Am I crazy taking her back?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Infaith1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As I try to distance myself from this situation (as much as possible) and look at it with an objective eye, I still find myself disagreeing with this statement as it completely contradicts everything I believe about faith and the grace of God. There is a reason I decided to post on this website and not elsewhere; it is because I believe there are some things that are possible only through faith and those not of the faith “just don’t get it.”
I understand your belief about faith and grace, but there is more to it than a belief that grace fixes everything.

Due to the fall of adam and eve, we are all broken. We are all touched with original sin. That is how all of this "less than perfection’ entered the world. For some, it’s a lifetime of struggle.

She’s cheated on every boyfriend she’s had, including you. What would you tell a friend in your situation? Would you advise your friend to marry her?
 
Ahh, thank you for bringing this up, I am not sure how to handle that fact. Is it wrong for me to consider it in this way: she fully admits that she cheated on her previous boyfriends knowing full well it was cheating, but didn’t care because she was young (high school and first year of college) and they weren’t serious relationships. She commented at the start of our relationship (when she fully disclosed her past of infidelity) that she was only with them to “pass the time.” With me, her first truly serious relationship, in regards to her infidelity, she didn’t recognize her actions as cheating at the time because she thought that was the “point of this break.” Afterward, she expressed shame (and not just guilt) regarding her actions and rebellion against God. Because of this, although her actions are as clear as black and white (and thus the reason I broke up with her), when trying to apply this betrayal to a pattern in her life, I hit a snag and am forced to ask, is this really of her character or not? I have been leaning towards no.
 
It seems to me that you came to this forum looking for someone to approve your want to get back together with this woman. Now that pretty much every single poster has said in agreement that you need to move on and let her go, you continue to talk yourself back into this relationship regardless of what anyone has said. Do you really want advice? I would have to guess that none of your friends or family have made any remarks that would encourage you to pursue this relationship, otherwise you wouldn’t be on this forum looking for support and advice from people who don’t know you at all. 🤷
 
It seems to me that you came to this forum looking for someone to approve your want to get back together with this woman. Now that pretty much every single poster has said in agreement that you need to move on and let her go, you continue to talk yourself back into this relationship regardless of what anyone has said. Do you really want advice? I would have to guess that none of your friends or family have made any remarks that would encourage you to pursue this relationship, otherwise you wouldn’t be on this forum looking for support and advice from people who don’t know you at all. 🤷
I am not looking for approval of my actions, rather I posted for 2 main reasons I have mentioned in my notes above. 1) is my logic crazy? (I have not gotten this from any posters…only that it would be “best to run”) 2) if i am to pursue a relationship with her, how can I do it in a manner that will facilitate radical change (and a truly Christian relationship).

My friends, Priest, and family all tell me the same thing: it is your decision and only you know best. My friends have not been helpful as I am the one they always turn to for advice, and they are just as in shock as to what she has done as I was. My Priest has told me to pray on it and truly consider if this is a pattern in her life or not, and if it is, if she has truly committed to a worthy course of change, before I contact her. My family wants me to take her back as my mother is very loving and caring and believes in second chances, and that her desire to change is indeed very real.

So no, I am not looking for approval from the members of this forum, I am looking for wisdom that has come from experience. As I pointed before, my original post is one-sided and I feel portrays my story with the negative highlighted. Do you disagree with anything I have said in particular or do you feel I am generally not accepting what you and others have said? If it is the later, I assure you that your challenges are affecting my thoughts greatly, and have greatly helped me shape my opinion (which I hope does not come off as defensive).

Still, the truest reason why I posted, and continue to post, is that I am prone to over analyzing everything (a product of my education), and do not want to repeat mistakes. Unlike other areas of my life, I have devoted most of my day to prayer and fasting for guidance in this situation, and perhaps the reason I am coming to this forum is for reassurance that I am not acting against better judgment.

I am truly grateful for the time everyone has spent responding.
 
I am not looking for approval of my actions, rather I posted for 2 main reasons I have mentioned in my notes above. **1) is my logic crazy? (I have not gotten this from any posters…only that it would be “best to run”) 2) if i am to pursue a relationship with her, how can I do it in a manner that will facilitate radical change (and a truly Christian relationship). **My friends, Priest, and family all tell me the same thing: it is your decision and only you know best. My friends have not been helpful as I am the one they always turn to for advice, and they are just as in shock as to what she has done as I was. My Priest has told me to pray on it and truly consider if this is a pattern in her life or not, and if it is, if she has truly committed to a worthy course of change, before I contact her. My family wants me to take her back as my mother is very loving and caring and believes in second chances, and that her desire to change is indeed very real.

