Anyone been to a meeting?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jaded27
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jaded27

Guest
I’m just wondering if any of you have ever actually taken the time to go to a meeting with Jehovah’s Witnesses. I know I’ve taken the time to investigate and go to church a few times. So that I have a balanced view of religions besides my own.

So just wondering, anyone ever think to actually check it out?
 
I went to Kingdom Hall a few weeks ago and checked out their large bookshelf. The meeting room, had the tour. I didn’t have a chance to participate, I just was able to take a look around. It was interesting and gave me a new perspective of Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Can you at anytime check out those archives or do you just read them at the Hall?

Scylla
 
That’s great. I’m not saying everyone should convert, just check it out ya know?

About the books and stuff, I’m sad to say I honestly dont’ know. I’ve never bothered to ask and I’ve never had need of them because I have my own resources and reading at home. That’s an interesting question though. Hmm.
 
I would have loved to look at them, since you go I encourage you to look into them and learn more about the Watchtower Organization. I am trying to learn as much as I can as it is very interesting to me.

What do you have at home? Besides this internet thing in front of me.

God Bless
Scylla
 
Well, you and I probably don’t have exactly the same interest in those books. I don’t have any need to “investigate” the society as I’ve already done that before I got baptized. But I do have a lot of resources for study available to me. They’re not “investigative” types of books though. 😉

They’re things like “reasoning from the scriptures” and “mankinds search for god” and one of my favorites “how did we get here: by evolution or by creation?” Stuff like that you know?

What type of books were they that you saw in the library? I’m sure you could get copies of almost all of them from any of the JWs you may know. Just a thought. I’ve never paid that much attention to what is in the libraries because I had most of hte publications at home. I think they’re just there in case someone is writing a talk or something and forgot to bring their own copy.
 
I think they were just a bunch of Watchtowers archived into large books. I wasn’t able to look through them, my friend just pointed them out and then we went to another room.

I have several books on Jehovah’s Witnesses, but would like to read old Watchtowers to see if they are correct in their assertions. I just don’t want to over step my bounds with my friend who gave me the tour of the Kingdom Hall he goes to.

I am looking for older material from the Watchtower from about 1914 to 1920.

God Bless
Scylla
 
40.png
Jaded27:
Well, you and I probably don’t have exactly the same interest in those books. I don’t have any need to “investigate” the society as I’ve already done that before I got baptized. But I do have a lot of resources for study available to me. They’re not “investigative” types of books though. 😉

They’re things like “reasoning from the scriptures” and “mankinds search for god” and one of my favorites “how did we get here: by evolution or by creation?” Stuff like that you know?

What type of books were they that you saw in the library? I’m sure you could get copies of almost all of them from any of the JWs you may know. Just a thought. I’ve never paid that much attention to what is in the libraries because I had most of hte publications at home. I think they’re just there in case someone is writing a talk or something and forgot to bring their own copy.
Jaded,
I’m curious as to how you “investigated” the Watchtower Society before you got baptized? Did you read only literature approved by the Society? Because let’s face it… if a person considering becoming a Scientologist only read material printed by the Church of Scientology - they would get a very one sided view of that organization. But if they read material by former Scientologists, read all the criticisms by people outside of that organization and STILL wanted to join the Church of Scientology - well… at least they went in with all the information.

Have you read any of the information put out by former witnesses - elders - overseers - Bethel workers - there is literally a mountain of material about the inner workings and history of the Watchtower Society that the average Jehovah’s Witness knows nothing about. I know that you are discouraged from reading any of those materials - but most of it is old publications of the Watchtower Magazine… writings of Russell etc. Surely you would be able to look at stuff that the Watchtower themselves published & distributed??? Some of it’s shocking… any interest???
 
You could always ask your friend right? Or would she be distrustful of why you want it?

I’m probably correct in saying that some of the material will have changed between then and now. Just a few things, nothing you all haven’t heard about I’m sure.

But I would think you could get bound volumes from any kingdom hall. Ooh, have you tried Ebay? I hate that they sell stuff on there since we give it away for free (doesn’t seem fair for people to make money off of something they didn’t pay for and were probably given under a belief they were actually interested), but it’s not a bad place to get stuff. Just type in JW or Jehovah’s Witness or Watchtower or something. It’s out there. Just gotta look for it.
 
Ok I will check it out, I think it would be cool to have a bound version of the Watchtower from the beginning of the century. From what I have read the Watchtower Organization has changed considerable on doctrine, and this can be found in the old publications.

It would be useful to have it for reference.

Thanks for the idea,
God Bless
Scylla
 
40.png
scylla:
I think they were just a bunch of Watchtowers archived into large books. I wasn’t able to look through them, my friend just pointed them out and then we went to another room.

I have several books on Jehovah’s Witnesses, but would like to read old Watchtowers to see if they are correct in their assertions. I just don’t want to over step my bounds with my friend who gave me the tour of the Kingdom Hall he goes to.

I am looking for older material from the Watchtower from about 1914 to 1920.

