Am I still allowed in?

  • Thread starter Thread starter plinko
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Geographer,
What exactly is your goal here? Consider your words and the need to be charitable to those who are not, perhaps, as excellent in the practice of your faith as you believe you are. You’ve gone far beyond telling someone what they need to hear in order for them to help themselves.

Where are my kites when I need them. What you, Louisianians, don’t get is that many of your bishops led you down heresy lane. I know first handed. Do you not understand sarcasm when you hear it.

There is no charity in watering down the truth. You are only adding to the problem by giving him imprudent advice for some control reason:shrug:. It is clear to me that he is not ready and needs to take more time out to discern. The priests we spoke through in RCIA also say the same thing. He should consider returning to RCIA for another year if he needs and try to find answers to questions that he is not satisfied with now. It sounds like your proselytizing rather than evangelizing, which is a fine line. And I do have problems just like any faithful Catholic.

Does the OP have problems with Catholic doctrine or dogma? Apparently. Does that mean they need to be horse whipped and admonished because they still want to call themselves a Catholic? Of course not.

I guess I need to pull out my horse whip now…apparently I forgot to horse whip him:rolleyes:Case and point. You did exactly what I did in my previous post. Is it your intention to be a hypocrite or is this really the way your think?

I hope that you’ll consider what you’ve written and give great thought to how best help someone who is struggling with aspects of our faith. After all, don’t we all struggle at times?
Of course we all struggle, but to lie to get in the door is really the same as a Catholic going to a protestant Church and participating fulling in their worship services. It’s a lie. Catholics that don’t accept and defend the teachings of the Church are no more Catholic that the next Protestant out there. This is NOT an insult but rather a compliment. 95% of my family is and always has been Protestant. About 90% of the Catholics of the 5% remaining have falling away from the faith and the rest are cafeteria Catholics. I’m speaking from experience. What you say about a life long learning is true, but the OP’s positions on serious sins is quite offensive and you’re just enabling him to sin, thus participating in evil in a sense. Abortion is the most offensive but allowing same sex marriages and relationships is equivalent to allowing heterosexuals shack up together and not call it sin. He is participating in evil. Now why, it’s because he probably doesn’t get some important things about the Church’s teaching rooted in orthodox Judaism which also condemns the use of condoms, same sex partner rights, etc.

BREAK

To the OP: Don’t give up on this journey. Some of your beliefs are inconsistent with Church teaching. But almost all of us have gone through times where our personal beliefs didn’t comply 100% with Church teachings. Many of us eventually came into alignment. And that’s not because we were brow beaten or because we wanted to check the “Catholic” block on the census document. It’s because as we age we continue to learn, to understand, and to gain wisdom.

May God’s grace be upon you during your journey.

Pax,
OA

PS: When I chose to convert as a teen, one of the biggest differences I saw between my Baptist church and the Catholic Church was the latter’s ability to welcome everyone and anyone. No homosexual coupleI know could walk into a Baptist church, enjoy the service and be comfortable. Yet I’ve never been in a Catholic Church that where that same couple couldn’t come and comfortably worship. How much more proof did I need that the Catholic Church was the true Church?
:eek: This is what I suspected. Love the sinner, but accept the sin is not the teachings of the Church. This is scandalous. No one pays attention at mass like this and wouldn’t know it unless they weren’t paying attention to the mass or if the “couple” held hands in a public display of their affection for each other.

Pax,
OA
 
That’s it, in a nutshell! My beliefs have evolved as well.

Interestingly, on the one hand my understanding and agreement with the teachings of the Church have increased although I still struggle in a few areas. On the other hand, after examining my own conscience, my compassion has increased and my desire to judge those who fall short, has decreased. I’ve come to realize that you don’t send a doctor to heal the healthy, and we are all in need of Christ’s redemption.

