Advice on charity

  • Thread starter Thread starter DiggidyDog
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DiggidyDog

Guest
Hi there,
Sorry if this is the wrong forum. I am looking for some advice on what I should do in being charitable to someone.

About 6 months ago, I was approached by a man at daily mass, who asked me to help him buy some food for his large family. After speaking to him for a while, I gave him a $20. A few weeks later, he approached me again and I went to the grocery store with him. I had to stop him when the basket had over $20 in it. I really felt that he took advantage of me, so I vowed not to help him again. So in the months since, every time he has asked me, I have said no.

Fast forward to this week. On Tuesday, I entered the church and saw him. Instead of trying to ignore him, I said hello. He quickly asked me for money for food. I told him that I would bring him something the next day, which I did, along with a $5 to buy some milk.

Well today, he is there again and is waiting for me. He tells me that I didn’t give him enough. I told him I had nothing more for him today.

Any advice on what I can / should do? I am feeling like I do not want to attend daily mass at this church any longer (it is not my regular Sunday parish) as it is a stressful situation for me. I am feeling like I am being taken advantage of. I am feeling like I don’t want to be made a fool of. And yet, this man has been placed into my life for some reason.

Thanks,
D.
 
This is why I’m uncomfortable giving directly. It sometimes is best handled by charities. If you feel something is wrong, then just let him know.
 
Hi there,
Sorry if this is the wrong forum. I am looking for some advice on what I should do in being charitable to someone.

About 6 months ago, I was approached by a man at daily mass, who asked me to help him buy some food for his large family. After speaking to him for a while, I gave him a $20. A few weeks later, he approached me again and I went to the grocery store with him. I had to stop him when the basket had over $20 in it. I really felt that he took advantage of me, so I vowed not to help him again. So in the months since, every time he has asked me, I have said no.

Fast forward to this week. On Tuesday, I entered the church and saw him. Instead of trying to ignore him, I said hello. He quickly asked me for money for food. I told him that I would bring him something the next day, which I did, along with a $5 to buy some milk.

Well today, he is there again and is waiting for me. He tells me that I didn’t give him enough. I told him I had nothing more for him today.

Any advice on what I can / should do? I am feeling like I do not want to attend daily mass at this church any longer (it is not my regular Sunday parish) as it is a stressful situation for me. I am feeling like I am being taken advantage of. I am feeling like I don’t want to be made a fool of. And yet, this man has been placed into my life for some reason.

Thanks,
D.
Refer him to the parish office if they help with that sort of thing, or the closest charity with a food bank. He could be selling the groceries for drug money or booze. Don’t see this as some sort of sign from God that this person has a reason for being in your life. If you hadn’t given him the original $20, he wouldn’t be in your life.

😉
 
I feel like this man is taking advantage of your kindness. Perhaps you could give him the telephone number and address of an organization that could help him with food for his family. I think you were very kind in helping him the way you did, and you are under no obligation to continue to do so when it is obvious this man is becoming, for lack of a better word, a pest. Please do not allow this to keep you from attending Mass. If you need to, just sit reeeeeeallly far away from him and don’t make eye contact! 😉
 
yes, you refer him to your parish office, catholic charities, or another social service equipped to handle this. get some business cards from thee services and hand them out.
 
Yes absolutely refer him to the parish office. I have a feeling, though, that he is going to be reluctant to go there (the whole thing sounds fishy to me, personally). So I would also suggest that you approach the parish office about this issue. They’ll either have resources for him or be able to tell you why they aren’t already helping him.
 
Direct him to the St Vincent De Paul society or another local charity (your parish office is going to refer him there along with the dozens of other people who call them every week asking the same thing).
 
All the parishes in our community send money to a city fund. People needing money contact the police department and the funds are given out from there.
 
Our parish bulletin always has a reminder NOT to give money to people panhandling in the parking lot. It says that the people say they are on their way out of town but that the same people show up week after week.

If this man continues to bother you after you refer him to other charities, I’d report it to the parish office.
 
I don’t give money to anyone directly. If I am buying food at McDonalds and someone asks for $$$ to buy food I will buy them what they want to eat, as long as it isn’t the same person day after day taking advantage. Doesn’t happen that often. I would refer him to a hunger center - many churches in the city serve a hot meal a day.

I am suspicious that some use the $$$ for drugs or alcohol. A friend went to medical school in Washington DC and commuted by public transit back and forth from his home in VA. He kept Kosher so always carried his lunch and had extra food for the day. He would get stopped all the time around subways stations by individuals asking for money. When he would tell them he had no money to offer but would give them a sandwich and a piece of fruit, most of the time they turned away. I was at a shopping plaza last weekend and a man was carrying around a sign and a bucket. Sign said “family of 4 almost homeless”. I felt badly but didn’t give him any money.
 
Hi there,
Sorry if this is the wrong forum. I am looking for some advice on what I should do in being charitable to someone.

About 6 months ago, I was approached by a man at daily mass, who asked me to help him buy some food for his large family. After speaking to him for a while, I gave him a $20. A few weeks later, he approached me again and I went to the grocery store with him. I had to stop him when the basket had over $20 in it. I really felt that he took advantage of me, so I vowed not to help him again. So in the months since, every time he has asked me, I have said no.

Fast forward to this week. On Tuesday, I entered the church and saw him. Instead of trying to ignore him, I said hello. He quickly asked me for money for food. I told him that I would bring him something the next day, which I did, along with a $5 to buy some milk.

Well today, he is there again and is waiting for me. He tells me that I didn’t give him enough. I told him I had nothing more for him today.

Any advice on what I can / should do? I am feeling like I do not want to attend daily mass at this church any longer (it is not my regular Sunday parish) as it is a stressful situation for me. I am feeling like I am being taken advantage of. I am feeling like I don’t want to be made a fool of. And yet, this man has been placed into my life for some reason.

Thanks,
D.
As sad as it is, it is not a good thing to just pass out cash to beggars. You definitely do not want to fuel addictions or any manner where they are hurting themselves. If you must give anything, provide sandwiches, but realize that they will flock. I had a friend who started giving sandwiches to one man regularly. Soon there were several homeless people who would hang out at the Church around mass time looking for things. They never really appreciated her generocity. They were always looking for money instead of sandwiches. Unforunately the homeless don’t tend to be like in the movies and people who refrain from giving directly to the homeless aren’t necessarily just cold judgmental people. It took me a long time to realize that.
 
Well today, he is there again and is waiting for me. He tells me that I didn’t give him enough. I told him I had nothing more for him today.
This strikes me as harassment. Tell an usher or the pastor so he can take steps so that he doesn’t harass anyone there.

As far as charitable giving, I am partial to giving gift cards for restaurants that do not serve liquor (like Subway), especially if they can be purchased through the parish Manna program.
 
This is why I’m uncomfortable giving directly. It sometimes is best handled by charities. If you feel something is wrong, then just let him know.
Direct them to a local pantry or soup kitchen. I don’t give out money to people I don’t know for safety reasons. It used to be you might be able to do that but these days it’s just too dangerous. I never carry much cash on me anyway.
 
Thank you all for your replies. I had come to the same conclusions, but wanted to make sure I wasn’t being callous. It is hard working in the downtown core where there are so many people asking for money.
God bless,
D.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top