I can’t really explain the reasons why but adult female servers are a HUGE turn-off to me. It’s something instinctual that I don’t really understand. I suspect to some degree it’s the actual individuals who try to serve but there is something more which I can’t explain.
The feeling is strong enough that I would consider switching parishes if most of the servers were adult females.
It seems like others in my parish feel the same way because when an adult female starts to serve, they typically stop fairly soon thereafter. I live in a very “progressive” diocese that no doubt champions this sort of thing but for some reason it just doesn’t work in my parish.
I do understand where you are coming from. However, our parish has an average of 25 people attend the Saturday Vigil Mass, and an average of approx. 50 people attend the Sunday mass. Add another 10 people who come only on Easter or Christmas and you have a parish of
maybe 100 people in the winter with the snow birds and 70 in the summer without the snow birds. We have 5 young men of the age to serve and all attend Sunday mass with their families and none attend daily mass. So if the adults didn’t serve, we’d not have anyone. We have 4 women and 1 man who regularly serve and one other man who is trained to serve but never has. No deacon.
Without the women servers, we’d not any servers at most daily masses and on Saturday.
Our priest has a VERY bad back and most often must use a cane. If he has no server it’s difficult for him to prepare for the Eucharist alone.
Bottom line, there was a need, no one else stepped forward, so we women did step forward. If any man in the parish doesn’t like the women serving, then he needs to volunteer. If other women don’t like it, then they need to get their hubby’s to step up and become servers.
We’re just doing the best we can. We all wear many hats as well, I’m also a lector, an EMHC, Sacristan for Saturday Vigil and Sunday mass, and I am a musician as well. There are times I long to go to a mass and just be a person in a pew!