Any Comments on this 'Scary' Sermon?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nsper7
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Settle down, you’re getting over-excited. Now to begin with, you know that 33,000 is an enormous sample. You also know that I don’t know the exact number of those who died without personal sin, but given the conditions in the early middle ages, let us pick the number of 1/4. That is, 1/4 of those who died did so before reaching the age of reason, either as miscarriages or as infants or as young children. You can of course do the math with any reasonable number you choose, and my point will remain.

I won’t post the math here, but having only 5 people not go to hell out of 33,000, with a 0.25 probability for each of those that they had no personal sin, gives a result over 100 standard deviations away from the mean. 100 standard deviations is a number so small that I doubt any of us can comprehend it. So the probability of getting the numbers as reported in the story is beyond vanishingly small. And that’s really all I need to say about it.
Again you are not answering my question by providing numbers and playing with models to justify your take. Where do you come with absurd 100 times off the standard deviation? Is going to heaven and hell a normal distribution? Are you saying that one individual can go at the same time a lot to hell and a little bit to heaven? This is the math that you are using! My math is based on a pure bi-modal delta distribution where you are got to hell or to heaven.

Just accept that a private revelation from God will not contradict the teachings of the Church and that your understanding of the private revelation is wrong!
…That certainly has nothing to do with what is being discussed, and I’m surprised you would make such an error.
It has a lot to do with it. It is about wrong judgment calls based on defective math assumptions (linearization of the problem, one more time).
 
I’m not 100% Holy right now, I have flaws, I also must seek Confession for grave sin, but if I don’t make it (like it’s a race), see ya, i’m toast. I’m dammed. I’m so tired of having scruples due to ideas and sermons like this!
I’m with ya on that one. We are in a spiritual battle, and as Father Corapi Likes to say, “Never give up, never surrender!” No matter how many times we fall… never give up, never surrender! I fall all the time, and many times into mortal sin, I pick myself up, brush myself off, go make the sincerest confession I can, and continue on.

It really helps me to remember that while Jesus was carrying His Cross. He fell so that when ever we fall we may get up again.

It’s also very important to have a strong devotion to our Blessed Mother. She will see us through this.
 
I stand by my post. 5 saved out of 33,000 simply cannot be reconciled with the Catholic faith and basic mathematics. What about all the baptized babies and children who must have been in that total? What about those who received the sacrament of confession on their deathbeds? What about the unbaptized innocents who at least cannot be condemned to hell for they have committed no personal sin?

No, my reasoning is sound, regardless of how it may upset you.
Throughout his sermon, St. Leonard assumed that the baptized infants went to heaven. The numbers he speaks about refer only to adults.
 
Jesus showed us with the parable of the Prodigal son that His Father forgives us if we repent, so yes it could be about repentance, all we have to do is turn back to God and stay in His favour, satan would like to stop that message.

I read that when a Priest preaches on the Divine Mercy of God, that satan decends to the very bottom of hell, so the demon don’t like Gods Mercy, all the more reason to go seek it.
 
I have an important question that has not been touched on in this thread.

How do we reconcile the assurances of salvation attributed to various devotions (such as the rosary and the brown scapular) with these numbers? Have not large numbers of people worn the brown scapular, especially in centuries past? (which, Our Lady says, will preserve you from the eternal fires if you die clothed in it)
 
I have an important question that has not been touched on in this thread.

How do we reconcile the assurances of salvation attributed to various devotions (such as the rosary and the brown scapular) with these numbers? Have not large numbers of people worn the brown scapular, especially in centuries past? (which, Our Lady says, will preserve you from the eternal fires if you die clothed in it)
There is a lot of false devotion to the brown scapular. The scapular itself is nearly useless without the personal consecration and devotional followings. One must be a carmelite or a lay 3rd order Carmelite or else at least a member of the carmelite confraternity and conform to all the requirements - daily prayer and the liturgy of the hours. Most laity do not follow this part. A true brown scapular devotion is actually a personal consecration and the brown scapular is an outward sign of that consecration.

James
 
There is a lot of false devotion to the brown scapular. The scapular itself is nearly useless without the personal consecration and devotional followings. One must be a carmelite or a lay 3rd order Carmelite or else at least a member of the carmelite confraternity and conform to all the requirements - daily prayer and the liturgy of the hours. Most laity do not follow this part. A true brown scapular devotion is actually a personal consecration and the brown scapular is an outward sign of that consecration.

James
I thought that a daily rosary could be substituted; but even that is for the attainment of the Sabbatine Privelage. For the promise of avoiding the eternal fires, I thought there were only the following requirements: 1) continually wear the scapular 2) Be enrolled in the confraternity by a priest, and 3) Maintain chastity with regard to your state in life
 
Continually wear the scapular? I thought it was just to pass away with it on. When you are enrolled, you are covered.

