Another "Kid" Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sariah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sariah

Guest
Hi! So, I’m looking for some feedback on something (but don’t worry, I plan on talking to my priest about this at my next confession)

In a nutshell…

I’ve never wanted to be a mother. I don’t particularly like children, and the thought of having a living being inside me does not fill me with the warm fuzzies, it…truthfully…leaves me feeling a little nauseous.

Husband has also never wanted children.

A few years ago I got my tubes tied.

Last spring I realized the sinfulness of that decision and confessed. While I am repentant of that action, the strong feelings against having children remain.

I guess maybe putting it another way would be better…I regret “playing God” with my body, but I still loathe the thought of having babies, and sometimes, deep down, I am glad that I can no longer get pregnant (I know, I know, nothing is 100%). Does that make more sense?

I guess I expected to have a whole big change of heart after receiving absolution and making penance, but I don’t feel any different, other than regretting going under the knife. I certainly don’t feel the need (nor have I felt like God expressly wants me to) to have the procedure reversed. Worth noting, my confessor told me that it was not required when asked.

I don’t know…It’s late, and I’m rambling…I’ve lost my point somewhere along the line…
 
Hi! So, I’m looking for some feedback on something (but don’t worry, I plan on talking to my priest about this at my next confession)

In a nutshell…

I’ve never wanted to be a mother. I don’t particularly like children, and the thought of having a living being inside me does not fill me with the warm fuzzies, it…truthfully…leaves me feeling a little nauseous.

Husband has also never wanted children.

A few years ago I got my tubes tied.

Last spring I realized the sinfulness of that decision and confessed. While I am repentant of that action, the strong feelings against having children remain.

I guess maybe putting it another way would be better…I regret “playing God” with my body, but I still loathe the thought of having babies, and sometimes, deep down, I am glad that I can no longer get pregnant (I know, I know, nothing is 100%). Does that make more sense?

I guess I expected to have a whole big change of heart after receiving absolution and making penance, but I don’t feel any different, other than regretting going under the knife. I certainly don’t feel the need (nor have I felt like God expressly wants me to) to have the procedure reversed. Worth noting, my confessor told me that it was not required when asked.

I don’t know…It’s late, and I’m rambling…I’ve lost my point somewhere along the line…
Pray for contrition.

And make an effort to think of it all as a miracle. With Christmas coming, truly reflect on God choosing to incarnate, to be a fetus in Mary’s womb, to be an infant, to nurse etc.

I wish I could put in words the kind of graces and blessings that come to us through our children.

It is sad to live not being able to appreciate the greatest gift God left for us. Children save us from ourselves. Sometimes we need to have them to be able to love them. Ideally, we should love children even if we don’t have any since God loves them and told us that to such as those is the Kingdom!

Also think of how you would feel if your mother had thought the same and made the same decision 20 or 30 or however many years ago. What a loss it would’ve been!
 
Read the passages where God tells us in Scripture that children are a blessing and ask yourself, why do I not want the blessings of God? Pray for God to soften your heart and bring you that contrition.
 
There is nothing wrong with you. Not all women are maternal, not all want kids, and not all of them have the ability to devote themselves to children. I’m glad that society is letting go of the idea that a “real” and “good” woman wants kids and devotes herself to them entirely. Sorry, but in the real world it just isn’t like that. And if you don’t want kids, you probably wouldn’t be able to give them what they deserve emotionally, so its better for all of you that you just don’t have them.
 
There is nothing wrong with you. Not all women are maternal, not all want kids, and not all of them have the ability to devote themselves to children. I’m glad that society is letting go of the idea that a “real” and “good” woman wants kids and devotes herself to them entirely. Sorry, but in the real world it just isn’t like that. And if you don’t want kids, you probably wouldn’t be able to give them what they deserve emotionally, so its better for all of you that you just don’t have them.
That is true, I suppose. But, if a woman is a Catholic and does not want children, she cannot marry validly in the Catholic Church. She is thus called to a vocation of lay single life or religious life.

Sariah has indicated she will speak with her priest at her next Confession. That is a very good idea.
 
That is true, I suppose. But, if a woman is a Catholic and does not want children, she cannot marry validly in the Catholic Church. She is thus called to a vocation of lay single life or religious life.

Sariah has indicated she will speak with her priest at her next Confession. That is a very good idea.
It’s been and done and overwith. As someone once said, just becuase they could have reason to get an annulment dosn’t mean a marriage is invalid. The marriage has been performed and she’s in it. The church will not and cannot declare otherwise unless there is a formal investigation.

