Am I sinning by using birth control pills?

  • Thread starter Thread starter chloebelle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

chloebelle

Guest
Hi everyone! So, about a month ago I was prescribed birth control pills, not for contraception (I’m 18, not married), but because I have excessively painful periods, crippling even. My cramps were so severe during my last cycle that I got very sick at school (big college, I commute) and was laying down on chairs and crying in front of other people, was very embarrassing, had to have a family member drive all the way there to get me because I wasn’t capable of standing up to get to my car. In a few weeks I have an appointment with a specialist to see what is causing this issue but couldn’t get in for months due to her being so busy, so in the mean time my family doctor prescribed me the pill to avoid my period, and thus, the pain. I have been taking them but feel some guilt in the back of my mind that maybe it’s not the right thing to do. Can anyone help me with this?
 
Last edited:
Blessings
No, you are not sinning. It is not contraception. It is for hormonal control. I had to do that a few times when I was younger.
Bless her Lord and help her have healthy and normal menses.
In Jesus name.
Amen.
 
Your OK. You have legitimate medical reasons. If in doubt-you should not be-just speak to your priest. He will set your concerns aside. Peace.
 
I do have serious reservations about the nature of birth control pills in relationship to your long-term health, not in relation to your soul. My experience with the pill is painful, and as a male I have never taken one, just been at the receiving end, are there alternatives for you? The day I flushed those pills down the toilet was the day I got my wife back.
 
I think it’s so sad that the belief that taking hormonal tablets to help a gynae problem is always forbidden, is even out there, particularly in the case of unmarried girls.

Somewhere the message seems to have been badly taught or misunderstood. How is it that so many years after Humanae Vitae, which said that taking medications to alleviate gynae problems wasn’t sinful, some Catholic women still see the Pill as intrinsically evil? Either this wasn’t understood at the time, and mothers and grandmothers have passed wrong information down the generations, or it is being preached from the pulpit or in the confessional, which is appalling.

Note, I am not saying that there might be better remedies. But there is something very wrong in the transmission of true Catholic teaching somewhere,
 
Like the other posters said, it’s fine because you’re not using it for birth control.

But the pills may not be the best option. I would suggest going to another doctor but since you are going to the specialist, you can just talk about your concerns with the doctor. It’s not a sin but there are plenty of undesirable side effects.

Also try your best to live a healthy lifestyle. Personally I find that when I exercise and drink looootttsss of water right before I get mine, the cramps are a lot more tolerable. Still hurts as heck but I am able to move.

Hope everything is fine with your health! :confused:
 
No not a sin at all.

However, if you ever want children I implore you to seek out a na-pro doctor. Even if you have to travel hours. Hormonal birth control can cover up many diseases like endometriosis and fibroids that can render you infertile by the time you’re ready to have kids.

I have painful periods and they are “unexplained”, that said, in working with a good doctor we actually discovered several uterine abnormalities (that wouldn’t contribute to pain) but would put me at high risk during pregnancy. Knowing about them allowed the doctors to monitor me appropriately.
 
Folks, the OP states she does have an appointment scheduled with a specialist. The prescription is a temporary tactic to get her through to that appointment.
 
I recommend that questions concerning the Pill, concerning sinfulness, etc are often best answered by the National Catholic Bioethics Center. It’s a great resource.
Https://www.ncbcenter.org
 
Darryb, it just that one solution does not fil all and the poster may have some serious health problems. Endometrious is a big problem and not just hormonal. A good examination is really the best course. Birth control piss seem to be a short course and not yet the ‘final’ course.’ There is a huge difference between debilating pain and suffering or the aches and discomfort from ‘normal’ minstrel cycles. As a male, this not something you suffer through, I do wonder why YOU flushed the pills, rather then your wife. Peace
 
Folks, the OP states she does have an appointment scheduled with a specialist. The prescription is a temporary tactic to get her through to that appointment.
Unfortunately, most “specialists” will still push the pill. That’s why NaPro should be mentioned separately. I’ve BTDT. I refused the pill for years and spent much time and money trying to find a doctor who would try to solve the pain rather than cover it up (yes even “renowned” specialists). I was fortunate to find such a doctor right before I was married—but I was in my late 20’s at that point and had 15+ years of debilitating periods.

In the US, research into menstrual and reproductive disorders is almost non-existent. Unless you’re looking to concieve there’s almost no research outside of what is being done by the NaPro scientists.
 
My comment was for all those posting that she needed to see a specialist - she said she already had an appt. Glad you finally found a good doctor.
 
Completely agree. Few research is done, and pill is the easiest solution.

If we found endometriosis on the OP, she will not remove from pill, because it will make the illness worst.

No problem from moral catholic perspective, because she is not married and not intend to prevent conception.
 
It is definitely not a sin as long as you are not married or sexually active. But I would echo what others have said, it may not be great medicine so get a second opinion.
 
My wife had been on the pill for hormonal reasons since 12 years old. When we got married we tried asking the doctor what alternatives their were, such as a pill with the hormonal side but not the contraceptive. The doctor blew us off. We ended up just stopping the bill and putting it in God’s hands and it ending up working out for us. I wish there was more Catholic doctors around. If you mention using NFP or not using contraceptive to most doctors around here they look at you like your a nut.
 
As a male, this not something you suffer through, I do wonder why YOU flushed the pills, rather then your wife.
That sounds like crusading words. My wife and I are married, if she is sad, I am sad, if she is in pain, I am in pain, if she suffers, I suffer, if she experiences a joy of jubilation, I experience a joy of jubilation, and if she flushes them down the toilet, I flush them down the toilet, we are extensions of each other.

I find your moot point redundant, and submit to reiterate.
 
Suppose you put yourself into Our Lady’s shoes (or sandals…hehehehe.) Okay, what if birth control pills were around, Jesus would had been born? [Taking side time to pray, sorry Lord Jesus. I am trying to dive in their logic. And run it wherefore it goes against You and Your Ten Commandments. Sorry Mary, not to be sacrilegious.]

Do you see/get my point?
 
Not sure, really. But if Our Lady had been prescribed those back in her time. Then Jesus would not had been born.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top