All these sex threads

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sierrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I went to a priest the other day and I was upset that men kept hitting on me even though I am not even divorced yet much less anulled and calling themselves “Good Catholic Men.” as their catch line. Well, he explained to me that Satan was setting two traps for me - the first of lust if I say yes. The second trap of condemnation when I finally get mad enough to tell one of these men what I really think. Could that be what this thread is really about?
No I just saw several threads regarding an issue (M) that I thought where posted more for attention then real advice.
 
Your right Sierrah. I find it disgusting as well. I also think people have NO SHAME sometimes.

Keep the descriptions of graphic personal problems to a bare minimum!
For the record I think some subjects should be banned and if I see the (M) word I do not read the thread just ignore it but that’s hard to do when you have 3 or 4 posts mentioning the same subject :eek::eek::rolleyes:
 
No I just saw several threads regarding an issue (M) that I thought where posted more for attention then real advice.
I feel like the OP usually isn’t the one seeking attention or shock value – it seems to me that there are certain regular posters who seek out these threads to “stir the pot” with their controversial opinions.

I think most OPs are really just looking for a yes or no; or else they are looking for someone to assuage their guilt feelings over something they are doing.

I think it comes up a lot here because many parents are not comfortable discussing sex in detail with their kids. As a result, people are poorly instructed in issues of sex and morality and come here looking for guidance.

I also think it comes up a lot here because Catholicism has a reputation, for better or worse, for having a lot of “rules” surrounding sex. 🤷

And of course, there is the odd troll. 🙂

What I notice, though, is in the “Ask the Apologists” section, like half the questions are: “Can I use ABC in this situation?” and “Can I go to this Wedding?” I get frustrated with that.
 
are turning my stomach. Enough already.

Really people some stuff is better left unsaid. When you think about certain things too much I think that’s where the problems come from :confused::eek:🤷
I believe the number of sex threads is because people are always looking for loopholes.
 
Your right Sierrah. I find it disgusting as well. I also think people have NO SHAME sometimes.

Keep the descriptions of graphic personal problems to a bare minimum!
Yes. I am no prude, but I said yesterday on one of the sex threads that some of them have crossed a line. These threads can be viewed by teenagers and by people who are battling purity daily. Some of these threads could be a real stumbling block.

Honestly what I want to say to each of those threads is STOP OVER ANALYZING.

Sex is like most things, it has it’s ups and downs. Newlyweds need to realize it takes practice to get it right. I honestly think all the worrying about it, over talking about it, reading every book on the subject and articles and statistics on orgasms 🤷:rolleyes:etc. are only worsening the problem.

The other thing I’d say is, make it your business as a Catholic to KNOW Catholic teaching on the marital embrace. It’s really quite clear and simple. I’m honestly a fan of having a marital embrace sub forum.
 
Yes. I am no prude, but I said yesterday on one of the sex threads that some of them have crossed a line. These threads can be viewed by teenagers and by people who are battling purity daily. Some of these threads could be a real stumbling block.

Honestly what I want to say to each of those threads is STOP OVER ANALYZING.

Sex is like most things, it has it’s ups and downs. Newlyweds need to realize it takes practice to get it right. I honestly think all the worrying about it, over talking about it, reading every book on the subject and articles and statistics on orgasms 🤷:rolleyes:etc. are only worsening the problem.

The other thing I’d say is, make it your business as a Catholic to KNOW Catholic teaching on the marital embrace. It’s really quite clear and simple. I’m honestly a fan of having a marital embrace sub forum.
Yes that’s what I was trying to say.
 
I think most OPs are really just looking for a yes or no; or else they are looking for someone to assuage their guilt feelings over something they are doing.

I think it comes up a lot here because many parents are not comfortable discussing sex in detail with their kids. As a result, people are poorly instructed in issues of sex and morality and come here looking for guidance.
I think it absolutely has to do with having too little information and too little confidence that a couple can apply the teachings of the Church in their own marriages. I was very lucky to have a course in high school that covered these issues in blunt terms. It was embarrassing to the seniors to hear about all of this, but it was better to get the information then than to go through life knowing that you’re ignorant and worried to death about making a mistake. Trying to please someone when you have no idea what is expected is anxiety-producing, and a married couple trying to make their whole married life pleasing to God, including their sex life, is no exception. Married couples need education on this topic that is sufficiently specific. On top of that, sex is, by its nature, profoundly moving. When emotions get involved, especially emotions that can run too deep for mere intellectual understanding, keeping cool about the marital decision-making process is that much more difficult.

