Any Opus Dei members or experience?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Brooklyn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I would like to retract my previous statements and links regarding Opus Dei.

Over the past months I have become more familiar with Opus Dei, its members, spirituality, and implementing their plan of life. It has born much fruit and I think it is a valuable way to sanctity.

In retrospect, the articles/ websites I cited fail to understand Opus Dei and ascribe a lot of motives to them that simply are not true.

I would recommend attendance at Opus Dei’s retreats and evenings/ mornings of reflection and especially their plan of life to keep in the presence of God.

God Bless
 
I would like to retract my previous statements and links regarding Opus Dei.

Over the past months I have become more familiar with Opus Dei, its members, spirituality, and implementing their plan of life. It has born much fruit and I think it is a valuable way to sanctity.

In retrospect, the articles/ websites I cited fail to understand Opus Dei and ascribe a lot of motives to them that simply are not true.

I would recommend attendance at Opus Dei’s retreats and evenings/ mornings of reflection and especially their plan of life to keep in the presence of God.

God Bless
And God bless you for your integrity! Thank you for sharing your experience.

Betsy
 
I find myself being drawn more and more to Opus Dei, but it has gotten such a bad rap in the media. I’ve been reading Josemaria Escriva’s books, and I think they are wonderful. I live in New York City, so I’m actually not far from the US headquarters for Opus Dei.

Just wondering if anyone can give me their experiences or thoughts on this organization. Thanks.
Pope John Paul II confirmed the creation of a special place in Canon Law for them and love thee. He canonized their founder --who is a Saint of the Catholic Church.

Pope Benedict XVI seems to love them. He has visited at least one Opus Dei Center since being Pope…

opusdei.us/art.php?p=12481

They are are a an excellent “work” of the Holy Spirit in the Church.

No question:thumbsup:
 
I would like to retract my previous statements and links regarding Opus Dei.

Over the past months I have become more familiar with Opus Dei, its members, spirituality, and implementing their plan of life. It has born much fruit and I think it is a valuable way to sanctity.

In retrospect, the articles/ websites I cited fail to understand Opus Dei and ascribe a lot of motives to them that simply are not true.

I would recommend attendance at Opus Dei’s retreats and evenings/ mornings of reflection and especially their plan of life to keep in the presence of God.

God Bless
Thank you so much for coming back and adding your new experiences. That was very big-hearted of you.

Given your suggestion to refer to “Traditional” sources in your previous post, I was hoping you could give me some insight into something I’ve never understood. Some of my extended family belongs to the SSPX. That organization seems to have a particular dislike for St. Josemaria and Opus Dei, beyond its normal dislike for anything they perceive as “non-Traditional.” I don’t want to go too far off-topic here, but if you have any thoughts on this you could share, I’d love to read them.

Best,

Margaret
 
I would like to retract my previous statements and links regarding Opus Dei.

Over the past months I have become more familiar with Opus Dei, its members, spirituality, and implementing their plan of life. It has born much fruit and I think it is a valuable way to sanctity.

In retrospect, the articles/ websites I cited fail to understand Opus Dei and ascribe a lot of motives to them that simply are not true.

I would recommend attendance at Opus Dei’s retreats and evenings/ mornings of reflection and especially their plan of life to keep in the presence of God.

God Bless
I second the thanks to you for your integrety and honesty.

Peace
James
 
I am not a member of Opus Dei and I have not had any experiences with them. However, I have read the writings of St. Josemaria and many articles on the Opus Dei website. Based on what I have read, I think Opus Dei is a great organisation.

In the past, I said negative things about Opus Dei because I accepted criticisms from its detractors without doing my own research. After I read a book about Opus Dei, I can sincerely say that most of my opinions where based on half-truths and misrepresentations. My whole opinion on Opus Dei has changed. The members of Opus Dei are faithful sons and daughters of the Church. They accept the teachings of the faith in their entirety and they are not afraid to preach this to the world. They live a truly authentic Catholic lifestyle, based on the traditional spirituality of the Church.

The fact is that Opus Dei is well respected and endorsed by the Magisterium. Both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have strongly endorsed them. If you want to live the faith properly and receive solid orthodox guidance, look no further than Opus Dei.
 