So no, I am not looking for approval from the members of this forum, I am looking for wisdom that has come from experience. As I pointed before, my original post is one-sided and I feel portrays my story with the negative highlighted. Do you disagree with anything I have said in particular or do you feel I am generally not accepting what you and others have said? If it is the later, I assure you that your challenges are affecting my thoughts greatly, and have greatly helped me shape my opinion (which I hope does not come off as defensive).

Still, the truest reason why I posted, and continue to post, is that I am prone to*** over analyzing everything (a product of my education***), and do not want to repeat mistakes. Unlike other areas of my life, I have devoted most of my day to prayer and fasting for guidance in this situation, and perhaps the reason I am coming to this forum is for reassurance that I am not acting against better judgment.

I am truly grateful for the time everyone has spent responding.
Answer to your first question:
Is your logic crazy?..Well, I think your over educated analytical mind has proven that you cannot understand the simple suggestion to this when people have said you would be “best to run”…so I will say it simply, Yes, your logic is crazy and yes you are acting against your better judgement. ( I have only stated it simply because that is what you specifically asked it to be)

Not to say that people cannot change, or that prayer cannot help them change, but two mths is not nearly enough time for a person to change, especially if this change involves mental, emotional and spiritual change. This kind of change will take years. More time is going to be required before you even think about dating her again.

Having answered your first question, your second one really doesn’t require answering because if you are taking the advice of running, then there would be no reason to “facilitate radical change”. (I am honestly not sure what that even means)

I am trying my hardest not to be too judgemental or unkind in my response, so I apologize if I have been rude. I can see why your friends and family have simply said “its up to you”, because you seem to already have your mind made up anyway, so I must assume that you respond to your friends and family the same way you have responded to all posters in this thread.

Good Luck and God Bless.
 
I am not looking for approval of my actions, rather I posted for 2 main reasons I have mentioned in my notes above. 1) is my logic crazy? (I have not gotten this from any posters…only that it would be “best to run”) 2) if i am to pursue a relationship with her, how can I do it in a manner that will facilitate radical change (and a truly Christian relationship).

I am saying this with respect, but;

1.Yes your logic is crazy. It is illogical to think that pattern of the core of who she is, is now going to suddenly “poof” change. You cannot seem to accept that that is who she is, and you are trying to mold her into what you want her to be. She is who she is, and it’s not logical or fair to expect her to be who she is not. (people do change somewhat, but the core of what makes them who they are is who they are).
  1. If you pursue a relationship with her THIS time, why would you expect anything to change? She is still who she is, and I think you feel guilty that you didn’t spend time with her, so she went to someone else. Most of us want more time with those we love, but we don’t run to someone else unless it is in our character to do so. You are still hellbent on twisting her and shaping her to fit what you want her to be, and someday she will resent you for it.
    A healthy marriage is not one of a puppet master pulling the strings and making his puppet do what he wants. You either accept her as she is ( and like EVERYONE (I think) has said, we all see heartache ahead for you, or you stay friends and help her if you must, but you go look for a relationship with someone who shares your core values, is stable, and doesn’t need you to “fix” her.
 
) 2) if i am to pursue a relationship with her, how can I do it in a manner that will facilitate radical change (and a truly Christian relationship).
You will continue to make bad relationship choices if you continue with this line of thinking.

You can NEVER facilitate change in another person. Never. It won’t happen. Especially when it’s a change you want.

Do not over analyze this. Just say no.
 
  1. You said that your relationship with her saved your soul b/c you were Protestant and your arguments about Faith taught you to introspect and you converted. Maybe b/c of that you are having a hard time. I’d suggest you separate out mentally how she helped you with the Faith and your struggles with her now. It may seem uncaring to break up with someone who helped you convert. But it’s a separate issue in my opinion whether it’s good for you to be together now. People do all kinds of things for each other and some are very significant but that does not mean they should always be together. I think that is something to think about as a separate issue.
  2. I’m still struck by the issue that her father blames her for something she did as a young teen and said she destroyed their relationship and left except episodically. How can a child do that to an adult? I’m assuming she was under 12 or 13. I would hope any parent of a child that age would work through their issues with the child. If not, and they break off the relationship, that’s not good. But blaming the child for it? What did she do (you don’t have to say this). I wonder if that is worth discussing with a priest. People who lose a parent either literally or emotionally early in life can have a huge fear of abandonment and she may need to work that through before you and she can be stable again, if that is possible. I think you said the real troubles began when you were apart. If she has a fear of abandonment you can’t make up for it no matter how loving and devoted you are. She needs to talk it through with a priest or therapist, in my opinion, if it’s a problem that causes her trouble. But she needs to want to change and work at it, not just talk about it. And it may take time.
 
