Annulment questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter gyspyvanner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are concerned about the legitimacy of his daughter should the decree of nullity be granted, don’t be. The Church recognizes that a legal (civil) marriage took place. The child would not suddenly be declared illegitimate. It won’t mean that her parents were committing any kind of sin by having her, and she is not the product of a sinful relationship. Nullity simply means that at the time of the wedding one or both parties were not properly disposed to enter into a valid (by Church definition) marriage. I have heard of a book that many people say explains what exactly a decree of nullity means to the spouses and what it means for the children. It is called Annulment: The Wedding That Was. I understand that it is a very clear, concise description of what annulment actually is, and what it is not. Maybe it will help you and your friend.
Juno, thank you for the book recommendation. I will try and pick up a copy this evening. I think in part that what you said may be the case but I also think that it is important to him to uphold his vows. He was an alter boy and considered the priesthood and making vows to and before God is not something to be taken lightly. If the annulment is granted, I don’t think he will contest it however I think that he is concerned about what this will teach his daughter about ones commitment to God and others. I guess what it comes down to is that if you don’t have to take your commitment to God seriously it makes all other commitments even less important. Does that make sense?
 
I recommend the book Annulment The Wedding That Was by Michael Smith Foster. It will help you understand what nullity is and isn’t.
 
Joanofarc thanks for your help! I think him getting an advocate is an excellent idea. Can his priest fill this role? He is the priest that married them, they were both parishioners of that church prior to the marriage and continued membership in that church throughout the marriage.

As to the second part of your comment, although they are legally divorced it is important to him that the sanctity of the act of marriage be upheld however I think your point is important and valid. I’ll attempt to bring it up with him this weekend 🙂
The priest can help with the beginning parts of this process. However, more necessarily an advocate is someone who is versed in Canon law. I my diocese where my decree is everyone who has a case before the Tribunal is assigned of advocate. My advocate is a pastor at a parish and this is an additional duty for him - he is a very nice man.

As far as the sanctity of marriage - the annulment process does protect the sanctity of marriage because in all honesty sometimes marriages do occur that are NOT marriages. It seems to me like this woman may not have been ready for marriage in a lot of ways. This may not have been a marriage through no fault of your friend’s own. By protecting marriage sometimes we need to look at defining marriage for what it is and what it sometimes isn’t.

I strongly recommend he speak to a priest. I also strongly recommend that while I know you are a friend and you are doing your best to help a friend that you encourage him to do more of the work on this. After all - it is his marriage. You two are friends - you don’t have a “horse in the race” so to speak so you should not care more about the validity of his marriage than he does. I only say this because it is important that you protect your heart and your feelings. We women can be funny creatures and sometimes going through this may bring up a lot of feelings. This is one of those times where it would be really easy to look at someone with the possibility of becoming potentially single again and start to have feelings. I don’t want to read to much in - I just want to caution you as you seem to be very good friends and it is a tough situation.

I say this from experience. I have had a few good male friends come and go from my life. I even had one who was a very good, Christian man catch some feelings and he had to bow out for a lot of these same reasons when his life got to crazy. Why - I couldn’t be there like he needed me to be. I’m still married in the eyes of God. So instead of gaining that (well-maybe if) suitor for later I ended up losing a friend.
 
Juno, thank you for the book recommendation. I will try and pick up a copy this evening. I think in part that what you said may be the case but I also think that it is important to him to uphold his vows. He was an alter boy and considered the priesthood and making vows to and before God is not something to be taken lightly. If the annulment is granted, I don’t think he will contest it however I think that he is concerned about what this will teach his daughter about ones commitment to God and others. I guess what it comes down to is that if you don’t have to take your commitment to God seriously it makes all other commitments even less important. Does that make sense?
It is good that he takes this so seriously. He should, as should all who contemplate marriage.
However, let him also consider that the matter is in the hands of God and the Holy Spirit through the good offices of The Church. Should the annulment be granted, he can and should accept this as the Will of God in the matter and not try to hold on to something that does not exist.

Peace
James
 
It may be too, that she might be trying to do the kindest thing ever for him, so he can find someone who he can truly be one with.

Maybe she has finally grown up or her conscience developed enough…and she just knows the marriage was never a valid one.

From the explanation for the grounds, it sounds like she is being honest from what you mention he has told you.
 
It may be too, that she might be trying to do the kindest thing ever for him, so he can find someone who he can truly be one with.

Maybe she has finally grown up or her conscience developed enough…and she just knows the marriage was never a valid one.

From the explanation for the grounds, it sounds like she is being honest from what you mention he has told you.
👍
 
joanofarc thank you again so much. I will suggest that he do more research on his own and I will suggest that he ask his priest about finding him an advocate familiar with cannon law 😃

I also completely understand what you are saying about keeping myself in check emotionally 👍 I’m a widow, I have some pretty serious health concerns, run a farm and caretake another. I tell myself that I am not even close to being in a place emotionally for a ‘relationship’ relationship, but you’re right, we women ARE funny creatures! I think my main concern in all of this is my friend’s daughter. My friend is an adult and I know he is capable of handling the outcome, what ever it is although if the annulment is granted it is going to take him quite some time to heal. I think I will put the idea in his head to maybe have HER talk to their priest 🙂

James and mamaslo, if it is okay with you I would like to print out what you have both said and have him tape it to the top of his monitor at work, to the sun visor in his truck, on the bathroom mirror and anywhere else I can think of so he can be reminded of your kind and helpful words 🙂 James you are right, whatever the outcome it is God’s will, no one elses. Mamaslo, you are right as well, she may be giving him a very precious gift in her own way. I would love to see him have the opportunity to have a marriage in the truest sense of the word. He certainly deserves it 😃
 
.

