ALL CHRISTIANS: How do you answer: "It doesn't matter which religion you 'pick'"

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But they do not contradict one another.

When Jesus proclaims “I am the way, the truth, and the life, no one gets to the Father but by me” it is at its core a message of exclusivity and you either accept it or contradict it by saying Jesus is NOT the only way.
The universal call and ministry of the Light is what brings people into relationship with God. Any ‘saving’ done IS through the Eternal One. Just because His “name” is not known, doesn’t mean He still cannot save those whom He “saves”.
 
Ok, but there is no question about the Divinity of Jesus or the Trinity, right?
That is an answer only each Friend could give you.

For this Friend, God is fully revealed in Jesus of Nazareth. In him the Word of God was spoken loudly and fully. In him the Light is manifested. In him God dwelt among us as our Immanuel.

If I want to know what God is like, I look to Jesus, if I want to know the character of the Spirit…I look to Jesus…in him the fullness of the Godhead dwells bodily…in him is our hope…in him the Light is made know to each and every man, woman, and child…he is our all and in all…in him God seeks to reconcile the world to Himself.
 
Please post a link for me. I am interetsed in what you believe as a Friend. It seems like I did not know your faith.
quakerinfo.org/quakerism/beliefs.html

For my own practice and belief, I fall along the lines of Thomas Kelly…I would suggest his “Testament of Devotion”, “Eternal Promise” as a good starting point to understand.

Friends don’t use creeds, true religion is known inwardly by immediate experience with the Light of Christ…he is our Teacher and Guide…we believe in his Real Presence among us during worship.
 
The universal call and ministry of the Light is what brings people into relationship with God. Any ‘saving’ done IS through the Eternal One. Just because His “name” is not known, doesn’t mean He still cannot save those whom He “saves”.
Whether or not I disagree is a moot point here, because the issue revolves around the person who in your face is claiming “it doesn’t matter which religion you pick”. And that is false. We are not talking about a peripheral issue about those who might not have heard of Jesus’ name (which is a WHOLE OTHER topic believe me!), we are talking about the person who claims that even for those who know His Name (for instance, in USA or Canada), they claim it does not matter if you reject Christ or accept Him and the Christian faith, all roads will go to heaven.

And that is just logically and theologically false.
 
Whether or not I disagree is a moot point here, because the issue revolves around the person who in your face is claiming “it doesn’t matter which religion you pick”. And that is false. We are not talking about a peripheral issue about those who might not have heard of Jesus’ name (which is a WHOLE OTHER topic believe me!), we are talking about the person who claims that even for those who know His Name (for instance, in USA or Canada), they claim it does not matter if you reject Christ or accept Him and the Christian faith, all roads will go to heaven.

And that is just logically and theologically false.
I do not believe all roads lead to heaven…there is only one road…the road of love, sacrifice, kindness, devotion, mercy, compassion, peace…there is only One whom ANY and all salvation comes through…but “life after death” is not the focus…Life in the here and now is…love now, be compassionate now, feed the hungry now, bind up the wounded now…the “here after” will take care of itself…Eternal Life begins now, not at some later date in the “here after.”
 
Ok, this thread is more geared toward how you would respond to a particular type of non-Christian. Typically, they call themselves “Spiritual”. They believe the main reason people are in any particular religion is because they were raised that way. They also believe one’s religion should be like picking out something on a menu…it doesn’t really matter cuz it’s an individual choice. Yet when you hear them talk more and more, it is clear they are anti-Christian.

I’m not looking for an argument for choosing Catholicism vs. a Protestant denom. (so let the ecumenism fly! :grouphug: ) I’m asking all of us “Christians” to address how you respond to this:

It doesn’t matter which religion you pick.
I have been confronted with this statement many times. A few things to consider are: Is this person clueless? Are they bashing my faith? Are they promoting theirs? Is it an empty, thoughtless comment that does not illicit an answer? Is the person seeking a response?

Often times you’ll find that this statement is a cop-out to ignorance. Don’t feel challenged is my advice to you. On the other hand, if (and only if) you determine that there is real substance worth pursuing, then try what I do. I remain silent and stare. If it is truly meant as an argumentative statement or a plea for information - the person will follow-up their comment with something else. Do not by any means assent to the comment giving it any kind of validity. My silence is usually followed by, “I wouldn’t be anything but Catholic myself”. It clarifies and solidifies my position without a shadow of a doubt.
The person will use some other cliche to end the conversation or will inquire further which in turn opens up all sorts of possibilities to evangelize.

I hope this helps.

Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum.
 
I do not believe all roads lead to heaven…there is only one road…the road of love, sacrifice, kindness, devotion, mercy, compassion, peace…there is only One whom ANY and all salvation comes through…but “life after death” is not the focus…Life in the here and now is…love now, be compassionate now, feed the hungry now, bind up the wounded now…the “here after” will take care of itself…Eternal Life begins now, not at some later date in the “here after.”
Well, I agree in a sense but this is only half true. To borrow a line from a movie “what we do in life echos in eternity” - that is very true. But primarily, if you reject Christ and His Gospel and are a ‘decent’ citizen and give to the poor, etc, then it does not matter in terms of salvation. Salvation is not based on works that you do so no amount of compassion or good deeds or love from say, an atheist, will make one lick of difference for his eternal state - he is lost without Christ.

