Am I crazy taking her back?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Infaith1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We can’t diagnose people online but I would suggest that, just from your account, this is going to lead you down a path of nothing but heart ache and sorrow.

I know a girl like your lady friend and they don’t really change. They may appear to change for a while but once that gets old they will go back to their ways.

She sounds a bit dependent. Not that she can’t function on her own but emotionally dependent on attention.

She was on a SHORT break from you and was already physically engaged with another man? She is a fast worker.

You won’t admit it to yourself but you are addicted to her and her drama. You may have the “rescue damsel in distress” complex and want to FIX her.

I can’t diagnose people but I can tell you this for certainty. Given my background I know you CAN"T CHANGE PEOPLE!! She has to change herself!

Pray and talk to a priest! Best advice
 
Hmm, my heartache for her salvation…sounds like a very familiar story.

Thank you all for the responses. Unfortunately, I do not know why it is the resounding sentiment of this board that I would take her back as she is. We have not been in contact for a few months, and that alone reveals a change in her personality (whether or not it is a lasting change is the question).

Everything in life is a ‘reaction’ to what we experience. For example, we react to the graces of God sprinkled throughout our lives and are thus able to love, forgive, and experience real joy. After all this, I am left in the current predicament of attempting to gauge whether her reaction to this last sin (and the hurt it has caused) is capable of shaking her into the hands of God.

Everyone has said I can not change her, and I have always believed this, and have never tried; but have made my convictions known to her from day one. The confounding truth is that she shares those same convictions and her actions are not of her character (that they are a pattern in her life seems to suggest otherwise, but consider a loving husband and father who is addicted to pornography and has been struggling to overcome the addiction his entire life yet fails from time to time…would you consider his character immoral? I would tend to believe he has stronger character because he lifts himself up when he fails).

Aside from determining weather or not she is solidified on a path of change (which I believe she may considering she has embraced psychological and spiritual counseling and has respected my wish not to be contacted), before I can take her back I have to also know whether I can ever have romantic feelings for her again considering the deep wounds her betrayal have caused.

I have been toying with the idea of, instead of taking her back as girlfriend, to “court” her: aka to abandon all physical intimacy and see her only for weekend Mass and counseling. I think this may be the best route to take, does it sound logical? I believe it would allow us to explore if we truly are meant for each other (aka able to bring glory to the name of the Lord through our relationship) without confounding the situation with dating and physical/emotional intimacy.

For those suggesting I “run away” from her, that does not ring true for me. Is it assumed that my future spouse will be free of difficulty? Is it assumed that I can possibly abandon a woman I promised to Love? (yes, we never took marriage vows, but as many say on these forums, the ceremony does not all of a sudden a couple make…rather a couple essentially “makes it official”.) So if me and her were married (as crazy a question as it may seem, please try to understand where I am coming from), how would you suggest I approach this situation.
 
If you were married, I say get your bums into marriage counceling. Look at retrouville. Many have suggested it. I’ve only read about the program.

That said.

I’ve yet to meet a successful marriage that STARTED in counceling. Doesn’t mean they don’t exist.
 
If you were married, and all that happened still happened after you two were married, including the cheating…then I would suggest counseling both together and separately, including seeking some professional advice for yourself. There would still be two people involved, not just her issues, but yours as well. I’d also consult a priest and/or find a regular spiritual advisor. I certainly hope you wouldn’t still be considering the “breaks” you took as a way to fix the issues involved in your relationship, that’s still not a way to deal with your problems.
 
If you were married, I say get your bums into marriage counceling. Look at retrouville. Many have suggested it. I’ve only read about the program.

That said.

I’ve yet to meet a successful marriage that STARTED in counceling. Doesn’t mean they don’t exist.
Doesn’t it make a difference that we have been together, essentially married, for 2 of the 3 years of our relationship. In fact, we would have gotten married a year and a half ago if our Priest hadn’t suggested we first wait until graduating college. Me starting grad school before her delayed it even further.

With that said, we tried getting counseling as a “couple” after the first incident of her emotional infidelity a little under a year ago, and the psychologist recommended that I not bother coming as these are “her demons” to work through and that I should just respond with “I am not your father” when she throws her insecurities at me. Its not like I have tried…I guess that’s why a second opinion is always necessary. I wish I didn’t listen, because without me attending with her, I lost interest as I “felt” she changed, and she believed she changed because I believed it, and she stopped going. Such a viscous cycle…I don’t know how I was so blind to it.

