Good morning, Sean.
As for pasture,…You present no valid argument.(no offense)I have not glossed over anything she said.
Out here in cattle country, the land used for pasture is not suitable for raising crops eaten by people.
This is the statement I was speaking of above.
You really shouldn’t underestimate the value of human industry. We can do practically anything. except making land that won’t support food crop, support food crops. You can do it for a few areas but not a large percentage. All the manure in the world wouldn’t cover much in the american west pasture lands.When you make an argument for your own limitations you have already failed.
When making an argument without knowing your limitations, you set your self up for failure, also.
Manure.Animals produce copious amounts of manure. For most livestock growers, including horse farmers, manure disposal or utilization is therefore of concern. Using manure as a source of fertilizer is an important aspect of sustainability for most small farmers. One of the main objects of this fertilization is to introduce nitrogen into the soil.
To get the nitrogen we typically apply manure with little thought to what we’re putting on the soil. We know the nitrogen is in there somewhere, and the rest, well, is organic matter. Right?
Only to a degree. Without knowing what is actually in the manure, we can’t possibly judge the efficacy of applying it to the soil. To maximize the benefit of your manure applications, you need to know both its carbon-to-nitrogen ratio and its concentration of phosphorus.
When you apply manure to your soil, the organic phosphorus binds to soil particles and is immobilized. Then, gradually, it becomes available to plants as phosphate. Because of this gradual release, excess phosphorus is initially not a problem. Applied year after year in large quantities, however, it can become an environmental hazard.
Because phosphorus binds tightly with the soil, few ways exist to remove it. One good way to remove it is to grow a crop that requires high phosphorus amounts. Corn is such a crop. Pastures, and even alfalfa, require much less phosphorus than corn, thus removing less of it from the soil.
Applied without consideration of the potentials for losing nitrogen and building up excess phosphorus, manure can become a hazard to your soil. On the other hand, due to its low cost and availability, manure used wisely is an excellent fertilizer for the small farmer.
I wasn’t discussing the use of manure at all. Although I did throw in a two word comment about it, I guess. Not intended to challenge your knowledge of manure.
As for the hydroponics issue.
Well, I must admit that this is my own private science fiction dream.
We all need to dream.
However, it IS feasible. For everyone to produce all food necessary thru hydroponics? How? I am in the process of constructing a hydroponic system for my fiancee so she can grow parsley, cilantro and mint out of season. Sounds great. I’ll bet she’ll be happy with it.
But, I come from the school of ‘Dream Big’.
Your arguments against insects is polemic, at best. Your implication is that I am taking a Jainist approach towards life. While, I am Vegan, and hold all life sacred(it’s a pro-life thing), I do not place insects above animals, nor animals above humans. To suggest otherwise is slander.
Relax… First it would be libel. Second the conditions of a misunderstanding cannot result in libel or slander. You presented a solution without considering the result of that solution. I was point that out. I’m sorry if you took offense.
I have done my share of hunting. I hunt no more. I gave my racks away. Archery was my game. I still target shoot. I have nothing against hunting. I don’t need it to survive. As an ex-omnivore, I think the meat is better for you. Plus, you got it yourself!
You made this generalization. I don’t necessarilly agree with sport hunting, as it is merely a pastime nowadays and not for survival.
I don’t hunt for sport, nor does anyone that I know of with a few exceptions. Yet you seem to claim that hunting is merely a pastime nowadays.
Hunt!Do it!

Someone has to manage the herds. But, to kill for the sport is entirely different than filling your freezer with a years worth of Elk. Agreed. I have little in common with a hunter that doesn’t use what God has provided.