Apostolic Succession Q

  • Thread starter Thread starter Departed_Light
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Departed_Light

Guest
Hello CAF Apologists, it’s me again. I hope you have not grown weary of replying to my questions.

I think I understand the idea of Catholic Apostolic Succession being that the bishops in communion with the current Pope of Rome have been selected through the years by the Holy Spirit working through previous bishops going back to the time of the Apostles. And I think there is something about there being a laying on of hands in that line that confers the bishopric office, or something similar. And the office of the papacy is a direct line of this same bishopric rite going back to the foremost of the Apostles, Saint Peter. Am I OK so far?

In Scripture we have Matthias being selected to fulfill the Apostolic seat vacated by the passing of Judas Iscariot (Acts 1). But we don’t have recorded in Scripture the same for James Zebedee when he was martyred (Acts 12).

Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?

Thanks,
d.l.
 
Hello CAF Apologists, it’s me again. I hope you have not grown weary of replying to my questions.

I think I understand the idea of Catholic Apostolic Succession being that the bishops in communion with the current Pope of Rome have been selected through the years by the Holy Spirit working through previous bishops going back to the time of the Apostles. And I think there is something about there being a laying on of hands in that line that confers the bishopric office, or something similar. And the office of the papacy is a direct line of this same bishopric rite going back to the foremost of the Apostles, Saint Peter. Am I OK so far?

In Scripture we have Matthias being selected to fulfill the Apostolic seat vacated by the passing of Judas Iscariot (Acts 1). But we don’t have recorded in Scripture the same for James Zebedee when he was martyred (Acts 12).

Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?

Thanks,
d.l.
Not for James the son of Zebedee, but there is mention of a successor to James, the brother of the Lord (most likely James, son of Mary and Clopas, a cousin of Mary, mother of Jesus). He was not one of the twelve, but given Acts 15, he certainly had a lot of authority.

Josephus states that he was killed a few years before the destruction of the temple by Annanias the high priest. He was replaced by Simeon, another relative of the Lord.

Hope this helps.

God bless,
Ut
 
In Scripture we have Matthias being selected to fulfill the Apostolic seat vacated by the passing of Judas Iscariot (Acts 1). But we don’t have recorded in Scripture the same for James Zebedee when he was martyred (Acts 12).

Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?

Thanks,
d.l.
Does this help you any? The James that took the place of the Apostle James is also believed to be James the lesser aka James the Just. What I have listed below the verses is the commentary from the USCCB

Acts 12
16
But Peter continued to knock, and when they opened it, they saw him and were astounded.
17
He motioned to them with his hand to be quiet and explained (to them) how the Lord had led him out of the prison, and said, “Report this to James 4 and the brothers.” Then he left and went to another place.

4 [17] To James: this James is not the son of Zebedee mentioned in Acts 12:2, but is James, the “brother of the Lord” (Gal 1:19), who in Acts 15; 21 is presented as leader of the Jerusalem Christian community. He left and went to another place: the conjecture that Peter left for Rome at this time has nothing to recommend it. His chief responsibility was still the leadership of the Jewish Christian community in Palestine (see Gal 2:7). The concept of the great missionary effort of the church was yet to come (see Acts 13:1-3).
 
Hello CAF Apologists, it’s me again. I hope you have not grown weary of replying to my questions.

I think I understand the idea of Catholic Apostolic Succession being that the bishops in communion with the current Pope of Rome have been selected through the years by the Holy Spirit working through previous bishops going back to the time of the Apostles. And I think there is something about there being a laying on of hands in that line that confers the bishopric office, or something similar. And the office of the papacy is a direct line of this same bishopric rite going back to the foremost of the Apostles, Saint Peter. Am I OK so far?

In Scripture we have Matthias being selected to fulfill the Apostolic seat vacated by the passing of Judas Iscariot (Acts 1). But we don’t have recorded in Scripture the same for James Zebedee when he was martyred (Acts 12).

Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?

Thanks,
d.l.
D.L., I believe if you do a bit of research, you may find some thought and/or scholarly research (including scripture, perhaps Galatians?) that suggests James the son of Alpheus succeeded James the Son of Zebedee as bishop of Jerusalem after the latter’s martyrdom in A.D. 44. If I get time, I might try to help you.
 