I am not a member of Opus Dei and I have not had any experiences with them. However, I have read the writings of St. Josemaria and many articles on the Opus Dei website. Based on what I have read, I think Opus Dei is a great organisation.

In the past, I said negative things about Opus Dei because I accepted criticisms from its detractors without doing my own research. After I read a book about Opus Dei, I can sincerely say that most of my opinions where based on half-truths and misrepresentations. My whole opinion on Opus Dei has changed. The members of Opus Dei are faithful sons and daughters of the Church. They accept the teachings of the faith in their entirety and they are not afraid to preach this to the world. They live a truly authentic Catholic lifestyle, based on the traditional spirituality of the Church.

**The fact is that Opus Dei is well respected and endorsed by the Magisterium. Both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have strongly endorsed them. **If you want to live the faith properly and receive solid orthodox guidance, look no further than Opus Dei.
Very Nicely put.
I highlighted the one sentence because for me that sealed it. I too had not done much research and was hearing different opinions from their great and holy to theya re miserable and unholy. When I heard that a) The Hoy Father had endorsed them and then that b) their founder had been declared a saint, that sealed it hands down.

If they are good enough for the Holy Father they are good enough for me.

Peace
James
 
I would also like to counter the claims of many traditionalists by stating that the spirituality of Opus Dei is based on the time-honoured spiritual practices of the Church. The lifestyle promoted by Opus Dei is not a novelty; in fact, it is very ancient and could even be said to be apostolic.

The spirituality of Opus Dei incorporates such traditional practices such as daily Mass, daily Rosary, daily spiritual reading, daily meditation, the Angelus, and mortifications. Nothing in these practices is novel. They have all been strongly endorsed and promoted by the Church. Even corporal mortification, even if it has fallen out of fashion, is encouraged by the Church for spiritually advanced individuals. Read the lives of many Saints and you will see that the majority of them all practiced mortifications such as the hair shirt and the discipline. Those who criticise corporal mortification should remember that many saints have practiced this in order to achieve holiness. However, it must be remembered that corporal mortifications should only be practiced under the supervision of an experienced spiritual director.

The only novel thing about Opus Dei is it’s canonical structure. Personal prelatures came about after Vatican II in response to the appearance of groups such as Opus Dei. This is the only novel thing about Opus Dei. It’s spirituality is time tested, proven, and promoted by the Church.
 
John Allen, a journalist with the National Catholic Reporter, wrote a book entitled Opus Dei which is supposed to be very fair.
Definitely. I can recommend this book for anyone who wants to read a thorough airing of the arguments for and against Opus Dei. Allen comes at it from a neutral perspective and really gets at the heart of all the issues (and ends up coming away with a surprisingly positive view). Fantastic book.
 
I can’t really add more to this thread, except to share my own experiences.
Here’s my story (totally ripped off from an old blog post 😃 )

A Different Kind of Love Story
I used to write love stories way back in high school and college. Those friends of mine from way back then can attest to the fact that they were pretty idealistic and full of the “kilig” factor rather than the substance of what true love really was. That’s the sort of thing one can expect from a girl who had never been in a relationship before. I sort of expected that something of the sort would happen to me. Boy, was I in for a surprise when my own love story unfolded a little over seven years ago.

It started with mosquitoes. (Yes, I have a pest to thank for everything!) One summer break, after taking up an Entomology subject, a few classmates and I thought of volunteering to help out a faculty member at our university’s biology department to do research on Aedes aegypti, those carriers of the dreaded Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever Virus. Turns out, she happened to be a numerary member of Opus Dei.

My friends and I got invited to attend the activities at the Center, and we felt right at home. The activities were fun as well as formative and we made a lot of new friends who were members of the Work as well as other young students our age who attended the activities. Eventually, we started attending the Circle given by the Center’s director and someone else, who happened to be a doctor by profession, talked with me regularly to help me improve in my spiritual life. The Center’s chaplain then was a very holy Spanish priest (who looks like Rowan Atkinson of Mr. Bean fame → as initially described by the biologist!) who patiently listened to my difficulties and slowly helped me grow in my relationship with our Lord.

