Am I Married?

  • Thread starter Thread starter married
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks to everyone, and especially puzzleannie, for your replies!

I agree that it would always be best to receive advice from someone who knows me well, knows canon law well, and is faithful to the magisterium. I’m still looking for that person.

Until then, we OPs (whatever that stands for) have you all to help us!
yes the Catholic Church recognizes as valid marriages between two non-Catholics who are otherwise free to marry. Two unbaptized persons enter into a valid natural marriage. Two baptized persons enter into a valid sacramental marriage. In both cases it does not matter who witnessed the event, as long as the parties were otherwise free to marry and entered into the union with the intent to marry with all that implies.

At the time you were received into the Church and were baptized, your valid natural marriage became sacramental. This should have been explained to you at the time as part of RCIA, chances are it was discussed but you missed it or did not understand all that was said about it.

In all such cases the situation should be discussed in detail with the priest who will be receiving you into the Church, with full open honesty about all aspects of the couple’s personal situation. He is the only one who knows both the marriage laws, and the couple. If you have a question now after the fact, simply call the priest and ask him. General comments on a discussion forum do not trump the advice of a priest who knows you personally and judges your personal situation.

Caveat to anyone who participates in the marriage and annulment threads–it is seldom helpful to take any general comments here and try to fit them to one personal unique marriage situation, as in all such cases there are dozens of variables that come into play.
 
I was in your situation, OP. 😉

My husband and I were converts from Protestantism. We were married in a Protestant ceremony. We neither of us had any prior marriages. When we were received into the Church, we did not have to do anything. Our already-valid, already-Sacramental (as we had both been baptized) marriage was perfectly fine.

That written, it was quite stressful for our priest when we first approached him about wanting to enter the Church. He is a dear, sweet, Franciscan, who has been at that parish for decades. When we said we wanted to convert, his brow furrowed, his face grew pale, and he sighed. “First,” he said seriously, “I have to talk to you about your marriage. Have either of you … ever been married before?” When I assured him that this was the first marriage for both us, he was so relieved he actually sat down. I felt so sorry for him. I knew that it would not be a problem, as I had researched the Church’s teachings on marriage before we go to that point. It was the Church’s teachings on marriage and birth control that actually drew us into conversion!
 
I was in your situation, OP. 😉

My husband and I were converts from Protestantism. We were married in a Protestant ceremony. We neither of us had any prior marriages. When we were received into the Church, we did not have to do anything. Our already-valid, already-Sacramental (as we had both been baptized) marriage was perfectly fine.

That written, it was quite stressful for our priest when we first approached him about wanting to enter the Church. He is a dear, sweet, Franciscan, who has been at that parish for decades. When we said we wanted to convert, his brow furrowed, his face grew pale, and he sighed. “First,” he said seriously, “I have to talk to you about your marriage. Have either of you … ever been married before?” When I assured him that this was the first marriage for both us, he was so relieved he actually sat down. I felt so sorry for him. I knew that it would not be a problem, as I had researched the Church’s teachings on marriage before we go to that point. It was the Church’s teachings on marriage and birth control that actually drew us into conversion!
I have experienced the same thing. At both churches I went to when I inquired about conversion, they looked at my husband and me, got a pained expression, and said “Have either of you been married before?” When I said no, they were so relieved.

It’s so sad that divorce is so common in our society that it’s pretty much expected when you go in.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top