Another odd priest in Minneapolis

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic29
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Catholic29

Guest
Servant of all
**Delma J. Francis **
Star Tribune Published August 6, 2005

He expresses disappointment over the Catholic Church’s role in promoting civil and gay rights. He believes celibacy among priests should be optional. He is ardently opposed to the war in Iraq and leads parishioners in weekly protest marches on the sidewalk in front of his church.:whacky:

At age 79, the Rev. John Brandes, pastor of St. Boniface Catholic Church in northeast Minneapolis, is hardly a retiring personality. And though he is nine years past the typical retirement age for priests, he is not yet ready for full-time R&R.

“This is pretty much a retirement parish for me, but I would go crazy if I were fully retired,” he said.

Brandes has been pastor of St. Boniface for 18 months, since returning from 10 years as a missionary in Guatemala, where he was assistant pastor of San Lucas Toliman Catholic Church. When he volunteered for the mission post, Brandes said, “it was my idea all the way. I wanted to go where I could slow time down.”

In thinking about where to go, Brandes considered the message in Mark 9:35, “Jesus called the Twelve and said, 'If anyone wants to be first, he must be the very last, and the servant of all.”

"I thought, ‘I’m old, I’m bald, I’m white, I’m skinny and I don’t know the culture of Guatemala. I’m everything a Guatemalan is not, so that’s the place to go [to serve].’ "

Brandes said he misses the warmth of the Guatemalan people but is finding satisfaction in leading the St. Boniface parish, just as he did at other metro parishes he’s served. He gets his energy and motivation from parishioners, who have taught him how to make sacrifices for justice through civil disobedience.

Although he’s never been jailed for his protests, “I have been to court seven times,” he said, mostly for charges of trespassing while demonstrating at Honeywell “back when they were making cluster bombs. The judge gave us community service. My feeling was that I was *doing *community service when I was arrested,” he said, with a smile.:whacky:

Lean and fit with blue eyes that twinkle behind wire-rimmed glasses, the cleric is often seen walking and biking around his neighborhood. So an hour a week walking up and down the sidewalk to protest the U.S. involvement in Iraq is hardly taxing.

“He’s just delightful,” said Patricia Foss, a Eucharistic minister and member of the church’s fledgling social justice committee. “He has far exceeded expectations. He’s open to trying new and different ideas as long as they meet within the guidelines of the Catholic Church.”

As the committee members and fellow war protesters march up and down the sidewalk Tuesday afternoons, “we are out there to bring joy and to promote peace,” Foss said. “We’ve had a lot of positive response. People smile and honk their horns.”

Brandes said the response “has been far better than I had expected. People are starting to recognize the dignity of all human beings,” he said.

Brandes is also just as passionate about his calling. He loves being a priest and knew from the time he was in fifth grade at St. Bridget Catholic School on Emerson Avenue N. in Minneapolis that this would be his life’s work.

Still, he wishes he had had the option of a wife and family along with it. He believes priestly celibacy should be optional.

Would marriage have made him a better priest?

“To know [firsthand] the trials and joys of a family, yes. Time-wise, no,” he said.

Parishioner Audrey Krolikowski said of Brandes: “So many priests live an isolated religious life, but he thinks there’s more to being a priest than serving in the building.”

She recalled a moment during a funeral when he invited family members to the altar and asked them to assist with communion. “He handed one lady the chalice, and she whispered, ‘But Father, I’m not Catholic.’ He said there wasn’t any reason she shouldn’t hand out the wine, and smiled and went about his business.”

Krolikowski added that Brandes “just keeps going and going and going. Everyone loves him. We hope he lives to be 100.”

When *will *Brandes retire?

“God knows,” he quipped.:whacky:

startribune.com/stories/614/5546492.html
 
40.png
Catholic29:
When Brandes retire?
One would hope that he’d be forced into retirement soon! I’m not holding my breath though…
 
Catholic29 said:
Servant of all
**Delma J. Francis **
Star Tribune Published August 6, 2005

She recalled a moment during a funeral when he invited family members to the altar and asked them to assist with communion. “He handed one lady the chalice, and she whispered, ‘But Father, I’m not Catholic.’ He said there wasn’t any reason she shouldn’t hand out the wine, and smiled and went about his business.”

Krolikowski added that Brandes “just keeps going and going and going. Everyone loves him. We hope he lives to be 100.”

When *will *Brandes retire?

“God knows,” he quipped.:whacky:

At 79 he has still not received basic catechesis?
 
