Anti Depressants wrong?

  • Thread starter Thread starter homewardbound
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

homewardbound

Guest
I know some Christians are against them completely…but are they against Catholic teaching as well? I am entering, yet again another bout of depression…the counselors I’ve seen want me on ant depressants and a mood stabilizer, plus stuff to help me sleep and such…but I’m just not sure how to feel about it. I just keep hoping and praying it will all go away someday. For good.
 
Why should anyone be against taking medicine to treat an illness?

That is what depression is–an illness. A mental illness, but illness just the same. Severe depression is often based in chemical imbalances in the brain, including a lack of serotonin. The SSRI anti-depressants correct that lack and restore the balance. So how is taking them so different from taking any other medicine that aims to correct something that is wrong with the body?

Are the Christians who are absolutely against them also absolutely against quinine to treat malaria? Chemotherapy to treat cancer? Insulin to treat diabetes?

I wish other Christians not suffering from this disease would stop being so harsh, it is hard enough to suffer in this way without feeling like a dartboard every time you go to church. 😦

Zirconia
 
I know some Christians are against them completely…but are they against Catholic teaching as well? I am entering, yet again another bout of depression…the counselors I’ve seen want me on ant depressants and a mood stabilizer, plus stuff to help me sleep and such…but I’m just not sure how to feel about it. I just keep hoping and praying it will all go away someday. For good.
I am on anti-depressants.

Efexor-XR 225 mgs a day.

I have suffered depression for 20 years, but only had it diagnosed a few years ago. Until then I just thought I was moody and subject to getting down quite a lot. It was a huge relief to have a name put to how I was.

I am not sure on official Catholic teaching, but I truly believe it is an illness, and needs medication for most people.

I pray quite a bit too, asking God to take this burden from me. He seems set in His ways of making me keep it though. And for whatever that reason is, I continue on, trusting in Him completely.

Take the medication homewardbound. I know how you must be feeling. And keep praying. I know it would be great for it all to disappear. I will keep you in my prayers too.
 
I know some Christians are against them completely…but are they against Catholic teaching as well? I am entering, yet again another bout of depression…the counselors I’ve seen want me on ant depressants and a mood stabilizer, plus stuff to help me sleep and such…but I’m just not sure how to feel about it. I just keep hoping and praying it will all go away someday. For good.
Depression is a bodily (brain) disease and if needed you should take medication like SSRI sometimes it can affect your soul as well with scrupulosity and malplaced guilt-feelings and anxiety.
It can be helpful to bring this up with your confessor as well as your doctor.
 
“Honor the physician with the honor due him, according to your need of him, for the Lord created him; for all healing comes from the Most High, and he will receive a gift from the king. The skill of the physician lifts up his head, and in the presence of great men he is admired. The Lord created medicines from the earth and a sensible man will not despise them.” Sir 38: 1-4

So the scripture clearly teaches that we should do as the doctor advises in matters of our health.
I know many people who are helped by anti-depressants. Clinical depression is serious business and you need all the help that modern medicine can provide. Unless you really want to become another suicide statistic.

Matthew
 
Anti-depressants are NOT against the teachings of the Catholic Church. If someone told you that they they are greatly misrepresenting the faith.

Sometimes illnesses can be crosses for us to bear in this life. If you knew someone with diabetes, would you consider it a sin to take insulin? What about high blood pressure? etc, etc, etc…
Mental illness still has a long way to go before it’s accepted as a true medical condition… some day this won’t be a question.

God bless and good luck throughout this trial in your life. I sympathize (have been there myself).

Take care of yourself… and stay close to God in prayer.
 
Anti-depressents are not wrong. In my family we have had several people who have needed them. However in today’s world the drug companies will have nearly everyone think that they are depressed. Doctors are often too quick to prescribe medicine. Get several opinions.😃
 
I use a very good herbal anti-depressant called St John’s Wort.

How could it be wrong, It’s even named after a saint! 😃
 
Yeah… but it’s named after his WART… uhhh, I mean WORT!
:rotfl::rotfl:
haha!😛

Thank you all very much. I will try to find a way to get some more help. I agree with all of you. God gave us doctors and medicine for a reason!🙂
 
I’ve been known to ask this forum if it’s a sin to be depressed? The concensus was that if I was doing everything possible (within reason) to avoid the depressed feelings, then “no” it’s not a sin. One of the things I have to do to lessen the depressed feelings is take medication. Anti-depressants have saved my life because without them, I know I wouldn’t be alive today.