A few months short of graduating with a biology degree, I knew that I was called to be in Opus Dei as well. The decision was not coerced at all, as some detractors of the Work might think, with all that brainwash nonsense. It was a decision I made with the help of the lay person who helped me with my spiritual life. I did not want to join yet though until I could know for certain whether my circumstances allowed me to be a numerary member or a supernumerary member.

Then, everything became clear to me at an instance when I was asked by the lay person helping me out: “Do you see yourself as G.(then a young unmarried supernumerary), as M.(then a young numerary, but is now no longer in the Work), or as D.(an associate)?”

My immediate answer, which caught me by surpise as well, was : “I see myself like D.”

I knew that I finally figured out the way I was to live as a member of Opus Dei when she said, “You know, we see the same thing.”

Shortly afterwards, I talked to the local director, and things were explained to me. The thing I would never forget was when she said, “It’s like getting married at twenty.” I was definitely ready to get married at twenty. I started a novena to Blessed Josemaria Escriva (now a canonized saint) for me to be allowed to join, and on his 99th birth anniversary (2 or 3 days short of finishing my novena), I wrote the letter to the Prelate to petition for admission (that is, to “whistle”) as an associate of Opus Dei (a celibate vocation who usually lives with family or elsewhere - not in a Center of Opus Dei - due to a difference in personal circumstances from a numerary).

I would be lying if I would say that it has been easy, with attending the different means of formation, and giving it as well to my friends while at the same time helping out in the apostolic initiatives while taking care of family obligations, going through medical school with a pioneering curriculum, and right now doing my residency. Commitment does entail sacrifice. But, I would also be lying if I would say that for a moment, I never felt God’s love through the other members of the Work, my friends and family. Commitment also promises that you will have joy if you live it well.

This is my love story. Everyday of my life though, I hope that I continue to live it faithfully.

Postscript: The past few months has been a “spiritual crisis” for me, totally my fault (sort of like technically being in the Work but not living the vocation well.) Today was an awakening (which took an angry director 😦 ), and I’m slowly trying to begin again.
Pray for me, please.
 
Hi,
Can anyone help me get in contact with Opus Dei in the Cincinnati area?
I went to their web page (the general one) and contacted them . They gave me an email address for the Pittsburgh Grandevue Center which is the women’s center that is in charge of the Cincinnati area but there website has been closed since the end of April 2010.
I found this out after unsuccessfully trying to email them twice. I have a (long distance) phone number but I really don’t know what to say or who to call and now I don’t even know what is going on at the other end. I just wanted to meet some people who are involved and find out more about it. I’m a little frustrated right now so if anyone could point me in the right direction I’d appreciate it.
Thanks
 
Hi,
Can anyone help me get in contact with Opus Dei in the Cincinnati area?
I went to their web page (the general one) and contacted them . They gave me an email address for the Pittsburgh Grandevue Center which is the women’s center that is in charge of the Cincinnati area but there website has been closed since the end of April 2010.
I found this out after unsuccessfully trying to email them twice. I have a (long distance) phone number but I really don’t know what to say or who to call and now I don’t even know what is going on at the other end. I just wanted to meet some people who are involved and find out more about it. I’m a little frustrated right now so if anyone could point me in the right direction I’d appreciate it.
Thanks
My dear friend

I’ve been a cooperator 20 yrs or so. Their much like the first christians - very warm and friendly and easy to talk to. You’ll ave no trouble if you phone them. You can ask about evenings of recollection for men or women ( they are separate ). They are very big on spiritual direction especially. You can ask about this. The priests often hear confessions at various locations and this may be of interest, and there are many retreats. You don’t have to join to get involved. It usually means recollections and spiritual direction to get the most out of it and get a feel for it. You can ask about locations of course. Don’t expect a cold shoulder when you ring, just tell them who you are and that you want to know more about Opus Dei and what it does and what you should do if you want to get involved and see if it’s for you. Don’t be shy. It’s really great. They are very big on education too with many schools run by pared which is people involved with Opus Dei ( not Opus Dei itself ) and my brothers have 8 kids in the schools and another one soon and they are absolutely fantastic schools ( one is in uni now ). It’s really quite an incredible organisation. Check it out.

Have you looked at the founders writings to see what it’s all about? Go here escrivaworks.org/

If you have any other questions just ask. Hope this helps.

