Advice Needed

  • Thread starter Thread starter garn9173
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

garn9173

Guest
I have my 9 year old son every other weekend and when I have him, I always ask if he would like to go to Mass with me (i’ve been an inactive Catholic for several years and recently returned home and my soon to be ex-wife & son had been going to a church affiliated with The Evangelical Free Church of America that I never went to except for the kids Christmas Program that my son took part in).

When I have my son, I would like for him to go to Mass with me and he doesn’t want to because he knows it will be different from what he’s used to, he normally goes to a friend’s house or the aforementioned church youth program as they have service the same time that Mass takes place.

I tell him that we don’t have to sit in the main church and could sit in the daily Chapel which is the cry room during the weekend. I would really like for him to go with me just once and if he doesn’t like it fine, end of discussion and if he likes it, my Parish does have an RCIC program.

Any advice on how I could convince him to go to Mass with me? I thought of a daily Mass when he doesn’t have school and he’s with me, but that has yet to happen

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
 
He’s 9. Tell him you’re going to church and out to breakfast afterwards, he picks the place. When I was 9 I certainly didn’t have a choice about going to church.
 
He’s not going to like it at first. If you give him the out by telling him if he doesn’t like it, he doesn’t have to go, then guess what he’s going to say?

Tell him that he will be going to Mass with you on a regular basis, and then take him to IHOP or wherever he wants afterward. Connect it with another event that he loves to do with you. He’s 9, he can understand more than a young child - talk to him about your faith and what it means.

I hope that his mother will not try to undermine you in this effort, but I suspect that she might, considering you and she must not have agreed to raise the children as Catholics. I hope you at least parted on good terms.

Just be his dad, and take him anyway. We all have to do lots of things we may not want to, for our own good. Like work, eating, bathing, exercising, etc.
 
I have my 9 year old son every other weekend and when I have him, I always ask if he would like to go to Mass with me (i’ve been an inactive Catholic for several years and recently returned home and my soon to be ex-wife & son had been going to a church affiliated with The Evangelical Free Church of America that I never went to except for the kids Christmas Program that my son took part in).

When I have my son, I would like for him to go to Mass with me and he doesn’t want to because he knows it will be different from what he’s used to, he normally goes to a friend’s house or the aforementioned church youth program as they have service the same time that Mass takes place.

I tell him that we don’t have to sit in the main church and could sit in the daily Chapel which is the cry room during the weekend. I would really like for him to go with me just once and if he doesn’t like it fine, end of discussion and if he likes it, my Parish does have an RCIC program.

Any advice on how I could convince him to go to Mass with me? I thought of a daily Mass when he doesn’t have school and he’s with me, but that has yet to happen

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
Why are you asking your son what he wants to do? This is a reversal of the traditional and correct role of a parent and child… 🤷
 
He’s not going to like it at first. If you give him the out by telling him if he doesn’t like it, he doesn’t have to go, then guess what he’s going to say?

Tell him that he will be going to Mass with you on a regular basis, and then take him to IHOP or wherever he wants afterward. Connect it with another event that he loves to do with you. He’s 9, he can understand more than a young child - talk to him about your faith and what it means.

I hope that his mother will not try to undermine you in this effort, but I suspect that she might, considering you and she must not have agreed to raise the children as Catholics. I hope you at least parted on good terms.

Just be his dad, and take him anyway. We all have to do lots of things we may not want to, for our own good. Like work, eating, bathing, exercising, etc.
Agree - why are you asking him? He’s nine yrs old.
 
Thanks for the answers. My son has never stepped foot inside a Catholic church before and I don’t want to cause a ripple and if I continue to push the issue, he’s likely to whip out his Android phone that he has (I don’t think he needs one as he got it after the seperation) and call Mom to say i’m being mean.
 
"…he’s likely to whip out his Android phone that he has (I don’t think he needs one as he got it after the seperation) and call Mom to say i’m being mean. "

Wow. Ok, you call her first and let her know that’s the plan.

Oh, by the way I’m the meanest man in the world according to my kids. I make them go to mass, CCD, expect them to clean up after themselves, ensure they do their homework, make them get shots at the Dr. etc. etc. Ok by me, they can feel however they feel about me-- I’m not their friend, I’m their father- I’ll never be their friend as it’s a completely different role.