And the point of this all is that Christ made some very exclusive claims about the path to salvation. Only those who profess that He is the Christ, the Son of the Living God, are on that road. To contradict Jesus is to say He was wrong - and He can’t be both right and wrong in a matter such as your eternal salvation.
 
Well, I agree in a sense but this is only half true. To borrow a line from a movie “what we do in life echos in eternity” - that is very true. But primarily, if you reject Christ and His Gospel and are a ‘decent’ citizen and give to the poor, etc, then it does not matter in terms of salvation. Salvation is not based on works that you do so no amount of compassion or good deeds or love from say, an atheist, will make one lick of difference for his eternal state - he is lost without Christ.

And the point of this all is that Christ made some very exclusive claims about the path to salvation. Only those who profess that He is the Christ, the Son of the Living God, are on that road. To contradict Jesus is to say He was wrong - and He can’t be both right and wrong in a matter such as your eternal salvation.
Faith is important, but who decides what is being “rejected” in relation to the Gospel…the Gospel Jesus preached was the Good News of the Kingdom of God in our midst, we now may live in this Kingdom…and many who were not deemed worthy by those initially invited to the banquet, will find themselves sitting in places of honor.

The questions Jesus posed to those at the last judgement weren’t about belief or doctrine…“I was thirsty, hungry, lonely, in prison…and you did not help me.”…“If you have done it to the least of these, you have done it to me…” This is the meat of the Gospel of the Kingdom…serve that of God in one another…be His Body in this world…it’s not about “doctine and dogma”, “doctine and dogma” leaves bellies empty, souls lonely, people thirsty…eternity begins now…not later…a cup of water given in His name is worth more than any book of doctrines.

I may get the “particulars” and “fine points of doctrine” wrong, but if I get the finer points of showing mercy and compassion, I miss the boat anyway. I’ll place myself in the Hands of the One I trust to do what is right and just…those Hands are the best place to be.
 
Faith is important, but who decides what is being “rejected” in relation to the Gospel…the Gospel Jesus preached was the Good News of the Kingdom of God in our midst, we now may live in this Kingdom…and many who were not deemed worthy by those initially invited to the banquet, will find themselves sitting in places of honor.
We are not talking about some abstract notion, we are taling about Jesus Christ being the Son of the Living God. Those who believe in Him (e.g., John 3:16) have eternal life. Who decides? God does and has in His word. When people openly reject the Gospel, how can you say “who decides”? We are merely calling a spade a spade because those who reject Christ’s Gospel are not saved.
The questions Jesus posed to those at the last judgement weren’t about belief or doctrine…“I was thirsty, hungry, lonely, in prison…and you did not help me.”…“If you have done it to the least of these, you have done it to me…” This is the meat of the Gospel of the Kingdom…serve that of God in one another…be His Body in this world…it’s not about “doctine and dogma”, “doctine and dogma” leaves bellies empty, souls lonely, people thirsty…eternity begins now…not later…a cup of water given in His name is worth more than any book of doctrines.
Actually, Christ asked his desciples who people said He was. The right answer was that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the Living God. Your eternal fate hinges on what you believe about Christ. You fail to recognize that many people left Him and rejected Him because they did not believe in Him and what he taught. Doctrine, basic fundamental doctrine, is not just important, it is integral. Christ makes that very plain. He said he is the way, the truth, and the life and no one can go to the Father but by Him. You either believe that or reject that - where is the middle ground? There is none. What He said it either true or false.
I may get the “particulars” and “fine points of doctrine” wrong, but if I get the finer points of showing mercy and compassion, I miss the boat anyway. I’ll place myself in the Hands of the One I trust to do what is right and just…those Hands are the best place to be.
We are not talking about finer points. We are talking about essential and basic Gospel truth. That Christ is the Son of God who came down to die a subtitionary death in our place, a death we justly deserve, and we are justified by grace through faith apart from works. This is a very basic Gospel understanding. To reject this is to reject eternal life.
 
Yet at the last judgement, there are no doctrinal questions posed. Those who seem to answer with all the doctrinal questions of casting out demons and doing miracles are the ones rejected…the ones who questioned even at the time of their judgement…“When did we see you…” still had no idea…yet in their ignorance, in their selfless service, not caring about “right belief”, they served the very One they seemed to even then, not recognize…“Lord we never saw you…”
 
Yet at the last judgement, there are no doctrinal questions posed. Those who seem to answer with all the doctrinal questions of casting out demons and doing miracles are the ones rejected…the ones who questioned even at the time of their judgement…“When did we see you…” still had no idea…yet in their ignorance, in their selfless service, not caring about “right belief”, they served the very One they seemed to even then, not recognize…“Lord we never saw you…”
Are you aware that James clarifies this, that faith without works is dead. These people had a dead faith. They claimed to belong, but were deceived (read 1 John). Are you suggesting our faith and belief is meaningless and only are works account for anything? That is senseless.

