J
Jay53
Guest
This is just your speculation regarding how Adam and Eve were evaluating their situation. My point is that Eve didn’t ASK God before she partook of the fruit. Eating of the fruit was not 1 of 2 equally acceptable options. It was a commandment that Adam & Eve broke.Again, the question becomes what Eve thought they needed versus what she had been told were her choices, and what her experiences had already led her to find out in the course of her life up to that point. She didn’t have wisdom at that point, nor reason to believe it would descend upon her along with the attribute of “joy” without her doing something to receive those qualities into her life along with Adam.
My point is that Adam being a “status quo” individual would have said to Eve, “wait–we have everything we need right here–don’t seek more than what we already have” and she could innately feel that that was not correct.
Again, what evidence that “God would have provided them what they needed” given that He had indeed provided them a tree with fruit about the knowledge of good and evil, but had given them a choice about eating that fruit and that led to consequences that brought the opportunities for experience, wisdom, and joy to humankind?
Again, she had a whole set of commandments and a few teachings, one of which was that they should “leave father and mother, and be one flesh”. If she has been told to leave her father (which she had been told) then why not be able to figure out that this leaving of her father means that she will be out of the presence of her father and that such an experience will offer the opportunity of gaining wisdom by making choices?
Every daughter who leaves the home of her parents, has to decide whether by leaving her parents she is expressing love to them or is expressing selfishness. If she thinks only that such a decision is expressing selfishness, then I think she does not really understand love or the love of a parent for their child. What parent (besides one who is self-centered enough to want to either protect their child from the outside world or to keep that child at home because that child happens to bring happiness to the parent) is not happy when that child leaves home, begins a marriage with a companion chosen by God, and begins experiencing life away from home?
I have said all along that Eve did not express not loving God by partaking the forbidden fruit, nor did God say “now I know you don’t trust me or trust my commandments”.
I don’t believe I ever said that Eve didn’t still love God or feel sorrow for her sin. Or that God didn’t love her anymore because of her sin.God never said “Eve, now I know you really don’t love me.” He said in so many words, "Eve, here are the consequences that I had promised you would receive (actually, more consequences but ones consistent with what I had promised to you and Adam).
And Eve did not need to “leave” God to experience companionship with Adam. God is certainly a part of my marriage and I didn’t/don’t need to leave Him to experience anything with my husband.
How would you expect me to describe what the alternate reality before the fall would have been if the fall had never taken place.Go ahead and describe their alternate reality, including the kinds of choices they could make and the kind of joy they could experience, and explain why it is not the comparative joy and decision-making of a five-year-old or a seven-year-old.
No, you obviously don’t need to go into the details. I am very familiar with the whole process.Wait–I don’t think I need to go into a discussion about what a menstrual cycle is, since that is taught in schools or can be researched in an encyclopedia. (Hint: It begins with a living egg cell, and something happens to that egg cell.)
I am guessing that you are theorizing that because the egg cell dies if it is not fertilized and there was no “death” in the Garden of Eden that Eve could not have children. ??? However, skin cells (as well as other body cells) also die and are regenerated through normal physical processes. Unless you are going to contend that Adam & Eve were somehow physically different than the rest of us.