Am I Married?

  • Thread starter Thread starter married
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

married

Guest
My wife and I were both atheist/agnostic at the time we were married (in a home, civilly). There was no mention of God in the ceremony, there were witnesses, it was an “official” marriage as far as marriage licences go. It was the first marriage for both of us. We both believed that marriage was forever.

Years (and children) later, we then both became baptized, confirmed, etc. Catholics (PTL!).

Is it now a sin to have sex with my “wife”? In other words, am I married?

Thanks, in advance, for your help.

P.S. I’ve read MANY posts here, and read Canon law, and I am still (obviously) confused. Our particular case doesn’t seem to be addressed, since neither of us were Christian at the time we were “married”. My feeling is that if I tried to get my “marriage” annulled, I would be successful, so therefore I must not be married, so therefore I shouldn’t have sex.
 
You are absolutely married.

The church presumes all marriages between non-Catholics are VALID, which yours was at the time.

When you both were baptized, your already valid marriage became SACRAMENTAL.
 
The Church considered you married prior to being baptised.

Now that you are both baptized, your marriage will be considered as a ‘Sacramental Marriage’
 
Were you both baptised Christians at the time?
This is important because a civil marriage is considered valid in the Catholic church when the couple is not Catholic. I don’t know what the status of civilly married protestants is, so in case you were baptised in protestant churches you should ask about this.

In any case, your marriage should be validated by the church. From what I’ve read about other couples’ cases, that should be addressed during the RCIA period. So basically, whatever the stage you are at in your conversion to Catholicism will determine the next steps. What you should do now is contact a priest, explain the situation and give all relevant info and take it from there.
 
Call up to the rectory and check with your priest about having your marriage convalidated - validated in the Church as a sacramental union.

Normally, this is initiated as part of RCIA.
 
Call up to the rectory and check with your priest about having your marriage convalidated - validated in the Church as a sacramental union.

Normally, this is initiated as part of RCIA.
The OP does not need to do this. As others mentioned, he is already married validly and sacramentally.
 
The OP does not need to do this. As others mentioned, he is already married validly and sacramentally.
Yes, OP, you are married. You can, and should, continue to have sex with your wife. And you should refrain from putting her title in “quotes”. She is really your wife.
 
You could renew your marriage vows in the Church, as many Catholic couples do on special anniversaries, either privately or publicly. You don’t have to have a priest or deacon present to do this (although you could) as your marriage is already valid and legal.
 
My husband and I are in a similar situation. Married civilly and Islamically. We were both muslim at that time. Priest said we are valid in our marriage but we still need to do a catholic ceremony after we are baptised next year. So yes you are married.
 
My husband and I are in a similar situation. Married civilly and Islamically. We were both muslim at that time. **Priest said we are valid in our marriage but we still need to do a catholic ceremony after we are baptised next year. **So yes you are married.
I don’t think this is correct. Your marriage is already valid. Your marriage will automatically become sacramental upon your and your husband’s baptism. No additional ceremony needed. I suppose having one wouldn’t hurt, but I don’t think it is necessary.
 
As many of the other posters have said, your marriage is both valid and sacramental. The Church assumes that marriages performed between two non-Catholics are valid. When you were baptized, your valid marriage also became a sacramental marriage.
 
I don’t think this is correct. Your marriage is already valid. Your marriage will automatically become sacramental upon your and your husband’s baptism. No additional ceremony needed. I suppose having one wouldn’t hurt, but I don’t think it is necessary.
I want one anyway just to make sure lol
 
I want one anyway just to make sure lol
Wanting one and needing one are two different things. If you want one to “make sure” then you need to study up on marriage. I do see you put the lol in there but I’m kind of worried you are serious anyway.

I can understand you wanting your marriage blessed as a sign of your renewed commitment as Christians and being thankful for the graces you will receive.

But please do your homework so that you don’t have any doubt about the validity of the marriage.
 