You need to find a proper balance.

What we believe is essential. And we demonstrate the validity of this belief by what we do. Obviously these people had it wrong because they appealed to their works for salvation, when in fact we are not justified by works. I guess, then, irony of ironies, it does matter what you believe!
 
Are you aware that James clarifies this, that faith without works is dead. These people had a dead faith. They claimed to belong, but were deceived (read 1 John). Are you suggesting our faith and belief is meaningless and only are works account for anything? That is senseless.

You need to find a proper balance.

What we believe is essential. And we demonstrate the validity of this belief by what we do. Obviously these people had it wrong because they appealed to their works for salvation, when in fact we are not justified by works. I guess, then, irony of ironies, it does matter what you believe!
I may need to “find proper balance” or you may need to catch a glimpse of the astounding grace and mercy and depth of the love of God in Christ Jesus…I’ll trust in His character instead of my beliief system, for my beliefs are nothing but dirty rags anyway…He is all and in all…I may be waaaayyyy off balance…but I’m ok with it.🙂
 
Ok, this thread is more geared toward how you would respond to a particular type of non-Christian. Typically, they call themselves “Spiritual”. They believe the main reason people are in any particular religion is because they were raised that way. They also believe one’s religion should be like picking out something on a menu…it doesn’t really matter cuz it’s an individual choice. Yet when you hear them talk more and more, it is clear they are anti-Christian.

I’m not looking for an argument for choosing Catholicism vs. a Protestant denom. (so let the ecumenism fly! :grouphug: ) I’m asking all of us “Christians” to address how you respond to this:

It doesn’t matter which religion you pick.

Maybe as follows:​

    1. Christian faith is faith in a Person - not in a religion
    1. Religion can be the worst enemy of faith in Christ
    1. If we are to discuss religion, let’s first of all make sure that we are not talking about different things
      There is a lot that could be said - & what one does say, should be addressed to that particular individual. Rather obviously, what is suitable for one person may be totally out of place with another.
I hope that answers your question 🙂
 
Ok, this thread is more geared toward how you would respond to a particular type of non-Christian. Typically, they call themselves “Spiritual”. They believe the main reason people are in any particular religion is because they were raised that way. They also believe one’s religion should be like picking out something on a menu…it doesn’t really matter cuz it’s an individual choice. Yet when you hear them talk more and more, it is clear they are anti-Christian.

I’m not looking for an argument for choosing Catholicism vs. a Protestant denom. (so let the ecumenism fly! :grouphug: ) I’m asking all of us “Christians” to address how you respond to this:

It doesn’t matter which religion you pick.
CATECHISM OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
****The Church and non-Christians ****
843 The Catholic Church recognizes in other religions that search, among shadows and images, for the God who is unknown yet near since he gives life and breath and all things and wants all men to be saved. Thus, the Church considers all goodness and truth found in these religions as "a preparation for the Gospel and given by him who enlightens all men that they may at length have life."332
844 In their religious behavior, however, men also display the limits and errors that disfigure the image of God in them:
Very often, deceived by the Evil One, men have become vain in their reasonings, and have exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and served the creature rather than the Creator. Or else, living and dying in this world without God, they are exposed to ultimate despair.333
845 To reunite all his children, scattered and led astray by sin, the Father willed to call the whole of humanity together into his Son’s Church. The Church is the place where humanity must rediscover its unity and salvation. The Church is “the world reconciled.” She is that bark which “in the full sail of the Lord’s cross, by the breath of the Holy Spirit, navigates safely in this world.” According to another image dear to the Church Fathers, she is prefigured by Noah’s ark, which alone saves from the flood.334
**“Outside the Church there is no salvation” **
**

**“Thus, the Church considers all goodness and truth found in these religions as "a preparation for the Gospel”
 
I would steer the conversation for now from “what religion do you pick” to “who is Jesus Christ” and “how do you respond to His claims”

Once you get this straight, then you are a Christian.
 
I would steer the conversation for now from “what religion do you pick” to “who is Jesus Christ” and “how do you respond to His claims”

Once you get this straight, then you are a Christian.
Not a bad idea. Have you tried this on a “Christian?” Sorry, I couldn’t resist 😉 😃
 
I may need to “find proper balance” or you may need to catch a glimpse of the astounding grace and mercy and depth of the love of God in Christ Jesus…I’ll trust in His character instead of my beliief system, for my beliefs are nothing but dirty rags anyway…He is all and in all…I may be waaaayyyy off balance…but I’m ok with it.🙂
You just don’t get it. How anyone who professes to belong to Christ and believe His Gospel can accept that those who openly and fragrantly reject Him and His Gospel are somehow on the road to salvation is crazy.

In case you didn’t notice, not everyone is saved. And those who are not saved, is it because God lacked grace? Lacked mercy? Or is it because they did not believe and/or rejected Christ’s Gospel?

Any simple read of Scripture will communicate that the Christian road is one of exclusivity and only “the few” will find salvation while “many” will not. Broad is the road, Jesus says… but you miss that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top