My favorite statement from a monk at our abbey is this: “I didn’t become a monk because I am righteous and a good Christian. I became a monk because I am a terrible Christian and without the support of my brothers I would surely head to my perdition. The monastery is not a resort for the righteous, it is a hospital for sick souls”.
The Church is a hospital for sinners, but it also tries to cure the sick. So judge not as in passing judgment into the eternal fires of hell is true. But to judge is merely an assessment that if one sees is obligated by their baptism to correct when appropriate. We are all called evangelism by our baptismal rites.

I knew a monk that left the monastery to attend a funeral of a parent or sibling. Upon his return for some reason he chose to share what he did during his time away. It included some pretty bad things that I won’t share. It was very over the top scandalous. He showed no remorse for it but said something similar above. This is no real reason to join the priesthood or to become a religious. In fact, now the Church is trying to weed out people like this. I was a seminarian and learned things the hard way after thinking exactly like some of these people on here. Once I realized it was wrong I ended up leaving the Church believing it was truly an apostate religion made up by men somehow during the first few centuries. Later on I found ACF that told a different story that proved the Church was actually Catholic/Orthodox.
 
I’ve done a lot of thinking recently and I’ve come to this conclusion: I believe every word of the Nicene Creed, but on issues of morality, I deviate from the Church. I’m against abortion and capital punishment but I support gay rights, condoms, the big bang theory (no intelligent design), impotent marriages, and little “sins” like accidentally taking a pen from the bank (well, “support” isn’t the right word for that last one, but you know what I mean) So can I still call myself a Catholic? I truly “believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty…in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only son of God…in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life…” ALL of that… I just have a problem with the non-core beliefs.
As far as you being a Catholic, if you were baptized you are **objectively **a Catholic. Nothing you do can change that **objective **fact.

On the other hand, subjectively, that might be a different issue altogether. As other posters have pointed out, there is a big difference between a lack of belief due to inadequate understanding and intentional rejection of the Faith. The first falls into the category of invincible ignorance while the second falls into the category of heresy.

2 Cor 4:3 And if our gospel be also hid, it is hid to them that are lost, 4 in whom the god of this world has blinded the minds of unbelievers, that the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God, should not shine unto them. As you struggle with these things, one thing that I would suggest is for you to consider that each and every one of use goes through catechesis in our lives. We are catechized by the church of the god of this world (see 2 Cor 4:4, above) at the same time we are catechized by the Church of the Jesus Christ.

We all receive instruction from the former: when we read news coverage of current events, when we watch entertainment programming, when we listen to secular music, when we surf the Internet, when we have conversations with worldly or even heterodox “Catholic” friends, and many other ways. The influences are ubiquitous and pernicious.

On the other hand, we may receive instruction in the latter…if we so choose. When we worship God, when we listen to a solid homily, when we listen to or read the Scriptures, when we study the teachings of the Church, when we read solid spiritual books and watch solid Catholic programming on TV, film, or radio, and, yes, potentially when we went to CCD classes, RCIA classes, or adult formation classes (provided that they teach the orthodox Faith and not some heterodox heresy).

But consider the Scripture that I posted above. We all receive instruction in how to believe from at least one or the other sources. So which do you WANT to believe?

Do you WANT to believe what Holy Mother Church teaches or do you WANT to believe what the church of the god of this world teaches?

If you WANT to believe the former and find it impossible to do so, then you need to change the mix in how you are catechized. You should pray for the grace to believe and then, as other folks have suggested, really take the time to prayerfully study what has been written on the subject. But note that I said prayerfully study…not just study: 1 Cor 2:14 But the sensual man perceives not these things that are of the Spirit of God. For it is foolishness to him: and he cannot understand, because it is spiritually examined.
 
The Church is a hospital for sinners, but it also tries to cure the sick. So judge not as in passing judgment into the eternal fires of hell is true. But to judge is merely an assessment that if one sees is obligated by their baptism to correct when appropriate. We are all called evangelism by our baptismal rites.

