Am I good or bad or something in between?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lasting_faith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lasting_faith

Guest
Be honest with my, am I a good or bad Catholic.

I pray every day, morning, day and evening and many times between. I read The Bible twice a day. I do not drink but I smoke. I am not [anymore] having sex or date anyone, and most likely I never will. I keep my home clean, I take care of my dog much better then I take care of my self. I shower evening and morning, I shave every morning, I do not go out and “have fun” nor do I watch porn. However, I don’t cover my eyes if I see a sex scene on TV, I am not waiting to see one, but if it happen it don’t bother me, it is not porn nor real sex, only people doing their job. I look at good looking girls/women but that does not lead to masturbation. I don’t look at them with lust, I look only because they are cute/sexy/good looking/beautiful. I confess once evey month, and I have always a few sins to talk about. I am not judging anyone, what others do even if it is a sin is really not my business. I pray for people who you would not even mention. I feel sorry for people who have a hard life but I am not thinking “well, he/she did get what deserved” nor do I lose sleep because my kids have sex before marriage. It is really their matter, but I do not say it is OK. I try to give a “good” example but I am also very aware of my own limitations. I am honest, but if that mean I must hurt someone I rather lie. I understand that there is a “real” world outside the Catholic Church and accept that all of mankind does not share our faith and understanding that they may sometimes be far better people then yours truly. I try to do God’s will but not because I am supposed to do so but because I love Him.

So, be honest with me. I will not report anything you may write as a answer and just for the moderators, I will take the “flack” so don’t punish those who maybe answer my question.
 
Why do you care whether you are a good or a bad Catholic? The rich young man came to Jesus asking essentially the same question, trying to understand if he was “good enough”. Jesus did not tell him whether he was good enough to be saved.

Jesus told him to give up his possessions and follow Him.

In selling out for Jesus, we receive abundant life. I’d much rather have that life than be a “good Catholic”.
 
Be honest with my, am I a good or bad Catholic.

By my personal definition of a good Catholic as someone trying to live their faith today as they see best - assuming you listed your “dos and don’ts” as what you see as important of living a good Catholic life… I’ll cast my vote as “a good Catholic”.

I pray

You keep your conversation going with God.

I read The Bible

You continue using Scripture to maintain your relationship with God.

I take care of my dog much better then I take care of my self.

You love your dog and take good care of him. (Remember that God loves you and expects you to also take care of yourself and to love yourself. I have a feeling you also take good care of yourself.)

I do not go out and “have fun”

I’m not sure what “have fun” means for you - remember God gives us many ways to have fun. He has not assigned us not to have fun (unless you are referring to sinful things). God made us to enjoy life - have fun, laugh, and be happy.

I confess once every month,

You make frequent use of his Sacrament, keeping your soul clean.

I feel sorry for people who have a hard life

You have compassion for others.

nor do I lose sleep because my kids have sex before marriage. It is really their matter, but I do not say it is OK.

You realize that you are not responsible for the actions of adults. You know they are responsible for their own action and their actions do not take away your peace.

I try to give a “good” example but I am also very aware of my own limitations.

You live as a good Catholic knowing you are not perfect.

I am honest,

I am so happy to see this, as I know you struggled with it in the past and now you can see this as part of who you are.

accept that all of mankind does not share our faith and understanding that they may sometimes be far better people then yours truly.

You sound to be a humble man without even realizing how humble you are.

I try to do God’s will but not because I am supposed to do so but because I love Him.

To me, that is a hallmark of being a Good Catholic - to want to do God’s will because you love Him.

Dearest Lasting Faith, May God continue to bless you, your children and granddaughter, your dog, and all those you visit with throughout your day. May God continue to lead you closer each day to Him. May you continue to find beauty in each day.
 
I do have a reason for this question. There seem to be a big gap between the new continent Catholics and the old continents Catholics. In US and Canada the Catholics are a bit like a island, isolated from the “real” world living a “perfect” life where the greatest sin that can be done is watching a nude woman or man. We are a bit more relaxed in Europe and UK. This question of mine was inspired by a thread about a man who did find out that his wife had been unfaithful, or had sex, when she was in high-school and first after the final “amen” in the Church he did find out what had happen. They had been togheter for a number of years and he was a virgin. OK, the advice most of the members gave was “annulment”. That made me think, and I have done, in my mind, a big effort to convince people here that it is really not such a big deal after all. It is a sin, and a mortal one, but she did come clean, and I reckon she have confessed and are forgiven. A great concern now among folks here on CAF is that she is unreliable and will cheat on him again. So, that made me a bit angry, and it also made me think about the fact am I a “good” Catholic in the eyes of the members on CAF. I know that I only need to be good in the eyes of Christ, and that is what I strive to be, but in general I am interested in what people think about European Catholics, we really live among all kind of people and we don’t avoid those who may have a other religion or have a different view on Christian life. So that is why I did ask. I am a aware of the fact that we have a much longer history, and that does not mean that we can sin, but we are different, and more open, I think. It is utmost important that every Catholic obey The RCC, but what I have been reading here on this forum have give me a feeling that “everything” is always a sin and if that is not the case it is time to make it one. What that girl did was a [stupid] mistake, but I think we should be able to understand that sometimes things don’t go as we want them to. But to condemn her and tell the OP that a annulment is all that is needed is not what I think God want to see. Maybe the annulment part may be, but I am sure He cry when He see how hard and cold people are. It is not up to us to say what to do in a case like this so I did start to defend her and I think my possibility to get a visa to US is impossible now. It just made me so angry and frustrated to read post after post with no Christian warmth what so ever, only a cold and faceless “get a annulment” verdict. As far as I know it is a old custom in US that people are not guilty until proven otherwise, as is the case in Europe and UK as well. What did happen with that virtue?
 
