Any former sedevacantists here?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DeepDeepTrouble3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know of at least one, but I’ll let them answer. I am not.
 
I am, I realized that sedevacantis really just had a bunch of hot air. Much of what they claimed wasn’t actually true if you look to the source. Or like putting ex cathedra on things that weren’t, in fact, ex cathedra.
Vatican II isn’t nearly like what they think so often.

I particularly followed MHFM, the Dimond bros. But I saw that baptism of desire is actually in the Council of Trent, and they deny even that.
 
I am not sure, I was somewhat young though. A year perhaps or a few? Perhaps lesser?
 
I saw their things when I was younger, and it was just so logical. Naturally they’d show the clown mass and stuff.
But it just seemed so logical, and it was, with the information they had given me. But the thing is, the info was off. It’s like how you can make a false conclusion even if the argument is logical if you start from a false premise.
 
I keep seeing stuff on the internet, complaining about Vatican II, and then using clown Masses as an example, but the Vatican II never said that we should use clown Masses so I’m not sure where that came from. A lot of the photos they use, aren’t even from Catholic church services, oftentimes they are from liturgical Protestant denominations. So that’s dishonest right there.
 
They use a LOT of misinformation, though I can’t be sure if this is on purpose or actual mistakes.
A lot of misinformation and legends.
 
I was one from February 28, 2013 to March 13, 2013. Prior to that, I was one from April 2, 2005 to April 19, 2005.

What made me cease being one in each case was when a Pope was elected 😉
 
Last edited:
I was a sedevacantist for a few days. Then I read into how to debunk sedevacantists and I was like “their points about the last Pope’s being false can’t be true” and “the Church could not have been destroyed by the forces of darkness.”

Someone tried to brainwash me, I believed it, then I did research. After leaving sedevacantism I accepted that the Church cannot be prevailed by the forces of darkness, and that schism is not the answer.
 
Last edited:
I’m embarrassed to say that it was a sedevacantist who made me first question Protestantism. That was early last year. I’m still joining the Church, but luckily I got any sympathies for sedevacantism out of me.

The main reason I rejected it (I never accepted it), was that it felt like the Protestant faith I was leaving.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top