PatriceA, do you consider what I am currently in a break then? I haven’t spoken to her in two months, and have avoided the temptation to contact her in order to let her grow on her own. In your opinion, would it then be the right move to end this “break-up” and start working on our problems? Would leaving her to her own growth for now be the better move? I never wanted these breaks, they always seemed false, but I thought they were what we had to do.
 
Doesn’t it make a difference that we have been together, essentially married, for 2 of the 3 years of our relationship. In fact, we would have gotten married a year and a half ago if our Priest hadn’t suggested we first wait until graduating college. Me starting grad school before her delayed it even further…
How is it that you’re essentially married?
 
How is it that you’re essentially married?
Perhaps that’s not the right way to think about it, but why i said “essentially” is because we felt the only difference was our intimate life (it caused us more shame than growth together), and our living situation (even though we lived together a year, and spent at least 3-4 nights a week together the other two).

We both felt the need for change, but I guess just weren’t convinced of the urgency of that change…we both thought our engagement would be the start of that change. Part of me even believes her rebellion against God and I were due in part to fears of our impending engagement.

My “courting” her (if I decide that is the best course of action) will look drastically different from “dating” her.
 
If you were married, I say get your bums into marriage counceling. Look at retrouville. Many have suggested it. I’ve only read about the program.

That said.

I’ve yet to meet a successful marriage that STARTED in counseling. Doesn’t mean they don’t exist.
Ding Ding Ding! This is not good for you, infaith. It won’t get better. It couldl get, maybe, manageable.

You are not married. You can walk away.
 
It won’t get better. It could get, maybe, manageable.
As I try to distance myself from this situation (as much as possible) and look at it with an objective eye, I still find myself disagreeing with this statement as it completely contradicts everything I believe about faith and the grace of God. There is a reason I decided to post on this website and not elsewhere; it is because I believe there are some things that are possible only through faith and those not of the faith “just don’t get it.” I have personally experience a radical conversion from a life of drugs, sex, and alcohol to that of faith, so I know it is possible. My personal dilemma in this situation is that I cannot fathom ever understanding disloyalty and infidelity…my culture values honor above all else, and it is difficult for me to look past her dishonorable actions.

I understand the severity of this situation and the implications it will have on my future life and that of my children, and this is why I am asking for advice: so as not to ruin the work of God due to my own weak understanding of grace. Although I cannot change her, since she has already accepted and embarked on a path to change, can I facilitate this change by attending mass and counseling with her, or is it better to leave her to it on her own and maintain this 2 month long radio-silence for even longer? When I do initiate dialogue with her, should I accept her fully as she is (assuming she remains on a Godly path of change) or do I ask her to earn my trust again? If I still have questions about her actions, do I bring them up, or just let them dissolve with time? Do I tell her of the torment I am going through, or do I maintain a strong outward appearance even with her? 🤷
 
As I try to distance myself from this situation (as much as possible) and look at it with an objective eye, I still find myself disagreeing with this statement as it completely contradicts everything I believe about faith and the grace of God. There is a reason I decided to post on this website and not elsewhere; it is because I believe there are some things that are possible only through faith and those not of the faith “just don’t get it.” I have personally experience a radical conversion from a life of drugs, sex, and alcohol to that of faith, so I know it is possible. My personal dilemma in this situation is that I cannot fathom ever understanding disloyalty and infidelity…my culture values honor above all else, and it is difficult for me to look past her dishonorable actions.

I understand the severity of this situation and the implications it will have on my future life and that of my children, and this is why I am asking for advice: so as not to ruin the work of God due to my own weak understanding of grace. Although I cannot change her, since she has already accepted and embarked on a path to change, can I facilitate this change by attending mass and counseling with her, or is it better to leave her to it on her own and maintain this 2 month long radio-silence for even longer? When I do initiate dialogue with her, should I accept her fully as she is (assuming she remains on a Godly path of change) or do I ask her to earn my trust again? If I still have questions about her actions, do I bring them up, or just let them dissolve with time? Do I tell her of the torment I am going through, or do I maintain a strong outward appearance even with her? 🤷
Here’s a question: why do you have to approach her as someone that wants to date her? Why can’t you just approach her as a friend, and friend only? You can still love her, care for her, but why does being in relationship with her or dating her have to even be considered? You can care for her and love her the rest of her life and yours, but that doesn’t automatically mean you should ever be in a relationship with her that leads to marriage. Why not just be friends, have you tried that or do you automatically have to think in terms of the future? Think of her as a person, not as a woman you have to be in a dating relationship with.
 
