Action movies-bad?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jason3477
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jason3477

Guest
You all remember those movies with Arnold Shwarzanaeger and those movies with Van Damne and or Steven Segeal=back in the 1980’s and 1990’s???

I watched most of them back in the day lol…

Do you think they’re bad/wrong/immoral to watch?
 
I don’t enjoy them personally, but they are only immoral/bad if they cause you to act immorally. IE-If violent video games make you want to kill people, avoid them. If violent movies make you want to kill people, avoid them as well.
 
The Old Testament is very violent, so clearly violence should not be tossed out for its mere presence.

Glorification of violence is bad, though.

So I would look at the plot, and how the violence advances it. For example, The Book of Eli is a fairly violent movie, but I believe that the violence makes perfect sense in the context and that in its totality, the plot of the film is very positive.
 
I’d say that it depends on how the movies affect you personally. If watching a car chase scene makes you feel like it’s a good idea to jump in your car and start driving unsafely, then it’s probably not a good idea to watch action movies with car chases. If watching a movie with a shooting scene makes you feel like getting a gun so you can feel that rush of shooting one, then gun movies are probably not a good idea. (That’s not to say that having a gun is a bad idea in and of itself, it’s just that people need to be responsible about owning one.)

If you are the type of person who can watch the movie and understand that it’s all faked–cinematic camera angles, small clips of video edited together so they look cool, done in a studio, etc–then you should be fine. Also context is important. Movies that are just out to glorify violence for the sake of violence are probably not a great idea to see. But some movies use violence and action to help further the plot.
 
Some are a bit silly, but I don’t see them as a black/white or good/bad issue… they just exist.

I do think that you should not let small children watch action flicks, and monitor what they do watch as they age… it’s never good to expose little ones to graphic violence!
 
I also watched a lot of the genre the OP brings up. Common elements of which are:

-extreme amounts of violence
-some use of profanity
-some sexual content

The violence is almost always used in a manner that would not qualify as just under Church teaching.

So putting aside any concerns about TV or movies in general, “action movies” of the type you bring up have several problems of their own.

For a very long time I resisted the idea that violent movies, tv, or video games desensitives people to violence. I’ve since changed my view. I think even more than desensitizing people, though, it distorts their view of violence.

If you watch Van Damme or Arnold or Stallone and think that is how violence is you are totally clueless. Put on some gloves and go a few rounds with your brother or go out in the backyard and shoot some targets with your dad. That is how a young man should learn the reality of conflict along with being taught by his father when and how force should be used and when it should not.

Pax
 
Thank you Dan. That’s what I was getting at… Steven Segal was a lot of vigilante justice or soemthing like that.

And a lot of the violence was uncalled for. But those were movies of the 1980’s and 1990’s.
 
You all remember those movies with Arnold Shwarzanaeger and those movies with Van Damne and or Steven Segeal=back in the 1980’s and 1990’s???

I watched most of them back in the day lol…

Do you think they’re bad/wrong/immoral to watch?
I certainly hope not. But if it’s rated R, it would probably be a good idea to stay away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top