Act of Contrition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter veilofveronica
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

veilofveronica

Guest
Hi all,
Both times I went to Confession recently, the priest didn’t prompt me to make an Act of Contrition…is this usual??
 
Hi all,
Both times I went to Confession recently, the priest didn’t prompt me to make an Act of Contrition…is this usual??
It’s not usual, but it’s not unheard of. Sometimes, the priest is pressed for time and doesn’t ask for one, and there are other reasons, as well. If he doesn’t ask you for one, it’s fine - just say it after you’ve been absolved and have left the confessional before you start your penance.
 
Hi all,
Both times I went to Confession recently, the priest didn’t prompt me to make an Act of Contrition…is this usual??
Sometimes it happens…Just say it when you leave the confessional.

I’ve noticed when it’s very busy sometimes they instruct me to pray it myself in the pew.
 
The last time I went to confession the priest didn’t ask me to recite the Act of Contrition. I started praying it just out of habit and the priest cut me off with a “God bless you and have a nice day.” Maybe he had poor hearing. But if he didn’t, it seems like he could have waited the extra 30 seconds.
 
I haven’t been asked for an Act of Contrition during Confession since 1990. The last priest who asked was a retired elderly man. I always make sure I say one before I go in.
 
Since I belong to a parish that has four or five priests, and since many of them are reassigned somewhat frequently, I’ve been to confession with some 15 priests or so over the past couple of years.

Of all of them, two did not regularly ask for an act of contrition. But, after offering advice and assigning a penance, they do ask something like this — *and you’re sorry for all of your sins, right?
*
I think the key to keep in mind is that the act of contrition is meant, amongst other things, to demonstrate to the priest that you actually have contrition. If the priest is able to make this judgment without an act of contrition, then they may very well carry on and absolve you. One way or t’other, it’s Father’s call.

Having said that, I’m not sure what the actual Rite of Penance calls for, and whether or not this is a bit of an abuse. I suspect the question I mentioned above probably fulfills any obligation on the priest’s part.
 
Hi all,
Both times I went to Confession recently, the priest didn’t prompt me to make an Act of Contrition…is this usual??
It depends on the country. In the English-speaking world, the Act of Contrition is traditionally required. Not so in the Eastern Europe.
 
It depends on the country. In the English-speaking world, the Act of Contrition is traditionally required. Not so in the Eastern Europe.
I’m in Canada…I’ve found it varies according to the priest.
 
It depends on the country. In the English-speaking world, the Act of Contrition is traditionally required. Not so in the Eastern Europe.
In Poland, the faithful pray the Act of Contrition while the priest says the Prayer of Absolution. Both are basically praying two different prayers at the same time.
 
I’m in Canada…I’ve found it varies according to the priest.
True. The last time I was asked for one was also the first time I’d ever had to confess in English. I had to ask Fr. if it was OK to recite it in French.
 
My priest has it written in bold letters in the confessional. He expects us to say it.
 
My priest never asks for an Act of Contrition. I do habitually end my confessions with “for these and all my sins, I am truly sorry” so I guess I make it clear without being asked that I am sorry for my sins.
 
True. The last time I was asked for one was also the first time I’d ever had to confess in English. I had to ask Fr. if it was OK to recite it in French.
At the abbey, I think they often get people in confession who haven’t been for a v-e-r-y long time. The regular confessor knows that I know the act of contrition, so he always invites me to say it. However he has been away since November in Rome. For the Year of Mercy he has been asked to be confessor at St. Paul-Outside-the-Walls until May. So the old confessor that was prior to him has been pressed back into service, and the last couple of times he said “I don’t recall if you know the act of contrition”, and I say “yes” and recite it.

The regular confessor, the first time I confessed with him, also asked me if I knew it, and said yes. But I remember one time I started to recite it and my mind went completely blank. I eventually found my words again and managed to get through it, but it was a bit embarrassing!

Like you I say in French. I wouldn’t know how to say it in English. Same with the Our Father for that matter. I can recite it in French, or Latin, but couldn’t recite it in English to save my life. And when I went to a Mass in English fir the first time in years last year, I hadn’t been for such a long time that it was the first time I heard the new translations and I was completely confused when it came to reciting the responses.
 