Joining the Catholic church has given me a much brighter outlook to the future. When I don’t feel loveable, I remember that no matter what my situation or what I may have done or said, God loves me and always will. We only have to endure a short time and them we will have eternal happiness. Can’t beat that. 😃
 
I know some Christians are against them completely…but are they against Catholic teaching as well? I am entering, yet again another bout of depression…the counselors I’ve seen want me on ant depressants and a mood stabilizer, plus stuff to help me sleep and such…but I’m just not sure how to feel about it. I just keep hoping and praying it will all go away someday. For good.
Anti-depressants are not wrong if they are truly needed, but it is cheaper and less time-consuming to take a pill once a day than to talk to someone about what’s going on. I believe anti-depressants are overused. If people would just allow themselves to get a proper amount of sleep, manage their diets, exercize more, and try to get rid of some of the stressful things in their lives, they would be a lot better off.
 
Poem 41. NO WORST, THERE IS NONE.

No worst, there is none. Pitched past pitch of grief,
More pangs will, schooled at forepangs, wilder wring.
Comforter, where, where is your comforting?
Mary, mother of us, where is your relief?
My cries heave, herds-long; huddle in a main, a chief
**
5Woe, world-sorrow; on an age-old anvil wince and sing—
Then lull, then leave off. Fury had shrieked ‘No ling-ering!
Let me be fell: force I must be brief’.
O the mind, mind has mountains; cliffs of fall
Frightful, sheer, no-man-fathomed.
Hold them cheap

10May who ne’er hung there. Nor does long our small
Durance deal with that steep or deep.
Here! creep,Wretch, under a comfort serves in a whirlwind: all
Life death does end and each day dies with sleep.

Gerard M. Hopkins, an English priest, wrote these words in the nineteenth century. “Hold them cheap May who ne’er hung there”. Hopkins knew what he was talking about.

Take a look at the lines - “Comforter, where is your comforting? Mary, mother of us, where is your relief?”

To suggest that all we who suffer with this illness need to do is:

“If people would just allow themselves to get a proper amount of sleep, manage their diets, exercize more, and try to get rid of some of the stressful things in their lives, they would be a lot better off.”

Would we say this to a cancer patient? I pray to God that the poster never has to endure what I endure and have endured. “Hold them cheap May who Ne’er hung there”.

Illness is illness. Medicine is medicine. There is no shame nor sin in taking medicine for one’s illness.
 
As the other posters, mentioned, I do not believe using prescribed Anti-depressants goes against Catholic teaching. I was on one for about a year and a half. That, therapy, prayer and support from my family and loved ones helped me get “over the hump” and taught me how to recognize if I was falling back into a slump. I needed the anti-depressants to stabilize me, my chemical imbalance and help me while I was in my darkest times. Once all of the other factors got stronger, I needed it less and less and eventually was weaned off of it. It can be misused, so you need to be sure that you have good physicians or psychiatrists taking care of you. It should only be a way to help you get back into your right senses. Although I do realize that some people will need to be on them for the rest of their lives. God bless.
 
I’ve been known to ask this forum if it’s a sin to be depressed? The concensus was that if I was doing everything possible (within reason) to avoid the depressed feelings, then “no” it’s not a sin. One of the things I have to do to lessen the depressed feelings is take medication. Anti-depressants have saved my life because without them, I know I wouldn’t be alive today.

Joining the Catholic church has given me a much brighter outlook to the future. When I don’t feel loveable, I remember that no matter what my situation or what I may have done or said, God loves me and always will. We only have to endure a short time and them we will have eternal happiness. Can’t beat that. 😃
Depression isn’t the sin; despair is. Depression is the state of feeling pessimistically inadequate and despondent, combined with uncontrollable mood swings, etc. Despair is a denial of hope in God – as in, “God can’t save me; I’m worthless.” So it’s possible for a depressed person to commit the sin of despair (though culpability is reduced or eliminated by the depression); but depression itself is not a sin.
 
Depression isn’t the sin; despair is. Depression is the state of feeling pessimistically inadequate and despondent, combined with uncontrollable mood swings, etc. Despair is a denial of hope in God – as in, “God can’t save me; I’m worthless.” So it’s possible for a depressed person to commit the sin of despair (though culpability is reduced or eliminated by the depression); but depression itself is not a sin.
However, depression may so affect the reason that the moral guilt is partially or completely removed from the issue of despair.
 
Not to make light of the subject but I thought this was cute.
I heard Dana the Irish Singer tell this story:

She always struggled with deep feelings of inadequacy. One day a priest friend told her he always felt inadequate. She asked how he dealt with it?? He said he went to his spiritual advisor and told him “he felt inadequate”.

His advisor responded, "you are inadequate, only God is adequate:)

(I hope it comes across OK written without Dana’s expression of emotion.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top