An update on the deadly risks of hormonal contraception and acne medicines

  • Thread starter Thread starter OurLadyPray4US
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

OurLadyPray4US

Guest
Please bear with me, I can’t (and would be forbidden to) advise any specific person for or against any specific drug. Whenever we decide to take a drug for a disease, it’s a decision based on an analysis of potential risks and therapeutic benefits.

But we need to raise awareness of the risks of “hormonal contraceptive drugs”, which are prescribed both for birth control and for non-contraceptive purposes such as treating gynecological conditions and acne.

Part of the problem is, many women will go to great lengths to avoid pregnancy, and they won’t mind taking drugs that have been shown to kill teenagers and twenty-somethings by causing blood clots, deep vein thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary and cerebral embolism, stroke, heart attack, and breast cancer.

The other part of the problem is that many doctors are way too easily prescribing the same dangerous medications for other women who are not trying to contracept, for the treatment of various gynecological conditions and acne.

Maybe a woman is suffering of such serious menstrual bleeding, cramps, endometriosis, or PCOS (polycystic ovary syndrome), that she truly needs some sort of hormonal drug to control it, even though the same drug has been shown to have caused the deaths of young women, due to pulmonary embolism, and has also been shown to cause a major risk of aggressive (triple negative) breast cancer. Sometimes we deal with desperate conditions that warrant taking major risks. But at the other end of the spectrum, does a woman really need to avoid acne or hirsutism (excessive facial and body hair) at the risk of taking a medication that could kill her (again, embolism, heart attack, stroke, breast cancer)?

We need to educate ourselves, because many doctors take a warped view and ignore the risks when prescribing dangerous hormonal drugs for non-contraceptive purpose, since the same doctors themselves might be taking the same dangerous drugs to avoid pregnancy. And these doctors may fail to realize that if they don’t mind taking deadly risks to avoid pregnancy, that doesn’t mean that they can nonchalantly and automatically prescribe the same dangerous drugs to other women who are not trying to contracept, and perhaps are only dealing with less serious medical problems that could be treated with other, safer drugs.

At last but not least, maybe some girls and young women who are sexually active and contracepting, against the Church’s teachings, will reconsider after they hear of the tragical deaths of so many young girls and women, caused by hormonal birth control medications. :gopray2: :signofcross:

quote from foxnews.com/story/2008/08/18/acne-medication-birth-control-pill-blamed-for-woman-death/ :

Acne Medication, Birth Control Pill Blamed for Woman’s Death
Published August 18, 2008
Newscorp Australian Papers

The contraceptive pill is being blamed for the death of a 24-year-old woman who was using it as part of her acne treatment.
Tanya Hayes, a student from Croydon in Melbourne, Australia, died Monday, hours after collapsing in her car.
Hayes had been taking Yasmin, an oral contraceptive recommended for patients using the acne medication Accutane, for about four months.
Hayes had ignored symptoms of a pulmonary embolism for about two weeks, including “breathlessness” and “a nasty, hard cough,” according to her family.
She collapsed outside a restaurant late Sunday night and was rushed to Angliss Hospital in Melbourne, Australia.
Hayes died less than five hours later after a pulmonary embolism, or blood clotting, occurred in her lungs.
Associate Professor Graeme Thomson, the hospital’s director of emergency medicine, said Hayes’ death had been “caused by blood clotting caused by factors related to taking the oral contraceptive pill.”

Read more: foxnews.com/story/2008/08/18/acne-medication-birth-control-pill-blamed-for-woman-death/#ixzz2ekYCdTcD

quote from cbc.ca/news/health/story/2013/06/11/birth-control-pills-yaz-yasmin.html :

Yaz, Yasmin birth control pills suspected in 23 deaths
Most died from blood clots, Health Canada documents obtained by CBC News show
CBC News Posted: Jun 11, 2013 8:51 AM ET

At least 23 Canadian women who were taking two of the most commonly prescribed birth control pills in the world have died, CBC News has learned.

According to documents obtained from Health Canada, doctors and pharmacists say Yaz and Yasmin are suspected in the deaths of the women, who mostly died suddenly from blood clots.

One of the women, 18-year-old Miranda Scott, was working out on an elliptical machine at the Okanagan gym at the University of British Columbia when she collapsed and died three years ago,

Risk of blood clots rises
According to Scott’s autopsy, she died of “disseminated intravascular coagulation,” which means that blood clots formed inside blood vessels throughout her body.

Teen girls as young as 14

According to the documents obtained from Health Canada, between 2007 and February 2013, doctors and pharmacists have reported 600 adverse reactions and 23 deaths where Yaz or Yasmin were suspected. More than half of the reported deaths were women under 26, with the youngest age 14.

Most of the deaths reported occurred soon after starting the pills. In Scott’s case, it was just over a month.

