Altar being used as table at VBS

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sharen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sharen

Guest
Hi Everyone!

I’m a new Catholic and volunteering for our Church’s Vacation Bible School for the first time. The opening and closing ceremonies, as well as the singing rotations are held in the sanctuary. Today I noticed that the Altar was being used as a table. There was an overhead projector on it, some books and files. Someone even left their coffee cup on it. (There are no linens on the Altar) The Tabernacle is empty and the door is open, but this still strikes me as really wrong and irreverent. There is plenty of room to set up a folding table in front of the Altar. I don’t want to cause problems or alienate the people who are in charge of VBS, but I’m thinking of mentioning it to Father. Am I overreaching? Please advise.

Thank you,
Sharen
 
Does the particular Altar contain a relic of any sort? Overall, I would feel it is best to avoid using an Altar as a place to put profane items.
 
Yes, St. John Neumann and two others I can’t remember right now.
 
Yes, St. John Neumann and two others I can’t remember right now.
you should point out to those running the VBS that the alar is a sacremtary and is due reverence and respect. It’s a bad example they are giving to do otherwise.
 
We move ours out of the way, but use the sanctuary area as a “stage”.

Limited room, limited resources in our parish. Methinks if it helps the little ones come closer to the Almighty, he would understand.

Think about it…in some new or very poor parishes folding tables have been used as an altar.

Best to avoid such use, if possible, especially if there’s a relic associated with the altar, as has been mentioned.
 
CALL THE BISHOP AND SHUT THEM ALL DOWN.
.
.
.
.
…
.
.
.
…
Or just talk to the Priest and explain your unease with how the Alter was being used/treated.
 
Cannon law states:.

Can. 1239 §1 An altar, whether fixed or movable, is to be reserved for divine worship alone, to the exclusion of any secular usage.
 
The use of the altar for the things you describe is totally wrong. The people in question probably are not aware of this. The altar is considered “sacred”, meaning “set apart”.
It is set apart to be used exclusively for sacred purposes.
Even if there were no relics in the altar, that would not affect whether or not this was an
abuse.
Even outside of Mass, we are to bow to the altar. This is actually a very serious situation,
and needs to be brought up with the pastor. It will affect the attitudes of all the young people involved, and they will adopt a casual attitude toward sacred things.
If the pastor doesn’t do anything about it, take it to the Bishop. This is not a small thing, it
is a serious problem. It’s actually a sacrilege. If knowingly done (I’m not saying that the people involved know better), it is a sin.
Actually, objectively speaking, it is a sin whether or not they know it. It’s just that they will
not be culpable for it if they don’t know it. It still remains an offense against God.
 
Cannon law states:.

Can. 1239 §1 An altar, whether fixed or movable, is to be reserved for divine worship alone, to the exclusion of any secular usage.
I wish Canon Law could be a bit more specific in what it proscribes, I’ve witnessed military services in which the movable altar was a piece of military hardware, part of a vehicle and part of a ship. Pretty hard to reserve that specifically for use during Mass!
 
I wish Canon Law could be a bit more specific in what it proscribes, I’ve witnessed military services in which the movable altar was a piece of military hardware, part of a vehicle and part of a ship. Pretty hard to reserve that specifically for use during Mass!
Bob, in the cases you are describing the items being used are not dedicated or blessed altars but are merely being used as a place to offer the sacrifice of the Mass under extreme conditions. Since these objects are not dedicated or blessed altars this canon would not apply.
 
Bob, in the cases you are describing the items being used are not dedicated or blessed altars but are merely being used as a place to offer the sacrifice of the Mass under extreme conditions. Since these objects are not dedicated or blessed altars this canon would not apply.
Makes sense, thanks.
 
If an altar is consecrated, (such an altar is always “fixed” meaning that it is not movable), using it for a profane purpose is a sacrilege. The same is true for a movable altar having a consecrated altar stone, unless the consecrated stone is removed.
 
I feel your pain. Our parish did this also. The altar was used as a table for water bottles, file folders, overhead projectors, etc.
I first went to the person in charge of VBS and was told it was ‘just a table’, and it was not a big deal. Luckily I had looked up Canon Law ahead of time and tried to nicely explain that it was going against Canon Law and it was not setting a good example for our kids in terms of showing respect for sacred objects. When I got nowhere I sent a note to our pastor. Even though our parish is very “progressive” and the VBS lead was a very influential member of the parish staff, my pastor agreed (after a couple email exchanges) this was wrong. I’m not sure what he said, but that was the last summer the altar was used as a table. 👍
So, there is hope! We all have to start speaking up when we see things like this happening, have done our research, and know they are incorrect. Just do it respectfully Some people truly aren’t aware of what is inappropriate or disrespectful - and why.
 
