Annulment questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter gyspyvanner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gyspyvanner

Guest
I’m wondering if somebody can provide me with information regarding the annulment process.

I am in a relationship with a gentleman who has been divorced from his wife for six years. They were together for eight years prior to getting engaged, engaged for a year and married for eight years. They have a ten year old daughter. He is the one who initiated the divorce process. His wife was involved with at least two other men while they were married and after the birth of their daughter she was no longer interested in being intimate with him. He is a diligent father to his daughter and while married he was a very good husband. His wife recently requested an annulment.

From the research I have done I am under the impression that it will be difficult for the annulment to be granted however for the sake of his daughter as well as his commitment to his faith, I would like to support him as much as possible and provide him with the necessary knowledge to maintain his commitment to God.
 
I have never been through the process, but it is my understanding that he can cooperate as much or as little as he likes since his wife is the one requesting the decree of nullity (which states that a marriage never existed in the eyes of the Church even if it did under civil law). He may have to fill out a questionnaire or be available for questioning.

If the marriage is NOT declared null, keep in mind that any relations you have with this man would be considered adulterous on his part (and this should be assumed now since the marriage has not been declared null yet and so is presumed to be valid.) If this man still is a practicing Catholic, he should not be engaging in relations with you anyway.

If the marriage is not declared null, he will not be able to marry you in the Church until the death of his ex-wife.
 
I think it is awesome you want to be supportive. It would be excellent to help and encourage helping. in the process. it is meant to be healing as well.
 
silicasandra, thank you for your response. When he received notification he was only asked to provide a response. His response was simply Matthew 19:6, nothing more.

Our relationship is based solely on companionship, not intimacy. We do not co-habitate, however when he has his daughter the often spend the weekend at my home. She has her own room here and he stays on the couch. I live in a very remote rural community and she enjoys the country.

We have no intention of marrying, we’re in our 40s and health concerns would prevent me from having any more children and I am not Catholic.
 
mamaslo, I can be nothing but supportive 🙂 It is important to me that the values that he and his wife have chosen to raise their daughter in are maintained. I know that it is important to him and I think that due to the current state of society, the values of the Church should be practiced, not just preached. When commitments are made, especially commitments before God, it’s not something you can simply fluff off just because you think the grass is greener elsewhere.
 
silicasandra, thank you for your response. When he received notification he was only asked to provide a response. His response was simply Matthew 19:6, nothing more.

Our relationship is based solely on companionship, not intimacy. We do not co-habitate, however when he has his daughter the often spend the weekend at my home. She has her own room here and he stays on the couch. I live in a very remote rural community and she enjoys the country.

We have no intention of marrying, we’re in our 40s and health concerns would prevent me from having any more children and I am not Catholic.
👍

Sounds good. I just wanted to make sure I covered all the bases in my explanation since there are some intricacies that many people, especially non-Catholics, don’t think to consider. I have heard of situations where a couple wants to get married the next month or have a civil marriage convalidated (or “blessed” by the Church) but they find that a previous marriage requires a decree of nullity first and then it turns into a huge mess. 😦
 
I understand 🙂 He was a friend of my adopted parents prior to his marriage, I’ve known him for quite a while. He was a kind and attentive husband, a good provider and has been an amazing father. He filed for divorce because of her infidelity, it was very out of hand and she refused marriage counseling. The only valid reason I can think of for her to get an annulment is because she did not intend to be faithful, however I cannot even remotely imagine her stating that. If it turns out that she is being dishonest in her petition do you know what happens?
 
I’m wondering if somebody can provide me with information regarding the annulment process.

I am in a relationship with a gentleman who has been divorced from his wife for six years. They were together for eight years prior to getting engaged, engaged for a year and married for eight years. They have a ten year old daughter. He is the one who initiated the divorce process. His wife was involved with at least two other men while they were married and after the birth of their daughter she was no longer interested in being intimate with him. He is a diligent father to his daughter and while married he was a very good husband. His wife recently requested an annulment.

From the research I have done I am under the impression that it will be difficult for the annulment to be granted however for the sake of his daughter as well as his commitment to his faith, I would like to support him as much as possible and provide him with the necessary knowledge to maintain his commitment to God.
We are not in a position to give any solid advice on whether his case is a candidate for annulment. My gut reaction is that it may well be but there are many details that would need to be looked into.