It’s comforting that these types get older and older every year. They had their moment in the sun. But the sun always sets and a new day begins. Someone needs to remind these people, charitably, that the 60’s are over and we don’t want to go back there.

Orthodoxy, reverence and FAITH are the future. The gray-haired hippie hand holders with flowers in their hair are the past. And good riddance. 👋
 
A priest who has ceased to be catholic. Always a disappointing situation.
 
I have some friends, fellow parishioners at my church who told me about this article.

I did a web search and found it and immediately my head exploded.

I actually went off about it in my blog.

I can’t believe how ignorant people are!

Granted, I used to be completely ignorant, too, like this priest’s parishioners, but the difference is this: I was not pretending to practice my faith. These people are, and this priest is educating them in all things un-Catholic and anti-Truth.

Well, as the messengers keep saying, the lines are being drawn. These are the souls we need to pray for.

And especially that priest.
 
40.png
severinus:
At 79 he has still not received basic catechesis?
Indeed,

Nevermind him being ill formed at the seminary, which as well he most probably was, someone forgot to offer this guy basic catechesis…:tsktsk:

Instead of leaving for Guatemala to spread to the gospel of Jesus Christ and the sacraments of the Church to those people, he was sucked in to the liberation theology that was so prevalent there at the time, and has now seemed to of imported that nonsense (or his version of it) back to us.:crying:

Definitely someone who needs our prayers, and especially those parishioners he is misleading.:gopray2:
 
40.png
Catholic29:
Indeed,

Nevermind him being ill formed at the seminary, which as well he most probably was, someone forgot to offer this guy basic catechesis…:tsktsk:

Instead of leaving for Guatemala to spread to the gospel of Jesus Christ and the sacraments of the Church to those people, he was sucked in to the liberation theology that was so prevalent there at the time, and has now seemed to of imported that nonsense (or his version of it) back to us.:crying:

Definitely someone who needs our prayers, and especially those parishioners he is misleading.:gopray2:
I would be curious as to when he was ordained. Late ordinations really did not start happening in any significant numbers until into the 80’s. If he was 29 when he was ordained (which would be 3 years later than the averageat the time, he would have been ordained in 1955, which was a tad bit before Vatican 2, and at a time the seminaries were still doing a relatively good job…
 
40.png
otm:
I would be curious as to when he was ordained. Late ordinations really did not start happening in any significant numbers until into the 80’s. If he was 29 when he was ordained (which would be 3 years later than the averageat the time, he would have been ordained in 1955, which was a tad bit before Vatican 2, and at a time the seminaries were still doing a relatively good job…
An interesting observation,

Maybe it was shear disilusionment with the Church over the changes, or the percieved changes the council wrought. It could of been that it appeared to him that the faith he had been raised in was completely turned on its head overnight, which made him lose faith in what the Church teaches. But who knows, I wasn’t alive and Catholic in the 60’s to of experienced what all happened.
 
40.png
otm:
I would be curious as to when he was ordained. Late ordinations really did not start happening in any significant numbers until into the 80’s. If he was 29 when he was ordained (which would be 3 years later than the averageat the time, he would have been ordained in 1955, which was a tad bit before Vatican 2, and at a time the seminaries were still doing a relatively good job…
Cardinal Cushing started a seminary for late vocations in Massachusetts in the mid to late 60’s.
 
Joe Kelley:
Cardinal Cushing started a seminary for late vocations in Massachusetts in the mid to late 60’s.
I am aware of that. As I said, the significant start was in the 80’s. That does not mean that this guy was not a late ordination, only that at his current age, that would put him in an unusual category. I am just curious; perhaps someone on the forum is from that diocese and can find out.
 