Like you I say in French. I wouldn’t know how to say it in English. Same with the Our Father for that matter. I can recite it in French, or Latin, but couldn’t recite it in English to save my life. And when I went to a Mass in English fir the first time in years last year, I hadn’t been for such a long time that it was the first time I heard the new translations and I was completely confused when it came to reciting the responses.
No problem with the Our Father and the Hail Mary for me. While not officially a Catholic school, the primary school I attended did have Catechism in class. It was also a bilingual school, so when I started school Mère Marie-des-Lys, fdj, taught grade 1 French in French, grade 1 English in English, and grade 2 English in English - in the same classroom. We heard all the prayers in English and in French so I learned them that way.

Needless to say I was fluent in English by the time I left grade 1. I was still not pronouncing my "h"s to my mother’s satisfaction but I learned – although I still have to hesitate when faced with a combination like “old house”, “happy otter”, etc. Of course in NL I don’t have to worry too much about it, they drop and pick up "h"s all over the place. Many locals who’ve never spoken a word of French would say “hold ouse” and “appy hotter”.
 
I was taught that priests are able to absolve sins if they discern that the penitent is contrite and has a firm resolve not to commit the sins again. Therefore, the purpose of the Act of Contrition is to help the priest reach the conclusion that this is the state of mind of the penitent.

Some priests wish the penitent to recite a memorized prayer; some allow the penitent to state these facts in their own words; still other priests are OK with discerning these things in the absence of a penitent’s prayer.
 
I was taught that priests are able to absolve sins if they discern that the penitent is contrite and has a firm resolve not to commit the sins again. Therefore, the purpose of the Act of Contrition is to help the priest reach the conclusion that this is the state of mind of the penitent.

Some priests wish the penitent to recite a memorized prayer; some allow the penitent to state these facts in their own words; still other priests are OK with discerning these things in the absence of a penitent’s prayer.
I’m not sure how reciting a memorized prayer can really help the priest discern contrition any more than just the fact that the person is in confession. If a person is in confession for some reason other than a true desire for the sacrament, then reciting an Act of Contrition would just be one more step in going through the motions.
 
My priest never asks for an Act of Contrition. I do habitually end my confessions with “for these and all my sins, I am truly sorry” so I guess I make it clear without being asked that I am sorry for my sins.
In your case and with that priest, that’s perhaps that’s true. My confessor invites me to recite an Act of Contrition anyway, even though “I accuse myself, furthermore, of all the sins I may have forgotten, and those of my past”. Maybe my contrition is not so evident. :o
But I remember one time I started to recite it and my mind went completely blank. I eventually found my words again and managed to get through it, but it was a bit embarrassing!
This happened to me last Saturday, in fact. It was my first confession after surgery; I don’t do well with general anesthesia. :banghead: Father had to prompt me with the first seven words. Still, given that the previous week I couldn’t always remember my name, I’m surprised seven words were enough to get me going…
And when I went to a Mass in English fir the first time in years last year, I hadn’t been for such a long time that it was the first time I heard the new translations and I was completely confused when it came to reciting the responses.
When the new English translation came into use I had not been to Mass in English for five years. The first time I did (in the UK, 2013), I was completely lost. Because English is my native language, the people I spoke to after Mass thought I was a lapsed Catholic who had been inspired to return to the Church, and they wanted to hear my “story.” God bless them. In reality, I had been attending Mass weekly for years and daily for several months…in French. 😃
 
In Poland, the faithful pray the Act of Contrition while the priest says the Prayer of Absolution. Both are basically praying two different prayers at the same time.
How interesting! We have a Peruvian priest at one of our churches who does the same thing. I was like: How rude! Man is drowning me out! (God forgive me…)
 
How interesting! We have a Peruvian priest at one of our churches who does the same thing. I was like: How rude! Man is drowning me out! (God forgive me…)
At the four different churches where I confess in Chicago, this is normal: Priest says the absolution while I am praying act of contrition.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top