Infaith, I am an adult child of an alcoholic, and some of the things you say remind me of how I used to think about relationships, and also about the kinds of people I used to date. In some ways I was like you, and in other ways, like your ex-girlfriend (I didn’t cheat but I would get emotionally dependent on men…unless they were stable and consistent, in which case I considered them boring).

By any chance, do your parents have any addiction issues, or do their parents? If so, you may find it helpful to check out some alanon meetings or adult children of alcoholics meetings. That helped me, as did reading books on codependency. I used to think I could save the complicated/tortured guys, and meanwhile, I ignored good, stable men who liked me. By the way, I did finally break that pattern after many years and am married to a wonderful man now.

Perhaps there’s a chance your ex-girlfriend can change, but if so, the change will come from God, not from another relationship. And it will most likely take years, not a few months. Whether or not she changes in that time, it might be a good idea to examine your part in this, your own patterns, why you’re more interested in her than other women, if your over-analyzing is just from being over educated or is it a way of trying to hold onto an illusion of control in your own mind (I’ve done that!), etc.

Maybe I’m way off base asking if you having addictions in your family of origin. However, some of your thought processes, and how you express yourself, just sound so much like how I used to be that I thought I’d mention it.

P.S. I always assumed “Women of Faith” was an evangelical Protestant conference (when I was in a Protestant church some of the women attended it).

Edited to add: In your first post, you said your relationship with her “literally saved my soul.” That’s the kind of thinking that reminds me of my old self…I used to think I could save others and they could save me. I am not an expert on Catholicism, but my understanding now is that only God can save your soul, not a relationship with a mortal being. Perhaps the relationship with her was part of the experience that led you to the Church, but do you see how even phrasing the sentence the way you did gives her so much power? Even if it was metaphorical, it’s a loaded statement. These are things you may want to examine on your own psychological and spiritual journey. You are young, so you have lots of time now to figure these things out, before you make any mistakes.
 
I am not looking for approval of my actions, rather I posted for 2 main reasons I have mentioned in my notes above. 1) is my logic crazy? (I have not gotten this from any posters…only that it would be “best to run”) 2) if i am to pursue a relationship with her, how can I do it in a manner that will facilitate radical change (and a truly Christian relationship).
  1. To be frank: Yes, I think your logic is crazy. Everyone in this thread is telling you that it would be best to walk away from this girl, yet you keep rationalizing why you should go back to her.
  2. You cannot facilitate radical change in another person. Change is up to her, and the kind of lasting change that she needs is going to take time – more time than two months. Would you go back to a drug addict or an alcoholic after only two months or less of sobriety? Two months is a short time to make a lasting emotional and spiritual change in one’s life.
I mentioned before that I had these sorts of drama-filled relationships when I was in high school and college. I never liked the drama, but I put up with it because I thought I had no other choice (I thought it was a necessary cost of all relationships).

I was even engaged to one of these dramatic men, because I thought I loved him. He cheated on me three months before our scheduled wedding day. I could have wasted my tears on him and tried to get him back, but that was the turning point in my life. I then realized our relationship was unhealthy, I realized that what I thought was true love was more like an unhealthy infatuation/addiction, I realized that I would never be able to fix him, and I realized that there were better men out there. I moved on, I dusted myself off, I healed, and eventually I found a man who is far, far better. If I had tried to fix my ex-fiance and stayed with him, I would have been very unhappy and our marriage probably would have ended in divorce within a couple years. My husband is such a better man than my ex-fiance ever was – a loving, stable, loyal man of integrity who is a good husband and father.

I would wish a similar happy ending for you. But to be quite honest, I think a happy ending is very unlikely with this girl.

(Edited to add: I agree with the previous two posters totally. I’d urge you to read their posts and prayerfully consider them.)
 
I firmly agree with everyone who posted above regarding, 1. Your logic, 2. wanting to change her.