This whole thread has made me understand further why it’s a bad idea to “act married” before actually being married. InFaith1, it seems that not only do you feel emotionally attached to this woman, but you consider yourself somehow morally obligated to continue to be in this woman’s life as a romantic partner, even though it seems she no longer wants to be in yours. I wonder if you’d feel this way if you hadn’t done sexually inappropriate things and even cohabited with her. Would you feel more justified in walking away?

I agree with PatriceA, though, that there is a difference between staying in her life as a friend and staying in her life as a lover. Even in the case of valid, Sacramental marriage, there are times when the most loving thing to do is to part. There are people who civilly divorce, don’t pursue annulment, and consider themselves to be married until death, but also realize that they can never actually live with that person as husband and wife again, because of major issues such as abuse, adultery, addiction, etc.

No one can tell you what to do, but if this woman has made it very clear to you that it is over, then I don’t think you’re obligated to chase her and beg her to take you back. If you have committed sins against her, then I’d suggest that you go to Confession. If you feel you need to do something to make up for your sins against her, then again, I think a priest might provide good counsel on how to do that. I don’t think the priest would say that you have to take her back in order to do that.
 
This whole thread has made me understand further why it’s a bad idea to “act married” before actually being married. InFaith1, it seems that not only do you feel emotionally attached to this woman, but you consider yourself somehow morally obligated to continue to be in this woman’s life as a romantic partner, even though it seems she no longer wants to be in yours. I wonder if you’d feel this way if you hadn’t done sexually inappropriate things and even cohabited with her. Would you feel more justified in walking away?

I agree with PatriceA, though, that there is a difference between staying in her life as a friend and staying in her life as a lover. Even in the case of valid, Sacramental marriage, there are times when the most loving thing to do is to part. There are people who civilly divorce, don’t pursue annulment, and consider themselves to be married until death, but also realize that they can never actually live with that person as husband and wife again, because of major issues such as abuse, adultery, addiction, etc.

No one can tell you what to do, but if this woman has made it very clear to you that it is over, then I don’t think you’re obligated to chase her and beg her to take you back. If you have committed sins against her, then I’d suggest that you go to Confession. If you feel you need to do something to make up for your sins against her, then again, I think a priest might provide good counsel on how to do that. I don’t think the priest would say that you have to take her back in order to do that.
If I made it seem she doesn’t want me back, than that’s a problem. She was not “taking me back” only during our break. When I found out of her affair, the roles reversed. After breaking up with her I essentially told her that if she were to disrespect my wishes and contact me that I would never talk to her again. I received an email from her a week later (which I never responded to) saying that she spoke with her priest who advised her to listen to me and to work on herself, and that she will be getting spiritual and psychological counseling. Occasionally I receive word from family members saying they bumped into her and she begs them to “pray for me and her.” I am certain that if I never asked her to stay away that she would be in constant communication with me begging for another chance. Her pain hurts me deeply, but as per my own reasoning (and hurt) and the advice of her parents and my Priest, I have not given in to my desires to speak with her again until now as my own emotions are less in the picture.

I have thanked the Lord everyday since learning of her infidelity for this opportunity for us to live in him again (whether together or apart). I guess sometimes we have to learn things the hard way…
 
How to Spot a Dangerous Woman

Dangerous Women - Are you at risk?

Before you marry him or her

How to Be The One

Think and then do whatever you decide with your eyes open.

There is an abundance of women, not a scarcity. Get out there, talk to other women, have fun approaching and making them laugh. It doesn’t matter if the woman is 18 or 80, just make conversation. You seem to have one-itis.
Thank you for the links, I will look through them. As to your last point, I have considered dating others, and have had ample opportunity to (not to sound arrogant, but I have never had a problem in this area). However, the more I consider it, the less I want to. If everyone thinks I am addicted to this girl, than perhaps I am, but I consider it Love…I believe that addiction leads one to make poor decisions without proper thought…I have done nothing but analyze this over and over, and am considering the best ways to approach this situation. Thus, I am less inclined to believe this is an addiction.
 
