C
Cristiano
Guest
Again you are not answering my question by providing numbers and playing with models to justify your take. Where do you come with absurd 100 times off the standard deviation? Is going to heaven and hell a normal distribution? Are you saying that one individual can go at the same time a lot to hell and a little bit to heaven? This is the math that you are using! My math is based on a pure bi-modal delta distribution where you are got to hell or to heaven.Settle down, you’re getting over-excited. Now to begin with, you know that 33,000 is an enormous sample. You also know that I don’t know the exact number of those who died without personal sin, but given the conditions in the early middle ages, let us pick the number of 1/4. That is, 1/4 of those who died did so before reaching the age of reason, either as miscarriages or as infants or as young children. You can of course do the math with any reasonable number you choose, and my point will remain.
I won’t post the math here, but having only 5 people not go to hell out of 33,000, with a 0.25 probability for each of those that they had no personal sin, gives a result over 100 standard deviations away from the mean. 100 standard deviations is a number so small that I doubt any of us can comprehend it. So the probability of getting the numbers as reported in the story is beyond vanishingly small. And that’s really all I need to say about it.
Just accept that a private revelation from God will not contradict the teachings of the Church and that your understanding of the private revelation is wrong!
It has a lot to do with it. It is about wrong judgment calls based on defective math assumptions (linearization of the problem, one more time).…That certainly has nothing to do with what is being discussed, and I’m surprised you would make such an error.