While I’d be leary to encourage a marriage between two people who “say” they don’t want kids (becuase one inevitably changes their mind) In this case it’s happened, the window of parenthood has passed.

IMO being “open to life” dosn’t necessarly mean biological children, or even adopted ones. It can mean a couple who can donate generously to a battered woman’s shelter. It means a couple who can voulenteer to support family services. It means the aunt and uncle who can be there for their necies and nephews when the parents need a break.
 
Hi! So, I’m looking for some feedback on something (but don’t worry, I plan on talking to my priest about this at my next confession)

In a nutshell…

I’ve never wanted to be a mother. I don’t particularly like children, and the thought of having a living being inside me does not fill me with the warm fuzzies, it…truthfully…leaves me feeling a little nauseous.

Husband has also never wanted children.

A few years ago I got my tubes tied.

Last spring I realized the sinfulness of that decision and confessed. While I am repentant of that action, the strong feelings against having children remain.

I guess maybe putting it another way would be better…I regret “playing God” with my body, but I still loathe the thought of having babies, and sometimes, deep down, I am glad that I can no longer get pregnant (I know, I know, nothing is 100%). Does that make more sense?

I guess I expected to have a whole big change of heart after receiving absolution and making penance, but I don’t feel any different, other than regretting going under the knife. I certainly don’t feel the need (nor have I felt like God expressly wants me to) to have the procedure reversed. Worth noting, my confessor told me that it was not required when asked.

I don’t know…It’s late, and I’m rambling…I’ve lost my point somewhere along the line…
Me neither, nor my husband. We have been married for 15 years now…we are not kid ogres we simply don’t want any of our own. We use our free time to donate to charity, grant wishes, donate to toys for tots, and do volunteer work. Between the both of us, we shouldn’t be alive with all the health problems we have. But we live life to it’s fullest every day and help out where we can.
 
That is true, I suppose. But, if a woman is a Catholic and does not want children, she cannot marry validly in the Catholic Church. She is thus called to a vocation of lay single life or religious life.

Sariah has indicated she will speak with her priest at her next Confession. That is a very good idea.
We did. He didn’t kick us out.
 
Hi! I guess I expected to have a whole big change of heart after receiving absolution and making penance, but I don’t feel any different, other than regretting going under the knife. I certainly don’t feel the need (nor have I felt like God expressly wants me to) to have the procedure reversed. Worth noting, my confessor told me that it was not required when asked.

I…
you had a conversion experience that is what change of heart means, came to a mature realization of the truth of the issue, went to confession, and have been absolved. You got good advice from your confessor that there is no obligation to reverse the procedure. YOu cannot control your feelings, which may have deep roots you don’t even realize or undersand. You can do as we all must do continue to grow deeper in knowledge and appreciation of what our faith teaches on this issue and related teachings, but you can’t make yourself feel something, even if you can acknowledge that such a feeling would be appropriate.

Put it behind you and put effort into making your marriage loving and fruitful in the ways open to you with Christ’s grace.
 
There is nothing wrong with you. Not all women are maternal, not all want kids, and not all of them have the ability to devote themselves to children. I’m glad that society is letting go of the idea that a “real” and “good” woman wants kids and devotes herself to them entirely. Sorry, but in the real world it just isn’t like that. And if you don’t want kids, you probably wouldn’t be able to give them what they deserve emotionally, so its better for all of you that you just don’t have them.
You know, I am going to try and be charitable here. You have come to a Catholic forum, as an atheist, to get a question answered about your boyfriend’s Catholic family. As best we could, we answered that question, although you didn’t particularly like our answers.

And now, you, as an atheist, are answering questions that other Catholics are asking, on a Catholic forum, saying things like “in the real world it just isn’t like that.” Excuse me? In the “real world?” Our faith is based on God’s plan for us, which includes being open to life. We live in the “real world,” and I for one do not appreciate the implication that our faith is not the real world.

If you are here to tear down our faith in front of us, you won’t succeed. The Catholics on this forum are more than cafeteria Catholics, we are as faithful as we possibly can be to the Church teachings. We take our faith seriously, and speaking for myself, it grieves my heart for the OP and her husband. She has confessed but is not repentant, as is evidenced by her gladness that she cannot get pregnant. Yes, it is done and over, but it could be reversed, and she could change her mind about having children.

So if you are just here to insert your atheism into otherwise Catholic issues, forgive us if we don’t pay you that much attention.
 
To the OP, have you considered volunteering time and/or money to some program that helps kids in need or disabled kids? Perhaps you already do.