The best thing you could do is to encourage him to contact his pastor. His pastor will likely recommend someone to him who is trained and handles such matters.
This person can explain the process provide him with the questionnaire, answer specific questions etc…

I HAVE been through the process and while it is necessarily detailed, it is not onerous.

He is lucky to have such a good friend.

Peace
James
 
silicasandra, thank you for your response. When he received notification he was only asked to provide a response. His response was simply Matthew 19:6, nothing more.
I’m a little confused…What was he “notified” about?

Peace
James
 
If either party was unable to form intent at the time of the marriage, the marriage can be annulled. There is an annulment forum on this site, but it would be better to consult with a pastor, or someone else who is knowledgeable enough to offer valid advice. Unfaithfulness is not sufficient reason.

Some diocese are more conservative than others. Best talk with someone locally.
 
Thank you JRKH. I am hoping for his benefit and more so his daughters that the annulment is not granted. I can understand how the infidelity would work into this.

He spoke with his pastor yesterday evening. I didn’t ask how it went. Maybe I should have but I felt that it was intrusive to do so.

He received some sort of notification from his wife’s diocese informing him that she was seeking an annulment, something saying lack of due discression but I am not really clear on what that mean. There were no specifics and there was no questioairre, just the option for a response which was scripture.
 
Thank you JRKH. I am hoping for his benefit and more so his daughters that the annulment is not granted. I can understand how the infidelity would work into this.

He spoke with his pastor yesterday evening. I didn’t ask how it went. Maybe I should have but I felt that it was intrusive to do so.

He received some sort of notification from his wife’s diocese informing him that she was seeking an annulment, something saying lack of due discression but I am not really clear on what that mean. There were no specifics and there was no questioairre, just the option for a response which was scripture.
Ah - OK so SHE has initiated annulment proceedings. Interesting.
Yes this is normal that the spouse is given an opportunity to respond…though I’ve never heard of it being a single question or opportunity to comment…hhmmmm

That said, and again he would need to check this out with someone local - O believe that even if the annulment is granted to her, he would still need to file for himself if he desired the marriage annulled…But this is more than I am familiar with and sounds kinda goofy…

Is this in the U.S. - If I may ask…

Peace
James
 
silicasandra, thank you for your response. When he received notification he was only asked to provide a response. His response was simply Matthew 19:6, nothing more.

Our relationship is based solely on companionship, not intimacy. We do not co-habitate, however when he has his daughter the often spend the weekend at my home. She has her own room here and he stays on the couch. I live in a very remote rural community and she enjoys the country.

We have no intention of marrying, we’re in our 40s and health concerns would prevent me from having any more children and I am not Catholic.
I understand he was trying to make a point by quoting that Scripture passage, but if he had the chance to explain his side of things, he should have taken that opportunity. She may actually be lying about the marriage, their commitment, everything. He should mention the infidelity and that they were married to each other with every intention of staying together forever.

Well, he will just need to wait and see. Maybe he will have another chance to tell his side of the story.

You sound like a good friend though!!
 
No if she is granted the annulment - the marriage is declared invalid - it is not one spouse being declared anulled and another one still married. It does not matter who files or doesn’t file.

Lack of due discretion basically in layman’s terms:
LACK OF DUE DISCRETION
This means that the person exercised poor judgment in entering into marriage. For some reason the person was not able to properly evaluate what s/he was undertaking, or to act in accord with good judgment. It must be a grave lack of discretion of judgment regarding essential matrimonial rights and duties which are to be mutually given and accepted (c. 1095.2). This is a very common ground, and encompasses many different situations, such as: gross immaturity, unwanted pregnancy, escape from an unhappy home life, substance abuse, emotional problems, etc.
We cannot say from the outside what she has said and what she has not said - we cannot really evaluate veracity as none of us were there at the time of their marriage which is when these grounds would apply. Your friends best bet is to get an advocate and tell the truth and go through the process.