Catholic29

Dear Catholic29, I can’t get these quotes just right, so I’m taking them right out of the Star/Trib article:
He is ardently opposed to the war in Iraq and leads parishioners in weekly protest marches on the sidewalk in front of his church.:whacky:
Hey, do I have a job for him!!! He can join the group that “marches” before the Planned Parenthood abortion mill on Ford Parkway, Saturday mornings at 10:00!!!
This is pretty much a retirement parish for me, but I would go crazy if I were fully retired," he said.
Well, sad commentary on how he has spent his life. My retirement is chock full to spilling over with things that I never had time to do before and endless new possibilities that arrive daily. Admittedly, drawing media attention to myself was never high on the list.
In thinking about where to go, Brandes considered the message in Mark 9:35, “Jesus called the Twelve and said, 'If anyone wants to be first, he must be the very last, and the servant of all.”
That includes even those both small and not on the media politically correct list!
He gets his energy and motivation from parishioners, who have taught him how to make sacrifices for justice through civil disobedience.
OOPS! Now he has me. There is no civil disobeience in our Rosary praying at Planned Parenthood. Again, no media attention. 😦
Lean and fit with blue eyes that twinkle behind wire-rimmed glasses, the cleric is often seen walking and biking around his neighborhood. So an hour a week walking up and down the sidewalk to protest the U.S. involvement in Iraq is hardly taxing.
Nor should an hour walking up and down saying the Rosary on Ford Parkway!
He’s open to trying new and different ideas as long as they meet within the guidelines of the Catholic Church."
That does it! I’ll call him tomorrow and suggest something that, although hardly"new and different," probably hasn’t even occurred to him! Let’s just see what happens!
“We’ve had a lot of positive response. People smile and honk their horns.”
Same at Planned Parenthood! There are even enough to cancel out the negative remarks! 🙂

Twin Citians, stay tuned!!! 👍

Anna
 
She recalled a moment during a funeral when he invited family members to the altar and asked them to assist with communion. “He handed one lady the chalice, and she whispered, ‘But Father, I’m not Catholic.’ He said there wasn’t any reason she shouldn’t hand out the wine, and smiled and went about his business.”

Does not this elderly priest realize that, at this point of the Mass, it is not wine in that chalice he handed the woman? This is sad, indeed.

Richard from Minneapolis
 
UPDATE: Friday, 3:25p.m. CDT

Telephoned the parish: only a recording of Mass times, etc. No indication of how to contact Father in an emergency. 😦

Website: no “contact us” feature…interesting “Pastor’s Page” suggesting creative liturgical ideas to stimulate participation. 😦

Email address: obtained not from website, but from an old (2002) Official Minnesota Catholic Directory…mail came back. 😦

On Monday, I will try again to reach him, If necessary I’ll go over there. Given the price of gas up here and the distance involved this will be a penance. But, all for the cause… 🙂

Anna
 
40.png
kaimpls:
She recalled a moment during a funeral when he invited family members to the altar and asked them to assist with communion. “He handed one lady the chalice, and she whispered, ‘But Father, I’m not Catholic.’ He said there wasn’t any reason she shouldn’t hand out the wine, and smiled and went about his business.”

Does not this elderly priest realize that, at this point of the Mass, it is not wine in that chalice he handed the woman? This is sad, indeed.

Richard from Minneapolis
You may be presuming a bit much. The quote is from another woman; she does not report in the quote that he said the non-Catholic should “hand out the wine”. In other words, it is ambiguous whether the words “hand out the wine” are a quote of the priest, or a statement that she is making; he might have said something specific such as “distribute the chalice” and she paraphrased it as handing out the wine.

Not trying to be obnoxious, but it is not given as a direct quote of the priest; it is given as a quote of the woman who directly quoted the non-Catholic, but may or may not have directly quoted the priest.

In other words, before we jump on him, let’s ascertain whether this is a “he said” or a “she said he said” quote. It is easy to misplace blame.
 
Anna Elizabeth:
UPDATE: Friday, 3:25p.m. CDT

Telephoned the parish: only a recording of Mass times, etc. No indication of how to contact Father in an emergency. 😦

Website: no “contact us” feature…interesting “Pastor’s Page” suggesting creative liturgical ideas to stimulate participation. 😦

Email address: obtained not from website, but from an old (2002) Official Minnesota Catholic Directory…mail came back. 😦

On Monday, I will try again to reach him, If necessary I’ll go over there. Given the price of gas up here and the distance involved this will be a penance. But, all for the cause… 🙂

Anna
Well, if you are going to ask questions, you might not only ask when he was ordained, but what seminary or seminaries he attended. I am curious.
 
Monday a.m.

OK, I got ahold of Father Brandes, thankfully by phone. I suggested that he might want to march before Planned Parenthood on behalf of the unborn, and he said that he had done that. I asked if he meant recently, and he said that he had just returned from Guatemala.

I understood that to mean that he hadn’t returned to prolife “marching,” and suggested that he come over to Ford Parkway on Saturday mornings at 10:00. He said he might do that “sometime,” and confirmed the time and place.

So, we shall see. :hmmm:
Anna
 
Saturday Afternoon: Rosary came and went; no Father Brandes. No surprise, although I suppose we must give him a few more Saturdays before drawing the conclusion that “no civil disobedience” and “no media attention” means no Father participation. 😦

Pray unceasingly,.

Anna
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top