Anti Evolution Conference Nov. 2009

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Exodus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

The_Exodus

Guest
I’ve read various places about the anti-evolution conference in Rome last November. I also read some of the presenter’s abstracts. I don’t know enough about any of the subjects really to have any take on their arguments, but I’m wondering if there is a place where I can read more about the actual conference itself?

It’s frustrating to get into the whole evolution/creationism debate. I listen to evolutionists who are terrible philosophers, and creationists who are bad scientists. I have some faith that Rome will be more thoughtful towards the debate.

So, my main question - is anyone aware of the results of this conference, any publishings in relation to it, etc?

Thanks
 
I’ve read various places about the anti-evolution conference in Rome last November. I also read some of the presenter’s abstracts. I don’t know enough about any of the subjects really to have any take on their arguments, but I’m wondering if there is a place where I can read more about the actual conference itself?

It’s frustrating to get into the whole evolution/creationism debate. I listen to evolutionists who are terrible philosophers, and creationists who are bad scientists. I have some faith that Rome will be more thoughtful towards the debate.

So, my main question - is anyone aware of the results of this conference, any publishings in relation to it, etc?

Thanks
Neither creationism nor evolution fall in the realm of science. The study of origins deals with an historical event or series of events and is not provable in the laboratory.
 
Neither creationism nor evolution fall in the realm of science. The study of origins deals with an historical event or series of events and is not provable in the laboratory.
Your understanding of science is flawed. Much of science examines past events. We observe the present effects of past events. I was not present when you were born, nevertheless the fact that I can observe you here and now allows me to reasonably suppose that you were born between five and a hundred years ago. With more detailed observations I could narrow the error bars on my observation.

Science is not in the business of “proving” theories. All scientific theories are provisional, just as Newton’s Theory of Gravity was provisional and never “proved”. It worked very well and it still works well within limits. Outside those limits we use Einstein’s General Relativity. GR is also provisional and will be replaced by a theory of Quantum Gravity.

rossum
 
You’re assuming things, however, when you start doing that. You’re assuming that things then were the same as today, so you use today as a template to explain how things were and developed into today.

Take, for example, a crater or large canyon. You note that rivers slowly engrave mini-canyons in the Earth. You therefore explain the large canyon by theorizing that a river slowly carved it out of the Earth. Judging by the breadth and depth of the canyon, you assume it must have taken millions of years for such a thing to take place, and therefore conclude that the Earth, also, must be at least that old. Of course, if there was some catastrophic event that caused a deluge, like a sudden melting of ice in the caps and Mountain peaks caused by an increase in temperatures due to enormous volcanic activity, for example, caused huge-wide scale flooding across the Earth, thereby expediting a natural process creating the appearance of age. What appeared to happen slowly in fact happened quickly. If the latter event occurred, then you’re assumption that the canyon was formed slowly over millions of years would be incorrect, as there is more than one way for things to form. You also have to assume you are aware of all the myriad possibilities that are causes for things to be. If aliens in some distant solar system tour the Earth once every thousand years in order to test their latest super-cannons for fun/target practice, then that could account for some of the craters, which to the aliens are more like pot-holes from their newest, latest bad-boy cannon 😉

Of course, I am using science-fiction in the latter example only to demonstrate that it is quite foolish for us to claim authoritatively what happened and when in absence of a witness. We must assume that what we know presently is satisfactory for explaining the origin of things accurately and truthfully. As a result, any new theory or discovery will upset the status quo as new data is considered for explaining past phenomena.

Hence an accurate historical account is necessary for science to determine origins; otherwise, we cannot know (based on observations alone) because we were not there to witness what actually happened. If we are correct, it is largely by accident, and if we are wrong, likewise, it is by accident.

The same goes with your age-of-man theory. If someone has a genetic disorder that causes him to age rapidly, then you’re ability to judge his age will be flawed, because you are not considering every possible factor that could create the appearance of his age. You therefore assume wrongly that a man is 40 when he may well only be 24. My best friend is 25; however, most people assume he is in his thirties because he had a disease as a young man that caused his bones and joints to grow too large, too fast, and he also started balding in his early 20s.

Had you bumped into Adam and Eve when they were first created, you would wrongly assume they were in there teens, twenties or thirties or older, when in fact they were only a few days old. They were created physically developed, endowed with some knowledge and with the appearance of age, all of which things would lead us to assume they were older than they in fact were.
 
I’ve read various places about the anti-evolution conference in Rome last November. I also read some of the presenter’s abstracts. I don’t know enough about any of the subjects really to have any take on their arguments, but I’m wondering if there is a place where I can read more about the actual conference itself?

It’s frustrating to get into the whole evolution/creationism debate. I listen to evolutionists who are terrible philosophers, and creationists who are bad scientists. I have some faith that Rome will be more thoughtful towards the debate.

So, my main question - is anyone aware of the results of this conference, any publishings in relation to it, etc?

