Apostles teaching and Catholic tradition

  • Thread starter Thread starter rd151
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

rd151

Guest
I am a Catholic and I recently was asked by a Protestant where the apostles ever wrote or taught about praying to Mary, rosaries, seeking indulgences so to loosen one from purgatory? I told him these were teachings that came later into the church, but he said by what authority does the Catholic church have to add teachings that were never taught by Christ or the apostles? How do you answer this?
 
You might remind your Protestant friend that not all of Christ’s teachings, as passed on by the Apostles, were written. Most of the Apostles were uneducated and probably could not read and write. Many of the Catholic Traditions are found in the writings of the “Fathers of the Church.” And, while we do not claim that these writings were inspired in the same way that the Bible was, it is clear evidence of what these holy men were taught and the teachings they were passing on.
 
rd:

you are being thrown off track. What is most important is the fact that the Lord entrusted the entire deposit of faith to the Apostles, and guaranteed that He would send His Holy Spirit to protect that deposit, and that the Church, and specifically Peter, would be kept free from error when teaching about faith and morals. This was true even before it was recorded in the Gospel of St. Matthew, and would continue to be true were it not recorded.

If you don’t accept the authority of the Apostles, and their successors, and specifically Peter, then the Bible itself loses authority, because if we did not have the authority of the Church, which we wouldn’t have the Bible.

It isn’t that the Church is adding teaching. The teaching is there, implicitly or explicitly. It is that they are subtracting, just as they subtracted books from the Bible.

Scott
 
I am a Catholic and I recently was asked by a Protestant where the apostles ever wrote or taught about praying to Mary, rosaries, seeking indulgences so to loosen one from purgatory? I told him these were teachings that came later into the church, but he said by what authority does the Catholic church have to add teachings that were never taught by Christ or the apostles? How do you answer this?
Praying to Mary: Let me go ahead and expand that to praying to Mary and the saints generally, ok? The overwhelming majority of Christians at the time the NT was written were alive, so you don’t see people saying things like “pray to Mary,” because Mary is alive. You can just write her a letter. Here’s the Biblical basis:
(1) Hebrews 11 recounts all the saints saved by faith - Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses’ parents, Moses, Rahab, etc., and then says in the next verse (12:1), "Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles, and let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us. "
(2) Paul tells us to pray intercessory prayers for one another in 1 Timothy 2:1. James 5:16 says, “Therefore, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The fervent prayer of a righteous person is very powerful.”
So the Church naturally concludes that since: (1) those who are dead in body are still spiritually alive in Heaven, and watching over us, and (2) we’re called to pray for each other and intercede for each other, then (3) the Saints in Heaven are still called to intercede for us. Heaven isn’t the abode of the selfish. Proof for this conclusion comes in the parable from Luke 16:19-31. The man in purgation (I’ll address it in a second) prays to Father Abraham to help his brothers. Even though Abraham refuses to do it, he’s *capable *of it, and aware of the man’s brothers. He just opts not to help out these corrupt gentlemen, given all the graces God has already provided them through Moses and the prophets.

**Rosaries: **These are a form of prayer created later. Just like, I might add, the “Sinner’s Prayer” used so often in Protestantism. Creating a new prayer isn’t bad. And the rosaries is chock full of Biblical verses - “Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee,” (Luke 1:28), the entire Our Father (Matthew 6:9-13), and so forth. How many other prayers are rooted this obviously in the Bible itself? Beyond that, nobody is required to pray the rosary to be saved, and nothing in the rosary is contrary to the Bible (since we’ve established that asking saints to pray for us isn’t wrong).

Indulgences: As far as I know, this is based in the binding/loosening power which Jesus gave Peter the authority to exercise over the whole Church in Matthew 16:19, and the other disciples to exercise over each local church in Matthew 18:18.

Purgatory: The parable above has a guy in torment, but not in hell. We know he’s not in hell because he can still feel compassion for others, which is a result only of grace (and thus, isn’t found in hell). If he’s not in purgatory, he’s in somewhere really similar. Matthew 12:32 says that the unforgivable sin won’t be forgiven in this age, or the age to come – implicitly, it’s thus possible for some sins not forgiven in this age to be forgiven in the age to come. The Catholic Church divides this between mortal and venial (non-mortal) sins. Or more precisely, St. John makes this division in 1 John 5:16-17. Finally, Rev. 21:27 says that nothing impure can enter Heaven. So… if we die with venial sins still on our souls, they’re not enough to damn us to hell if we’re believers, but they’re enough to keep us out of Heaven until they’re totally remedied - Matthew 12:36 says that “men will have to give account on the day of judgment for every careless word they have spoken.”