Yeah, you can be joyful about mass and all that but it just isn’t thrilling for a young boy. (Unless perhaps he takes enough of an interest to become an altar server, which I loved doing as a kid.) Part of their growing up is learning there are important things that aren’t all fun and games. Obligations, duty, responsibility. My 13 yr old doesn’t like going to mass, but he goes. As he learns and appreciates more about the Church and sacraments he’s understanding more about it’s importance. And he sees how my faith has helped me through the divorce and in taking care of them.

I’m luckier in that I can point out to him that I made a vow to God when he was baptized to raise him in the Church. He can choose something else when he’s older, but I’ll fulfill my vow to God.

(Actually had my eldest daughter scream, in front of a friend no less, at the age of 13 that she hated me after I told her to stop what she was doing and clean her room as she’d been told several times that morning. My response? ‘You can feel whatever you like about me, but you will do as you’re told’. )

I actually gave all my kids cell phones as it’s easier to track them, pick them up from various activities, arrange stuff. And my ex can call them at bed time every night, or they can call her during the night if they want/need to talk to their mommy. I trust that you are calling him every night he’s not with you, texting him little notes during the day, and he knows he can always call you.
 
Thanks for the answers. My son has never stepped foot inside a Catholic church before and I don’t want to cause a ripple and if I continue to push the issue, he’s likely to whip out his Android phone that he has (I don’t think he needs one as he got it after the seperation) and call Mom to say i’m being mean.
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

My kids used to call their dad and say I was mean. Then they would hand the phone over to me and he would give me a stern “talking to.”

Well, they are 21 and 24 now. Guess who is the nicest and best mom and cook in the world? 😛
 
Thanks for the answers. My son has never stepped foot inside a Catholic church before and I don’t want to cause a ripple and if I continue to push the issue, he’s likely to whip out his Android phone that he has (I don’t think he needs one as he got it after the seperation) and call Mom to say i’m being mean.
And Mom should say, “Son, do as your father asks you to do.” End of discussion. But I suspect you are going to say that she would drop everything, race over to pick him up, and assure him that he will never have to attend church if he doesn’t want to.

:mad:

Have the talk with your wife and lay down the conditions. Tell her that she needs to back you up on this, and that it’s for his own good.

Yeah, right…If you don’t want to cause a ripple, your boy is going to be sunk.

😦
 
What was your agreement with your wife while married regarding religious up bringing?

For example, in our case, DH agreed to raise children Catholic. It was explained upfront that was not up for negotiation.

Now, if for some reason we were divorced and he tried to take the kids to a different church, I’d have him in court. I would not budge on this unless court ordered to allow them to go elsewhere.
 
Unless I’m misreading, it seems that the kid also goes to a non-Catholic church. Aren’t any of you concerned that he could be getting conflicting religious instruction? That would be fine if it were a comparative religion course, but here it sounds like two sides pushing one religion as absolute fact… could be negative consequences there unless it’s straightened out.
 
And Mom should say, “Son, do as your father asks you to do.” End of discussion. But I suspect you are going to say that she would drop everything, race over to pick him up, and assure him that he will never have to attend church if he doesn’t want to.

:mad:

Have the talk with your wife and lay down the conditions. Tell her that she needs to back you up on this, and that it’s for his own good.
In an ideal world. There’s a reason why they divorced. Just guessing, but they can’t agree on a lot of things.:o
Yeah, right…If you don’t want to cause a ripple, your boy is going to be sunk.
I agree.
 
For all of those who say “Just tell a 9yo what to do” it’s not so easy when it comes to divorced parenting. And the custodial parent ususally gets to decide religion.

If your wife agrees than the kid have to go, if she dosnt’ you’re stuck.
 
For all of those who say “Just tell a 9yo what to do” it’s not so easy when it comes to divorced parenting. And the custodial parent ususally gets to decide religion.

If your wife agrees than the kid have to go, if she dosnt’ you’re stuck.
You’re right about the legality of what’s in the divorce agreement. If it’s covered, then the OP needs to abide by it or get it amended. Either by going back to court or by sitting down with the ex. In any case, since the OP had chosen to raise the boy along these lines prior to the divorce, he can not expect his son to embrace Catholicism. But I think it’s reasonable to expect the son to accompany his Dad to mass, to allow Dad to show the boy he wants to include him in all aspects of his life.

If the OP has the legal right to decide on how weekends with his son are spent including religious observances, I don’t think he should make it optional for his son. I think he needs to avoid the divorced-parent mentality/temptation of trying to make up for the divorce by catering to the child.