This forum is an attractive place to ask the questions because an answer can be had without having to ever look anyone in the eye. The problem with that is that the confidence needed comes from getting reassurance from a real person with real authority that looks you in the eye and says, “Relax. God is on your side. You two can find your way through this.” It comes from talking to other couples who are struggling with the same thing and whom you know are not perfect…and again, while privacy and confidentiality are in order, it is better to have these conversation not virtually, but in real time. Unfortunately, guilt, like mildew, flourishes in shadows and dank conditions. There needs to be sunlight and air circulation to keep it from growing.

IOW, as well-meaning as we hope to be, it would probably be better in the long run if couples with questions talked to a priest in person–or a Catholic counsellor, if they have confidence in that answer.
 
are turning my stomach. Enough already.

Really people some stuff is better left unsaid. When you think about certain things too much I think that’s where the problems come from :confused::eek:🤷
**
This thread is in full view of children, is it not?** Children aren’t stupid, particularly not in this day and age, when most of them have a Twitter and Facebook page before they have even learned the multiplication table. Does the specter of scandal and “corrupting a child’s morals” bother nobody else? If I were 6 or 7 years old and came across some of these pages, I would have treated this Catholic message forum like the womens’ undergarment section of those old Sears & Roebuck catalogs.

Why can’t there be an age-restricted sub-section for adults if people absolutely have to talk about using hildos? I mean, c’mon… this is really getting ridiculous.
 
I think it absolutely has to do with having too little information and too little confidence that a couple can apply the teachings of the Church in their own marriages. I was very lucky to have a course in high school that covered these issues in blunt terms. It was embarrassing to the seniors to hear about all of this, but it was better to get the information then than to go through life knowing that you’re ignorant and worried to death about making a mistake. Trying to please someone when you have no idea what is expected is anxiety-producing, and a married couple trying to make their whole married life pleasing to God, including their sex life, is no exception. Married couples need education on this topic that is sufficiently specific. On top of that, sex is, by its nature, profoundly moving. When emotions get involved, especially emotions that can run too deep for mere intellectual understanding, keeping cool about the marital decision-making process is that much more difficult.

This forum is an attractive place to ask the questions because an answer can be had without having to ever look anyone in the eye. The problem with that is that the confidence needed comes from getting reassurance from a real person with real authority that looks you in the eye and says, “Relax. God is on your side. You two can find your way through this.” It comes from talking to other couples who are struggling with the same thing and whom you know are not perfect…and again, while privacy and confidentiality are in order, it is better to have these conversation not virtually, but in real time. Unfortunately, guilt, like mildew, flourishes in shadows and dank conditions. There needs to be sunlight and air circulation to keep it from growing.

IOW, as well-meaning as we hope to be, it would probably be better in the long run if couples with questions talked to a priest in person–or a Catholic counsellor, if they have confidence in that answer.
And there’s the rub. This can be exceedingly hard to come by. This is why I wouldn’t want the subject to be banned but rather would love to see a designated area for such discussions, maybe where only those over 18 could view it? I dunno.🤷

There are threads that are tasteful too, and the title will be something like “a sensitive question for married folks only”. Some of these threads lately are over the top right from the thread title.
 
**
This thread is in full view of children, is it not?** Children aren’t stupid, particularly not in this day and age, when most of them have a Twitter and Facebook page before they have even learned the multiplication table. Does the specter of scandal and “corrupting a child’s morals” bother nobody else? If I were 6 or 7 years old and came across some of these pages, I would have treated this Catholic message forum like the womens’ undergarment section of those old Sears & Roebuck catalogs.

Why can’t there be an age-restricted sub-section for adults if people absolutely have to talk about using hildos? I mean, c’mon… this is really getting ridiculous.
If a child has lost enough innocence to understand these conversations, this forum is the least of the moral dangers that child faces on the internet. Meanwhile, there are Catholics who were apparently afraid of ruining the innocence of their 20 year-olds, such that people reach marriagable age and are totally ignorant of what the Church teaches on these subjects. (My mother knew a young woman who became pregnant back in the 1940s before she had any theoretical education concerning even how that happened. She was within a year of graduating from high school!)

While I don’t think it is an imperative to restrict these threads, I also feel it would also be reasonable if CAF were to restrict explicit questions to the “Ask the Apologist” forum, with the understanding that the Apologists could edit out unnecessary details in favor of broader descriptions and answers.

