T
The_Geographer
Guest
Geographer,
What exactly is your goal here? Consider your words and the need to be charitable to those who are not, perhaps, as excellent in the practice of your faith as you believe you are. You’ve gone far beyond telling someone what they need to hear in order for them to help themselves.
Where are my kites when I need them. What you, Louisianians, don’t get is that many of your bishops led you down heresy lane. I know first handed. Do you not understand sarcasm when you hear it.
There is no charity in watering down the truth. You are only adding to the problem by giving him imprudent advice for some control reason:shrug:. It is clear to me that he is not ready and needs to take more time out to discern. The priests we spoke through in RCIA also say the same thing. He should consider returning to RCIA for another year if he needs and try to find answers to questions that he is not satisfied with now. It sounds like your proselytizing rather than evangelizing, which is a fine line. And I do have problems just like any faithful Catholic.
Does the OP have problems with Catholic doctrine or dogma? Apparently. Does that mean they need to be horse whipped and admonished because they still want to call themselves a Catholic? Of course not.
I guess I need to pull out my horse whip now…apparently I forgot to horse whip himCase and point. You did exactly what I did in my previous post. Is it your intention to be a hypocrite or is this really the way your think?
I hope that you’ll consider what you’ve written and give great thought to how best help someone who is struggling with aspects of our faith. After all, don’t we all struggle at times?
Of course we all struggle, but to lie to get in the door is really the same as a Catholic going to a protestant Church and participating fulling in their worship services. It’s a lie. Catholics that don’t accept and defend the teachings of the Church are no more Catholic that the next Protestant out there. This is NOT an insult but rather a compliment. 95% of my family is and always has been Protestant. About 90% of the Catholics of the 5% remaining have falling away from the faith and the rest are cafeteria Catholics. I’m speaking from experience. What you say about a life long learning is true, but the OP’s positions on serious sins is quite offensive and you’re just enabling him to sin, thus participating in evil in a sense. Abortion is the most offensive but allowing same sex marriages and relationships is equivalent to allowing heterosexuals shack up together and not call it sin. He is participating in evil. Now why, it’s because he probably doesn’t get some important things about the Church’s teaching rooted in orthodox Judaism which also condemns the use of condoms, same sex partner rights, etc.
BREAK
To the OP: Don’t give up on this journey. Some of your beliefs are inconsistent with Church teaching. But almost all of us have gone through times where our personal beliefs didn’t comply 100% with Church teachings. Many of us eventually came into alignment. And that’s not because we were brow beaten or because we wanted to check the “Catholic” block on the census document. It’s because as we age we continue to learn, to understand, and to gain wisdom.
May God’s grace be upon you during your journey.
Pax,
OA
PS: When I chose to convert as a teen, one of the biggest differences I saw between my Baptist church and the Catholic Church was the latter’s ability to welcome everyone and anyone. No homosexual coupleI know could walk into a Baptist church, enjoy the service and be comfortable. Yet I’ve never been in a Catholic Church that where that same couple couldn’t come and comfortably worship. How much more proof did I need that the Catholic Church was the true Church?
This is what I suspected. Love the sinner, but accept the sin is not the teachings of the Church. This is scandalous. No one pays attention at mass like this and wouldn’t know it unless they weren’t paying attention to the mass or if the “couple” held hands in a public display of their affection for each other.
Pax,
OA