Does this help you any? The James that took the place of the Apostle James is also believed to be James the lesser aka James the Just. What I have listed below the verses is the commentary from the USCCB

Acts 12
16
But Peter continued to knock, and when they opened it, they saw him and were astounded.
17
He motioned to them with his hand to be quiet and explained (to them) how the Lord had led him out of the prison, and said, “Report this to James 4 and the brothers.” Then he left and went to another place.

4 [17] To James: this James is not the son of Zebedee mentioned in Acts 12:2, but is James, the “brother of the Lord” (Gal 1:19), who in Acts 15; 21 is presented as leader of the Jerusalem Christian community. He left and went to another place: the conjecture that Peter left for Rome at this time has nothing to recommend it. His chief responsibility was still the leadership of the Jewish Christian community in Palestine (see Gal 2:7). The concept of the great missionary effort of the church was yet to come (see Acts 13:1-3).
Some what. Is this saying that James the brother of our Lord was installed as an Apostle to fill the vacancy for James Bar Zebedee?
D.L., I believe if you do a bit of research, you may find some thought and/or scholarly research (including scripture, perhaps Galatians?) that suggests James the son of Alpheus succeeded James the Son of Zebedee as bishop of Jerusalem after the latter’s martyrdom in A.D. 44. If I get time, I might try to help you.
But James Bar Alpheus was already an Apostle (Luke 6:15) so he being made bishop of a certain jurisdiction is not the same as replacing the martyred James Zebedee as an Apostle.
 
Some what. Is this saying that James the brother of our Lord was installed as an Apostle to fill the vacancy for James Bar Zebedee?
I haven’t heard of this kind of research. I’d be interested in seeing it.

That being said, if you read acts 15, you see James making pronouncements along side Peter, which would indicate a certain level of authority on par with that of an apostle.

You should also note that there were certain people who were not of the twelve who were also called apostles, such as Barnabas, and Appolos. You also see Timothy, Titus, and Silvanus acting as representatives of the apostles. Even though they were not replacing the apostles, the certainly had apostolic authority. (Timothy and Silvanus were co-authors of Paul’s letters to the Thessalonians).
But James Bar Alpheus was already an Apostle (Luke 6:15) so he being made bishop of a certain jurisdiction is not the same as replacing the martyred James Zebedee as an Apostle.
Well James the brother of the Lord would have been an eye witness to Jesus’ teachings, and he certainly had a great deal of authority with Jewish Christians. But I don’t see any record of him being considered a replacement to James the son of Zebedee.

God bless,
Ut
 
Some what. Is this saying that James the brother of our Lord was installed as an Apostle to fill the vacancy for James Bar Zebedee?

But James Bar Alpheus was already an Apostle (Luke 6:15) so he being made bishop of a certain jurisdiction is not the same as replacing the martyred James Zebedee as an Apostle.
James, the lesser, also an Apostle and the brother (close relative, probably a cousin) replaced James the Greater (aka James Bar Zebedee) as the Bishop of Jerusalem. Yes, he was already an Apostle and someone would have been installed in his place at his previous station. (I don’t remember where that was right now)
 
I haven’t heard of this kind of research. I’d be interested in seeing it.

That being said, if you read acts 15, you see James making pronouncements along side Peter, which would indicate a certain level of authority on par with that of an apostle.

You should also note that there were certain people who were not of the twelve who were also called apostles, such as Barnabas, and Appolos. You also see Timothy, Titus, and Silvanus acting as representatives of the apostles. Even though they were not replacing the apostles, the certainly had apostolic authority. (Timothy and Silvanus were co-authors of Paul’s letters to the Thessalonians).

Well James the brother of the Lord would have been an eye witness to Jesus’ teachings, and he certainly had a great deal of authority with Jewish Christians. But I don’t see any record of him being considered a replacement to James the son of Zebedee.
God bless,
Ut
The James that took the place of the Apostle James is also believed to be James the lesser aka James the Just. What I have listed below the verses is the commentary from the USCCB

Acts 12
16
But Peter continued to knock, and when they opened it, they saw him and were astounded.
17
He motioned to them with his hand to be quiet and explained (to them) how the Lord had led him out of the prison, and said, “Report this to James 4 and the brothers.” Then he left and went to another place.