IOW, I’m less concerned that the answers given here are too explicit and more concerned that the answers are either incorrect or irrelevant. If someone gives a wrong answer about how to keep chicken from drying out, the consequences aren’t dire. Spreading false impressions about what the Church does or does not teach about private matters of marriage, even if done with no ill intent, is another thing altogether.
 
I just wanted to say that my husband and I were not looking for detailed sexual advise. Our issue was that we were wondering if we were overthinking the issue by being too dead set on Gregory Popcak’s one rule when our sexual experience so far has indicated that it is not always easy to meet that one rule. This overall was a sexual question for other married couples because I figured if we had the problem and needed to figure it out, they might have the problem and find it difficult to actually acheive that one rule. And I did specifically give a warning at the top about the content.

We’re both very familiar with the Theology of the Body. I own both translations. I also own Love and Responsibility. In marriage prep, we ended up with two free copies of the Good News about Sex and Marriage. We only bought Gregory Popcak’s book and any Christian book because we had gotten married and weren’t physically able to consumate our marriage. Unforunately, we’ve found no single Catholic author who even acknowledges this problem exists for women. Then I got diagnosed with vaginismus and have been having to try to figure out how to make the treatment fit Catholic morality as well as reviewing my past to figure out what false ideas I developed about sex and sexual morality, what I’ve falsely inferred into Catholic teaching, etc. Its either that or be lead to believe by secular psychologists that my religion has caused my problem.

My questions were sincere and honest. They were not based on trying to look for loopholes and since it took us two months to even be physically able at all to consumate my our marriage, I really don’t think this is a situation that can just be “figure it out for yourselfs because you’re leading us into sin.” I’m trying to avoid sin as well! But I also have to acknowledge that my conscience is confused and I need to sort out between ideas that stemmed from my grandmother telling me that being molested was my fault when I was 8 as well as other things that influenced my very negative view of human sexuality which influenced me to see the Church’s teaching as making sense to me because my experience with sexual encounters told me that men’s lusts (and reasonably lust in general) were to blame for the trauma I went through. I wanted to be nothing like the person who sexually violated me. It made sense to me, but it was a very disordered prespective. Theology of the Body has helped a lot with that, but I still have questions and I’m still petrified that in my desire to overcome my problems that I’m going to fall into sin. I don’t want to sin, but I also do not want to get caught in a misinterpretation of the rule that is interferring with this aspect of my husband’s and I’s marital life together.

I really do not appreciate feeling forced to explain so much of the background (especially very personal stuff) in order to defend myself from accusations of “just looking for loopholes”.
 
I just wanted to say that my husband and I were not looking for detailed sexual advise. Our issue was that we were wondering if we were overthinking the issue by being too dead set on Gregory Popcak’s one rule when our sexual experience so far has indicated that it is not always easy to meet that one rule. This overall was a sexual question for other married couples because I figured if we had the problem and needed to figure it out, they might have the problem and find it difficult to actually acheive that one rule. And I did specifically give a warning at the top about the content.

We’re both very familiar with the Theology of the Body. I own both translations. I also own Love and Responsibility. In marriage prep, we ended up with two free copies of the Good News about Sex and Marriage. We only bought Gregory Popcak’s book and any Christian book because we had gotten married and weren’t physically able to consumate our marriage. Unforunately, we’ve found no single Catholic author who even acknowledges this problem exists for women. Then I got diagnosed with vaginismus and have been having to try to figure out how to make the treatment fit Catholic morality as well as reviewing my past to figure out what false ideas I developed about sex and sexual morality, what I’ve falsely inferred into Catholic teaching, etc. Its either that or be lead to believe by secular psychologists that my religion has caused my problem.

**My questions were sincere and honest. They were not based on trying to look for loopholes **and since it took us two months to even be physically able at all to consumate my our marriage, I really don’t think this is a situation that can just be “figure it out for yourselfs because you’re leading us into sin.” I’m trying to avoid sin as well! But I also have to acknowledge that my conscience is confused and I need to sort out between ideas that stemmed from my grandmother telling me that being molested was my fault when I was 8 as well as other things that influenced my very negative view of human sexuality which influenced me to see the Church’s teaching as making sense to me because my experience with sexual encounters told me that men’s lusts (and reasonably lust in general) were to blame for the trauma I went through. I wanted to be nothing like the person who sexually violated me. It made sense to me, but it was a very disordered prespective. Theology of the Body has helped a lot with that, but I still have questions and I’m still petrified that in my desire to overcome my problems that I’m going to fall into sin. I don’t want to sin, but I also do not want to get caught in a misinterpretation of the rule that is interferring with this aspect of my husband’s and I’s marital life together.