From the research I have done I am under the impression that it will be difficult for the annulment to be granted .
there is absolutely no grounds to make such an assumption based on facts presented here, nor is it likely, even getting to know him well, that you will ever be in a position to know all the factors that pertained at the time of their marriage, and that is what is the basis of grounds for annulment. The only way for him to find out will be to apply through his own priest for an annulment investigation, give his testimony, provide witnesses who can attest to those facts. His ex will be allowed to give her testimony as well, and provide her own witnesses, but even if she does not participate or cooperate that will not stop the proceedings.

If you want to support him send him to his priest, and remind him that your romantic involvement cannot go any further until this is resolved.

sorry I read it wrong and got the genders of the parties mixed up. The fact remains the only way to get an answer that is relevant in this situation is to go through the annulment process. The status of the child is not affected in any event so is not an issue.

The waiting time can be one of immense grace if you do it in a spirit of looking for God’s will for you in this matter. It is also important, however, for you since you contemplate a possible future relationship with this person, to know why he may have some reluctance to pursue an annulment, because the answer could be very important to that future relationship.
 
there is absolutely no grounds to make such an assumption based on facts presented here, nor is it likely, even getting to know him well, that you will ever be in a position to know all the factors that pertained at the time of their marriage, and that is what is the basis of grounds for annulment. The only way for him to find out will be to apply through his own priest for an annulment investigation, give his testimony, provide witnesses who can attest to those facts. His ex will be allowed to give her testimony as well, and provide her own witnesses, but even if she does not participate or cooperate that will not stop the proceedings.
Hi puzzleannie, you are right, I am basing my thoughts on assumptions. From the outside their courtship and marriage seemed positive, they were both happy by appearances. But you’re right, it’s assumption on the part of myself and others.
If you want to support him send him to his priest, and remind him that your romantic involvement cannot go any further until this is resolved.
I think I said a few times that he has been speaking with his priest. I also thought I made it clear that we are not romantically involved. There is no physical involvement in our relationship.
sorry I read it wrong and got the genders of the parties mixed up. The fact remains the only way to get an answer that is relevant in this situation is to go through the annulment process. The status of the child is not affected in any event so is not an issue.
No problem on the mix up 🙂 He knows the status of the child is not an issue, his concern is for the moral effect this will have on his daughter. She is only ten, but only ten is far different from only ten when I was ten!
The waiting time can be one of immense grace if you do it in a spirit of looking for God’s will for you in this matter. It is also important, however, for you since you contemplate a possible future relationship with this person, to know why he may have some reluctance to pursue an annulment, because the answer could be very important to that future relationship.
I have a feeling the waiting process is going to make him bonkers. He understands that he and his wife’s marriage is no longer viable in the sense that she has remarried a non-catholic and has had two more children. He does not seek reconciliation but on the other hand he feels he made a commitment before God and he doesn’t feel that it is something to be taken lightly. I don’t contemplate a future relationship with him in a romantic sense, I enjoy his companionship. I have come to look at him as a brother, he understands this and he tells me that he feels as if I am the sister he never had, nothing more. I lost a brother at a very young age under horrible circumstances which has had a very profound effect on my life. My friendship with this person has been very healing for me and has allowed me to make huge strides in forgiveness which I hope will continue. If the annulment is granted I hope he is able to see it as some others have expressed. I would love to see him find somebody that he can have a true marriage with if he ever decides that is what he wants. I understand that it’s likely that our friendship would take a drastic change at that point and I’m okay with that. He’s allowed me to get to the point where I can be happy and I want the same for him 🙂
 
tell him to be encouraged…I like your idea for him to remind himself, that she might just be trying to change her life and help him.

Also, I have a friend who is my brother too. If we aren’t married to them that is all they can be anyway. I get so frustrated with people who ask my kids who their boyfriend/girlfriend is or do they have one. When they should be honing their friendship skills and taking care of one another, looking out for one another. If we say we are the body of Christ…his hands and feet…Christ is the head…we are the bride…then we best figure out how to take care of one another. Let go of jealousies, and pride…etc. If a person is married then you are still in the body of Christ. But that person is your flesh. So like a unit within a unit.

just me rambling. :rolleyes:
 
James and mamaslo, if it is okay with you I would like to print out what you have both said and have him tape it to the top of his monitor at work, to the sun visor in his truck, on the bathroom mirror and anywhere else I can think of so he can be reminded of your kind and helpful words 🙂 James you are right, whatever the outcome it is God’s will, no one elses. Mamaslo, you are right as well, she may be giving him a very precious gift in her own way. I would love to see him have the opportunity to have a marriage in the truest sense of the word. He certainly deserves it 😃
Thank you so much for your kind words. I hope that your friend knows how lucky he is to have a friend like you - and his daughter is mighty lucky too. You will be a tremendously positive role model for her…

Yes of course you can print off our comments. We seek to be of help to our brother in Christ, just as you are.

God has blessed both of you with this great friendship.

Peace
James
 
I want to let you all know how much I appreciate your advice and kindness. It really means a lot. I really just expected dry responses. This has been a wonderful surprise and helpful not only to my friend and his daughter, but for myself. In a way much more profound than you could imagine. Thank you.
 
Your post above warms my heart. Thank you.

The Church is indeed a warm blooded living thing. Full of great kindness in Truth.

Peace
James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top