God Bless
Scylla
There are several books that minister to those wanting to leave the Watchtower Society but are afraid to do so. I’ve read several of the books (Kingdom of the Cults by Martin is a good one) a Christian Bookstore would have a section on Jehovah’s Witnesses. Alot of the books have copies of the actual WT publications from way back when…

I doubt very seriously that the Kingdom Hall would keep copies of the older publications (1914-1920) Since none of the predictions they made came true, they have repeatedly tried to distance themselves from the earliest of writings… most of what Charles Russell wrote they’ve turned away from. Alot of it is really new age… stuff that a JW today would be shocked to find out about. But like I said, many books have copies of the literature.
 
I’m just wondering if any of you have ever actually taken the time to go to a meeting with Jehovah’s Witnesses.
Oh yes. About 25 years ago, when I was “searching”, I began a book study with jws and went to many meetings. This went on for about 18 months - and then I began looking into the history of this organization, and questioning much of what they were teaching. I remember well that they do not like anyone digging into their history or questioning their beliefs. That was a huge red flag for me.
Thank God, He found me and I am now a Confirmed, practicing, believing, rosary telling, Mass attending, and joyfilled Catholic. I have been for years and will die one also.
 
40.png
Jaded27:
I’m just wondering if any of you have ever actually taken the time to go to a meeting with Jehovah’s Witnesses. I know I’ve taken the time to investigate and go to church a few times.
A fair question, to be sure.
40.png
Jaded27:
So that I have a balanced view of religions besides my own.
But I wonder. Does going to various meetings really fit the bill of investigation into any particular faith? I would submit that they are not. How long would one have to attend meetings with any organization to find out what is at the core of the teachings? I think that happens through study rather than attending meetings. By attending Mass does one learn what the Church teaches with regard to the Social Gospel? One may get a hint, but definitely not get into the bricks and mortar. I think the JW’s would agree here as well, as far as to get into the inner teachings of the JW’s meetings should be coupled by individual and group study.
 
40.png
b_justb:
But I wonder. Does going to various meetings really fit the bill of investigation into any particular faith? I would submit that they are not. How long would one have to attend meetings with any organization to find out what is at the core of the teachings? I think that happens through study rather than attending meetings. By attending Mass does one learn what the Church teaches with regard to the Social Gospel? One may get a hint, but definitely not get into the bricks and mortar. I think the JW’s would agree here as well, as far as to get into the inner teachings of the JW’s meetings should be coupled by individual and group study.
Oh yea, you’re right. I just wanted to know if anyone had gone to get at least a general sense of what it’s like. I mean, until I went to church I could have said, “Oh, those Catholics. They worship satan and sacrifice children to jesus on their altars.” A far cry from the truth, to be sure, but I could have said it having never been there.

I just think that JW meetings get a bad rap sometimes because they are so much longer than church meetings on sunday. And for other reasons as well. I was just curious if anyone had taken the time to go.

But for really finding out what it entails to be in a religion you woudl have to do more than attend a religious meeting, yes.

Hey look! I agreed with you for once! 😉
 
As far as I see the meetings are similar to our religious education classes, we hold those here after Mass here at my Church. Actually they will start up again in about a week and we will have Mass for about an hour, then religious education for about an hour after that in various classrooms.
How is it structured for you?

God Bless
Scylla
 
40.png
scylla:
How is it structured for you?

God Bless
Scylla
Well, first off the kids are not seperate from their parents in like CCD class or something. (Not saying our way is better, just saying.) I’d personaly rather have my kids with me during religious meetings. You’d be surprised how quickly they pick up on being quiet and paying attention. I was answering at the meetings by the time I was four.

So: Sunday - one hour public discourse usually from a speaker from another congregation. then forty five minute discussion of teh watchtower article for that week. songs at beginning, middle, and end. prayer at beginning and end.

Tuesday - Theocratic ministry school for the first hour (demonstrations of going out in service, conducting bible studies, etc. Bible reading for the week), forty five minutes of announcments and usually two talks about varying subjects having to do with the ministry or local needs of hte kingdom hall. (say, for example there is a lot of gossip of late. they will have a talk on why that is not proper.) song and prayer schedule same as sunday.

Thursday - book study. one hour discussion on a chapter in whatever book we are studying. we’ve studied many many books obviously. Some have been really interesting - like Daniel’s prophecy and the book of Isaiah. Fascinating stuff, really. no song, but a prayer at beginning and end.

Depending on what hall you go to tuesday and thursday schedules may be switched to accomadate that congregation’s schedule.

Any other questions about it? Don’t know what else I can think of right now. . .
 
Wow, thank you taking the time to type that out, I appreciate it.

Usually kids are taught in CCD separate from parents to specialize the teachings to different agegroups. As parents we frequently assist and some more than others are involved. (as is the case with all people)

My kids attend Mass with me and don’t need to sit in the crying room anymore, (until we have another baby). 🙂

Again thank you, will post more later, but I should get back to work.

God Bless
Scylla
 
I spoke to a Jehovah’s Witness, she says old publications ain’t really valid eversince the watchtower discovered “new light”

Evanescence
 
40.png
Evanescence:
I spoke to a Jehovah’s Witness, she says old publications ain’t really valid eversince the watchtower discovered “new light”

Evanescence
yea. It’s not like we’ve had many changes to our beliefs, but there have been a few. I guess they were misinterpretations is the best way to say it. Anyway, there haven’t been any in MY lifetime at least. It’s all pretty much right there to find out anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top