I think if I were the type of person who didn’t really want or like kids, I’d try to help out those people who dedicate their life to this cause.
 
There is nothing wrong with you. Not all women are maternal, not all want kids, and not all of them have the ability to devote themselves to children. I’m glad that society is letting go of the idea that a “real” and “good” woman wants kids and devotes herself to them entirely. Sorry, but in the real world it just isn’t like that. And if you don’t want kids, you probably wouldn’t be able to give them what they deserve emotionally, so its better for all of you that you just don’t have them.
You know BEL, there are other atheists on here, who have enough respect and decency to give CATHOLIC ANSWERS since this is what these forums are for. They put aside their own convictions and give the person what she is here for- a CATHOLIC perspective ( as best as they understand it)!

You, on the other hand, not only go about answering using atheist relativism, you also start debates with solid, Catholic users, who are doing what is expected on these forums.

If you do not know enough about the faith, please refrain from responding. People don’t come on here looking for your opinion, they come on here to understand what their faith teaches in a given circumstance. You are welcome to stay and learn Catholic position on every aspect of life but please have the decency to stop your out of place interventions. It makes it very tiresome for all of us.
 
IMO being “open to life” dosn’t necessarly mean biological children,…
I’m sorry. I like you, but this is factually inaccurate. 😉

The Church is very clear what being “open to life” means for couples who are married in the Church. Converts to the Church are not exempt from this obligation. Open to life is exactly that… open to life.

To the OP: Having said that, we all need to be mindful that God can do whatever he wants. I have two personal friends, one woman who had her tubes tied, and a man who had his lines cut. The woman later married and has had three children after being sterilized. The man and his wife had another child as well.

No, you are not required to have the surgery, but any Catholic couple that is still of child-bearing age, who would maintain that they are sorry for having the procedure done, but would refuse to have it reversed, would be manifestly guilty of hypocrisy, and would have no firm purpose of amendment. This is why the confessor will necessarily impose as a condition to the granting of absolution that the penitent accept to have the reversal of the sterilization performed, if it is at all possible. If the urologist or the gynecologist insists that it is not possible to reverse the sterilization, or if he maintains that the chances of success in this particular case are extremely low, then the couple is no longer bound in conscience to have the reversal done. Since reversal procedures are expensive and generally not covered by health insurance, it often happens that a couple does not have the funds for a reversal procedure. They should do all in their power to borrow or save up the funds to have the reversal done, but if this truly is not possible and for as long as it is not possible, then they are not bound to do what they cannot do.

God knows what’s in our hearts, and we know when God is calling us. You are on the right track. Keep listening to your confessor, and you and your husband will be fine.
 
I’m sorry. I like you, but this is factually inaccurate. 😉

The Church is very clear what being “open to life” means for couples who are married in the Church. Converts to the Church are not exempt from this obligation. Open to life is exactly that… open to life.

To the OP: Having said that, we all need to be mindful that God can do whatever he wants. I have two personal friends, one woman who had her tubes tied, and a man who had his lines cut. The woman later married and has had three children after being sterilized. The man and his wife had another child as well.

No, you are not required to have the surgery, but any Catholic couple that is still of child-bearing age, who would maintain that they are sorry for having the procedure done, but would refuse to have it reversed, would be manifestly guilty of hypocrisy, and would have no firm purpose of amendment. This is why the confessor will necessarily impose as a condition to the granting of absolution that the penitent accept to have the reversal of the sterilization performed, if it is at all possible. If the urologist or the gynecologist insists that it is not possible to reverse the sterilization, or if he maintains that the chances of success in this particular case are extremely low, then the couple is no longer bound in conscience to have the reversal done. Since reversal procedures are expensive and generally not covered by health insurance, it often happens that a couple does not have the funds for a reversal procedure. They should do all in their power to borrow or save up the funds to have the reversal done, but if this truly is not possible and for as long as it is not possible, then they are not bound to do what they cannot do.

God knows what’s in our hearts, and we know when God is calling us. You are on the right track. Keep listening to your confessor, and you and your husband will be fine.
Hmm this is interesting I have always read that in no way is a couple expected to have a reversal in this case. Like you said they are very expensive and not guarenteed to work anyway. Besides donlt you think that far better use could be put to that money? Like donating to a charity that helps children. Rather then spend thousands of dollars on a procedure that may well fail so you MAY have a kid. And if you find that you still can;t have kids afterwards.? Well guess what you just wasted a lot of money that could have gone to more concrete useful purposes that helped existing people.
 