Also, if your friend is living in a chaste state - why wouldn’t your friend want to know if his marriage is actually valid? I saw that you had stated that you hoped it didn’t go through for his sake. I am not sure what purpose this would serve for him to hold on to a marriage that was so obviously broken if the Tribunal does find that it was not valid when vows were taken or is there a different understanding you have or something else that I am missing?
 
Thank you JRKH. I am hoping for his benefit and more so his daughters that the annulment is not granted.
If you are concerned about the legitimacy of his daughter should the decree of nullity be granted, don’t be. The Church recognizes that a legal (civil) marriage took place. The child would not suddenly be declared illegitimate. It won’t mean that her parents were committing any kind of sin by having her, and she is not the product of a sinful relationship. Nullity simply means that at the time of the wedding one or both parties were not properly disposed to enter into a valid (by Church definition) marriage. I have heard of a book that many people say explains what exactly a decree of nullity means to the spouses and what it means for the children. It is called Annulment: The Wedding That Was. I understand that it is a very clear, concise description of what annulment actually is, and what it is not. Maybe it will help you and your friend.
 
Ah - OK so SHE has initiated annulment proceedings. Interesting.
Yes this is normal that the spouse is given an opportunity to respond…though I’ve never heard of it being a single question or opportunity to comment…hhmmmm
I didn’t see the paperwork, I’ll see it this weekend. From the way he described it he was only provided an opportunity for comment.
That said, and again he would need to check this out with someone local - O believe that even if the annulment is granted to her, he would still need to file for himself if he desired the marriage annulled…But this is more than I am familiar with and sounds kinda goofy…
Is this in the U.S. - If I may ask…
Peace
James
Yes James it is in the U.S.
 
I understand he was trying to make a point by quoting that Scripture passage, but if he had the chance to explain his side of things, he should have taken that opportunity. She may actually be lying about the marriage, their commitment, everything. He should mention the infidelity and that they were married to each other with every intention of staying together forever.

Well, he will just need to wait and see. Maybe he will have another chance to tell his side of the story.

You sound like a good friend though!!
Hi Juliane, I agree. If he wanted to quote scripture I think that is fine, however he should have included an explanation of some sort I would think. I think they go to the tribunal thing or at least meet with individuals from her diocese, so hopefully he will speak up at that point and explain his side.
 
No if she is granted the annulment - the marriage is declared invalid - it is not one spouse being declared anulled and another one still married. It does not matter who files or doesn’t file.

Lack of due discretion basically in layman’s terms:

We cannot say from the outside what she has said and what she has not said - we cannot really evaluate veracity as none of us were there at the time of their marriage which is when these grounds would apply. Your friends best bet is to get an advocate and tell the truth and go through the process.

Also, if your friend is living in a chaste state - why wouldn’t your friend want to know if his marriage is actually valid? I saw that you had stated that you hoped it didn’t go through for his sake. I am not sure what purpose this would serve for him to hold on to a marriage that was so obviously broken if the Tribunal does find that it was not valid when vows were taken or is there a different understanding you have or something else that I am missing?
Joanofarc thanks for your help! I think him getting an advocate is an excellent idea. Can his priest fill this role? He is the priest that married them, they were both parishioners of that church prior to the marriage and continued membership in that church throughout the marriage.

As to the second part of your comment, although they are legally divorced it is important to him that the sanctity of the act of marriage be upheld however I think your point is important and valid. I’ll attempt to bring it up with him this weekend 🙂
 
Joanofarc thanks for your help! I think him getting an advocate is an excellent idea. Can his priest fill this role? He is the priest that married them, they were both parishioners of that church prior to the marriage and continued membership in that church throughout the marriage.

As to the second part of your comment, although they are legally divorced it is important to him that the sanctity of the act of marriage be upheld however I think your point is important and valid. I’ll attempt to bring it up with him this weekend 🙂
I certainly HOPE that priest can be his advocate! If the priest knew both of them, he’d certainly know whether either of them could qualify as having a lack of discretion. She wouldn’t be able to claim something that wasn’t true unless she would be lying.

If I were in that situation I’d feel the same as your friend. If he knows that the marriage was valid, it’s rather insulting to have your spouse approach the Church as though it was never valid. It does call into question the entire marriage…it would be deeply troubling, as though the other person wants to say now, that he or she really never felt married or believed that they were.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top