Thanks
Howdy Exodus,

As an attempt to answer your question (rather than debate the topic), I found this from the Vatican website. I haven’t had a chance to read it. It isn’t from the most recent conference, but it may address some of your questions.
vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_academies/acdscien/2008/BOOKLET_10.pdf
 
You’re assuming things, however, when you start doing that. You’re assuming that things then were the same as today, so you use today as a template to explain how things were and developed into today.
In many cases it is reasoanble to assume. It is possible that garysibio is over 500 years old or that he is six weeks old, but the likelihood of that is so very small that for practical purposes I can ignore both possibilities. Science is about “beyond reasoanble doubt”. I would also point out that science makes fewer assumptions than you seem to think. Many of what you call assumptions are actually checked scientific results.
Take, for example, a crater or large canyon. You note that rivers slowly engrave mini-canyons in the Earth. You therefore explain the large canyon by theorizing that a river slowly carved it out of the Earth. Judging by the breadth and depth of the canyon, you assume it must have taken millions of years for such a thing to take place, and therefore conclude that the Earth, also, must be at least that old.
There is more to it than that, but basically yes.
Of course, if there was some catastrophic event that caused a deluge, like a sudden melting of ice in the caps and Mountain peaks caused by an increase in temperatures due to enormous volcanic activity, for example, caused huge-wide scale flooding across the Earth, thereby expediting a natural process creating the appearance of age.
If the ice caps melted then none of the existing ice caps would be older than the proposed date of the flood. If there was enormous volcanic activity then there should be lots of lava dated to around the date of the flood. If there was a large flood then we should not see land animal footprints from the middle of the flood, land animal burrows from the middls of the flood, lithified sand dunes (formed by wind, not water) in the middle of a flood and various other things.

When we look at, say, the Grand Canyon we find land animal burrows at many levels, land animal footprints at many levels, lithified sand dunes and other features that indicate that the Grand Canyon was not formed quickly by a large flood. We find ice caps in Greenland older than the proposed flood. There are some very large lava fields such as the Deccan Traps or the Siberian Traps but they are not of the right date for the proposed global flood being millions of years older that the Grand Canyon.

Scientific evidence has to hang together into a reasonably consistent whole. The proposed catastrophic formation of the Grand Canyon does not hang together with what we can observe today.
Hence an accurate historical account is necessary for science to determine origins;
How do you know that what purports to be an accurate historical account is actually that? We do not have Homer’s original copy of the Iliad; what we have is a copy of a copy of a copy. We have different versions, each with their own indicative copyists errors. We have no absolute proof that the whole thing was not forged hundreds of years after Homer was meant to have lived. There is at least as much uncertainty about any supposed historical account as there is about scientific data.

rossum
 
@Timothy17

What we find in science is independent, unrelated observations from a variety of unrated fields that all point to the same explanation, hence why is is reasonable to draw conclusions.
 
Your understanding of science is flawed. Much of science examines past events. We observe the present effects of past events. I was not present when you were born, nevertheless the fact that I can observe you here and now allows me to reasonably suppose that you were born between five and a hundred years ago. With more detailed observations I could narrow the error bars on my observation.

Science is not in the business of “proving” theories. All scientific theories are provisional, just as Newton’s Theory of Gravity was provisional and never “proved”. It worked very well and it still works well within limits. Outside those limits we use Einstein’s General Relativity. GR is also provisional and will be replaced by a theory of Quantum Gravity.

rossum
No, YOU are wrong. At one time, phrenology was “science”. Then animal magnetism was “science”. You, like most people today confuse science fiction with science. You state that something is science, and then when it is proven false, you say that now science teaches us something different. The old “science” is now false. Well, if it is false now, it was false when it was in vogue.

Real science is demonstrable. Otherwise, it is science fiction. Until you can prove something, don’t call it science.

And another thing, science is not based on assumptions. Evolution is based on the idea that life came into being as a result of natural forces, and “evolved” into the variations of flora and fauna seen today, and in the fossil record. THIS IS AN ASSUMPATION, and science is NOT based on assumptions.

Until you can prove that life can originate of its own volition, from natural processes, Evolution remains in the realm of science fiction.
 
Until you can prove something, don’t call it science.
Was Newton’s Theory of Gravity science? It was shown to be incorrect by Einstein’s General Relativity. We already know that General Relativity is not the complete answer so we are now looking for a theory of Quantum Gravity.
And another thing, science is not based on assumptions.
Correct. Wherever possible assumptions are avoided.
Evolution is based on the idea that life came into being as a result of natural forces, and “evolved” into the variations of flora and fauna seen today, and in the fossil record. THIS IS AN ASSUMPATION, and science is NOT based on assumptions.
What is the assumption? Evolution has been observed many times. Every time an insect evolves immunity to an insecticide we are observing evolution.

Abiogenesis is a different field where there is still a lot more work to do. We are in the process of studying the chemistry of the early earth. All we have for abiogenesis are hypotheses; we do not yet know enough to construct a fully-fledged theory.
Until you can prove that life can originate of its own volition, from natural processes
You have no answer to the question of the origin of life. You cannot use a living God to explain the origin of life. At most the living God can only explain the origin of the second living thing, not the first. What is your explanation for the origin of the first living thing?
Evolution remains in the realm of science fiction.
You are confusing abiogenesis with evolution. They are two different things.

rossum
 
Rossum is correct you are confusing theories.

Also you state “Until you can prove something, don’t call it science.”

This is incorrect, science does not “prove” anything.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top