P
pipper
Guest
Jacob, you seem to be laboring under the delusion that all extempore prayers are "from the heart, and all liturgical, written prayers are from, shall we say somewhere else.
That could not be further from the truth.
I too was brought up in a nonliturgical Evangelical church where all prayers were “off the cuff”, and thus assumed to be ‘from the heart’ and sincere. So many times I heard: “Dear heavenly Father, we just want to thank you for letting us come and worship you. Just let us agree to the truth of thy Holy WORD, and speak to our hearts through the sermon, In Jesus’ Name, aymin.” How is that not formulaic and ‘from the heart’?
But now I am a Catholic and think differently. I realise that extempore prayers are no more ‘from the heart’, and sincere than liturgical, written prayers.
What makes a prayer from the heart and sincere is not whether the prayer is extempore or written, it is that the pray-er thinks about what s/he says and means it.
One big advantage to me is that when liturgical prayers are used, they are all written down for the worshiper to participate. With extempore prayers that is of course impossible. In that case all the worshipper can do is sit and listen, they are given no chance at all to participate.
That could not be further from the truth.
I too was brought up in a nonliturgical Evangelical church where all prayers were “off the cuff”, and thus assumed to be ‘from the heart’ and sincere. So many times I heard: “Dear heavenly Father, we just want to thank you for letting us come and worship you. Just let us agree to the truth of thy Holy WORD, and speak to our hearts through the sermon, In Jesus’ Name, aymin.” How is that not formulaic and ‘from the heart’?
But now I am a Catholic and think differently. I realise that extempore prayers are no more ‘from the heart’, and sincere than liturgical, written prayers.
What makes a prayer from the heart and sincere is not whether the prayer is extempore or written, it is that the pray-er thinks about what s/he says and means it.
One big advantage to me is that when liturgical prayers are used, they are all written down for the worshiper to participate. With extempore prayers that is of course impossible. In that case all the worshipper can do is sit and listen, they are given no chance at all to participate.