Am I committing sacrilege?

  • Thread starter Thread starter EstherTherese
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EstherTherese

Guest
I don’t know if this is just scrupulosity coming back to me; I can really never be sure. Unfortunately, most of my posts surround that fear. :confused:

In my living room there are several icons and pictures of Jesus, Mary, and other disciples. There is also the HD screen TV that I spend some leisure time in front of. Once in a while I choose a channel that is showing something more lewd or undignified than I’d like.

I can’t help but feel that when I decide to watch something profane or provocative that I’m committing some sort of sacrilege in front of such holy figures.
Are my fears valid?
 
I don’t know if this is just scrupulosity coming back to me; I can really never be sure. Unfortunately, most of my posts surround that fear. :confused:

In my living room there are several icons and pictures of Jesus, Mary, and other disciples. There is also the HD screen TV that I spend some leisure time in front of. Once in a while I choose a channel that is showing something more lewd or undignified than I’d like.

I can’t help but feel that when I decide to watch something profane or provocative that I’m committing some sort of sacrilege in front of such holy figures.
Are my fears valid?
They are
 
Hrm, then I guess not accepting the Eucharist was a good idea. I was going to take communion until the eucharistic minister momentarily ran out of them one person in front of me. It reminded me of a story of a saint who saw the same thing happen to another sister. Who the saint was eludes me, but in any case I took it as a queue to change my heart.
 
Hrm, then I guess not accepting the Eucharist was a good idea. I was going to take communion until the eucharistic minister momentarily ran out of them one person in front of me. It reminded me of a story of a saint who saw the same thing happen to another sister. Who the saint was eludes me, but in any case I took it as a queue to change my heart.
Take full charge of what you observe on your TV, this includes what commercials you will allow on it if you want to keep your vision clean, just understand, I do not watch TV at all anymore except for rare occasions, I don’t even own one. Life goes on just fine without it believe it or not, and you will find yourself spending your free time much more constructively.
  • I* Can watch movies and most tv shows off of the web regardless, without commercials, so it’s not like I’m missing out on anything, well, except for bills and commercials…
 
Well…
Even discounting the amount of faith-destroying rubbish one finds in even an hour of telly, there is the commercial aspect (is your hard-earned leisure time in any way enhanced by being a target audience?) and the obvious issues that any thinking person would have with the contents- based only on its, say originality…too cruel, too cruel:D
I don’ watch much either, but when the occasional bad bit does cross my screen it’s not the feelings of the crucifix or prayer cards adorning my common room that matter, it’s what kind of slow, subtle, creeping influence it has on the soul that I shall spend the rest of my life (trying at least) modelling after Jesus.
Television is like a pesky booger; fetch a tissue, roll it up, bin it!
I like books and Catholic Answers better!😛
 
A sacrilege? Here’s the definition of sacrilege from the Catechism: “Sacrilege consists in profaning or treating unworthily the sacraments and other liturgical actions, as well as persons, things, or places consecrated to God” (CCC 2120). (Quotation pulled from the answer to a CA quick question)
Certainly, it is sinful to view lewd or provocative material, if you chose to view it to be provoked by it. Sacrilegious? No. That would suggest that if you first went around the room, turning the statues around and covering up the pictures, the sacrilege would go away. I think it pretty clear that this is a ridiculous supposition. I’d say, the only way that this would be sacrilegious is if you placed these objects in your living room, and then specifically watched lewd or pornographic materials with them because doing so heightened the excitement you got from watching the material. It does not sound from your post that this is what you are doing.
 
I don’t know if this is just scrupulosity coming back to me; I can really never be sure. Unfortunately, most of my posts surround that fear. :confused:

In my living room there are several icons and pictures of Jesus, Mary, and other disciples. There is also the HD screen TV that I spend some leisure time in front of. Once in a while I choose a channel that is showing something more lewd or undignified than I’d like.

I can’t help but feel that when I decide to watch something profane or provocative that I’m committing some sort of sacrilege in front of such holy figures.
Are my fears valid?
From the Modern Catholic Dictionary:

SACRILEGE. The deliberate violation of sacred things. Sacred things are persons, places, and objects set aside publicly and by the Church’s authority for the worship of God. The violation implies that a sacred thing is desecrated precisely in its sacred character. It is a sin against the virtue of religion.

Personal sacrilege is committed by laying violent hands on clerics or religious of either sex; by unlawfully citing them before secular courts, i.e., without just cause and without express permission of their ecclesiastical superiors; by unlawfully demanding of them the payment of civil taxes or military service; and by the commission of acts of unchastity by or with a person bound by the public vow of chastity.

