J
Jeanne_S
Guest
My two older grandkids have always called us Grandma (first name) Grandpa(first name)
With our newest grandbaby my husband is PaPa.
With our newest grandbaby my husband is PaPa.
That’s what we did for our grandparents, too (and I too do Aunt/Uncle Firstname). Nobody on my side of the family is particularly “ethnic,” so it was always Grandma/Grandpa Lastname to differentiate. I was also very fortunate to know some of my great-grandparents, and in some cases it was easier to continue saying Grandma Lastname rather than Great-grandma Lastname (no overlap on last names, if so that might have been necessary.)Those are last names!
Yes, looking back, that was a little weird. Very helpful in making sure kids get the genealogy, though!
All the grandparents I saw day-to-day (my paternal grandparents plus a great-grandma) I called “Grandma Firstname” or “Grandpa Firstname.” My parents also used “Uncle Firstname” and “Aunt Firstname” religiously, although I notice that a lot of my cousins just call my parents by their first names.
Still waiting for the invite to call my in-laws by their first names…I think MIL would like to be called “mom” by me.
That’s what happened with me and my now twelve year old granddaughter.I was Grandma Jeanne,she couldn’t pronounce my name so She called mecGiGi.Which I actually prefer and now refer to myself by that name with my newest grandbaby!I’m a big fan of calling people what they are. I dislike the adult driven egoism of changing names. I have seen may women who do not ever want to be called grandma because of the old person connotation. So they come up with all sorts of oddities that usually indicate a relationship that is false. Men do this too, just a few examples.
Paw Paw. Or Papa… This is a name for a dad…
Nanny This is the name of someone you pay money to take care of your kids…
Now, here is where I give in a little. If the child calls them something or babytalks a name or title I am fine with that being the term of endearment they use.
For instance
: Gammy gam gam, g-pa
One of my childrens grandparents name is Ernie. They try to say “grandpa Ernie” and it comes out Gurney. So that is what the name became.
None of this is a social norm for everyone. Families are different and relationships can be complicated. No need to complicate them more by deciding what you will or won’t be called. Just let the natural name happen.
I just cringe though when I can see the vanity or silliness of denying a relationship because of the connotation of age. But I think that is common.
I will be a proud grandpa someday, or whatever it is those sweet little things call me…
I really agree with this.I’m a big fan of calling people what they are. I dislike the adult driven egoism of changing names. I have seen may women who do not ever want to be called grandma because of the old person connotation. So they come up with all sorts of oddities that usually indicate a relationship that is false. Men do this too, just a few examples.
Paw Paw. Or Papa… This is a name for a dad…
Nanny This is the name of someone you pay money to take care of your kids…
Now, here is where I give in a little. If the child calls them something or babytalks a name or title I am fine with that being the term of endearment they use.
For instance
: Gammy gam gam, g-pa
One of my childrens grandparents name is Ernie. They try to say “grandpa Ernie” and it comes out Gurney. So that is what the name became.
None of this is a social norm for everyone. Families are different and relationships can be complicated. No need to complicate them more by deciding what you will or won’t be called. Just let the natural name happen.
I just cringe though when I can see the vanity or silliness of denying a relationship because of the connotation of age. But I think that is common.
I will be a proud grandpa someday, or whatever it is those sweet little things call me…
My mother said they used, to call one of her grandmothers “Granny [town she lived in].”On our house we went with Nana and grandpa.
Since one set of grandparents lived out of town, there was little confusion.
We’d refer to “your grandpa in Texas” if we needed to.
Papa is a nice alternative though.
My wife’s father is referred to as Poppy [given name].My grandparents were called (addressed) “Nanny” and “Poppy” (maternal) and “Nanny” and “Grandpa” (paternal). They were referred to (third person) as, say, “Nanny Surname”. I never called my grandmother “Nanny Surname”, any more than I would call my father “Dad Surname”.
My mom called her maternal grandfather “Old Dad”. Donna’s father is called “Pop” by his grandkids and great-grandkids; she called her grandfathers “Poppy” and “Pop”.
These are very valid points, and I admit having considered some of this myself. My wife, in fact, doesn’t want the old-person sounding names such as Granny, etc. She wants to be called “Mommy [first name]”, like her own mother is called.I’m a big fan of calling people what they are. I dislike the adult driven egoism of changing names. I have seen may women who do not ever want to be called grandma because of the old person connotation. So they come up with all sorts of oddities that usually indicate a relationship that is false. Men do this too, just a few examples.
Paw Paw. Or Papa… This is a name for a dad…
Nanny This is the name of someone you pay money to take care of your kids…
Now, here is where I give in a little. If the child calls them something or babytalks a name or title I am fine with that being the term of endearment they use.
For instance
: Gammy gam gam, g-pa
One of my childrens grandparents name is Ernie. They try to say “grandpa Ernie” and it comes out Gurney. So that is what the name became.
