between the type of gifts the wealthier family members gave and the poorer family members gave.
How soon would you feel comfortable considering your adult child’s SO family?
When they’re married. Other than that they are so and so SO.
What about your adult sibling’s SO?
Same. When they’re married.
Did it take years after you were married to really feel included in your spouse’s family?
No. I’d say the biggest adjustment was getting used to the idea that my husband was my family. I had a lot of trouble breaking out of the mold that my parents and siblings were my immediate family. My in-laws are my in-laws. Now my mother in law invited me to call her mom after we got married. However once we got married I switched from calling her Mrs. (last name) to her first name. I don’t think I’d ever be comfortable calling her “Mom.”
 
My mother-in-law was notorious for asking me to step out of pictures when they were taking family pictures. I’ve been asked to get out of pictures with my husband and his siblings, and even pictures with my children and other family members. It’s a hurtful and mean thing to do to someone who is actually part of the family whether or not you like them.
That is seriously disgusting. You’re the mother of her grandchildren. If she rejects you she’s rejecting her own son and her grandchildren as well. Praying for your family and especially her.
 
I’ve been married for years and had my husband’s son, but I’m still not accepted as family. My in-laws treat me like dirt. This last Thanksgiving, I let him make the 3-hour drive to visit them with our son, but stayed home and had some “me” time rather than let those people pick on me for two whole days.

The last words my husband’s sister said to him as he was leaving were: “Tell your wife we missed her – we missed picking on her!”

I’m so jealous of people with nice accepting loving families I could cry. 😦 😦 😦
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top