I knew a monk that left the monastery to attend a funeral of a parent or sibling. Upon his return for some reason he chose to share what he did during his time away. It included some pretty bad things that I won’t share. It was very over the top scandalous. He showed no remorse for it but said something similar above. This is no real reason to join the priesthood or to become a religious. In fact, now the Church is trying to weed out people like this. I was a seminarian and learned things the hard way after thinking exactly like some of these people on here. Once I realized it was wrong I ended up leaving the Church believing it was truly an apostate religion made up by men somehow during the first few centuries. Later on I found ACF that told a different story that proved the Church was actually Catholic/Orthodox.
And we are all called to do so in compassion, charity, and love…those things were lacking from your original response to the OP.
 
And we are all called to do so in compassion, charity, and love…those things were lacking from your original response to the OP.
Charity comes in humor too…you guys are kicking a dead horse and this seems to be the nature of Catholics everywhere. Protestants do the same thing, only they kick much harder and from my side. I’d be the one defending the ones they attack.

I forgive you for attacking me. This man can obviously come into the Church. That’s up to him and the bishop. But I’m trying to give him a head start and to see some things from a more humorous perspective. I’m sorry that you guys lack a sense of humor. If it weren’t for my new founded humor that I gained from the Army and being a anti-Catholic Protestant I might not have ever returned to the Catholic Church. 😦 Originally three years ago I really wanted to be Orthodox Christian because they seem to have a better understanding of practicing what they preach. The Catholic Church is full of dissenters. And I’m following our DRE and bishops call to evangelize, even if its with my bazaar sense of humor. I’ve recently heard several priests say similar things so I have a difficult time of giving non-clergy precedence over them. Catholics are giving the Church away hook line and sinker by not standing up for the teachings of the Church. You are not doing this person charity by bringing him into being more culpable for his sinful beliefs. At least now he’s covered by God’s loving grace of ignorance. In order to accepted in the ancient church you first had to actually believe without heretical beliefs. What you call being charity is Satan’s way of convicting you in the end. Satan is the father of lies and you seem to be buying into it. I’m trying to actually help this guy. My use of humor may not be your taste, but it is in many others I know in life. My spirituality may not be yours, but it is acceptable. You have chosen to take the less charitable view of my posts. Then by your own admission you are being very uncharitable towards me. But I understand that you are trying to do something that you believe is good. But I would say it is misguided. Your concupiscence is showing…😃

But, nonetheless, I’ll always seek those that get my humor, and they do.😃 You’re acting like a bunch of fairy tale women that want a prince in shining armor. Be gone. lol. Go play ball in the street somewhere where the traffic is fast and crowded. That’s a way of saying leave me alone, or do you really think I mean go play in the road. Naive aren’t we? Go search for your sense of humor. And stop trying to take the spec out of my eye when it has been made clear the log in your own.
 
Lots of good responses to the OP’s question. I just wanted to highlight this particular point made by James:
My concern here is not with someone who “struggles” with learning and understanding the faith (which I do as well). No - my concern is with those who misrepresent Church teaching publically by claiming to be catholic and publically standing in opposition to The Church.

I will give an example from myself.
I do not fully understand the “Immacuate Conception”. I understand the line of reasoning, but I do not understand why The Church teaches it as a required belief for salvation. That being said, I accept the belief because The Church says so and I would not present that it is acceptable for a Catholic to reject the Immaculate Conception. Any doubts I have are private to myself and to God.

Private doubts, concerns, etc are one thing. Professing these doubts publically is another.
Indeed. Even if you disagree with a Church teaching or don’t see the point of it, I think you still need to believe that the Church has the authority to teach on these issues and to prayerfully seek to harmonize your views with the Church’s. If someone doesn’t accept the Church’s authority, not to mention publicly challenging it, then I don’t see how s/he can be a “real” Catholic.

.
 