2 Maccabees 12:39-46 also discusses this in the OT. Protestants reject this book, but it at least establishes that the Jews believed this, and Jesus, et al, did nothing to change this belief. Finally, Acts 26:20 calls us to “do penance, and turn to God, doing works worthy of penance.” Indulgences are achieved through doing these works - usually something like: being heartily sorry for our sins, attending Mass and receiving Communion, and making a religious pilgrimage to someplace in particular. Those sorts of things. The abuse which Luther protested was the *sale *of indulgences, and in that, he was right, and the Church stopped abusing Her power in this regard. Indulgences themselves date back as far as one can find in the Church.

Finally, two tips to help you further. First, this might be a good jumping off point to get some more in-depth info: bringyou.to/apologetics/audio.htm. Second, read the Early Church Fathers. Show your Protestant friend that the very people who saved the Gospel were people who firmly held Catholic teachings.

Hope that helps!
 
I am a Catholic and I recently was asked by a Protestant where the apostles ever wrote or taught about praying to Mary, rosaries, seeking indulgences so to loosen one from purgatory?

  1. *]Pray = ask. As St John records, Jesus and Mary are at the wedding feast of Canna. They ran out of wine. Mary was asked to interceed about running out of wine. Why did they ask Mary? What could SHE do about it anyway? THEN Mary asks Jesus and Jesus performs his first miracle… One might get the impression from Jesus response to His mother, that He and Mary weren’t to get involved. But Jesus did what His mom asked. Moms have influence with their sons 🙂 that’s why they went to Mary, and that doesn’t change for us.
    *]The rosary is merely praying the gospel. Jesus taught us the Our Father, Mary, the angel Gabriel, and Elizabeth,gave us the words of the Hail Mary.
    *]As far as loosen someone from their sin after death but before entrance into heaven, that teaching came from the OT and was refined in the NT. I’m sure by now you’re familiar with [2 Macc 12: 39…]. and [1 Cor 3:11…] Here’s a story you might use with your friend. Malachi 3:3 says: ‘He will sit as a refiner and purifier of silver.’ This verse puzzled some women in a Bible study and they wondered what this statement meant about the character and nature of God. (must have been Protestants ;)) One of the women offered to find out the process of refining silver and get back to the group at their next Bible Study. That week, the woman called a silversmith and made an appointment to watch him at work. She didn’t mention anything about the reason for her interest beyond her curiosity about the process of refining Silver. As she watched the silversmith, he held a piece of silver over the fire and let it heat up. He explained that in refining silver, one needed to hold the silver in the middle of the fire where the flames were hottest as to burn away all the impurities. The woman thought about God holding us in such a hot spot; then she thought again about the verse that says: ‘He sits as a refiner and purifier of silver.’ She asked the silversmith if it was true that he had to sit there in front of the fire the whole time. The man answered that yes, he not only had to sit there holding the silver, but he had to keep his eyes on the silver the entire time it was in the fire. If the silver was left a moment too long in the flames, it would be destroyed. The woman was silent for a moment. Then she asked the silversmith, ‘How do you know when the silver is fully refined?’ He smiled at her and answered, ‘Oh, that’s easy – when I see my image in it.’
    *]Indulgences is a power of the Church and the Keys.[Mt 16:13…] It’s not a figment of anyone’s imagination it’s a gift from Jesus to be exercised by the Church. All fully scriptural. BTW, this is exercised by the only Church Jesus founded. The Catholic Church.
    rd:
    he said by what authority does the Catholic church have to add teachings that were never taught by Christ or the apostles? How do you answer this?
    Using his litmus, where did Christ and the apostles give authority to Protesters to Our Lord’s Church?.
 
The practices of praying to the saints (Daniel 3:86) and the angels (Psalm 103:21-22; Psalm 148:2; Daniel 3:58) and of doing penance to gain an indulgence for the souls in Purgatory (2 Maccabees 12:38-46) are firmly rooted in the Old Testament, especially in the deuterocanonical books which Martin Luther and the other Protestant Reformers decided to remove from the Christian Bible some 500 years ago.
 
I am a Catholic and I recently was asked by a Protestant where the apostles ever wrote or taught about praying to Mary, rosaries, seeking indulgences so to loosen one from purgatory? I told him these were teachings that came later into the church, but he said by what authority does the Catholic church have to add teachings that were never taught by Christ or the apostles? How do you answer this?
Well first they are not Teachings, they are expressions of belief or Devotions which did in fact develop over time. Praying the psalms was known to the Apostles, which is what the Rosary is modeled after. Praying for the dead was known to the Apostles, as it’s rooted in Jewish practice. We know from the book of Acts the the Apostles spent 9 days in prayer with Mary the Mother of God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top