B
buffalo
Guest
I wonder if God will ask - Why did you love your pet more than Me? I am present in the poor, the suffering, the sick, the dying, etc…
They wouldn’t be vicious in Heaven, I’m pretty sure, whatever form they take.The problem is that many people are annoyed by vicious killer dogs ready to attack and bite at any moment. I would like to be able to sleep at night instead of having to listen to these vicious animals barking all night long. I thought that in heaven I would be able to get away from these vicious creatures and get some peace and rest. I am not too happy about being in an afterlife with these vicious attack dogs.
Indeed, but we don’t know exactly what that’s going to look like; doesn’t really matter, I’d say. Similarly, it doesn’t matter HOW God might include all His Creation in the new heavens and the new earth, but there’s enough referenced that I’m pretty convinced He will.Well we do know that we will have our bodies but they will be glorified.
But all of Creation is groaning NOW…that includes the animals already here, which include our pets. It is heavily implied that all of EXISTING creation will have some sort of part to play.This of course is a separate issue from animals being in the New Heaven and earth at the end of time. Some people seem confused and think this means their pets
I’d would think Jesus’ resurrected body shows us.Indeed, but we don’t know exactly what that’s going to look like
That it is not a teaching of Jesus and His Church is convincing also.but there’s enough referenced that I’m pretty convinced He will.
We are not talking about the end of time and the New Heaven.But all of Creation is groaning NOW…that includes the animals already here, which include our pets. It is heavily implied that all of EXISTING creation will have some sort of part to play.
We’re talking about eternity with God, so yes we are.We are not talking about the end of time and the New Heaven.
Please show in the Catechism where the Church teaches this.We are saying that the Church teaches only humans have an immortal soul.
Like all animals when your pet dies its material soul ceases to exist. It does not go to Heaven.
Read all parts and you will understand.Please show in the Catechism where the Church teaches this.
None of that speaks to a definitive answer. Many Popes, however, have flat-out stated that the creatures will be with us in some form or fashion, including Pope John Paul II and then Pope Francis in Laudato Si.
Funny, how so many people cling to St. Thomas’ speculation on this matter and ignore the speculation of many very holy men and women since.
It is a definitive answer. Animals have souls but not immortal souls. When your pets die, for example, their souls do not go to Heaven. They cease to exist.. Many Popes, however, have flat-out stated that the creatures will be with us in some form or fashion, including Pope John Paul II and then Pope Francis in Laudato Si
Again, please show where the Catechism states this.It is a definitive answer. Animals have souls but not immortal souls. When your pets die, for example, their souls do not go to Heaven. They cease to exist.
Please show where the Catechism states this.Your comment is about something different. I also believe it is likely that “creatures will be with us in some form or fashion” but that has nothing to do with the topic because that is about the end of time and not now when cats and dogs etc are dying.
Please show where the Catechism states that animals will not go to Heaven.Its interesting too that you are simply picking and choosing from what individuals have said about this instead of sticking to what the Church actually teaches.
It doesn’t say anything about the souls of animals, so it’s not relevant.I already quoted the CCC. You have chosen to dismiss it.
Yup.. It teaches that from creation we have immortal souls.
Sure, but neither does it tautologically imply that animals don’t have a part to play in the afterlife.It does not therefore have to say animals don’t.
Maybe so. That still doesn’t mean that our animals don’t have some part to play. God is forever, and we know that He knows even when a sparrow falls. God does not create junk that is thrown away. Everything God creates was done for a purpose, and we have it that all Creation awaits the new heaven and the new earth.We are the only creatures with immortal souls.
So are many of the Popes then, apparently.You are blind.
I’m not saying that I can prove they have souls like hours. I’m saying that the evidence suggests we will see them again in some form or fashion. I have no idea how that would be.If I wanted to play your silly games I would ask you for a Church document that states animals have immortal souls and go to Heaven when they die!!
What exactly does that mean? What if we can see God in all that He has created, once we’re there? Do you think we’ll be looking at an old guy in white robes?A more important point - why would you even look away from God to see an animal in the first place? God will have your complete attention.