It seems a number of people have made assumption that the OP is seeking to "Enter the church. In fact he/she evidently is already a baptized Catholic. Their profile says so as well as This - in the body of their post.
So can I still call myself a Catholic?
So the issue is not one of whether they can be accepted into the Church but whether they can/should remain in the Church holding such views.
 
Lots of good responses to the OP’s question. I just wanted to highlight this particular point made by James:

Indeed. Even if you disagree with a Church teaching or don’t see the point of it, I think you still need to believe that the Church has the authority to teach on these issues and to prayerfully seek to harmonize your views with the Church’s. If someone doesn’t accept the Church’s authority, not to mention publicly challenging it, then I don’t see how s/he can be a “real” Catholic.

.
👍
 
It seems a number of people have made assumption that the OP is seeking to "Enter the church. In fact he/she evidently is already a baptized Catholic. Their profile says so as well as This - in the body of their post.

So the issue is not one of whether they can be accepted into the Church but whether they can/should remain in the Church holding such views.
Ahhhhh! Woops. Then I retract my silly little comments. But I still think they were funny.

I always tell open minded non-Catholics that they really are Catholic but that they just don’t know it yet.😃 You see the baptismal rite is Catholic and the Church is dialoging with other faiths using baby steps to try to reel them in slowly one at a time. It’s thte distortion of not allowing infants for example, because some say you must be a believer and then that gets distorted even further and further down the line. Confession time: I baptized my oldest son in a non-Catholic church. I confessed it, but the Church recognized it. In fact, we never were capable of getting a record of my wife’s baptism because of the way that congregation practices, even though there is a record of it in storage. But the fact that her daddy was a bishop and all of his children required being believers then our parish priest understanding that faith knew that she would never say she was baptized when in fact she was. Had he pursued it they would have resisted just to try to keep her saved in their views. The protest but do not consider themselve’s “so called Protestants”. You see to them we are all apostate and Catholics are the worst of the bunch because they worship statues and Mary. This group “planted their seed” in me when I was very young, 8 or 9 and that carried with me all of my life. This is why I recommend people not to attend Protestant bible classes or services. Unless you truly know the teachings of the Catholic Church or truthfully a strong understanding of your Catholic faith please don’t do those things. I thought I knew mine good enough, but they countered so many things so effectively that they literally backed me into a corner I couldn’t get out of. And I was preparing to return to the seminary. My excuse is that I was not catechized well.
 
Charity comes in humor too…you guys are kicking a dead horse and this seems to be the nature of Catholics everywhere. Protestants do the same thing, only they kick much harder and from my side. I’d be the one defending the ones they attack.

I forgive you for attacking me. This man can obviously come into the Church. That’s up to him and the bishop. But I’m trying to give him a head start and to see some things from a more humorous perspective. I’m sorry that you guys lack a sense of humor. If it weren’t for my new founded humor that I gained from the Army and being a anti-Catholic Protestant I might not have ever returned to the Catholic Church. 😦 Originally three years ago I really wanted to be Orthodox Christian because they seem to have a better understanding of practicing what they preach. The Catholic Church is full of dissenters. And I’m following our DRE and bishops call to evangelize, even if its with my bazaar sense of humor. I’ve recently heard several priests say similar things so I have a difficult time of giving non-clergy precedence over them. Catholics are giving the Church away hook line and sinker by not standing up for the teachings of the Church. You are not doing this person charity by bringing him into being more culpable for his sinful beliefs. At least now he’s covered by God’s loving grace of ignorance. In order to accepted in the ancient church you first had to actually believe without heretical beliefs. What you call being charity is Satan’s way of convicting you in the end. Satan is the father of lies and you seem to be buying into it. I’m trying to actually help this guy. My use of humor may not be your taste, but it is in many others I know in life. My spirituality may not be yours, but it is acceptable. You have chosen to take the less charitable view of my posts. Then by your own admission you are being very uncharitable towards me. But I understand that you are trying to do something that you believe is good. But I would say it is misguided. Your concupiscence is showing…😃

But, nonetheless, I’ll always seek those that get my humor, and they do.😃 You’re acting like a bunch of fairy tale women that want a prince in shining armor. Be gone. lol. Go play ball in the street somewhere where the traffic is fast and crowded. That’s a way of saying leave me alone, or do you really think I mean go play in the road. Naive aren’t we? Go search for your sense of humor. And stop trying to take the spec out of my eye when it has been made clear the log in your own./QUOTE

Your post speaks volumes about your attitude…I’ll leave it to the moderators to determine if your verbal tirade should continue on here.
 