None of this is a social norm for everyone. Families are different and relationships can be complicated. No need to complicate them more by deciding what you will or won’t be called. Just let the natural name happen.
I just cringe though when I can see the vanity or silliness of denying a relationship because of the connotation of age. But I think that is common.
I will be a proud grandpa someday, or whatever it is those sweet little things call me…
I think this varies widely with culture, ethnic group and which part of the country (in the USA at least) people live in. Where my kids grew up people didn’t have nannies as in paid babysitters, Nannies were grandmothers.Paw Paw. Or Papa… This is a name for a dad…
Nanny This is the name of someone you pay money to take care of your kids…
Is it complicating things to tell a child that we call this person by such and such a title or name? I think it’s fair for people to correct someone who uses a name they dislike, or suggest one they prefer rather than let a child make up any name or title that suits and accept it in the name of being “natural”.None of this is a social norm for everyone. Families are different and relationships can be complicated. No need to complicate them more by deciding what you will or won’t be called. Just let the natural name happen.
I know you will! I love being a grandmother, even if he doesn’t call me GrandmaI will be a proud grandpa someday, or whatever it is those sweet little things call me…
Totally agree! My sil’s kids call their grandmother " mama" and grandfather " papa". I don’t like this. So when we had our baby, mil insisted to be called " mama"I’m a big fan of calling people what they are. I dislike the adult driven egoism of changing names. I have seen may women who do not ever want to be called grandma because of the old person connotation. So they come up with all sorts of oddities that usually indicate a relationship that is false. Men do this too, just a few examples.
Paw Paw. Or Papa… This is a name for a dad…
Nanny This is the name of someone you pay money to take care of your kids…
Now, here is where I give in a little. If the child calls them something or babytalks a name or title I am fine with that being the term of endearment they use.
For instance
: Gammy gam gam, g-pa
One of my childrens grandparents name is Ernie. They try to say “grandpa Ernie” and it comes out Gurney. So that is what the name became.
None of this is a social norm for everyone. Families are different and relationships can be complicated. No need to complicate them more by deciding what you will or won’t be called. Just let the natural name happen.
I just cringe though when I can see the vanity or silliness of denying a relationship because of the connotation of age. But I think that is common.
I will be a proud grandpa someday, or whatever it is those sweet little things call me…
And that’s exactly why I put the kibosh on that. I think my step-mother actually takes my daughter out in public hoping that she can intentionally confuse people into thinking she is her baby. She loves it when strangers give her attention over the baby and ask if she is hers. I think she thinks that means she isn’t old yet.I am always amazed at the names people come up with for grandparents. Unless “Grandma” and “Grandpa” are used, it isn’t really clear to anyone new coming on the scene (friends, acquaintances, visitors) who the person is talking to or about. In my opinion, continuing to use baby-ish names for Grandma / Grandpa beyond a child’s second year is cloying. I think using the name “Papa” or “Mama” for grandparents is very confusing.
.
That was my grandmother. She had beautiful auburn hair and when I was born with coal black hair, she started dyeing her hair black. She truly wanted to make it seem like I was hers in public. I don’t remember, but story has it that this one time I corrected her after someone asked if I was hers by saying, “you are my Nana, not Mama.” Well, I got upset when she got on to me and ended up telling my mom. That didn’t go over too well.And that’s exactly why I put the kibosh on that. I think my step-mother actually takes my daughter out in public hoping that she can intentionally confuse people into thinking she is her baby. She loves it when strangers give her attention over the baby and ask if she is hers. I think she thinks that means she isn’t old yet.Obviously, if she looked even remotely young enough to be the baby’s mother, complete strangers wouldn’t ask her if she was hers, they’d just assume she was hers! I go the store all the time with the baby and people come up and tell me how cute she is. Not one person has asked me if she was mine.
Anywho. I told her from the beginning. I am Mama, you are Grandma. And that was that.
When I had my youngest son, (No. 9) many times I was asked if he was my grandson. One time in the groc. line I told him he could have a candy bar and when he laid it up on the counter, the clerk asked, “Did your Grandma say you could have that?” and he responded, “NO but my Mom did !!” When he started kindergarten, lots thought I was his grandma. I was a bit older than most of the moms ! God Bless, MemawAnd that’s exactly why I put the kibosh on that. I think my step-mother actually takes my daughter out in public hoping that she can intentionally confuse people into thinking she is her baby. She loves it when strangers give her attention over the baby and ask if she is hers. I think she thinks that means she isn’t old yet.Obviously, if she looked even remotely young enough to be the baby’s mother, complete strangers wouldn’t ask her if she was hers, they’d just assume she was hers! I go the store all the time with the baby and people come up and tell me how cute she is. Not one person has asked me if she was mine.
Anywho. I told her from the beginning. I am Mama, you are Grandma. And that was that.