You can never enter in a relationship hoping to change someone and expect it to work. ALWAYS fails! People don’t change b/c someone made them. They change due to something within themselves and ONLY when they are ready.

You are just setting out to live a life of torture and heartache if you continue.

As I said before, looks like you might have the superman complex. Wanting to rescue and fix broken damsels in distress b/c it makes you feel good inside.

Cut it out. You may need to seek counseling for yourself to figure out why in the world you are addicted to helping and fixing broken people

I used to be EXACTLY like that and I always ended up heart broken. Only until I fixed myself did I realize what I was doing.

Pray much and speak to a priest
 
Well, as if you need another voice to chime in…😉 Everyone here is unanimous - get out and stay out of this woman’s life!

Listen, I had a revelation a number of years ago. I don’t know if it can transfer to anyone else, or if it’s just my private learning, but here goes:

People who have this kind of drama and chaos in their lives WANT IT. It’s not something they are trapped in, or something they just happened to fall into, and they don’t need or want to be rescued. THEY CREATE IT BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT AND NEED IT. For whatever psychological reason, need, etc., it’s just what they do, and if you ever did manage to “fix” any of her problems, she’d either leave you or get even sicker.

So, you will not change her, and the fact that you are attracted to that kind of drama means you also have issues to work on, only if you keep rationalizing your relationship, you will really be in the thick of things, with her junk and your junk swirling around in the same beaker until you can’t tell whose junk belongs to whom.

Take her exactly as she is, not as who you want her to be or who you think she might be some day. If you had not already had sex with this woman, would you be this attached? Or would you say to yourself, “Whew! Narrow escape - I’ll be more careful next time!”

That bit of knowledge - that people who are surrounded by drama and chaos are not there by accident and are not waiting for someone to rescue them, but for someone to add to the drama, has kept me out of a lot of other people’s stuff over the years. My sister was one of those damsels in distress, and I did my share of trying to help her. But it was always something. You’d help her in one arena, and something else would go wrong. How much bad luck can ANYONE have??? Oh Snap! It’s not bad luck at all, it’s what she creates in her life. Not consciously of course, no one believes they want all that junk to happen, but nonetheless…people like that absolutely DRAIN me of my own life.

And by the way, SHE did not save your soul, God did. Give Him the credit please. She may have been there for you and you may be seriously projecting onto her something she could not possibly be - a spiritual guide for you.

She has cheated on every boyfriend she’s had??? Has she been tested for STDs yet? She justifies the cheating by saying the relationships “didn’t mean anything?” I wonder if the boys she cheated on felt that way.

RUN AWAY from this! Or, take your chances, but I don’t want to read in 6 mos that you married her, she’s pregnant and threatening to abort your baby or throw herself off a bridge, or that she’s pregnant by some other guy.

seriously, dude, my brain starts to hurt from reading all the twists your are doing trying to justify and rationalize and make excuses and backtrack!
 
Well, as if you need another voice to chime in…😉 Everyone here is unanimous - get out and stay out of this woman’s life!

Listen, I had a revelation a number of years ago. I don’t know if it can transfer to anyone else, or if it’s just my private learning, but here goes:

People who have this kind of drama and chaos in their lives WANT IT. It’s not something they are trapped in, or something they just happened to fall into, and they don’t need or want to be rescued. THEY CREATE IT BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT AND NEED IT. For whatever psychological reason, need, etc., it’s just what they do, and if you ever did manage to “fix” any of her problems, she’d either leave you or get even sicker.

So, you will not change her, and the fact that you are attracted to that kind of drama means you also have issues to work on, only if you keep rationalizing your relationship, you will really be in the thick of things, with her junk and your junk swirling around in the same beaker until you can’t tell whose junk belongs to whom.

Take her exactly as she is, not as who you want her to be or who you think she might be some day. If you had not already had sex with this woman, would you be this attached? Or would you say to yourself, “Whew! Narrow escape - I’ll be more careful next time!”

That bit of knowledge - that people who are surrounded by drama and chaos are not there by accident and are not waiting for someone to rescue them, but for someone to add to the drama, has kept me out of a lot of other people’s stuff over the years. My sister was one of those damsels in distress, and I did my share of trying to help her. But it was always something. You’d help her in one arena, and something else would go wrong. How much bad luck can ANYONE have??? Oh Snap! It’s not bad luck at all, it’s what she creates in her life. Not consciously of course, no one believes they want all that junk to happen, but nonetheless…people like that absolutely DRAIN me of my own life.