I really do not appreciate feeling forced to explain so much of the background (especially very personal stuff) in order to defend myself from accusations of "just looking for loopholes".
Two Angels,
You did not owe us any explanation. I am sorry that you felt compelled to do so, but I am even sorrier about what happened to you and how it continues to affect you today in your marriage. I do not believe that the speculation about trolls or people looking for loopholes was directed at you and your thread. Your questions seemed very sincere from the beginning, which is why so many people quickly tried to reassure you that it takes a while to work through things as newlyweds, and with your particular condition, even more patience and compassion is required. Much of the advice given you in your own thread was very good, and I encourage you to PM anyone who really seemed to understand your questions. That way any extra details or explanation can be shared only between you and them, and you won’t open yourself up to questioning about your motives by people who haven’t read all your posts.
 
I just wanted to say that my husband and I were not looking for detailed sexual advise. Our issue was that we were wondering if we were overthinking the issue by being too dead set on Gregory Popcak’s one rule when our sexual experience so far has indicated that it is not always easy to meet that one rule. This overall was a sexual question for other married couples because I figured if we had the problem and needed to figure it out, they might have the problem and find it difficult to actually acheive that one rule. And I did specifically give a warning at the top about the content.

We’re both very familiar with the Theology of the Body. I own both translations. I also own Love and Responsibility. In marriage prep, we ended up with two free copies of the Good News about Sex and Marriage. We only bought Gregory Popcak’s book and any Christian book because we had gotten married and weren’t physically able to consumate our marriage. Unforunately, we’ve found no single Catholic author who even acknowledges this problem exists for women. Then I got diagnosed with vaginismus and have been having to try to figure out how to make the treatment fit Catholic morality as well as reviewing my past to figure out what false ideas I developed about sex and sexual morality, what I’ve falsely inferred into Catholic teaching, etc. Its either that or be lead to believe by secular psychologists that my religion has caused my problem.

My questions were sincere and honest. They were not based on trying to look for loopholes and since it took us two months to even be physically able at all to consumate my our marriage, I really don’t think this is a situation that can just be “figure it out for yourselfs because you’re leading us into sin.” I’m trying to avoid sin as well! But I also have to acknowledge that my conscience is confused and I need to sort out between ideas that stemmed from my grandmother telling me that being molested was my fault when I was 8 as well as other things that influenced my very negative view of human sexuality which influenced me to see the Church’s teaching as making sense to me because my experience with sexual encounters told me that men’s lusts (and reasonably lust in general) were to blame for the trauma I went through. I wanted to be nothing like the person who sexually violated me. It made sense to me, but it was a very disordered prespective. Theology of the Body has helped a lot with that, but I still have questions and I’m still petrified that in my desire to overcome my problems that I’m going to fall into sin. I don’t want to sin, but I also do not want to get caught in a misinterpretation of the rule that is interferring with this aspect of my husband’s and I’s marital life together.

I really do not appreciate feeling forced to explain so much of the background (especially very personal stuff) in order to defend myself from accusations of “just looking for loopholes”.
I think experiences of your type are tragically far too common. I hope you can find “someone with skin on” to talk to. After all, it isn’t the intellectual facts that you lack. It is the emotional confidence and heart-felt sense of security. Once robbed of that, it can take such a long time and so much inner work for a person to reach and continue with a freedom from fear. It is like a lifetime of physical therapy and continuation of special exercises needed by someone who suffered a physical trauma. You don’t just need a page of directions telling you what to do. You need the ongoing personal encouragement and support, and on a continuing basis. You will always have a certain amount of scarring to cope with, but with God’s help, you can do it. It is no fault of yours that this takes effort. It is a service to God that you are willing to make that effort, even when it gets very tiring.

Hang in there, and give yourself credit for how far you’ve come. You’ve been given a difficult road to travel. Your perseverance is admirable. That you need to perservere and cannot simply “as you ought” automatically is evidence of how hard the road is. It is nothing wrong with you! Rather, you do well to keep on going, even though it is hard. That is a great gift to God and your husband, and a loving sacrifice that will cover many faults.

I don’t know if this is the best place to come for the support you need. Your case needs to have special concern taken for the injury and scarring you have suffered. It irritates the injury to have to give all this background that lets others know that the injury is there. Your case is far from atypical–how we all wish it were–but it isn’t the automatic default that people will assume without a heads-up. If they do not know about the injury, even the most charitable will probably fail to assess your situation with even remote accuracy. It is for you to decide, of course, but I suspect it would be less traumatic and more profitable for you to have these conversations with a person who knows to take your case into account without you having to constantly remind them of facts you’d rather not dwell on.
 