Wanting one and needing one are two different things. If you want one to “make sure” then you need to study up on marriage. I do see you put the lol in there but I’m kind of worried you are serious anyway.

I can understand you wanting your marriage blessed as a sign of your renewed commitment as Christians and being thankful for the graces you will receive.

But please do your homework so that you don’t have any doubt about the validity of the marriage.
My priest was kind of pressuring my husband and I to get one, even though I told him that according to Canon law we didn’t need one since we are validly married, baptized Christians, but he kind of just said “I would really like to see you get one.” Honestly, it’s kind of annoying. I just see it as being pointless, our marriage is already sacramental, so what’s the point? Make it “extra-sacramental?” It also seems kind of insulting to the sacrament, like it wasn’t “good enough” in the first place. I am very “non-girly” and “non-mushy/sappy” and have no interest in another “wedding” type ceremony. One was enough for me.
However, I am also a pushover, and I have respect for the priest, so if he continues to push me on it, I will probably do it to make him happy.
 
My wife and I were both atheist/agnostic at the time we were married (in a home, civilly). There was no mention of God in the ceremony, there were witnesses, it was an “official” marriage as far as marriage licences go. It was the first marriage for both of us. We both believed that marriage was forever.

Years (and children) later, we then both became baptized, confirmed, etc. Catholics (PTL!).

Is it now a sin to have sex with my “wife”? In other words, am I married?

.
yes the Catholic Church recognizes as valid marriages between two non-Catholics who are otherwise free to marry. Two unbaptized persons enter into a valid natural marriage. Two baptized persons enter into a valid sacramental marriage. In both cases it does not matter who witnessed the event, as long as the parties were otherwise free to marry and entered into the union with the intent to marry with all that implies.

At the time you were received into the Church and were baptized, your valid natural marriage became sacramental. This should have been explained to you at the time as part of RCIA, chances are it was discussed but you missed it or did not understand all that was said about it.

In all such cases the situation should be discussed in detail with the priest who will be receiving you into the Church, with full open honesty about all aspects of the couple’s personal situation. He is the only one who knows both the marriage laws, and the couple. If you have a question now after the fact, simply call the priest and ask him. General comments on a discussion forum do not trump the advice of a priest who knows you personally and judges your personal situation.

Caveat to anyone who participates in the marriage and annulment threads–it is seldom helpful to take any general comments here and try to fit them to one personal unique marriage situation, as in all such cases there are dozens of variables that come into play.
 
My priest was kind of pressuring my husband and I to get one, even though I told him that according to Canon law we didn’t need one since we are validly married, baptized Christians, but he kind of just said “I would really like to see you get one.” Honestly, it’s kind of annoying. I just see it as being pointless, our marriage is already sacramental, so what’s the point? Make it “extra-sacramental?” It also seems kind of insulting to the sacrament, like it wasn’t “good enough” in the first place. I am very “non-girly” and “non-mushy/sappy” and have no interest in another “wedding” type ceremony. One was enough for me.
However, I am also a pushover, and I have respect for the priest, so if he continues to push me on it, I will probably do it to make him happy.
Perhaps your priest is talking about the Nuptial Blessing, which can be conferred on a couple who has not yet received it. It would be a very nice thing for you to receive that. I think the Nuptial Blessing is a beautiful blessing.

This is not the same thing as a convalidation, which you cannot do since you are already married.
 
My husband and I are in a similar situation. Married civilly and Islamically. We were both muslim at that time. Priest said we are valid in our marriage but we still need to do a catholic ceremony after we are baptised next year. So yes you are married.
Perhaps your priest is referring to the Nuptial Blessing.

He cannot be talking about a marriage ceremony, because you are already validly married.
 
Perhaps your priest is talking about the Nuptial Blessing, which can be conferred on a couple who has not yet received it. It would be a very nice thing for you to receive that. I think the Nuptial Blessing is a beautiful blessing.

This is not the same thing as a convalidation, which you cannot do since you are already married.
Yes, perhaps that is what he meant and he was just mixing the terms up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top