Yes, I don't mean to be disrespectful, but you urge non-Catholic Christians to chime in, so here goes.
I am a 'big tent' Christian, which is to say that I try my best to honor the different expressions of the faith. Personally, I am what many would call a 'liberal Protestant' in that I do not find either legalistic, ritualistic practices or Biblical fundamentalism attractive.
As for what we sometimes refer to as 'high church', whenever I attend a Catholic or a high Episcopal Church (such as 'Smoky Mary's' near Times Square, an Anglo-Catholic parish) I feel like - sorry - I am at a medieval ceremony, that I am witnessing an ancient rite that might have attracted me 1000 years ago when there were so many superstitions, before the microscope and telescope, but seems alien to me today. The Adoration of the Holy Sacrament is among those ancient practices that I find interesting from an historic point of view but not one I could indulge in today. Frankly, such traditions seem like idolatry, giving too much respect to graven images. On the other hand, I know that sincere worshipers don't regard them that way and try my best to appreciate their perspective.
At the same time, I have trouble with Bible-pounding preachers who lift up this or that Bible verse to threaten us with hell fire, anticipate the Second Coming "anytime now" and seem to delight in anticipating Armageddon with its massive slaughter. They also applaud when Saul "kills his thousands but David kills his ten thousands", actually believe that the God of love commanded Joshua to slay everyone in Jericho, told Saul to murder every last Amalekite, etc. No wonder we get into all these wars! But I can't believe Jesus would sanction such wanton violence. And what about the Ten Commandments?
God bless Catholics, Protestants, Jews and others of every faith who seek to serve God in spirit and in truth. May religion become a bridge and not a barrier! And may we have peace in our lives, in our homes, and in our war-weary world.