If I made it seem she doesn’t want me back, than that’s a problem. She was not “taking me back” only during our break. When I found out of her affair, the roles reversed. After breaking up with her I essentially told her that if she were to disrespect my wishes and contact me that I would never talk to her again. I received an email from her a week later (which I never responded to) saying that she spoke with her priest who advised her to listen to me and to work on herself, and that she will be getting spiritual and psychological counseling. Occasionally I receive word from family members saying they bumped into her and she begs them to “pray for me and her.” I am certain that if I never asked her to stay away that she would be in constant communication with me begging for another chance. Her pain hurts me deeply, but as per my own reasoning (and hurt) and the advice of her parents and my Priest, I have not given in to my desires to speak with her again until now as my own emotions are less in the picture.
Sorry for the misunderstanding. It’s great that you have indeed asked for advice from your priest. However, I am a little confused, did your priest tell you to not contact her until you were less emotional, did he give you some kind of time frame such as two months, or did he suggest you have nothing to do with her again?

Also, I would like to point out that, although you two seem to have done many things best reserved for marriage, if you truly see yourself as similar to a married couple, then it would follow that you think it is acceptable to “take breaks” in marriage every time there is a problem. Perhaps you no longer feel that way, and it also seems you did not interpret “break” as a license to date others much less be intimate with them, but you found out she thought differently. Now, how do you know if she has changed her mind on this? Do you want to get married, have problems, and wake up one morning to find a note from her telling you she has to take a break and won’t be back for a few weeks? What if you had children, and she had either abandoned them or whisked them away with her to parts unknown? Would you really want to do that to your children, even if you were fine with her doing it to you?

It also seems that to me that if you really do love this lady, then you may need to seriously consider that’s what’s best for her as well as for you is to simply pray for her from afar. I certainly don’t think there’s any rush to re-establish a dating or courting relationship with her.

I also don’t think you have to date others if you really don’t feel like it, or don’t think you’re ready. I myself tried the “dating others” to try to get over someone I knew I could never be with (since he’s married, as I mentioned in another topic). It really didn’t help, and I started to feel like a user, since I couldn’t very well be honest and say “The only reason I agreed to go on a date with you is to distract me from feelings I have for a married guy!” Similarly, if a man asked me on a date because he was trying to get over his ex-girlfriend who he’d cohabited with and who he saw himself as “essentially married” to, I’d, uh, tell him I had to do laundry that night instead.
 
InFaith1, I hope this doesn’t sound harsh, but what you have posted doesn’t sound like a healthy, adult relationship at all. I was in relationships with similar dynamics when I was younger, and it never ended well.

Before I met my husband, I went through all sorts of relationship drama. Being cheated on, breaking up, getting back together, breaking up again, on and on. It was exhausting, but I thought that’s just the way relationships were “supposed to be.”

And then, after I had healed from a particularly dramatic (and unhealthy) relationship, I was introduced to my husband. From the moment we met, there was no drama. He said what he meant, he kept his word (even on minor things like what time he’d call me), he acted like an adult, and he was a man of loyalty and integrity. It was like night and day from my previous relationships.

There are women out there who do not have this same level of drama.
 
InFaith1, I hope this doesn’t sound harsh, but what you have posted doesn’t sound like a healthy, adult relationship at all. I was in relationships with similar dynamics when I was younger, and it never ended well.

Before I met my husband, I went through all sorts of relationship drama. Being cheated on, breaking up, getting back together, breaking up again, on and on. It was exhausting, but I thought that’s just the way relationships were “supposed to be.”

And then, after I had healed from a particularly dramatic (and unhealthy) relationship, I was introduced to my husband. From the moment we met, there was no drama. He said what he meant, he kept his word (even on minor things like what time he’d call me), he acted like an adult, and he was a man of loyalty and integrity. It was like night and day from my previous relationships.

There are women out there who do not have this same level of drama.
Romanova, I appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut. I am hoping that with time apart spent getting right with the Lord, that she would come back to me (and I to her) renewed and ready to begin a drama-free relationship as God intended. It sounds like you were a willing participant in those drama-filled relationships, and changed when you met your husband. Please pray the same occurs for me. In slight jest, I will add that I have never met a woman that didn’t cause at least some drama 😉

Toeinthewater, neither of us thought breaks were the best way to deal with our problems, but we succumbed to the way our friends dealt with their problems (they were not Christian). It wasn’t until this last break that she ever thought dating someone else was acceptable, and I believe it was due to circumstances surrounding this break (the feelings of neglect and fear of impending graduation and “growing up”). If her story stopped there, however, than I would have a very hard time taking her back. She, however, has expressed shame and disgust of how she handled this break and has been going to spiritual and psychological counseling to try to prevent it from ever happening again. You are right, it would be foolish for me to take back a woman who thinks its acceptable to run off with someone else when the going gets tough. Although I can never be certain if she has truly changed inside, I pray the Lord opens my eyes if she truly isn’t changing and is just putting on a show to win me back (which I highly doubt, but am aware of the possibility).