Hmm this is interesting I have always read that in no way is a couple expected to have a reversal in this case. Like you said they are very expensive and not guarenteed to work anyway. Besides donlt you think that far better use could be put to that money? Like donating to a charity that helps children. Rather then spend thousands of dollars on a procedure that may well fail so you MAY have a kid. And if you find that you still can;t have kids afterwards.? Well guess what you just wasted a lot of money that could have gone to more concrete useful purposes that helped existing people.
The fact is that people will spend inordinate amounts of money on other things, but not the operation, thus falling into the category mentioned above. Look at the cost of the procedure, and look at what people spend on a new car, only to get another new one every five years. I find it implausible that couples with few or no children cannot afford it, but I can raise six children on less than $70,000/yr with no state benefits.

The OP here is taking counsel with the Church. This does not apply to her, but we need to be honest with ourselves.
 
You know, I am going to try and be charitable here. You have come to a Catholic forum, as an atheist, to get a question answered about your boyfriend’s Catholic family. As best we could, we answered that question, although you didn’t particularly like our answers.

And now, you, as an atheist, are answering questions that other Catholics are asking, on a Catholic forum, saying things like “in the real world it just isn’t like that.” Excuse me? In the “real world?” Our faith is based on God’s plan for us, which includes being open to life. We live in the “real world,” and I for one do not appreciate the implication that our faith is not the real world.

If you are here to tear down our faith in front of us, you won’t succeed. The Catholics on this forum are more than cafeteria Catholics, we are as faithful as we possibly can be to the Church teachings. We take our faith seriously, and speaking for myself, it grieves my heart for the OP and her husband. She has confessed but is not repentant, as is evidenced by her gladness that she cannot get pregnant. Yes, it is done and over, but it could be reversed, and she could change her mind about having children.

So if you are just here to insert your atheism into otherwise Catholic issues, forgive us if we don’t pay you that much attention.
👍👍👍
 
“any Catholic couple that is still of child-bearing age, who would maintain that they are sorry for having the procedure done, but would refuse to have it reversed, would be manifestly guilty of hypocrisy, and would have no firm purpose of amendment.”

Not for nothing, but it’s worth saying that my husband is not Catholic.

Thanks for the feedback, everyone. I know I haven’t responded individually, but I’ve been reading and processing (and praying!)

Hope you all have a good day!

S
 
So if you are just here to insert your atheism into otherwise Catholic issues, forgive us if we don’t pay you that much attention.
So much for your attempt to be charitable. If you’ll note there is a reason that I did not say anything about her marriage, what she should do, or whether or not she should go back to her priest. All I told her was that there was no reason to feel guilty for not having a maternal instinct. It isn’t a choice, and it is something that women of all faiths, and no faith, struggle with. And I think that we can all agree that people who hate the idea of having kids shouldn’t. That’s not an “atheist thing”, that’s a common sense thing. Now, whether or not her marriage should have happened or is valid is not for me to say.

I know you didn’t ask (And why would you? I’m an atheist, so it’s easy to presume to know what I think) but I am suspicious of the OP’s claim that she’s sorry. True remorse is usually accompanied by a desire to set things right. Whether she is obligated to reverse the procedure or not is immaterial. I think that she needs to be honest with herself and god and realize that the real issue is probably that she isn’t sorry. That’s what she needs to talk to a priest about.

Most people don’t generally say “I’m truly and deeply sorry for what I did, but I am grateful that I did it”.
 
So much for your attempt to be charitable. If you’ll note there is a reason that I did not say anything about her marriage, what she should do, or whether or not she should go back to her priest. All I told her was that there was no reason to feel guilty for not having a maternal instinct. It isn’t a choice, and it is something that women of all faiths, and no faith, struggle with. And I think that we can all agree that people who hate the idea of having kids shouldn’t. That’s not an “atheist thing”, that’s a common sense thing. Now, whether or not her marriage should have happened or is valid is not for me to say.

I know you didn’t ask (And why would you? I’m an atheist, so it’s easy to presume to know what I think) but I am suspicious of the OP’s claim that she’s sorry. True remorse is usually accompanied by a desire to set things right. Whether she is obligated to reverse the procedure or not is immaterial. **I think that she needs to be honest with herself and God and realize that the real issue is probably that she isn’t sorry. That’s what she needs to talk to a priest about.

Most people don’t generally say “I’m truly and deeply sorry for what I did, but I am grateful that I did it”.**
👍:clapping:

I agree with your post. I corrected your lower case for God, though.

😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top