I agree with your concerns. It is inappropriate to use an altar that way. It is a very holy sacramental and is to be used ONLY for Divine Worship
 
I would like to thank everyone for their thoughtful responses. I did make my concerns known to the leaders and the VBS Director, who, to my surprise, does not attend our church and is not a Catholic. My concerns were generally dismissed (with a few eyerolls) and I was told that everything was OK because the Host was not in the Tabernacle.“This is the way its always been done”.
I think some people were embarassed and that was not my intention. I chose the Catholic Faith for myself when I was confirmed at Easter Vigil this year and I intend to live by it. One of the reasons I felt disillusioned with Protestantism was the casual attitiude in many congregations and the willingness to “sell out” their beliefs to be politically correct or to broaden their appeal. Father was away this week so I was unable to get his opinion. It just seems like common sense to me not to put your coffee cup and trash on the Altar! Sheesh!

I have resolved to be proactive for next year and discuss the subject at our Parish Council meeting before VBS starts next summer.

Thank you again,
Sharen
 
+JMJ+
I did make my concerns known to the leaders and the VBS Director, who, to my surprise, does not attend our church and is not a Catholic.
That’s a red flag. If parents are not educating their children in the Catholic faith and taking time to read Scripture with them (a sad state of affairs), it’s one thing for them to entrust their children to qualified and competent Catholics who can offer genuine Catholic catechesis. But I would think twice before allowing a non-Catholic to direct a Bible study at a Catholic parish. I would want to closely examine the “syllabus” of study, to be sure there was nothing being taught about Scripture and the Church that is opposed to Catholic doctrine.

This is not a judgment against any Protestant Scripture teacher, but I would think very carefully before entrusting the education of my children in the Catholic faith (and that includes learning about and reading the Scriptures) to a non-Catholic.
It just seems like common sense to me not to put your coffee cup and trash on the Altar! Sheesh!
You are right to be concerned and alarmed. For a religion which holds a high regard for Tradition, the “it’s always been done this way” line (i.e. an appeal to tradition) can sometimes exercise a bit too much authority and overrule genuine and legitimate traditions, such as reverence for the altar of sacrifice, which is a sign of Christ.
I have resolved to be proactive for next year and discuss the subject at our Parish Council meeting before VBS starts next summer.
May God bless you abundantly for your resolve in this matter, and may He grant you the fortitude to stand firm in your convictions!
 
Nothing shocks me now a days…you even have the reverse happening in a lot of places…Priest using tables as if they were Altars when Consecrating
 
in the orthodox church, no one but people in major orders gets near any holy item. If its used in ritual, you stay away from it. you will never see a cake and drinks on it. the roman church needs to bring back proper ritual form.
 
I would like to thank everyone for their thoughtful responses. I did make my concerns known to the leaders and the VBS Director, who, to my surprise, does not attend our church and is not a Catholic. My concerns were generally dismissed (with a few eyerolls) and I was told that everything was OK because the Host was not in the Tabernacle.“This is the way its always been done”.
I think some people were embarassed and that was not my intention. I chose the Catholic Faith for myself when I was confirmed at Easter Vigil this year and I intend to live by it. One of the reasons I felt disillusioned with Protestantism was the casual attitiude in many congregations and the willingness to “sell out” their beliefs to be politically correct or to broaden their appeal. Father was away this week so I was unable to get his opinion. It just seems like common sense to me not to put your coffee cup and trash on the Altar! Sheesh!

I have resolved to be proactive for next year and discuss the subject at our Parish Council meeting before VBS starts next summer.

Thank you again,
Sharen
What you have described has me HORRIFIED. :eek:

Canon law does indeed state the Altar is to be reserved for holiness. NO item that is not used in Holy Mass is to be placed upon an Altar. Not even flowers are allowed to be placed upon the Altar.

My parish was renovated several years ago. The flooring around the Altar has a decorative border that only the priests and deacons are supposed to actually be within so as to keep a “holy place” around the Altar. I love that.

And WHAT THE HECK is a NON-CATHOLIC doing teaching VBS in the Catholic Church??? That would be like having a Protestant teach RCIA!!!

The fact that the Host was not present in the Tabernacle does not change what the Altar is or how it should be treated. (So - did they use the Tabernacle to house their VBS kids’ crayons and paints? Well, why not? It does not have the Host residing within…so what’s the big deal???) :eek:

A different table can always be placed in the Church to use for VBS. AND - I should add - that table should NOT be on the Altar space/sanctuary. The table should be on the floor where the pews are. I TOTALLY do not understand why any Catholic would be so disrespectful and use the sanctuary area as some sort of a playground.

I actually do not like the idea that VBS would even be held within the Church proper, unless the kids are brought there to pray or have some sort of liturgical service or a Mass, etc. Unless there is absolutely NO other spot where it can be held, the Church should be reserved for Church — Mass, prayer, Baptism, weddings, and so on.

I certainly hope and pray that your priest was not aware of this activity and that he will dosomething about it when he returns. If he “rolls (his) eyes” and thinks it is OK because it has “always been done this way”…you need to contact the Bishop.

Coffee cups and trash on the altar…God help us…😊
 
in the orthodox church, no one but people in major orders gets near any holy item. If its used in ritual, you stay away from it. you will never see a cake and drinks on it. the roman church needs to bring back proper ritual form.
Amen, thank you Fr Corey
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top