Z
zemi
Guest
Hi everyone,
was there any council in the history of the Church dealing with the issue of reincarnation?
was there any council in the history of the Church dealing with the issue of reincarnation?
I don’t know if this was ever discussed in a Council or not but the Catechism clearly states there is no reincarnation and this is based on Scripture (see Heb 9:27)Hi everyone,
was there any council in the history of the Church dealing with the issue of reincarnation?
I know of that, thank youI don’t know if this was ever discussed in a Council or not but the Catechism clearly states there is no reincarnation and this is based on Scripture (see Heb 9:27)
CCC 1013 Death is the end of man’s earthly pilgrimage, of the time of grace and mercy which God offers him so as to work out his earthly life in keeping with the divine plan, and to decide his ultimate destiny. When “the single course of our earthly life” is completed, we shall not return to other earthly lives: “It is appointed for men to die once.” There is no “reincarnation” after death.
Hebrews 9:27
Just as it is appointed that human beings die once, and after this the judgment.
The Second Council of Constantinople in 553 (the fifth of the Ecumenical Councils) condemned Origen and specifically mentioned the doctrine of pre-existence, which implies a condemnation of reincarnation as well (it’s possible to believe in pre-existence without believing in reincarnation, of course). There has been some debate about the genuineness of these anathemas, but my old professor Elizabeth Clark, in the afterword to her monograph on the fourth-century Origenist controversy (The Origenist Controversy, Princeton University Press, 1992, p. 249) seems to assume that they are genuine.Hi everyone,
was there any council in the history of the Church dealing with the issue of reincarnation?
Yup, thanks.The Second Council of Constantinople in 553 (the fifth of the Ecumenical Councils) condemned Origen and specifically mentioned the doctrine of pre-existence, which implies a condemnation of reincarnation as well (it’s possible to believe in pre-existence without believing in reincarnation, of course). There has been some debate about the genuineness of these anathemas, but my old professor Elizabeth Clark, in the afterword to her monograph on the fourth-century Origenist controversy (The Origenist Controversy, Princeton University Press, 1992, p. 249) seems to assume that they are genuine.
Edwin
No later council has addressed the subject as far as I know.Yup, thanks.
And afterwards? Any council for instance officially condemning specifically the reincarnation? Or this was the last word upon the subject (though implictly stated)?
Just to clarify - the above was a modernist teaching that the Pope was condemning.I. Pantheism, Naturalism and Absolute Rationalism
reformation.org/syllabus_of_pius.html
- There exists no Supreme, all-wise, all-provident Divine Being, distinct from the universe, and God is identical with the nature of things, and is, therefore, subject to changes. In effect, God is produced in man and in the world, and all things are God and have the very substance of God, and God is one and the same thing with the world, and, therefore, spirit with matter, necessity with liberty, good with evil, justice with injustice. – Allocution “Maxima quidem,” June 9, 1862.
Been awhile since I’ve studied this issue but I believe the Anathema’s were pronounced by an anti-pope were they not? Also again if memory serves while Origen did indeed speak of pre-existance of souls I believe he also condemned traditional reincarnation in the same text.The Second Council of Constantinople in 553 (the fifth of the Ecumenical Councils) condemned Origen and specifically mentioned the doctrine of pre-existence, which implies a condemnation of reincarnation as well (it’s possible to believe in pre-existence without believing in reincarnation, of course). There has been some debate about the genuineness of these anathemas, but my old professor Elizabeth Clark, in the afterword to her monograph on the fourth-century Origenist controversy (The Origenist Controversy, Princeton University Press, 1992, p. 249) seems to assume that they are genuine.
Edwin
I could be wrong on the anti-pope thing but I know that Vigilius’ election was highly irregular. He was first declared a papal successor when Boniface II tried to set things up so that a Pope would decide on his successor. The clergy though were not keen on this so he burned the declaration and instead Agapetus became Pope after Boniface II.Been awhile since I’ve studied this issue but I believe the Anathema’s were pronounced by an anti-pope were they not? Also again if memory serves while Origen did indeed speak of pre-existance of souls I believe he also condemned traditional reincarnation in the same text.
No. The anathemas quoted by Daniel Marsh were issued by Emperor Justinian some time before the Council, and are not quite the same as those attributed to the Council.Been awhile since I’ve studied this issue but I believe the Anathema’s were pronounced by an anti-pope were they not?
The text is unclear, because we have the Latin version of Rufinus and Rufinus admitted to changing the text to make Origen more orthodox (with regards to the Trinity). I think you’re right that in the Latin there is a rejection of reincarnation. However, there were Greek fragments presented to the Fifth Council (or quoted by Justinian–I can’t remember the details) as Origen’s that endorsed reincarnation. So the question is, whom do we trust: Rufinus or Justinian? Gustave Bardy argued that the sixth-century quotations were not from Origen but were encapsulating the teaching of later “Origenists,” and also that Rufinus’s changes can be assumed to be confined to Trinitarian theology.Also again if memory serves while Origen did indeed speak of pre-existance of souls I believe he also condemned traditional reincarnation in the same text.
Thank you for the post. You are correct I’ve looked over some things since I posted. Also I’m glad you brought up the Commentary on Matthew was what I was thinking of actually. So I was kind piece milling it. However, you are correct that Constantinople II clearly landed on the no reincarnation side, at least in terms of any traditional understanding of the concept.No. The anathemas quoted by Daniel Marsh were issued by Emperor Justinian some time before the Council, and are not quite the same as those attributed to the Council.
The text is unclear, because we have the Latin version of Rufinus and Rufinus admitted to changing the text to make Origen more orthodox (with regards to the Trinity). I think you’re right that in the Latin there is a rejection of reincarnation. However, there were Greek fragments presented to the Fifth Council (or quoted by Justinian–I can’t remember the details) as Origen’s that endorsed reincarnation. So the question is, whom do we trust: Rufinus or Justinian? Gustave Bardy argued that the sixth-century quotations were not from Origen but were encapsulating the teaching of later “Origenists,” and also that Rufinus’s changes can be assumed to be confined to Trinitarian theology.
I see from wikipedia that Origen also rejected reincarnation in the commentary on Matthew, which we do have in Greek and so is a reliable record of his views.
However, the point I was making is that 2 Constantinople was clearly rejecting the idea of pre-existence and by extension reincarnation.
Edwin