I am also deciding to wait at least another two weeks before contacting her. She returns from a Women of Faith conference tonight, and I was planning to contact her tonight. I believe, however, that waiting will not only give the Lord more time to work in her, but will also be a lesson in self-discipline for myself (which I can never get enough of).
 
Just as women are told “men don’t change, don’t marry them and expect them too” rings true for men to women as well. It is so hard to see clearly when you are the one in the relationship, but from your OP it seems that this woman has some clear mental issues (you yourself said she suffers from anxiety). Taking quick breaks during your dating does nothing but show that she is not ready for marital commitment! So unless you are prepared for frequent “breaks”, inconsistent behaviors of possible cheating and anxiety attacks, then go for it. She is obvisouly immature though, because she was so flippant to assume one of your “breaks” as a means to go out and get physically intimate with someone else. If my husband had done that to me, we would never have gotten married! Respect yourself!! Get into some personal counseling yourself. Not all women are needy, anxiety ridden and have daddy issues. Oh, and another thing, courting her won’t change the fact that she is who she is…
 
Just as women are told “men don’t change, don’t marry them and expect them too” rings true for men to women as well. It is so hard to see clearly when you are the one in the relationship, but from your OP it seems that this woman has some clear mental issues (you yourself said she suffers from anxiety). Taking quick breaks during your dating does nothing but show that she is not ready for marital commitment! So unless you are prepared for frequent “breaks”, inconsistent behaviors of possible cheating and anxiety attacks, then go for it. She is obvisouly immature though, because she was so flippant to assume one of your “breaks” as a means to go out and get physically intimate with someone else. If my husband had done that to me, we would never have gotten married! Respect yourself!! Get into some personal counseling yourself. Not all women are needy, anxiety ridden and have daddy issues. Oh, and another thing, courting her won’t change the fact that she is who she is…
Thank you mamanurse, but i don’t expect courting to change her, rather I hope to use it as a means for exploring if she has indeed learned and grown from this mistake (instead of giving up on her I am praying for her that she lives up to this final chance). I say “courting” her instead of “dating” her because I don’t want to fall into the same nonsense we were in before. I want this to truly be different. If there is a better way to do this, I am open to suggestions.

one last note, we only went on 3 breaks total in 3 years. The 1st two were after incidents where I found her engaging in what I interpreted as “emotional cheating”…in hindsight I can see the innocence in what she did as they were both situations where the men were leaving or already out of the country. The last break was this most recent one, and I have explained it as best as I could. We were not taking frequent breaks as it may have sounded, and each of the first 2 breaks lasted a week tops secondary to longing for each other.

As I write this I am coming to a conclusion that perhaps the two incidents of “emotional cheating” and this last one of physical cheating are somewhat linked to 1) her self-reliance on what she thought was the appropriate thing to do, and 2) my lack of attending to her feelings of being on the back burner. If the Lord were to bless me with a second chance at this relationship, I believe it can be one he is proud of (as it was for 90% of the past 3 years). I have such a longing to be with her again right now. These next weeks will truly be a test of my self-discipline.
 
Um…RUN. Run far and fast.

Yeah, I’m being pretty cold, but when I was a teen/young adult, I was a hot mess emotionally/mentally.Your GF sounds like I was in some ways, not all…and trust, I was NOT marriage material then…let’s just say that the only place I needed to be was in the local mental ward…which I wound up in a few times…
The guy I was dating then saw the writing on the wall, and bolted, bless his soul…of course THEN I thought that was the worst thing ever to happen to me…but…let’s just say it was the BEST thing he ever did, for him, for sure, and for me, by default.

I wish you well in any event…I’m sure there is someone out there that is right for you. I’m sensing that you are VERY young, so, hey, you have all the time in the world, focus on your studies and have some fun with your friends, you know? marriage will come soon enough…

Oh, and BTW, what’s a ‘born again virgin’? Huum…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top