Acts Committed While Lucid Dreaming; Can They be Sinful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joshua_M
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joshua_M

Guest
I am interested in lucid dreaming, but I am concerned about the spiritual risks involved.
If you have control over your dream and if you commit sinful acts in the dreams, are you actually sinning?

Some people have described being able to lucid dream fighting monsters and such things. Since this would be mere fantasy, like a game, I doubt that these things are sinful.

However, people have also reported committing sexual acts while in a lucid dream. Would this be a sin of lust?
If it is a sin, can other things in a lucid dream be sins?
 
This is where the skepticism and conundrum really comes in. Because evidently, you are not culpable for anything you dream about, because it’s just that a dream, thus some would say it’s IMPOSSIBLE to “sin” in a dream.

However, full disclosure, in the times I have had a lucid dream, I always try to fly or have as much sex as possible if we’re being honest. So hence that’s a great question you have.
 
Jimmy Akin (a Catholic apologist who has had a long relationship with Catholic Answers) addressed this in a blog post once: Sinful Activity In Lucid Dreams? – Jimmy Akin

To try to put his response in a nutshell, if you just happen to have a lucid dream, you don’t really have full control over your actions in the dream, and so the most you could be guilty of is venial sin, and even that might be a stretch. However, if you deliberately try to have lucid dreams so that you can fantasize about engaging in sinful activity, that would be a sin. Also, if you find that deliberately having lucid dreams tends to lead you to fantasizing about committing sinful acts, then it is a near occasion of sin that you should avoid.
 
reminds me of the Freddy Kruger movies, If you die in your dream , you die in real life !

1,2 Freddy’s coming for you;

( disclaimer, none of this is a personal attack on anyone, if anyone is offended please feel free to say so and whine till your hearts delight, i wont engage in a conversation with those who are offended )
 
Last edited:
So if you intend to enact something sinful by the power of your imagination it is a sin. However, if you’re like me and just want to be able to pray / fly while you sleep its okay.
 
As I understand it, that is correct. But, if you find that when you go into lucid dreams intending to fly around, you end up doing things you shouldn’t, then you would need to recognize that it is a near occasion of sin.

Personally, I sometimes have lucid dreams without trying, but I avoid trying to have them.
 
I think we’re getting a little too scrupulous and analytical here. After all we’re talking about dreams and imagination in general. In a state of REM sleep the last thing anyone needs to worry about is guilt about flying or having sex or indulging in any fictional fantasy. Because…it’s a dream and not real.
 
There is a big difference between fantasizing about flying, which has no moral implications as far as I know, and sexual fantasy. The latter takes something created for a sacred purpose and turns it into something that is merely a source of physical pleasure.
Matthew 5:27-28 – “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall not commit adultery.’ But I say to you, everyone who looks at a woman with lust has already committed adultery with her in his heart.”
CCC:2351
“Lust is disordered desire for or enjoyment of sexual pleasure. Sexual pleasure is morally disordered when sought for itself, isolated from its procreative and unitive purposes.”
 
I agree, but isn’t it accepted 100% that you can’t sin if you’re dreaming? So what about sexual dreams and nocturnal emissions, which are quite real and happen quite often?
 
In an ordinary dream, thoughts just occur, and there is no control or choice involved. If one of these ordinary dreams includes sexual scenarios, it is still not a sin, because the dreamer had no more choice in dreaming about sex than if he were to have been dreaming about being late for work or having forgotten to put his pants on before going on stage to give a speech.

With nocturnal emissions, again, there is no choice involved – it is a spontaneous event.

Lucid dreaming is specific type of dream in which the dreamer is aware of being in a dream state and is able to control the narrative to some extent. Often, people enter this state without trying – they just happen to be in the middle of a dream during normal sleep and suddenly find themselves aware at some level that they are dreaming. Then, sometimes, they are able to manipulate the situation to their liking, even making the people around them respond the way they want. I have these kinds of dreams sometimes, and while I do have some ability to impact the direction of the dream, I am not able to make clear moral decisions about what goes on in the dream. Usually, I am already imagining a particular scenario within a dream when the dream becomes lucid, and at that point I can kind of mentally nudge things in a certain direction. Sometimes I can “undo” bad things within the dream and make them come out better. But there is no real moral decision making involved, even if the situation I find myself in happens to involve sinful behavior. Therefore, I agree with Jimmy Akin (linked above) that this kind of dream is not really a sin.