“And that was all it took, five weeks start to finish, and that was the end of a beautiful, beautiful girl,” her mother said.
 
quote from foxnews.com/health/2013/01/28/diane-35-acne-drug-linked-to-deaths-prompting-french-investigation/ :

Diane-35 acne drug linked to deaths, prompting French investigation
Published January 28, 2013
Reuters

France’s health regulator has opened an inquiry into acne drug Diane-35, which is also used as a contraceptive, after four deaths linked to the drug in the past 25 years.
Health regulator ANSM said on Sunday that Diane-35, produced by German drugmaker Bayer, is authorized in 135 countries and sold in more than 116. Last year about 325,000 women in France used the drug, ANSM said, adding it would publish its report next week.
ANSM said the four deaths were due to thrombosis linked to the use of Diane-35.

Read more: foxnews.com/health/2013/01/28/diane-35-acne-drug-linked-to-deaths-prompting-french-investigation/#ixzz2eknyLviI

quote from livemint.com/Industry/L6D0VwDLy23iyJDK3XH5lJ/France-suspends-acne-drug-after-contraception-deaths.html?ref=also_read :

France suspends acne drug after contraception deaths
Over 25 years, four women have died and 125 fallen ill from blood clots attributed to Diane-35
AFP
First Published: Wed, Jan 30 2013

quote from dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2299783/Contraceptive-pill-kills-20-women-year-blood-clots-says-French-health-watchdog.html :

Contraceptive pill kills 20 women a year through blood clots, says French health watchdog
Oral contraceptive ‘also causes 2,500 non-fatal blood clots’
Third and fourth generation pills under particular scrutiny
An estimated 60 per cent of women in France are on the pill
By SAM WEBB
PUBLISHED: 04:00 EST, 27 March 2013

Read more: dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2299783/Contraceptive-pill-kills-20-women-year-blood-clots-says-French-health-watchdog.html#ixzz2ekpvZBVD
 
It might be worth to seek out doctors who are open to trying to find alternatives to hormonal contraceptive drugs in gynecological conditions.

Quote from crisismagazine.com/2013/no-more-tears-moral-healthcare-for-women :

With tears in her eyes, Lindsey approached me during her junior year in high school after hearing a lecture I gave on the negative side effects of contraception and the alternatives offered by the science of NaPro Technology.

Lindsey was on “the pill” because her obstetrician insisted that it was the best means to manage the severe pain, vomiting, and irregular cycles she was experiencing. Lindsey hated being on the pill. It made her feel “gross,” she sensed that it was just managing symptoms instead of fixing the problem, and she worried about her future marriage and ability to have children.

She pleaded for help. I could offer little. There were no OB/GYNs in Houston who did not prescribe contraception.

Lindsey began charting her cycles, and found out that she had endometriosis on her appendix and other organs. Lindsey noted, “It turned out my right ovary was stuck to my pelvis due to the endo.” No wonder she was in such pain! She had surgery to remove the endometriosis this winter and feels better than she has in years.

Lindsey still has a ways to go as some symptoms still persist, but now for the first time she has a doctor who is seeking to find and cure the cause of those gut-wrenching symptoms. She recently wrote me, “The experience has been wonderful and switching to her has been one of the best decisions for my health. It has been so nice to finally find an OB/GYN who actually listens to what I am going through and actively searches for a solution instead of just giving away birth control.”
 
I have never taken anything for birth control, OF COURSE, and would be hesitant to take anythign oral for acne. And let me tell you, i have very severe, VERY painful, very ugly cystic acne all over my face. The creams I use are expensive and they burn, but I’d much rather use those than ABC
 
Please bear with me, I can’t (and would be forbidden to) advise any specific person for or against any specific drug. Whenever we decide to take a drug for a disease, it’s a decision based on an analysis of potential risks and therapeutic benefits.

But we need to raise awareness of the risks of “hormonal contraceptive drugs”, which are prescribed both for birth control and for non-contraceptive purposes such as treating gynecological conditions and acne.

Part of the problem is, many women will go to great lengths to avoid pregnancy, and they won’t mind taking drugs that have been shown to kill teenagers and twenty-somethings by causing blood clots, deep vein thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary and cerebral embolism, stroke, heart attack, and breast cancer.

The other part of the problem is that many doctors are way too easily prescribing the same dangerous medications for other women who are not trying to contracept, for the treatment of various gynecological conditions and acne.

Maybe a woman is suffering of such serious menstrual bleeding, cramps, endometriosis, or PCOS (polycystic ovary syndrome), that she truly needs some sort of hormonal drug to control it, even though the same drug has been shown to have caused the deaths of young women, due to pulmonary embolism, and has also been shown to cause a major risk of aggressive (triple negative) breast cancer. Sometimes we deal with desperate conditions that warrant taking major risks. But at the other end of the spectrum, does a woman really need to avoid acne or hirsutism (excessive facial and body hair) at the risk of taking a medication that could kill her (again, embolism, heart attack, stroke, breast cancer)?

