An apologest Answer i dont agree with

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dchsknight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dchsknight

Guest
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=324940

is the thread, and to be honest i completely disagree with this answer. I don’t believe a clone would even have a soul. I think Cloning is an abomination and man trying to play in the realm of God and to be quite honest i believe that people who dabble in cloning will be damned to hell.
 
Let’s stick some numbering in your text:
  1. I don’t believe a clone would even have a soul.
  2. I think Cloning is an abomination and man trying to play in the realm of God
  3. and to be quite honest i believe that people who dabble in cloning will be damned to hell.
  1. All living things have souls.
  2. Yes, it is. So is in vitro fertilization. Are children conceived via IVF soulless? Obviously not.
  3. Not for you to say.
– Mark L. Chance.
 
Do you understand the process? While they are manipulating the variables of the egg…so to speak…a person is a person
 
Really? Even things like scum and bacteria?
Well, I’m not sure scum is alive, but yes. There are two types of souls. Humans have rational souls, which are immortal. Everything else doesn’t, but, if it’s alive, it has a soul, an animating, immaterial principle. This applies to animals, plants, et cetera.

– Mark L. Chance.
 
Though I appreciate the comfort, I think we can leave my ex-wife out of the discussion 😃
I assume she’s the bacteria since my ex-girlfriend is the scum… though she SERIOUSLY calls into doubt my belief that scum has a soul… 😛
 
…some still believe the earth is flat. Vivala difference…👍
The problem is that we know that the Earth is Flat. We have no idea what a Cloned human will be like. I think it is Playing in a realm that as humans we have Business playing in.
 
Let’s stick some numbering in your text:
  1. All living things have souls.
  2. Yes, it is. So is in vitro fertilization. Are children conceived via IVF soulless? Obviously not.
  3. Not for you to say.
– Mark L. Chance.
👍
 
The problem is that we know that the Earth is Flat. We have no idea what a Cloned human will be like. I think it is Playing in a realm that as humans we have Business playing in.
We know the earth is flat?:confused:

You think God would deprive a human being a soul because of something that is no fault of their own?
 
We know the earth is flat?:confused:

You think God would deprive a human being a soul because of something that is no fault of their own?
Clones arent Humans. They are exactly that, Clones. They are not made in the way that God Intended or Allows(Invetro). Cloning is Dabbling in God’s Playground and is man trying to be God.

And yes we know the Earth is round we have been in space and Seen it, People have flown around it, We have pictures and we have satilites that have taken Pictures.
 
The question on the cloning is are we starting at a embionic state or a stamped carbon compy? A walking organic robot? But living things as we understand them have souls.
Yes a compleat abomination along with other embionic manipulation.
Only God can judge man.
 
Clones arent Humans. They are exactly that, Clones. They are not made in the way that God Intended or Allows(Invetro). Cloning is Dabbling in God’s Playground and is man trying to be God.

And yes we know the Earth is round we have been in space and Seen it, People have flown around it, We have pictures and we have satilites that have taken Pictures.
Your the one that said we know the earth is flat. I know its round, was that a typo on your part?
Ok, well identicle twins are natural clones and they are human. If you clone a goat what do you produce? A goat right? If some immoral person clones a human being what will be born is a human being. Stop watching too much science fiction. God is not going to deprive an innocent human a soul because of someone elses sinfulness. He didn’t with “test tube babies” and He won’t do it here either.
 
Clones arent Humans. They are exactly that, Clones. They are not made in the way that God Intended or Allows(Invetro). Cloning is Dabbling in God’s Playground and is man trying to be God.

And yes we know the Earth is round we have been in space and Seen it, People have flown around it, We have pictures and we have satilites that have taken Pictures.
Are you saying then that ALL test tube babies are soulless and not really human? What is the difference, if the objection is that their conception is ‘unnatural’, between cloned and uncloned testtube babies? What about babies conceived premaritally or extramaritally? They too are ‘not made in the way God intended or allows’.

By the way - the fact that cloning happens necessarily means God allows it. Nothing happens without His permission, and He allows many things that He doesn’t approve of.
 
Aquinas argues that the number of souls corresponds to the number of living bodies. If you have me and also 100 clones of me, you have 101 souls.

I am against cloning as well, but for other reasons. There are better arguments than the “no-souls” argument.
 
yes it was a typo on my Part.

I guess what i am trying to say is that other then the no Soul, WHich i will hold to, it is again Man trying to Play God, which is why Cloning has not been very Successful.

There is also the point that God made you Uniquely you. Say for insistence that There is only one Heath Ledger. God made him, him and only him, There can never be another Heath Ledger again, there never will be. The thing is God has made man and has numbered his Days, We ahve free will but God knows our Lives like a book, and he wrote it. What cloning is, is to make another Heath Ledger( so to Speak) A Duplicate, That can not happen. God has already made Heath ledger and God took him away, By that God has ended heath ledger, Cloning is man coming in and say i know better then God and i am gonna make another one and be better then God, because i know better, it is one of the reasons as to why Abortion is wrong and Contraception is so wrong. Man trying to be better then God. it is what Satan tried to do, it is what he is still trying to do.
 
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=324940

is the thread, and to be honest i completely disagree with this answer. I don’t believe a clone would even have a soul. I think Cloning is an abomination and man trying to play in the realm of God and to be quite honest i believe that people who dabble in cloning will be damned to hell.
If the clone lives and breathes, it has a soul. And if the clone has will and reason, or the capacity thereof, it is a person, and therefore, has an immortal soul. A human clone, even in a vegetative state, would have a human brain, and therefore ordered to reason, and is therefore a person with a soul.

True, people who dabble in cloning risk their souls. But the precise reason cloning is so reprehensible is because the clone has a soul, and would from the beginning have had his human dignity violated, especially since he has been denied his own unique genetic makeup due to interference.

If clones were soulless, then there would be nothing wrong with it.
 
yes it was a typo on my Part.

I guess what i am trying to say is that other then the no Soul, WHich i will hold to, it is again Man trying to Play God, which is why Cloning has not been very Successful.

There is also the point that God made you Uniquely you. Say for insistence that There is only one Heath Ledger. God made him, him and only him, There can never be another Heath Ledger again, there never will be. The thing is God has made man and has numbered his Days, We ahve free will but God knows our Lives like a book, and he wrote it. What cloning is, is to make another Heath Ledger( so to Speak) A Duplicate, That can not happen. God has already made Heath ledger and God took him away, By that God has ended heath ledger, Cloning is man coming in and say i know better then God and i am gonna make another one and be better then God, because i know better, it is one of the reasons as to why Abortion is wrong and Contraception is so wrong. Man trying to be better then God. it is what Satan tried to do, it is what he is still trying to do.
A clone of Heath Ledger won’t BE Heath Ledger - it’ll be a different person with the same DNA. Identical twins or triplets or whatever have the same DNA as each other, having come from the same egg. They’re not the same person as each other, though. So your assumption is incorrect.

EVERY ONE of our sins says, in effect, that we know better than God. That’s a reason why cloning, IVF etc are sins, but there’s no reason why the human beings produced by these means are not human or are soulless.
 
Cloning is absolutely wrong but our physical body is only part of who we are. Heath Ledger was who he was because of his body and his soul. If someone cloned Heath Ledger, the new human born would look like Heath Ledger physically but he would not be Heath Ledger. There is more to us than DNA. Most importantly the unique human soul God gives us. Identical twins have the same genetic make up, but they are individuals, different people even though they look the same.

Unfortunately we try to play God all time. The first time that happened was with Adam and Eve, when the serpent tempted Eve by saying if she ate from the forbidden tree she would be like God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top