4 [17] To James: this James is not the son of Zebedee mentioned in Acts 12:2, but is James, the “brother of the Lord” (Gal 1:19), who in Acts 15; 21 is presented as leader of the Jerusalem Christian community. He left and went to another place: the conjecture that Peter left for Rome at this time has nothing to recommend it. His chief responsibility was still the leadership of the Jewish Christian community in Palestine (see Gal 2:7). The concept of the great missionary effort of the church was yet to come (see Acts 13:1-3).
 
Thanks to all for looking into this. I do sincerely appreciate it and I know it takes a generous personality to take the time to research this stuff for complete strangers on the internet. Thank you. This question is an objection I have heard from others against the Catholic claim of Apostolic Succession and the need for it. That’s why I posted it. I’m not sure why this thread was voted as terrible. I didn’t think I was being rude or anything. If I was taken that way I apologize.
 
Thanks to all for looking into this. I do sincerely appreciate it and I know it takes a generous personality to take the time to research this stuff for complete strangers on the internet. Thank you. This question is an objection I have heard from others against the Catholic claim of Apostolic Succession and the need for it. That’s why I posted it. I’m not sure why this thread was voted as terrible. I didn’t think I was being rude or anything. If I was taken that way I apologize.
Eh, I enjoyed the thread. No need for an apology, the way I see it. Very interesting question. :aok:
 
Thanks to all for looking into this. I do sincerely appreciate it and I know it takes a generous personality to take the time to research this stuff for complete strangers on the internet. Thank you. This question is an objection I have heard from others against the Catholic claim of Apostolic Succession and the need for it. That’s why I posted it. I’m not sure why this thread was voted as terrible. I didn’t think I was being rude or anything. If I was taken that way I apologize.
No offense taken here. Maybe it was my confusion over all the different James. 😊

God bless,
Ut

P.S. Cool, I just figured out how to vote for the first time. 🙂
 
Sorry for arriving late to the discussion, but a bit of clarification…

I don’t think Apostolic Succession is rooted in the Papal office, since the Orthodox (and several other particular churches) have recognized Apostolic Succession outside of communion with the Bishop of Rome. I believe the CCC addresses this, as well as several other Papal letters over the years.

Grace and peace–
 
Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?
According to the Church historian Eusebius, writing in the early 4th century, the apostolic succession of the Jerusalem Church is as follows:

James the Just, Simeon, Justus I, Zacchaeus, Tobias, Benjamin, John, Matthias, Phillip, Senecas, Justus II, Levi, Ephres, Joseph, Judas, etc.

Blessings
 
=Departed Light;5565525]Hello CAF Apologists, it’s me again. I hope you have not grown weary of replying to my questions.
I think I understand the idea of Catholic Apostolic Succession being that the bishops in communion with the current Pope of Rome have been selected through the years by the Holy Spirit working through previous bishops going back to the time of the Apostles. And I think there is something about there being a laying on of hands in that line that confers the bishopric office, or something similar. And the office of the papacy is a direct line of this same bishopric rite going back to the foremost of the Apostles, Saint Peter. Am I OK so far?
In Scripture we have Matthias being selected to fulfill the Apostolic seat vacated by the passing of Judas Iscariot (Acts 1). But we don’t have recorded in Scripture the same for James Zebedee when he was martyred (Acts 12).
Is there something in Catholic Tradition that says a similar practice was followed in filling James’ seat as was done with Judas’ though not directly spoken of in Scripture?
Thanks,
d.l.
***Great question!

The fact that Judas was replaced was largely symbolic to regain the number of “twelve” Apostles. One for “each tribe.” It was a sign that others may be chosen for the same task. And such has been the case for some 2,000 years.

Recall that Jesus Himself selected Saul / “Paul” and made him the thirteenth “Apostle.” All Bishops were annointed with the laying on of hands, and in a similar way so are all priest, and for that matter, so are all who are “Confirmed” in the Sacrament of Confirmation.

The fact that Matthias was selected “by throwing lots [dice]” is to signify that those called are called personally by God. John 15:16 “You did not choose me, but I chose you and appointed you that you should go and bear fruit and that your fruit should abide”*

The wording, intent and oils vary, but in each case there is a “Commissioning” to live, preach and teach God’s Word according to “ones call.”.**

Love and prayers,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top