Good luck plinko, Sorry you guys don’t have much of a since of humor. Like beauty, humor is in the eyes of the beholder. So I’ll be on my way and keep to myself. I’ll be praying for all of you guys and for God to be merciful in the end for all of us…after this I’ll unsubscribe because I receive 2 infractions for my posts. I hope that you realize that an infraction on a man made forum does not trump God’s justice. Keep it in perspective and you’ll live a joyful like. Otherwise you’ll end up on the scrupulosity role in the priests confessional.

I read through what I posted originally. My humor is a bit to swallow I agree. And I said some things that I feel very strongly about because I do see it far too much to be true. But I do see how it can be received with such unwelcoming charity. So if you are offended I apologize but even if you are I ask you to not be one of the dissenters that are in deed trying to tear the Church apart.

I’m in a really ornery mindset right now trying to get through this week waiting for my wife’s biopsy. I’m bouncing off the walls, trying to trust in God. This is my shortcoming. I was molested in the seminary by a priest and the way it was buried under the carpet I feel surprised they didn’t send a hitman to bury me. So any time someone tries to bury me now I react rather harshly towards anyone that tries to water down the faith both in teaching and in practice. To ignore Church teaching is the most serious offense against charity when you are verbose about it. So keep your doubts to yourself for your own sake and for those struggling around you.
 
I’ve done a lot of thinking recently and I’ve come to this conclusion: I believe every word of the Nicene Creed, but on issues of morality, I deviate from the Church. I’m against abortion and capital punishment but I support gay rights,
What would you consider to be “gay rights”? The Church itself teaches that we should not discriminate against persons with homosexual tendencies with regard to employment, housing, or basic necessities - however, we believe that it is physically impossible for them to be married to each other.
Educate yourself about the meaning of sex.
the big bang theory (no intelligent design),
I’m confused. Do you not believe that God is our Creator? :confused:
impotent marriages,
This was addressed above.
and little “sins” like accidentally taking a pen from the bank (well, “support” isn’t the right word for that last one, but you know what I mean)
The Church would consider that to be a venial sin.
So can I still call myself a Catholic? I truly “believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty…in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only son of God…in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life…” ALL of that… I just have a problem with the non-core beliefs.
Whether or not God is our Creator seems like a core belief, to me.
 
Although some people misunderstood my post slightly, I am comforted by all the nice responses. I wasn’t saying that I equate gay marriage with taking a pen; I realize that those are two different levels of morality. I’m saying here that I don’t think people need to freak out over accidental sins. You didn’t mean to take the pen, so why feel guilty? Put it back the next time you go to the bank. But I digress.

My main concern is that I’m open to certain teachings of the church, but I don’t ever see myself wavering on things like gay marriage or masturbation. I don’t want to turn this thread into a debate on the morality of these topics; I just wanted to see if it’s possible to not agree with certain teachings and still be accepted as a fellow Catholic.

I thank everyone for their nice encouraging words as I attempt to figure out how I can mesh my beliefs with the church’s. It’s nice to know that there are people out there like me who can take decades to figure it out.
 