**
This thread is in full view of children, is it not?** Children aren’t stupid, particularly not in this day and age, when most of them have a Twitter and Facebook page before they have even learned the multiplication table. Does the specter of scandal and “corrupting a child’s morals” bother nobody else? If I were 6 or 7 years old and came across some of these pages, I would have treated this Catholic message forum like the womens’ undergarment section of those old Sears & Roebuck catalogs.

Why can’t there be an age-restricted sub-section for adults if people absolutely have to talk about using hildos? I mean, c’mon… this is really getting ridiculous.
Yes I think they should have have their own section and not have place certain questions in the “FAMILY” forum.
 
I wonder how about dividing Family Life into “General” and “PG-13” sections? A lot of what’s discussed here is very disturbing (more explicit discussions of sexual issues, also stuff like marital infidelity, divorce, annulments), but the issues are legitimate and need a place where they can be brought up and discussed.

On second thought, though, some 80% of what’s being discussed in Family Life would fall under “PG-13”, with barely anything left for the “General” section. Beyond the “How to cook chicken without it coming out dry”, “Wedding cookies”, and “Finally our cat returned home after wandering off” threads there’s little I can think of for the “General” section. But the threads are often tough and disturbing because real life tends to present tough and disturbing situations. In addition, people do not show up asking for advice when everything goes well, they show up when there are problems. It’s like a doctor’s office. Maybe only 1% of people on the street are sick, but you can bet that exactly those 1% will show up, concentrated, at the doctor’s office. Healthy people have no reason to go there.
 
I find this sad.

Would you rather have people ask questions about sex here, partake in an open and honest religiously and faithfully oriented discussion of sex here (including perhaps some knowing youngsters) or would you rather ban such discussions here and force them to ONLY ask those questions at secular sites, many of which are quite - should we say - unseemly?

Whatever happened to the concept of a “hospital for sinners?”
 
Maybe we could keep everyone happy and have a subforum for it - Sex and Morality
 
Maybe we could keep everyone happy and have a subforum for it - Sex and Morality
sounds good to me. My threads certainly aren’t meant to expose anyone to anything. i am trying to figure things out, which is why I come here for a catholic perspective. Its certainly better than most other places I could go to do so. And I try to keep graphic detail in my threads and posts to an absolute minimum, focusing on the core issues instead of the details. If I need to start putting warnings in titles, I will.
 
sounds good to me. My threads certainly aren’t meant to expose anyone to anything. i am trying to figure things out, which is why I come here for a catholic perspective. Its certainly better than most other places I could go to do so. And I try to keep graphic detail in my threads and posts to an absolute minimum, focusing on the core issues instead of the details. If I need to start putting warnings in titles, I will.
Then write the mods and let them know.
 
I believe the extremely graphic sex threads are probably trolls taking advantage of the good natured but extremely gullible people of CAF.

Besides, how else are you going to get away with talking about diry, naughty sex? You can either have voyeuristic discussions on sexual morality or you can talk about not talking about sex. 🤷
If you really want to find those kind of forums, they are out there. Don’t be so naive to think Catholics are coming here to engage in sex talk. And guess what - sex isn’t all naughty, dirty.

And I find calling people “trolls” condescending and judgemental. Don’t like it, don’t read the threads.

Bottom line is as previous posters noted - even Catholics have serious questions about sex and sexuality, and probably more so than most because of what the church teaches. There are serious issues couples are dealing with and are looking for information, help, points of view, interpretations, you name it. Why do you think there ARE so many threads of varying kinds about sex in a marriage?

And I would say the graphic nature of some of the threads are not that graphic. If you’re expecting to come to a Catholic website to avoid it, then that’s not realistic. I will say that two of the threads about married sexuality and activities within a marriage are probably the most honest and open I’ve seen. Why the heck should Catholics actually avoid conversing and asking questions in what should be a safe, anonymous environment? Do Catholics not engage in certain activities or have questions about them? It is refreshing to find people who are not beating around the bush and talking in circles, being cryptic - just say it, tactfully, but say it.

There are probably just as many Catholics here (and everywhere) who are engaging in different things as married couples and have questions, as there are Catholics who have a very conservative, “purist” (for lack of a better term) view of sex in a marriage and do not do certain things. I think both sides are looking for information - some maybe to bring sex in marriage more in line with the church, others to find out that there really are not that many restrictions and maybe find ways to become more intimate.

Who is to say any one of them is wrong?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top