Any Apophaticism In Rome?

  • Thread starter Thread starter WoundedIcon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

WoundedIcon

Guest
I was wondering if, beyond St. John of the Cross, there is any apophatic theology in Roman Catholicism. I’ve studied cataphatic stuff to the point where it isn’t as interesting to me anymore, (it doesn’t touch my prayer life as much, etc.) especially since I’ve had some mystical experiences and have tasted what’s behind the flurry of words. I’ve been considering Byzantine Catholicism but I like the rites and more scholarly approach of the West better, so this is important because it’ll help me find where I fit.

Your help is appreciated,

Tony
 
I was wondering if, beyond St. John of the Cross, there is any apophatic theology in Roman Catholicism. I’ve studied cataphatic stuff to the point where it isn’t as interesting to me anymore, (it doesn’t touch my prayer life as much, etc.) especially since I’ve had some mystical experiences and have tasted what’s behind the flurry of words. I’ve been considering Byzantine Catholicism but I like the rites and more scholarly approach of the West better, so this is important because it’ll help me find where I fit.

Your help is appreciated,

Tony
Pseudo-Dionysius
Meister Eckhart
The Cloud of Unknowing

et cetera
und so wieder
 
I was wondering if, beyond St. John of the Cross, there is any apophatic theology in Roman Catholicism. I’ve studied cataphatic stuff to the point where it isn’t as interesting to me anymore, (it doesn’t touch my prayer life as much, etc.) especially since I’ve had some mystical experiences and have tasted what’s behind the flurry of words. I’ve been considering Byzantine Catholicism but I like the rites and more scholarly approach of the West better, so this is important because it’ll help me find where I fit.

Your help is appreciated,

Tony
May the grace and peace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you.

I suggest that you read some books written by Fr George Maloney, S.J.
amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=george+maloney+sj

God bless you,
Quis ut Deus 3
 
John Scotus Eriugena

I think Anselm’s Proslogion has real apophatic qualities to it as well, though most people wouldn’t think of it that way.

I don’t know if I would call Pseudo-Dionysius Roman though.
 
Osuna and Richard of St. Victor. Ruusbroec to a degree.

Many mystics have elements of this though they don’t fall exclusively into one school or the other.
 
Osuna and Richard of St. Victor. Ruusbroec to a degree.

Many mystics have elements of this though they don’t fall exclusively into one school or the other. I think St. Teresa of Avila is an example of this: kataphatic practice leads to apophatic contemplation which, in turn, is sustained by the kataphatic.
 
P.S.

I think St. Teresa of Avila is an example of someone who speaks of both: kataphatic practice leads to apophatic contemplation which, in turn, is sustained by the kataphatic. At least how I see it.
 
I believe the mysticism of Thomas Aquinas was apophatic but this is just something I heard once and didn’t investigate.
 
I will also add my recommendation of the Cloud of Unknowing and the great Carmelites St. John of the Cross and St. Teresa of Avila and their commentators, including, for example, Fr. Thomas Dubay. For a more contemporary writer, Thomas Merton’s writings on prayer, particularly “New Seeds of Contemplation,” are very good.

For a good treatment of the transition from meditative prayer to contemplative prayer, I suggest Thomas Green, S.J.'s “When the Well Runs Dry” and “Water from a Dry Well.” Although a Jesuit, Fr. Green draws heavily from the Carmelite tradition.

I am a big believer that spiritual direction is especially important for those who practice contemplative prayer.

I am not a big fan of the contemporary Contemplative Prayer movement and its proponents such as Thomas Keating, OCSO, and M. Basil Pennington, OCSO. I prefer St. Teresa of Avila’s more cautious approach that sought to assess a person’s readiness for the prayer of quiet and was less focused on technique.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top