By the way, the scapular is misunderstood by non-Catholics who think it’s weird. I tell them it is like an orthodox wearing his yamulka, or a mormon wearing his “garment”. It shows “a constant devotion to God”.

That is how I look at it. So, if it gets raggedy, or I forget, or it gets entangled in my jewlery, I don’t worry too much it it’s off.

And I always take it off the siderail and put it back on people’s necks when I see it in the hospital.
 
I did not read the full sermon, and I don’t want to scare anyone
but for quite sometime I have felt that its probably easier to get into Harvard then Heaven.
The good news is that it can be done and Jesus is the way!
 
Assuming that this sermon was actually made by a Saint, and not some people on the net with an agenda, keep in mind that saints are not infallible.

The Church teaches that people who die unrepentant of a mortal sin will go to Hell, but for a sin to be mortal not only does the matter have to be grave but the state of mind cannot be of misunderstanding/ignorance.

Even people who might appear to us to be sinful may not be guilty of mortal sin because of mitigating circumstances. There is no way for anyone, not even a saint, to know people’s state of mind.
 
"Saint Jerome. At the end of his life, in the presence of his disciples, he spoke these dreadful words: “Out of one hundred thousand people whose lives have always been bad, you will find barely one who is worthy of indulgence.”
  • that’s an opinion…btw, what does he classify as someone who’s life has “always been bad”, why wouldn’t he just say out of 100,000 people only 1 will be saved, why use the “bad people”?
“St. Chyrstodome said…Among so many thousands of people, we would not find a hundred who are saved, and I even doubt for the one hundred.”
  • again…just an opinion…and his opinion contradicts Jerome’s opinion…he said out of so many thousands of people maybe 100 would be saved…so if 999,999 people died…out of every 100,000 people who died, 10 would be saved…not 1…since these 2 saints were alive at the same time, one of them had to be wrong.
"The following narrative from Saint Vincent Ferrer will show you what you may think about it. He relates that an archdeacon in Lyons gave up his charge and retreated into a desert place to do penance, and that he died the same day and hour as Saint Bernard. After his death, he appeared to his bishop and said to him, “Know, Monsignor, that at the very hour I passed away, thirty-three thousand people also died. Out of this number, Bernard and myself went up to heaven without delay, three went to purgatory, and all the others fell into Hell.”

-…maybe that was just a bad day where ALOT of bad people died, that doesn’t neccesarily mean those numbers are the norm
  • this is also a “what he said/she said” scenario
  • according to today’s stats, every 4 seconds a child dies, and i’m guessing it was alot worse back then so it seems kind of a miracle in itself that only 3 children could have died at the same hour as the other 2. And what about all the native americans and what not that were isolated from christianity, I’m sure alot of them died also at the same hour. so I agree with Mike.
"Our chronicles relate an even more dreadful happening. One of our brothers, well-known for his doctrine and holiness, was preaching in Germany. He represented the ugliness of the sin of impurity so forceful that a woman fell dead of sorrow in front of everyone. Then, coming back to life, she said, “When I was presented before the Tribunal of God, sixty thousand people arrived at the same time from all parts of the world; out of that number, three were saved by going to Purgatory, and all the rest were damned.”

-another “he said/she said” situation from a vision from a lay person, not saint…that lady could have had mental problems for all we know

-also no mentions of babies, children, invicible ignorant people, or death bed confessors

I believe that more will be damned than saved, but sometimes I question if it’s brought to the extreme as this sermon states. I don’t know, just food for thought. BTW, St. Padre Pio said president John F. Kennedy was saved and we all know what kind of sins JFK commited, so if somebody like JFK can make it, there’s hope for us too
 
I thought that a daily rosary could be substituted; but even that is for the attainment of the Sabbatine Privelage. For the promise of avoiding the eternal fires, I thought there were only the following requirements: 1) continually wear the scapular 2) Be enrolled in the confraternity by a priest, and 3) Maintain chastity with regard to your state in life
But how does one interpret the Virgin Mary’s statement to St. Simon Stock that whosoever dies wearing the Brown Scapular will avoid “everlasting fire”? And I think the ‘Sabbatine Privilege’ has been done away with.
A Byzantine priest told me, that, people don’t go to hell so much for their sins as for their bitterness of heart, and lack of seeking and giving forgiveness. He criticizes the Western Church for just the above attitudes that lead people into coldness and sterility, and stifling the movement of the Holy Spirit. I am inclined to agree with him.
I have to agree. After reading this sermon and see the fear of Hell that seems to be a motivation in much of Christianity (not just Catholicism, I was a Protestant before who came to faith after reading ‘Left Behind’ and my faith has always been based on fear of Hell) has caused me in some ways to hate God with an extreme passion. As I said in another thread, if I saw Jesus and did not think such a move would cost me my Salvation, I would spit right in His face (and I know that is a terrible thing to say/think, but it is sometimes how I feel). My faith has been one nervous breakdown/psychological mess after another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top