I’m saying here that I don’t think people need to freak out over accidental sins. You didn’t mean to take the pen, so why feel guilty? Put it back the next time you go to the bank. But I digress.
I think any good priest would say the same thing, so I don’t understand where the disagreement comes in, with regard to the pen.
My main concern is that I’m open to certain teachings of the church, but I don’t ever see myself wavering on things like gay marriage or masturbation.
I think that if you were to educate yourself about the meaning of sex (Theology of the Body is a good starting place) you would be able to see the Church’s point of view, I think.
I thank everyone for their nice encouraging words as I attempt to figure out how I can mesh my beliefs with the church’s. It’s nice to know that there are people out there like me who can take decades to figure it out.
Oh, yes. It takes a very long time to “unlearn” the lessons that the secular world gives us. Sex as a recreational pastime, sex as the key to happiness, and all that sort of thing.
 
Plinko, my advice is to come on in and join our great big dysfunctional family! Keep on reading, praying, and pondering these issues. If every person who had a philosophical disagreement with the Church left, I wonder if there would be enough money for the Vatican to pay the light bill. The Church would crumble. We’d lose about half of all priests. So of course, we need ALL people who are called to be Catholic (even the imperfect, struggling ones)!!!
 
Plinko, my advice is to come on in and join our great big dysfunctional family! Keep on reading, praying, and pondering these issues. If every person who had a philosophical disagreement with the Church left, I wonder if there would be enough money for the Vatican to pay the light bill. The Church would crumble. We’d lose about half of all priests. So of course, we need ALL people who are called to be Catholic (even the imperfect, struggling ones)!!!
The Church would not crumble, even if there were only one faithful Catholic left on this planet, the Church would be glorious and eternal.
 
Although some people misunderstood my post slightly, I am comforted by all the nice responses. I wasn’t saying that I equate gay marriage with taking a pen; I realize that those are two different levels of morality. I’m saying here that I don’t think people need to freak out over accidental sins. You didn’t mean to take the pen, so why feel guilty? Put it back the next time you go to the bank. But I digress.

My main concern is that I’m open to certain teachings of the church, but I don’t ever see myself wavering on things like gay marriage or masturbation. I don’t want to turn this thread into a debate on the morality of these topics; I just wanted to see if it’s possible to not agree with certain teachings and still be accepted as a fellow Catholic.

I thank everyone for their nice encouraging words as I attempt to figure out how I can mesh my beliefs with the church’s. It’s nice to know that there are people out there like me who can take decades to figure it out.
In all reality it took me many years to come to understand those things I do now. I figured out in vitro fertilization on my own and when I returned to the Church 18 years later I discovered joyfully that I figured it out correct. I still struggle with NFP. But it is a Church teaching as long as its not used like a contraception, which still causes me trouble. You see I learned the hard way about some of the things you brought up. I felt much the same way. But in seeing with my own eyes the mess these things have brought us to it is now obvious to me that they are objectively wrong or incorrect. to accept them. I do understand that it may take you some time to learn. As I said, I’m trying to be humorous so I don’t lose my mind until I get word about my wife’s condition. We’ve already had one bout of cancer and this one is more serious. I believe its from her taking contraception and possible sterilization, which I’ve never approved of because of what it did to us during our marriage. I married assuming she had similar Catholic beliefs. What a very incorrect assumption.
 
The Church would not crumble, even if there were only one faithful Catholic left on this planet, the Church would be glorious and eternal.
Sorry for the exaggeration there. It would not crumble; we’d just lose a whole lot of members.
 
This is what I suspected. Love the sinner, but accept the sin is not the teachings of the Church. This is scandalous. No one pays attention at mass like this and wouldn’t know it unless they weren’t paying attention to the mass or if the “couple” held hands in a public display of their affection for each other.
I said nothing about holding hands, or public displays of affection. Indeed, let’s say they didn’t even go as a couple but simply an openly gay man or woman went to Church. That is not a problem in a Catholic Church (assuming he or she doesn’t accept communion). That would be, however, a big issue in a Baptist church. And that was my point.

By the way, you’ll notice I’m from Yokosuka, Japan.

You and I will simply have to disagree on what’s proper and what’s not.

Pax,
OA
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top