Be honest with my, am I a good or bad Catholic.

By my personal definition of a good Catholic as someone trying to live their faith today as they see best - assuming you listed your “dos and don’ts” as what you see as important of living a good Catholic life… I’ll cast my vote as “a good Catholic”.

I pray

You keep your conversation going with God.

I read The Bible

You continue using Scripture to maintain your relationship with God.

I take care of my dog much better then I take care of my self.

You love your dog and take good care of him. (Remember that God loves you and expects you to also take care of yourself and to love yourself. I have a feeling you also take good care of yourself.)

I do not go out and “have fun”

I’m not sure what “have fun” means for you - remember God gives us many ways to have fun. He has not assigned us not to have fun (unless you are referring to sinful things). God made us to enjoy life - have fun, laugh, and be happy.

I confess once every month,

You make frequent use of his Sacrament, keeping your soul clean.

I feel sorry for people who have a hard life

You have compassion for others.

nor do I lose sleep because my kids have sex before marriage. It is really their matter, but I do not say it is OK.

You realize that you are not responsible for the actions of adults. You know they are responsible for their own action and their actions do not take away your peace.

I try to give a “good” example but I am also very aware of my own limitations.

You live as a good Catholic knowing you are not perfect.

I am honest,

I am so happy to see this, as I know you struggled with it in the past and now you can see this as part of who you are.

accept that all of mankind does not share our faith and understanding that they may sometimes be far better people then yours truly.

You sound to be a humble man without even realizing how humble you are.

I try to do God’s will but not because I am supposed to do so but because I love Him.

To me, that is a hallmark of being a Good Catholic - to want to do God’s will because you love Him.

Dearest Lasting Faith, May God continue to bless you, your children and granddaughter, your dog, and all those you visit with throughout your day. May God continue to lead you closer each day to Him. May you continue to find beauty in each day.
Well, I don’t know what to write, I have tears in my eyes right now, I have done my best to be honest, and with the help of God and you here on CAF, and personally you, have made it possible. So all I can say is thank you, and God bless you.
 
Well some things you do are very good. Other things not so much. If you are doing all the good things with love then that is even better because if you aren’t then it is all invane. Assuming you do these things in love then I would say you are like every other human seeking Gods love. A Repentant sinner who stumbles and then gets up again. Instead of asking us why don’t you ask God because it is his opinion who matters.
 
Well some things you do are very good. Other things not so much. If you are doing all the good things with love then that is even better because if you aren’t then it is all invane. Assuming you do these things in love then I would say you are like every other human seeking Gods love. A Repentant sinner who stumbles and then gets up again. Instead of asking us why don’t you ask God because it is his opinion who matters.
Used to be a song that went “When you’re up, you’re up, and when you’re down, you’re down. And when you’re only half way up you’re neither up nor down!”
judyanddavid.com/Songbook/N.html‎
He marched them up the hill. And then he marched them down again. And when you’re up you’re up. And when you’re down, you’re down. And when you’re …
 
Be honest with my, am I a good or bad Catholic.

I pray every day, morning, day and evening and many times between. I read The Bible twice a day. I do not drink but I smoke. I am not [anymore] having sex or date anyone, and most likely I never will. I keep my home clean, I take care of my dog much better then I take care of my self. I shower evening and morning, I shave every morning, I do not go out and “have fun” nor do I watch porn. However, I don’t cover my eyes if I see a sex scene on TV, I am not waiting to see one, but if it happen it don’t bother me, it is not porn nor real sex, only people doing their job. I look at good looking girls/women but that does not lead to masturbation. I don’t look at them with lust, I look only because they are cute/sexy/good looking/beautiful. I confess once evey month, and I have always a few sins to talk about. I am not judging anyone, what others do even if it is a sin is really not my business. I pray for people who you would not even mention. I feel sorry for people who have a hard life but I am not thinking “well, he/she did get what deserved” nor do I lose sleep because my kids have sex before marriage. It is really their matter, but I do not say it is OK. I try to give a “good” example but I am also very aware of my own limitations. I am honest, but if that mean I must hurt someone I rather lie. I understand that there is a “real” world outside the Catholic Church and accept that all of mankind does not share our faith and understanding that they may sometimes be far better people then yours truly. I try to do God’s will but not because I am supposed to do so but because I love Him.

So, be honest with me. I will not report anything you may write as a answer and just for the moderators, I will take the “flack” so don’t punish those who maybe answer my question.
That is an interesting thought, and important. And here are some thoughts.

For a rule of thumb, the day a catholic quits trying to improve in the love and/or knowledge of God, is the day they should begin to worry. Any fish that dosen’t swim upstream is a dead fish headed downstream. There is no standing still, because movement always takes place, with us or without us.

To become perfect as our heavenly Father means not keeping the status quo but becoming better in some way. Perfection means a striving toward. And if there is no striving then there is only failure. Sin is to fail, but even a worse is not to care.

So a good catholic is one who is a sinner, wherever they are at, but giving effort to improve their knowledge and love of God. And usually growth is a slow process.

Each in his/her heart has to decide whether they are still trying, and not so much whether they are at the top or bottom of the spiritual order.

May God bless and keep you. May God’s face shine on you. May God be kind to you and give you peace.
 
Do you love Jesus? Do you hope in Him and trust Him? Do you have compassion on those around you?

If you answered “Yes” to these questions, then you are a good Catholic.
 
Yes, I do. I put my life in the hands of God every and each day knowing that is the best thing to do, I mean, what more we can do? That is my choise.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top