God bless you and pray for me please:thumbsup:🙂

John
 
Hi,
Can anyone help me get in contact with Opus Dei in the Cincinnati area?
I went to their web page (the general one) and contacted them . They gave me an email address for the Pittsburgh Grandevue Center which is the women’s center that is in charge of the Cincinnati area but there website has been closed since the end of April 2010.
I found this out after unsuccessfully trying to email them twice. I have a (long distance) phone number but I really don’t know what to say or who to call and now I don’t even know what is going on at the other end. I just wanted to meet some people who are involved and find out more about it. I’m a little frustrated right now so if anyone could point me in the right direction I’d appreciate it.
Thanks
Calling is a good suggestion, but, if you prefer, you could go back to the contact area of the general website and tell them what happened when you tried the website. Real people take care of these inquiries, and someone should be more than willing to look things up for you.

Betsy
 
I read the whole of the last article and part of the Odan link. There were very few arguments – most of it was slurs and innuendo rather than argumentation – and most of the arguments in there were very weak. I could see holes in the arguments or plausible counter-explanations as soon as I read what was said. Some of the sources also appeared unreliable. And Opus Dei’s enemies, or the author condemning Opus Dei, always got the last word in every part of the article. Opus Dei itself had very little room in the article to give facts or statistics defending themselves- only page room for a sentence of denial here and there. The section at the end where the author interviewed ordinary members of Opus Dei and heard their impressions (how happy they were there and how their experiences were the opposite of everything in the article) seemed good to have, though the arguer/writer framed and presented it in a negative manner.

I can believe some Opus Dei members have tried to push people into joining the order inappropriately. Fervent people trying to drag others into joining their particular group (whether it be religious or not) can be found almost anywhere. The evidence the author provided did not convince me that this is the order’s method or normal practice.

That was the only argument the article made that seemed to me to have any strength. I was not impressed at all.
 
I would like to retract my previous statements and links regarding Opus Dei.

Over the past months I have become more familiar with Opus Dei, its members, spirituality, and implementing their plan of life. It has born much fruit and I think it is a valuable way to sanctity.

In retrospect, the articles/ websites I cited fail to understand Opus Dei and ascribe a lot of motives to them that simply are not true.

I would recommend attendance at Opus Dei’s retreats and evenings/ mornings of reflection and especially their plan of life to keep in the presence of God.

God Bless
Wow, thanks for sharing that!
 
I’m afraid I can’t accept any of these links. One is from the Society of St. Pius X, which, even though Pope Benedict XVI has reached out to them, is still considered heretical, and your other two links seem very critical of the post Vatican II Church. I agree there are a lot of problems in the Church, but I wonder if you are one of those who doesn’t believe there has been a valid pope since Pius XII.

Our Lord promised that the gates of hell would never prevail against the Church. The organizations associated with the links you posted to do not believe that. Therefore, since they reject the words of Christ, I must reject them.
Brooklyn!

I congratulate you for your objectivity and interest on following the Catholic Church. I was memeber of Opus Dei for some years and it is the best experience I have had. It follow the Pope’s teaching, it is 100% reliable, everything is supported and logical. Somebody comments about San Josemaria wtiting being one thing and life experience another, it is true, BECAUSE WE ARE WEAK, WE COMMIT MISTAKES, BECOMING A SAINT ON A DAILY LIFE IS NOT EASY. I have met a lot of people in Opus Dei, and I can tell you that everybody strives to be saint. Incossistencies, yes, bad examples, yes, but because we are all human. That is the reason why is so important to follow the Pope, because he is illuminated with the Holy Spirit and supported by the Church Magistery and Tradition. The Catholic Church is formed with humans full of weaknesses, and so we commit mistakes. The important thing is to pray for each other, pray for the Pope, and try our best bu looking for spiritual guidance.
I just moved to Cincinnati, and I know there is no Opus Dei center around here, but I will contact them to see the possibility of assiting to the annual retreat in Chicago.
 
Hi everyone! I’ve been reading this thread, because I live in the Cincinnati area and am interested in learning more about Opus Dei and formation. Did anyone have any luck getting connected in this area?

Ilea
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top