Sacred places are violated by sacrilege through defilement, e.g., serious and unjust shedding of blood, as in willful homicide or by putting the sacred place (church or shrine) to unseemly use, e.g., secular trading, acts of debauchery; by grave theft from the Church or consecrated edifice; and by violating the immunity of a place as having the right of sanctuary.

Sacred objects are desecrated by sacrilege whenever something sacred is used for an unworthy purpose. This includes the Mass and the sacraments, along with sacramentals; sacred vessels and church furnishings; and ecclesiastical property. Desecration in each of these areas includes the deliberate invalid reception of the sacraments, simulation of Mass, grave irreverence to the Eucharist; gravely profane use of sacred vessels or vestments; and the unlawful seizure of sacred things or ecclesiastical property.

Sacrilege is many times reprobated in Sacred Scripture, notably in the second book of Maccabees and in the writings of St. Paul. Grave sacrilege in the Old Testament was punishable by death, and in the Catholic Church is considered a mortal sin. (Etym. Latin sacrilegium, the robbing of a temple, the stealing of sacred things.)
 
From the Modern Catholic Dictionary:

Sacred objects are desecrated by sacrilege whenever something sacred is used for an unworthy purpose. This includes the Mass and the sacraments, along with sacramentals; sacred vessels and church furnishings; and ecclesiastical property. Desecration in each of these areas includes the deliberate invalid reception of the sacraments, simulation of Mass, grave irreverence to the Eucharist; gravely profane use of sacred vessels or vestments; and the unlawful seizure of sacred things or ecclesiastical property.
Hmm… it seems that I did not USE these images/icons for some unworthy purpose. However, I still wonder if its sinful that I turn on such unholy images with holy figures in my room at the same time.
 
I think the problem is not, should you watch these programs in front of the religious images, but: Are these programs good to watch, period? 😉

Isn’t it sometimes said that you shouldn’t do with your girlfriend/boyfriend what you wouldn’t your mother or your priest to see?

How about, along a similar line: You shouldn’t watch anything on TV that you wouldn’t want to watch with a bunch of religious images in the room?)
🙂
 
How interesting it is that the enemy uses distractions such as your worry about sacrilege to keep attention off the real sinful issues. It seems to be a foregone conclusion that you will continue to watch the lewd TV programs. That’s the real sin here, not whether the holy images will be profaned by being in the same room. It’s your immortal soul that’s being profaned. Wake up - stop watching bad programs - the devil is laughing at you.

Betsy
 
How interesting it is that the enemy uses distractions such as your worry about sacrilege to keep attention off the real sinful issues. It seems to be a foregone conclusion that you will continue to watch the lewd TV programs. That’s the real sin here, not whether the holy images will be profaned by being in the same room. It’s your immortal soul that’s being profaned. Wake up - stop watching bad programs - the devil is laughing at you.

Betsy
👍 Exactly;;;;;;
Television has become a cesspool of filth. I would call it inviting sin to purposely watch something not appropriate. I for instance, don’t like to watch anything on TV anymore except for EWTN (the Catholic Channel) and news channels. Even on the news channels I have had to flip it off (on rare occassion) when there was something on that was sexually explicity. Never the less, they show indecent quips once in a blue moon… There’s not a lot you can watch anymore that isn’t immoral. It’s unbelievable!!
 
I I can’t help but feel that when I decide to watch something profane or provocative that I’m committing some sort of sacrilege in front of such holy figures.
Are my fears valid?
would these programs be any less offensive or dangerous to your spiritual health if you had no religious images in your home?
 
How interesting it is that the enemy uses distractions such as your worry about sacrilege to keep attention off the real sinful issues. It seems to be a foregone conclusion that you will continue to watch the lewd TV programs. That’s the real sin here, not whether the holy images will be profaned by being in the same room. It’s your immortal soul that’s being profaned. Wake up - stop watching bad programs - the devil is laughing at you.

Betsy
Agreed.
Better just to quit TV. Or, at least quit watching whatever it is that you seem to know you shouldn’t be watching anyway.
 
would these programs be any less offensive or dangerous to your spiritual health if you had no religious images in your home?
I am scrupule myself and have a bad case of OCD. many things I have done in sacrilege in my past that I have confessed. and many things I have not, but beleaved to be sacrilege.

for eg. I once had blessed lourdes water in a bath, and I sadly teased myself in a profane way for a couple of seconds before I realised what I was doing. I did not do it because the Holy water enhanced the exitement, No it was more compulsive, I never wanted to do it because of the holy water and yet somehow did it and suffered because of it for over a year of fears and discust with myself because of it.

However If i am wearing a scapuler and am in church, and an item of clothing brushes past my nipple, giving a tingle of tickiling, thats not sacrilege, though with ocd, the guilt can still come from something like that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top