Am I a heretic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

FireFromHeaven

Guest
I was reading a very thoughtful book on early Christian heresies. I ended up thinking, What if Christ died for those he knew would have great faith yet not works? Thus there sins are washed away and they enter purgatory, while the Christians who give up all for him and do great deeds and have a great faith, for all intents and purposes saints, enter heaven with their sins washed away. Pardon of it makes little sense. Is this heretical? If it is how to I purge it? How can it be refuted? Are there any church teachings on this? Do we have record of repentant heresiarchs?
 
I was reading a very thoughtful book on early Christian heresies. I ended up thinking, What if Christ died for those he knew would have great faith yet not works? Thus there sins are washed away and they enter purgatory, while the Christians who give up all for him and do great deeds and have a great faith, for all intents and purposes saints, enter heaven with their sins washed away. Pardon of it makes little sense. Is this heretical? If it is how to I purge it? How can it be refuted? Are there any church teachings on this? Do we have record of repentant heresiarchs?
To work on understanding a teaching of the Church isn’t sinful. To teach others what the Church does not teach while purporting membership would be heretical. In this, no, you aren’t a “heretic.”

But read carefully this Catholic Answers tract, “Assurance of Salvation.” As Catholics, we know that the life that God calls us to is mostly a “both-and” condition. We receive the grace of God through baptism, unearned, but we must also use that grace, not just for ourselves but for others, so that they can receive God’s help and love through us through acts of charity, evangelization, ministry, and service.

Christianity is not a “club.” You just don’t profess a pledge and pat yourself on the back for joining as well as expecting a full reward of your membership without contributing to the club. Our faith is demonstrated through our actions because we are God’s instruments. If we accept God’s gift but do not share it, we are no better than a Pharisee.

The work itself doesn’t “prove” anything to God in itself. He created the UNIVERSE. Anything we do cannot be compared to that–except when we do as Christ does, when we give of our very selves to help others, with our very lives if required. That’s why Christ warned that just giving Him lip-service (“Lord, lord”) isn’t enough. It’s why he told the otherwise-pious young man that, in addition to following the scriptures and obeying the Commandments, that he must detach himself from his things, that to whom much is given (our Grace) much is required from us by God (our actions that are works of our Grace).
 
Works both expose faith (“I’ll show you my faith by my works”) and build faith.

Are you talking, maybe, about people who have an “aha” moment and suddenly have “great faith” and then die before something exposes it? Personally I might call that an insight or belief, but I don’t think I’d call it “faith” until they exercised it. Faith is purified and refined by testing it. Testing happens when one goes about trying to use one’s faith. One reason is that testing can help us separate acts of the will, from acts of surrender to the Lord.

That said, I trust God knows exactly what each of us would have done had we not died, so He knows whether this “faith” is pure. On a human basis, we turn to scripture, a person says they have faith without works, and we say we’ll show you our faith by our works. So we’re not really saying “you have no faith without works,” just that we have seen no human sign of it and from a human’s standpoint, if the faith was not accompanied by works, then we don’t know that it’s pure faith.

That being said, the “works” required don’t have to be great. Mother Teresa said, “we cannot all do great things, but we can do small things with great love.” I would say a kind and loving word to someone on one’s death bed, uttered in faith, would technically be a “work.” Forgiving someone could be a work. Someone with an “aha” moment where suddenly everything makes sense, is apt to go straight into some of these kinds of “works.”

Alan
 
Works both expose faith (“I’ll show you my faith by my works”) and build faith.

Are you talking, maybe, about people who have an “aha” moment and suddenly have “great faith” and then die before something exposes it? Personally I might call that an insight or belief, but I don’t think I’d call it “faith” until they exercised it. Faith is purified and refined by testing it. Testing happens when one goes about trying to use one’s faith. One reason is that testing can help us separate acts of the will, from acts of surrender to the Lord.

That said, I trust God knows exactly what each of us would have done had we not died, so He knows whether this “faith” is pure. On a human basis, we turn to scripture, a person says they have faith without works, and we say we’ll show you our faith by our works. So we’re not really saying “you have no faith without works,” just that we have seen no human sign of it and from a human’s standpoint, if the faith was not accompanied by works, then we don’t know that it’s pure faith.

That being said, the “works” required don’t have to be great. Mother Teresa said, “we cannot all do great things, but we can do small things with great love.” I would say a kind and loving word to someone on one’s death bed, uttered in faith, would technically be a “work.” Forgiving someone could be a work. Someone with an “aha” moment where suddenly everything makes sense, is apt to go straight into some of these kinds of “works.”

Alan
Ok thanks.
 
So then it is heretical but I’m not a heretic?
I wouldn’t say you are a heretic. You are just looking for answers to a certain question. It only becomes heretical when you accept something as absolute doctrine when it is wrong.
 
A heretic is a Catholic who obstinately denies some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or who otherwise holds an obstinate doubt concerning the same. True heresy is a grave sin against faith and is grounds for automatic excommunication. So, chances are that you are not a heretic 😃

You are searching for the truth. That is good. What is bad is to “impugn the revealed truth”, meaning to oppose what the Church teaches in faith and morals. This is also a sin against the Holy Spirit, and obviously predisposes us to heresy or worse :o But your approach is clearly that of someone trying to understand, and Christ wants us to be humble and obedient, but also to understand:
I no longer call you servants, because the servant does not understand what his master is doing.
But I have called you friends, because I have revealed to you everything I heard from my Father.
You refute erroneous ideas by (1) distrusting yourself and trusting the Church and (2) learning what the Magisterium teaches about these things. In 20 centuries, there is no error that has not been thoroughly refuted by the Church :o

And mind you, nobody has great faith and yet not works 😉 Those who don’t have works, may have faith, but such would be a fides informis, a dead faith.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top