And by the way, SHE did not save your soul, God did. Give Him the credit please. She may have been there for you and you may be seriously projecting onto her something she could not possibly be - a spiritual guide for you.

She has cheated on every boyfriend she’s had??? Has she been tested for STDs yet? She justifies the cheating by saying the relationships “didn’t mean anything?” I wonder if the boys she cheated on felt that way.

RUN AWAY from this! Or, take your chances, but I don’t want to read in 6 mos that you married her, she’s pregnant and threatening to abort your baby or throw herself off a bridge, or that she’s pregnant by some other guy.

seriously, dude, my brain starts to hurt from reading all the twists your are doing trying to justify and rationalize and make excuses and backtrack!
Not that it really matters as the OP hasn’t commented on anyone’s replies in a few days, but I don’t believe that they have had sex…they had sex in previous relationships, but claimed “born again virginity” in this relationship. I think what he means by “cheating” is not actual intercourse, but an emotional sense of the word, maybe with kissing and other kinds of intimacy…nothing of this changes your main content though…other than that I totally agree with you!
 
Not that it really matters as the OP hasn’t commented on anyone’s replies in a few days, but I don’t believe that they have had sex…they had sex in previous relationships, but claimed “born again virginity” in this relationship. I think what he means by “cheating” is not actual intercourse, but an emotional sense of the word, maybe with kissing and other kinds of intimacy…nothing of this changes your main content though…other than that I totally agree with you!
He said this: “I have to add that we had physical struggles as a couple, and even cohabited a year (due to circumstances beyond our control).”

Due to circumstances beyond their control??? Huh??? No, you CHOOSE who to share your domicile with! If you are determined NOT to have a physical relationship with someone, shacking up with them isn’t a great decision!

I just get the feeling that the OP is couching the reality in softer terms than it should be, and this is consistent with what we do as humans when we have already bonded with someone through sexual intimacy. Instead of recognizing their problems, and that they would not be a good match for us, we rationalize it all away, find reasons why it doesn’t matter, twist ourselves in knots rather than face the truth. The OP seems to be doing a whole lot of that, and I doubt seriously that someone who hadn’t already been intimate with this woman would be entertaining taking her back for one second!

It’s sex that makes people do this crazy stuff. We form that bond made for marriage, and we’re not supposed to break it, IF we’re married, so we try not to break it even though we weren’t supposed to be there in the first place. A friend of mine compared this to getting blind drunk and signing a business contract - not knowing anything about what you are signing! I’d say it’s a blackout!
 
Well, to be fair to the OP’s ex, this is what the OP actually posted:
She is a virgin, I am a “born-again” virgin (ironically, 1 mistake I made 1 month before meeting her…). It was a very difficult thing for her to get over the first half year of our relationship, but we worked through it, and we just “knew” we were meant to be together.
So it seems the “physical struggles” did not result in the OP actually having intercourse with his GF. I don’t know what kind of sexual acts they have actually done, whether he means French kissing, that sometimes a hand would go where it shouldn’t, or if they’ve actually done “everything but”. I’m not sure that’s relevant. What is relevant that whatever they have done, as well as the cohabitation, may very well have helped put the OP in a mindset that they are “essentially married” and that it would be wrong to abandon her. The OP himself seems to understand that the sexual acts were shameful and sinful. However, I’m not sure if the GF did or does.

Anyway, it seems to me that both the OP and his ex-GF have serious problems with appropriate boundaries. The OP is treating his GF as if she’s his “wife” when she’s not, and he admits that even when the relationship was doing well that she was clingy. She also has a history of having inappropriate relationships with men when she feels neglected by the OP, not to mention her cheating on BFs in high school. I’m wondering if she actually thinks that because she didn’t have intercourse with any of these other men that she didn’t really cheat, and has nothing to apologize for to the OP. She may be a technical virgin, but she seems quite far from chaste.

Also, OP, I wonder if you’ve really come to terms with your past sins, or if you somehow think that because you are such a sinner, that you don’t deserve any better than this girl. Now, I’d agree with you in terms of being fit to enter Heaven, etc. But just because you are both sinners and “no one’s perfect”, that doesn’t mean you are obligated to marry her, or that you’d be a hypocrite.

I actually have serious doubts about whether either the OP or his GF even have the ability to enter a valid, Sacramental marriage at this point, though I’m far from an expert in that topic. Maybe others here can comment on that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top