We need to educate ourselves, because many doctors take a warped view and ignore the risks when prescribing dangerous hormonal drugs for non-contraceptive purpose, since the same doctors themselves might be taking the same dangerous drugs to avoid pregnancy. And these doctors may fail to realize that if they don’t mind taking deadly risks to avoid pregnancy, that doesn’t mean that they can nonchalantly and automatically prescribe the same dangerous drugs to other women who are not trying to contracept, and perhaps are only dealing with less serious medical problems that could be treated with other, safer drugs.

At last but not least, maybe some girls and young women who are sexually active and contracepting, against the Church’s teachings, will reconsider after they hear of the tragical deaths of so many young girls and women, caused by hormonal birth control medications. :gopray2: :signofcross:

quote from foxnews.com/story/2008/08/18/acne-medication-birth-control-pill-blamed-for-woman-death/ :

Acne Medication, Birth Control Pill Blamed for Woman’s Death
Published August 18, 2008
Newscorp Australian Papers

The contraceptive pill is being blamed for the death of a 24-year-old woman who was using it as part of her acne treatment.
Tanya Hayes, a student from Croydon in Melbourne, Australia, died Monday, hours after collapsing in her car.
Hayes had been taking Yasmin, an oral contraceptive recommended for patients using the acne medication Accutane, for about four months.
Hayes had ignored symptoms of a pulmonary embolism for about two weeks, including “breathlessness” and “a nasty, hard cough,” according to her family.
She collapsed outside a restaurant late Sunday night and was rushed to Angliss Hospital in Melbourne, Australia.
Hayes died less than five hours later after a pulmonary embolism, or blood clotting, occurred in her lungs.
Associate Professor Graeme Thomson, the hospital’s director of emergency medicine, said Hayes’ death had been “caused by blood clotting caused by factors related to taking the oral contraceptive pill.”

Read more: foxnews.com/story/2008/08/18/acne-medication-birth-control-pill-blamed-for-woman-death/#ixzz2ekYCdTcD

quote from cbc.ca/news/health/story/2013/06/11/birth-control-pills-yaz-yasmin.html :

Yaz, Yasmin birth control pills suspected in 23 deaths
Most died from blood clots, Health Canada documents obtained by CBC News show
CBC News Posted: Jun 11, 2013 8:51 AM ET

At least 23 Canadian women who were taking two of the most commonly prescribed birth control pills in the world have died, CBC News has learned.

According to documents obtained from Health Canada, doctors and pharmacists say Yaz and Yasmin are suspected in the deaths of the women, who mostly died suddenly from blood clots.

One of the women, 18-year-old Miranda Scott, was working out on an elliptical machine at the Okanagan gym at the University of British Columbia when she collapsed and died three years ago,

Risk of blood clots rises
According to Scott’s autopsy, she died of “disseminated intravascular coagulation,” which means that blood clots formed inside blood vessels throughout her body.

Teen girls as young as 14

According to the documents obtained from Health Canada, between 2007 and February 2013, doctors and pharmacists have reported 600 adverse reactions and 23 deaths where Yaz or Yasmin were suspected. More than half of the reported deaths were women under 26, with the youngest age 14.

Most of the deaths reported occurred soon after starting the pills. In Scott’s case, it was just over a month.

“And that was all it took, five weeks start to finish, and that was the end of a beautiful, beautiful girl,” her mother said.
Thank you. God bless you. When I was a teenager, I had excessive bleeding (age 13 or 14) the Doctor wanted to get me on “safe” birth control pills to help the problem. Thank God, my mother said NO. Guess what, my period became regular on its own, without any drugs. But, the Doctor was very persistent, he made it sound like I would not get relief without them 😦
 
Thank you. God bless you. When I was a teenager, I had excessive bleeding (age 13 or 14) the Doctor wanted to get me on “safe” birth control pills to help the problem. Thank God, my mother said NO. Guess what, my period became regular on its own, without any drugs. But, the Doctor was very persistent, he made it sound like I would not get relief without them 😦
I’m glad it worked out for you. Temporary hormonal imbalances are pretty common. Often a few cycles of birth control can help a female to not pass out from blood loss 😉
 
Megan7, thank you for the kind words, may God bless you too. 🙂
Often a few cycles of birth control can help a female to not pass out from blood loss 😉
That’s where the analysis of risks and therapeutic benefits comes in. How bad is the bleeding? Is there any other way to manage it? What are the risks of the pill? And what are the risks of not doing anything to treat the bleeding?

The scary part is, some girls and women died literally within weeks of being but on the pill.

Eighteen year old Miranda Scott was dead within 5 weeks after starting the medication:

“And that was all it took, five weeks start to finish, and that was the end of a beautiful, beautiful girl,” her mother said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top