I also understand the concerns about participating in two approaches to christianity. However, I don’t think that is as big an issue for a 9 yr old. The differences should be explained, as well as the similarities/areas of agreement/common ground- with neither being disparaged. Dad needs to continue supporting his son’s participation with Mom in religious observance. The approach really needs to be exposure to two different practises and reasons as opposed to attempted conversion. I.E. son, this is important to me and I want to be able to share it with you. I appreciate you doing this with me as it helps me with my relationship with God. Just as I hope you have a good relationship with Him through whatever method you choose in the future.
 
Thanks for the answers. My son has never stepped foot inside a Catholic church before and I don’t want to cause a ripple and if I continue to push the issue, he’s likely to whip out his Android phone that he has (I don’t think he needs one as he got it after the seperation) and call Mom to say i’m being mean.
Take the phone away.
 
Take the phone away.
Really? I’ll tell you this much, if I were the custodial parent and I got my child a cellphone and my ex took it from him specifically so that he couldn’t contact me while away I would have my ex in court faster than you can say ‘android’. I would fight so hard to ensure that all future visits were supervised. Calling a parent is not a privilege, its a right, especially when it comes to the custodial parent.
 
My son has never stepped foot inside a Catholic church before. …
That is the very reason why it’s important to take him when he’s with you. So he doesn’t grow up afraid of setting foot inside a Catholic church . . .I had only been to one a few times, and if we hadn’t had an exchange student who insisted on attending a Catholic church, I still probably wouldn’t have. A Catholic church can seem huge, incomprehensible, unfriendly to someone who has never attended one, and is used to the smiley happy-music brand of Christianity.
 
Thanks again for the suggestions. I have my son this weekend and will bring up the subject this afternoon when we have our after school phone chat, this time with a different twist.

I will suggest going to Saturday evening Mass and will check with the Parish office to see if it would be okay if I bought my son in during the afternoon after Christmas shopping for his Mom so that he could look around and get used to the surroundings as well as if Father would have time to meet my son and he could ask whatever questions he may have (we all know how busy our Priests are prior to the start of Mass). Of course, all of this would be after I do my best to explain “the flow of” Mass to him.

Following Mass, we would go grab a bite to eat and then drive around town looking at Christmas lights.
Unless I’m misreading, it seems that the kid also goes to a non-Catholic church. Aren’t any of you concerned that he could be getting conflicting religious instruction? That would be fine if it were a comparative religion course, but here it sounds like two sides pushing one religion as absolute fact… could be negative consequences there unless it’s straightened out.
My guess would be right now he’s not getting any religion in his life.
 
Thanks again for the suggestions. I have my son this weekend and will bring up the subject this afternoon when we have our after school phone chat, this time with a different twist.

I will suggest going to Saturday evening Mass and will check with the Parish office to see if it would be okay if I bought my son in during the afternoon after Christmas shopping for his Mom so that he could look around and get used to the surroundings as well as if Father would have time to meet my son and he could ask whatever questions he may have (we all know how busy our Priests are prior to the start of Mass). Of course, all of this would be after I do my best to explain “the flow of” Mass to him.

Following Mass, we would go grab a bite to eat and then drive around town looking at Christmas lights.

My guess would be right now he’s not getting any religion in his life.
Very good plan - but present it as a PLAN not a suggestion.
(as in: YOU = parent, HE = child)

The idea of ending the evening with a drive looking at Christmas lights?
WOW! Brilliant. Good for you.

My son and I lived in the Midwest in his childhood and he still talks about
missing the Christmas lights in every neighborhood back there.
(He’s 37 yrs old now!)
 
Thanks again for the suggestions. I have my son this weekend and will bring up the subject this afternoon when we have our after school phone chat, this time with a different twist.

I will suggest going to Saturday evening Mass and will check with the Parish office to see if it would be okay if I bought my son in during the afternoon after Christmas shopping for his Mom so that he could look around and get used to the surroundings as well as if Father would have time to meet my son and he could ask whatever questions he may have (we all know how busy our Priests are prior to the start of Mass). Of course, all of this would be after I do my best to explain “the flow of” Mass to him.

Following Mass, we would go grab a bite to eat and then drive around town looking at Christmas lights.

My guess would be right now he’s not getting any religion in his life.
Not sure I would bring your priest into this yet - but you’re the dad and it’s your call. If your priest is very good with kids, then it could be positive. I think any kid would agree to that evening! Good for you for persevering!

Agree that it should be the PLAN and not a suggestion. What if he says “No thanks, Dad, I’d rather stay home and play video games.” You gotta present it as a done deal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top