There is yet another kind of lucid dreaming, however, that some people can enter deliberately. It is essentially self-hypnosis – one gradually puts oneself into a dreamlike state, meanwhile envisioning certain scenarios that one wishes to dream about. I think it is fine if one is just going to imagine flying around, or exploring magical caves, or whatever. Where it becomes a problem is if one deliberately enters this state intending to dream about – and experience pleasure in – engaging in immoral behavior. Also, if one has a tendency to enter this process intending to engage in benign fantasy but end up fantasizing about the immoral, I would describe that as a near occasion of sin. For me, I can enter this state if I try, but I find it better if I don’t.
 
Last edited:
if you just happen to have a lucid dream, you don’t really have full control over your actions in the dream, and so the most you could be guilty of is venial sin, and even that might be a stretch. However, if you deliberately try to have lucid dreams so that you can fantasize about engaging in sinful activity, that would be a sin. Also, if you find that deliberately having lucid dreams tends to lead you to fantasizing about committing sinful acts, then it is a near occasion of sin that you should avoid.
I agree with you.
 
However when it really comes down to it, you never have total control about what you dream about. Therefore I don’t see how it could ever be counted as a “sin” in my opinion. Just think of the guilt one would have if you dreamt about doing really bad things.
 
In the end it seems like a “what happens when an immovable object meets an irresistible force” type question. A tautology.

In other words its a prudential judgement whether “lucid dreams” really are as free as we think they are.
And if we don’t normally go around wanting sex with every woman we meet then is that really us in the lucid dream.

If we wanted to be casuistic about it we could pose the following questions perhaps:
  1. Can a dream ever be grave matter despite feelings of lucidness. I believe the answer is traditionally no.
    In which case venial sin is possible but not mortal sin.
  2. Is it a capital sin even if not grave matter? Yes, acts of lust are capital sins (though the least). What this means is that they incline one further to sin and other sins also. Therefore wanting to have such lucid dreams (in addition to voluntarily engaging in them) is definitely not the path to a closer walk with Jesus but the opposite.
  3. Is real life and dreaming in fact a human continuum anyways? Not only can some of us have lucid dream, some of us can be spaced out in daily life. We drive home and try to recall the last 5 mins and…complete blank. We were on auto-pilot, we know we were “aware” at the time but now…zero. Scary.
And actually nornmal life is like this even in more subtle ways surely. We have set/routine ways we deal with people, home relationships. We may well commit serious sins by doing so in non-routine circumstances we do not fully avert to. Sometime totally avert, sometimes partially avert. Its surely naiive to think we always totally avert to our daily bads. So we dream a bit even in normal “real life” too.

The normal rules apply I would think to everything then:
  • if conscious of grave sin confess asap.
  • if not sure…confess at your usual regular time.
  • if personally sure you didn’t sin in a grave matter (highly unusual) … confess asap if a public matter (like receiving Communion publicly while remarried but are sure in conscience you are innocent 🙂 ).
So dreaming, lucid or not, seems to fall into the second type as above to me.
 
Last edited:
To whatever extent one does have control, if one exercises that control in order obtain pleasure in fantasizing about doing evil, one is responsible. I’m assuming the OP is talking about deliberate lucid dreaming, not spontaneous.
 
There is no such thing as deliberate lucid dreaming. You can concentrate and try, but you can’t fully control ever what you dream about.
 
That is not quite true Jamie, we can control our dreams with practice. With practice we can solve a problem or end a recurring dream/nightmare. There are also techniques to significantly increase the chances of lucid dreaming.
 
With practice we can solve a problem or end a recurring dream/nightmare. There are also techniques to significantly increase the chances of lucid dreaming.
Exactly. And if someone finds that when they employ these techniques, they generally end up taking pleasure in things they shouldn’t, I would say they need to consider whether deliberately having lucid dreams is a near occasion of sin for them.

There are also processes involving self-hypnosis through which one can basically dream whatever one wants. I don’t think it’s necessarily sinful to use this technique if one has the right motives, but that’s the issue.

In either case, the choice in question is the one we make before going to sleep – am I trying to indulge in something I shouldn’t?

I wouldn’t worry about the dreams one just happens to have that seem to be lucid. In that case, the dreamer probably has very little control over the dream, and no control=no choice=no sin, unless one deliberately relinquishes that control.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top