Bill W., the founder of AA, had tried EVERYTHING to stop drinking. His wife Lois had tried everything she knew how, too. They were both at their wits’ end. Do you know that his desire to drink was COMPLETELY removed from him when he asked God to help him? He was sitting in a hospital room, after several admissions for excessive drinking, and prayed to God to release him from bondage to alcohol. He was released that day. He sought the company of other men like him, who could not stop drinking on their own, and that is how AA began. It is a spiritual program that always depends upon the free will of the alcoholic - they can and do have relapses.
Do not judge AA by the program that your relatives were or were not working. It is a wonderful program and has helped millions of people live contented and sober lives. Al-Anon has helped their families recover too. Believe it or not, it is not just your husband who has been affected by alcohol. You and your children have also gone through this family disease and you would benefit from talking to people who understand what you’ve been through. Wouldn’t you like to sit in a room with people who understand, will listen, and not judge you? They will let you tell your story, and that alone is very healing.
The 12 Steps help the families of alcoholics in a somewhat different way, but they really do help. I know you say that your husband should be at his bottom, but it is always up to the person whether or not they have had enough and want to get help.
You say AA is not about free will? It is totally about free will. Your husband would get a lot of support, which is what helps alcoholics the most - they can’t isolate when they are working a program!
I think you would find comfort in Al-Anon, whether or not you leave your husband.
Look, I think it is great when it works, but it hasn’t worked for anyone that I’ve ever known. Probably because they’re all atheists (or would probably call themselves agnostics–but really saying you’re an agnostic really just means “ambivalent” as opposed to “strident” atheist…so far as I can tell) to begin with. My husband included. I’m trying to get him to join me in RCIA. And he seems to be enjoying it–if nothing else, for the curiosity of it all. I honestly couldn’t tell you whether he believes in anything or not. That’s between him and God in the end. All the ones I’ve known came away with in the end was that they were powerless against alcohol, still didn’t believe in God, and that it was all someone else’s fault for not understanding their “disease”.
As for Al-Anon, I’d really rather focus on the positive in my life. Despite my appearance here at a moment of extreme stress (really, I’m quite literally about to rip my hair out)…I don’t want to focus on problems. Maybe going to support groups helps some individuals, but I’d rather be doing something positive than rehashing what’s bothering me 99% of the time.
Since I’ve got four kids, Al-Anon attendance would require a half-hour drive to and a half- hour drive back plus a sitter for the younger ones (maybe) plus the time sitting around in a circle talking about how frustrating alcoholics are.
I’m/we’re not the sort who would be helped by that. I’m good for a little burst of catharsis now and then, but real therapy for me usually entails prayer, reading, or volunteering my time to help others. Usually if my hands are busy doing something positive I feel closer to God and happier in general. My kids and I volunteer for local shelters, etc. all the time. I’d rather spend my time that way and use that as an outlet. Put all our hurt into an act of love.
Maybe that’s weird, but that’s what we do. I’m not sure how it sounds, at the moment, to outsiders, but this has worked well for maintaining sanity in the past.
I don’t think I’ve got a warped sense of alcoholism and what it is. Probably the biggest problem is not believing in God in the first place–for the people I’ve known. That’s probably why they feel so powerless.
Again, though, it is like anything else: you have to want it. That’s all. Without that, and some vague understanding of your own culpability (I’m not saying one should flog themselves over past wrongs, BTW, just own up to it rather than throwing hands up saying “I’m powerless! Poor me and my disease!”).
As for now, I’ve agreed to stay on the condition that we have a chat with the priest for advice, that he continues in RCIA/marriage prep, the kids don’t go anywhere in the car with him, and if I see any bottles around I’m filing for legal separation until he undergoes full-blown treatment–to protect the kids and myself from further harm.
It isn’t the world, and we’ll have to work on rebuilding trust, but as he’s agreed to those items, that’s a start.