We went through this process in February of 2010. My husband is a cradle catholic, and I was actually baptized in the Catholic church but my family moved to a Methodist church when I was a child. We were married in 1998 in the Methodist church, since he was not an actively practicing Catholic at the time and I honestly never identified myself as Catholic. Neither of us knew the church’s rules on marriage, so it made sense at the time to get married in the church I had been raised in.
We had stopped going to the Methodist church and didn’t really have a church for several years when we decided to go back to the Catholic church. We went back in January of 2010 and made an appointment to meet with the priest right away. Since we’d been married almost 12 years, the only preparation he made us go through was doing a survey that we took separately and then he reviewed the answers and we talked about anything where our views seemed to differ. We got our baptism records (mine were local, his had to be sent over from his hometown in the UK), and then planned the ceremony. We opted to have just the Liturgy of the Word portion without a full Mass. We had my family and another family that are good friends of ours come to the ceremony on a Saturday morning in the chapel. Afterwards, we had a nice lunch at a local restaurant that let us use a private dining room. We just wore nice church clothes, and I wore a white chapel veil. We did get a ring bearer’s pillow, and one of our boys carried our rings in and then the priest blessed them. I also made up some little programs with our names and the date on the front, since none of our guests were familiar with a Catholic liturgy or how to use a missal.
All in all it was a very quick and easy experience for us. Neither of us had been married to anyone else and we were both baptized Catholics already, so there wasn’t much red tape to wade through.